Upload
kyunghwa-kirsten-lee
View
93
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Sex differences in a C. elegans sensory behavior
Kyung Hwa LeeAdvisor: Douglas S. Portman
Interdepartmental Graduate Program in Neuroscience
Sex differences in the neural circuitry and behavior
Swaab et al., 2003
Females
Anorexia nervosaAnxiety disorder
Unipolar depression
Males
AutismADHD
Schizophrenia
Gender influences neurological and mental health
SEX Sex differencesin common behaviors
and/or
structure
(e.g., neuronal number, connectivity)
molecular, cellular properties in the same neural circuit
(e.g., neurochemical composition)
Sex differences in the neural circuitry
Sex differences can arise independently of sex hormones
Agate et al., 2003
♀♂
Sex differences can arise independently of sex hormones
Agate et al., 2003
♀♂HVC HVC
♂ ♀
Sex differences can arise independently of sex hormones
Agate et al., 2003
♀♂
Sex chromosome in the brain itself(i.e., cell-intrinsic sex determination)contributes to neural sex differences
HVC HVC
♂ ♀
Sex differencesin behaviors
Sex chromosomes
Does “Neural sex” control the sex of neural circuit and behavior?
Sex differences in the neural circuitry
C. elegans as a model system to study sex differences in the neural circuit and behavior
• the complete wiring diagram of the Hermaphrodite neural circuitry
• no sex hormones
• well-defined cell-intrinsic sex determination pathway
• easily tractable, relatively simple behaviors
• available tools to tweak the neural function at the single neural level
XX Hermaphrodite
959 somatic cells
X0 Male
1031 somatic cells
somaticgonad
tail tip
Vulva
Oocytes Sperm
SpermMale tail sensilla
Portman, 2007
C. elegans exhibits extensive sex differences
Cell-intrinsic sex determination pathway regulates all known somatic sex differences in C. elegans
Sex chromosome
XX
X0
⚥
♂
tra-1
tra-1
Terminal sex regulator
Cell-intrinsic sex determination pathway regulates all known somatic sex differences in C. elegans
• XX animals carrying tra-1 null mutation develop as complete normal somatic XX males (Hodgkin, 1987; Hodgkin and Brenner, 1977)
Sex chromosome
XX
X0
⚥
♂
tra-1
tra-1
Terminal sex regulator
Cell-intrinsic sex determination pathway regulates all known somatic sex differences in C. elegans
• XX animals carrying tra-1 null mutation develop as complete normal somatic XX males (Hodgkin, 1987; Hodgkin and Brenner, 1977)
• Cell-autonomous control of sex differentiation by TRA-1 (Hunter and Wood, 1990)
Sex chromosome
XX
X0
⚥
♂
tra-1
tra-1
Terminal sex regulator
HermaphroditeTotal 302 neurons
MaleTotal 383 neurons
Sex differences in the C. elegans nervous system
8 Hermaphrodite-specific neurons
VC HSN
89 Male-specific neurons
CEM CA/CPRn, HO, SP, PC
EF, DV, DX, PDC, PGA, PV
(mate searching, mating)
(egg-laying)
Portman, 2007
HermaphroditeTotal 302 neurons
MaleTotal 383 neurons
Sex differences in the C. elegans nervous system
“Core”294 neurons
feedingsmell, taste
touchmovement
8 Hermaphrodite-specific neurons
VC HSN
89 Male-specific neurons
CEM CA/CPRn, HO, SP, PC
EF, DV, DX, PDC, PGA, PV
(mate searching, mating)
(egg-laying)
Portman, 2007
Sex differences in the core nervous system at the molecular level
Male
srj-54::YFP
AIM
AIM
Hermaphrodite
srd-1::GFP
ASI
ADF
ASI
Troemel et al.,1995
ADF
Portman DS, unpublished
Sex differences in common behaviors
core neural circuitryfeeding
smell, tastetouch
movement Male. olfaction
Herm. olfaction
e.g.
e.g.
?
Do common behaviors differ between sexes?
