Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
What can we
learn from
citation listsManolis Wallace
1
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/20152
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
EU member
Euro € currency
10,816,286 population
16.5 million tourists per year
More than 6,000 islands
Up to 227 are inhabited
22/6/20153
Greece
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Founded in 2002
Located in Tripoli, Corinth, Kalamata,
Nafplion, and Sparta
6,000 students
Department of Informatics…
… and Telecommunications
22/6/20154
University of Peloponnese
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research
Laboratory
Knowledge
Γνώση - Ghnosi
Uncertainty
ΑΒεβαιότητα - AVeveotita
22/6/20155
The group
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Italian → bau-bau; arf-arf
Turkish → hev-hev
Thai → hong-hong
Korean → mung-mung; wang-wang
Swedish → voff-voff; vov-vov
Greek → ghav-ghav
22/6/20156
Barking dog
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/20157
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/20158
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/20159
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201510
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201511
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201512
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201513
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201514
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201515
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201516
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201517
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201518
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Researcher evaluation
Volume of work
Quality of work
Difficulties
Objectivity
Data availability
22/6/201519
Today’s talk
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Publication lists
YES
Publications
NO
Citations
Yes, partially
22/6/201520
What is available
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Publications
Count
Journal / book / conference / chapter
Indexed
Monograph / with associates
How many contributors
All / recent
Researcher has # <criterion> publications
22/6/201521
Volume
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Citations
Self-citations / group citations
All / recent
Researchers has # <criterion> citations
22/6/201522
Quality
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
count
average per paper/author
h index
h1, h2, h3
g index
e index
s index
i-10 index
22/6/201523
Citation metrics
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Currently examining count of local edges
What else is there?
Who is citing your work?
What types of publications cite you?
How important are the papers citing you?
How many works are you affecting in the long run?
What are the subjects of the citing papers?
22/6/201524
Citation graph
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Ontology engineer for research project
22/6/201525
A simple example
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Stephen
93.034 citations
Panos
69 citations
22/6/201526
The candidates
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Stephen Hawking
93.034 citations
Theoretical physics
Panos Alexopoulos
69 citations
Ontology engineering
22/6/201527
The candidates
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Citation
Title
Abstract
Keywords
Full text
Where it was published
22/6/201528
Scientific field of impact
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Citation acquisition
Citation analysis
Impact quantification
Presentation
22/6/201529
Evaluation process
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201530
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201531
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201532
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Run application
See results
22/6/201533
Let’s try this
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201534
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201535
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Color coding
22/6/201536
Presentation
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Size for count
Direction/color for field
22/6/201537
Visualization
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Run application
22/6/201538
Let’s try this
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201539
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201540
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201541
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
22/6/201542
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
..this is just the citation count
22/6/201543
And…
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
Evaluation based on citations
Citations are (almost) open data
Publication medium shows field
Visualization assists comprehension
Dogs go ghav-ghav in Greece
22/6/201544
Concluding
Knowledge and Uncertainty Research Laboratory
What can we
learn from
citation listsManolis Wallace
45