Olfaction is mediated by core neural circuitry
olfactory neuronal circuit Sensory neurons
Benzaldehyde (bz) 2-‐Butanone (bu)
Diacetyl (da) Pyrazine (py) Repellents
AWC AWA AWB
InterneuronsAIY AIZ
RIA
Olfaction is mediated by core neural circuitry
olfactory neuronal circuit Sensory neurons
Benzaldehyde (bz) 2-‐Butanone (bu)
Diacetyl (da) Pyrazine (py) Repellents
AWC AWA AWB
Motor neurons
SMD RMD
InterneuronsAIY AIZ
RIA
Olfaction is mediated by core neural circuitry
olfactory neuronal circuit Sensory neurons
Benzaldehyde (bz) 2-‐Butanone (bu)
Diacetyl (da) Pyrazine (py) Repellents
AWC AWA AWB
control B A odorant
CI = (A-B) / total
Are there sex differences in C. elegans olfaction?
Bargmann et al., Cell (1993)
Sex differences in C. elegans olfactionCh
emot
axis
Inde
x
Odorant dilution
diacetyl(AWA)
pyrazine(AWA)
benzaldehyde(AWC)
2-butanone(AWC)
10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$0
1
0.5
0
1
0.5
* ***
***
* * ***
*
Hermaphrodite Male
Lee and Portman (2007) Curr. Biol.
Sex differences in C. elegans olfactionCh
emot
axis
Inde
x
Odorant dilution
diacetyl(AWA)
pyrazine(AWA)
benzaldehyde(AWC)
2-butanone(AWC)
10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$0
1
0.5
0
1
0.5
* ***
***
* * ***
*
Hermaphrodite Male
Males are also attracted to 4 canonical odorants
Male olfaction is significantly reduced in response to da, bz
Lee and Portman (2007) Curr. Biol.
Olfactory preference assay
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
Lee and Portman (2007)
Olfactory preference assay
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
OPI =b – a
b + a
Lee and Portman (2007)
a b
Olfactory preference assay
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
OPI =b – a
b + a
Lee and Portman (2007)
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
a b
Olfactory preference assay
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
OPI =b – a
b + a
Lee and Portman (2007)
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
worms
Odorant B+ NaN!
Odorant A+ NaN!
a b
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
daAWA
pyAWA
bzAWC
bzAWC
Odorant
AOdorant
B
Two sensory neurons
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
daAWA
buAWC
pyAWA
iaaAWC
Single sensory neuron
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Each sex has distinct and characteristic olfactory preferences
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Lee and Portman (2007)
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
daAWA
pyAWA
bzAWC
bzAWC
Odorant
AOdorant
B
Two sensory neurons
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
daAWA
buAWC
pyAWA
iaaAWC
Single sensory neuron
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Each sex has distinct and characteristic olfactory preferences
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
daAWA
pyAWA
bzAWC
bzAWC
Odorant
AOdorant
B
Two sensory neurons
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
daAWA
buAWC
pyAWA
iaaAWC
Single sensory neuron
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Hermaphrodite MaleOPI
–1 +10
A B
py / bz***
da / py***
da / bz***
*bu / bz
AWA
ODORANT
AWC
AWA AWC
AWA AWA
AWC AWC
Each sex has distinct and characteristic olfactory preferences
Does gonad influence?
Do sex-specific neurons contribute to?
How does sexually different olfaction arise?
Gonadal signaling is not necessary for sex difference in olfaction
Lee and Portman (2007)
L1 L2 L3 L4Embryo
Herm.-specificcircuitry
Male-specificcircuitry
Mating
Egg laying
Mate searching
The C. elegans life cycle
Adult
Sexual differences in olfaction precede sex-specific differentiation
The core nervous system itself may regulate sexually different olfaction
Sexual differences in olfaction precede sex-specific differentiation
core neural circuitry
Sex differences in olfactory behaviors
?orXX X0
molecular, cellular properties in the same neural circuit
Does “Neural sex” generate sexually different olfactory behaviors?
Sex chromosome
XX
X0
⚥♂
tra-1
tra-1
Terminal sex regulator
The terminal sex regulator, tra-1, controls sex difference in olfactory preference
Lee and Portman (2007)
Sex chromosome
XX
X0
⚥♂
tra-1
tra-1
Terminal sex regulator
Hermaphrodite Male XX Pseudomale
da py
bzpy
Wild type
tra-1
Wild type
tra-1
A
OPI–1 +10
AWA AWA
OPI–1 +10
B da py
***
AWA AWC
Wild type
AWA AWA
Prab-3::fem-3(+)
oxEx862oxEx863
Posm-5::fem-3(+)
fsEx160fsEx161
Pglr-1::fem-3(+)
fsEx158fsEx159
******
******
*
Hermaphrodite Male XX Pseudomale
da py
bzpy
Wild type
tra-1
Wild type
tra-1
A
OPI–1 +10
AWA AWA
OPI–1 +10
B da py
***
AWA AWC
Wild type
AWA AWA
Prab-3::fem-3(+)
oxEx862oxEx863
Posm-5::fem-3(+)
fsEx160fsEx161
Pglr-1::fem-3(+)
fsEx158fsEx159
******
******
*
The terminal sex regulator, tra-1, controls sex difference in olfactory preference
Lee and Portman (2007)
⚥
♂
tra-2 tra-1XX
X0
fem-3
tra-2 tra-1fem-3
Reprogramming the sex of the core neural circuit
Prab-3::fem-3(+)
Wild type Sexual mosaics
⚥
♂
tra-2 tra-1XX
X0
fem-3
tra-2 tra-1fem-3
Reprogramming the sex of the core neural circuit
Prab-3::tra-2(ic)
Prab-3::fem-3(+)
Wild type Sexual mosaics
Lee and Portman (2007)
Neural sex-transformation was successful!
Prab-3::fem-3(+)Hermaphrodite
Wild typeHermaphrodite
Wild typeMale
DIC
tph-1::GFP(Midbody)
pkd-2::GFP(Head)
srj-54::GFP(Head)
pkd-2::GFP(Tail)
A
B
C
D
E
Prab-3::fem-3(+)Hermaphrodite
Wild typeHermaphrodite
Wild typeMale
DIC
tph-1::GFP(Midbody)
pkd-2::GFP(Head)
srj-54::GFP(Head)
pkd-2::GFP(Tail)
A
B
C
D
E
DIC
srj-54::GFP
Male Herm.
Lee and Portman (2007)
Neural sex-transformation was successful!
Prab-3::fem-3(+)Hermaphrodite
Wild typeHermaphrodite
Wild typeMale
DIC
tph-1::GFP(Midbody)
pkd-2::GFP(Head)
srj-54::GFP(Head)
pkd-2::GFP(Tail)
A
B
C
D
E
Prab-3::fem-3(+)Hermaphrodite
Wild typeHermaphrodite
Wild typeMale
DIC
tph-1::GFP(Midbody)
pkd-2::GFP(Head)
srj-54::GFP(Head)
pkd-2::GFP(Tail)
A
B
C
D
E
Prab-3::fem-3(+)Hermaphrodite
Wild typeHermaphrodite
Wild typeMale
DIC
tph-1::GFP(Midbody)
pkd-2::GFP(Head)
srj-54::GFP(Head)
pkd-2::GFP(Tail)
A
B
C
D
E
Masculinizednervous system
DIC
srj-54::GFP
Male Herm.
Sex transformation of core neurons at the level of sex-specific gene expression
Lee and Portman (2007)
Neural sex-transformation was successful!
Prab-3::fem-3(+)Hermaphrodite
Wild typeHermaphrodite
Wild typeMale
DIC
tph-1::GFP(Midbody)
pkd-2::GFP(Head)
srj-54::GFP(Head)
pkd-2::GFP(Tail)
A
B
C
D
E
Prab-3::fem-3(+)Hermaphrodite
Wild typeHermaphrodite
Wild typeMale
DIC
tph-1::GFP(Midbody)
pkd-2::GFP(Head)
srj-54::GFP(Head)
pkd-2::GFP(Tail)
A
B
C
D
E
Prab-3::fem-3(+)Hermaphrodite
Wild typeHermaphrodite
Wild typeMale
DIC
tph-1::GFP(Midbody)
pkd-2::GFP(Head)
srj-54::GFP(Head)
pkd-2::GFP(Tail)
A
B
C
D
E
Masculinizednervous system
DIC
srj-54::GFP
Male Herm.
Neurons masculinized
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
None
Prab-3::fem-3(+)All
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
******
WT
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
Lee and Portman (2007)
Neural sex determines the sex phenotype of olfactory preference
Neurons masculinized
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
None
Prab-3::fem-3(+)All
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
******
WT
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
Lee and Portman (2007)
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
Olfactory Preference Index (OPI)
HermaphroditeMale
–1 +10
da py
***
wild type
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #4
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #8***
***
Neurons feminized
None
All
WT
Prab-3::tra-2(ic)
Olfactory Preference Index (OPI)
HermaphroditeMale
–1 +10
da py
***
wild type
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #4
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #8***
***
Olfactory Preference Index (OPI)
HermaphroditeMale
–1 +10
da py
***
wild type
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #4
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #8***
***
Olfactory Preference Index (OPI)
HermaphroditeMale
–1 +10
da py
***
wild type
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #4
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #8***
***
Olfactory Preference Index (OPI)
HermaphroditeMale
–1 +10
da py
***
wild type
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #4
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #8***
***
Olfactory Preference Index (OPI)
HermaphroditeMale
–1 +10
da py
***
wild type
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #4
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #8***
***
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
WTPrab-3::tra-2(ic)
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
***
***None
All
Neural sex determines the sex phenotype of olfactory preference
Sex-transformation of subsets of core neurons
Sensory neurons
Interneurons
Neurons masculinized
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
None
Prab-3::fem-3(+)All
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
******
Posm-5::fem-3(+)SensoryNeurons
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
******
WT
Pglr-1::fem-3(+)Interneurons
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
Lee and Portman (2007)
Neural sex modification on sensory neurons generate sexually different olfaction
Neurons feminized
None
Sensory neurons
None
Olfactory Preference Index (OPI)
HermaphroditeMale
–1 +10
da py
***
wild type
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #4
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #8***
***
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
***
Posm-5::tra-2(ic)
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
*** Posm-5::tra-2(ic)
WT
WT
Sensory neurons
Olfactory Preference Index (OPI)
HermaphroditeMale
–1 +10
da py
***
wild type
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #4
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #8***
***
Olfactory Preference Index (OPI)
HermaphroditeMale
–1 +10
da py
***
wild type
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #4
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #8***
***
***
Olfactory Preference Index (OPI)
HermaphroditeMale
–1 +10
da py
***
wild type
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #4
Prab-3::tra-2(ic) #8***
***
Sexually different properties of the sensory neuronscontrol the sex phenotype of olfactory preference
AWA
AIY AIZ
RIA
AWC AWB
SMD RMD
Sex-transformation of a single pair of sensory neuron
AWA
AIY AIZ
RIA
AWC AWA AWB
SMD RMD
Sex-transformation of a single pair of sensory neuron
AWA Podr-7::fem-3(+)
**
***
None
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
WT
Neurons masculinized
Single sensory neurons impart sex difference to olfactory preference behavior
AWA Podr-7::fem-3(+)
**
***
None
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
WT
Neurons masculinized
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
Podr-7::tra-2(ic)
None
AWA*
**
WT
Neurons feminized
Single sensory neurons impart sex difference to olfactory preference behavior
AWA Podr-7::fem-3(+)
**
***
None
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
WT
Neurons masculinized
Hermaphrodite Male
OPI–1 +10
da pyAWA AWA
Podr-7::tra-2(ic)
None
AWA*
**
WT
Neurons feminized
AWA neurons are sexually differentiated at the molecular levelto adopt sex differences in olfactory preference
Single sensory neurons impart sex difference to olfactory preference behavior
AWA neural sex regulates olfactory circuit function
AWA
AIY AIZ
RIA
AWC AWB
SMD RMD
X0
Male Olfaction
AIY AIZ
RIA
AWC AWA AWB
SMD RMD
XX
Herm. Olfaction
Chem
otax
is In
dex
Odorant dilution
diacetyl(AWA)
pyrazine(AWA)
benzaldehyde(AWC)
2-butanone(AWC)
10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$0
1
0.5
0
1
0.5
* ***
***
* * ***
*
Hermaphrodite Male
Lee and Portman (2007)
How AWA neurons are sexually different?
AWA
Herm. Male
AWA
Da Da
?
Py Py
Chem
otax
is In
dex
Odorant dilution
diacetyl(AWA)
pyrazine(AWA)
benzaldehyde(AWC)
2-butanone(AWC)
10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$0
1
0.5
0
1
0.5
* ***
***
* * ***
*
Hermaphrodite Male
Lee and Portman (2007)
How AWA neurons are sexually different?
AWA
Herm. Male
AWA
Da Da
?
Py Py
Chem
otax
is In
dex
Odorant dilution
diacetyl(AWA)
pyrazine(AWA)
benzaldehyde(AWC)
2-butanone(AWC)
10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$0
1
0.5
0
1
0.5
* ***
***
* * ***
*
Hermaphrodite Male
Lee and Portman (2007)
How AWA neurons are sexually different?
XXX
odr-‐7
AWA
Herm. Male
AWA
Da Da
?
Py Py
Chem
otax
is In
dex
Odorant dilution
diacetyl(AWA)
pyrazine(AWA)
benzaldehyde(AWC)
2-butanone(AWC)
10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$ 10!" 10!# 10!$0
1
0.5
0
1
0.5
* ***
***
* * ***
*
Hermaphrodite Male
Lee and Portman (2007)
How AWA neurons are sexually different?
XXX
odr-‐7X
XX?
odr-‐7
Male AWA neurons mediate response to Pyrazine (Py) as hermaphrodites’
!"
!#$"
!#%"
!#&"
!#'"
!#("
!#)"
!#*"
!#+"
!#,"
$"
-./("0" -./("1" 2*-("0" 2*-("1"
******
Py 1/100C.I
MaleHerm. odr-7 Herm. odr-7 Male
Male AWA neurons mediate response to Pyrazine (Py) as hermaphrodites’
Male
AWA
PyHerm.
AWA
Py
!"
!#$"
!#%"
!#&"
!#'"
!#("
!#)"
!#*"
!#+"
!#,"
$"
-./("0" -./("1" 2*-("0" 2*-("1"
******
Py 1/100C.I
MaleHerm. odr-7 Herm. odr-7 Male
AWA neurons are not required for male response to Diacetyl (Da)
!"
!#$"
!#%"
!#&"
!#'"
!#("
!#)"
!#*"
!#+"
!#,"
$"
-./("0" -./("1" 2*-("0" 2*-("1"
Da 1/100*
C.I
MaleHerm. odr-7 Herm. odr-7 Male
AWA neurons are not required for male response to Diacetyl (Da)
!"
!#$"
!#%"
!#&"
!#'"
!#("
!#)"
!#*"
!#+"
!#,"
$"
-./("0" -./("1" 2*-("0" 2*-("1"
Da 1/100*
C.I
MaleHerm. odr-7 Herm. odr-7 Male
AWA AWC
Herm.
Da
ODR-10
AWAChou et al., 2001
AWA neurons are not required for male response to Diacetyl (Da)
!"
!#$"
!#%"
!#&"
!#'"
!#("
!#)"
!#*"
!#+"
!#,"
$"
-./("0" -./("1" 2*-("0" 2*-("1"
Da 1/100*
C.I
MaleHerm. odr-7 Herm. odr-7 Male
Male
AWCAWA
Da
AWA AWC
Herm.
Da
ODR-10
AWAChou et al., 2001
AWA neurons are not required for male response to Diacetyl (Da)
!"
!#$"
!#%"
!#&"
!#'"
!#("
!#)"
!#*"
!#+"
!#,"
$"
-./("0" -./("1" 2*-("0" 2*-("1"
Da 1/100*
C.I
MaleHerm. odr-7 Herm. odr-7 Male
Male
AWCAWA
Da
AWAAWA AWC
Herm.
Da
ODR-10
AWAChou et al., 2001
AWA neurons are not required for male response to Diacetyl (Da)
!"
!#$"
!#%"
!#&"
!#'"
!#("
!#)"
!#*"
!#+"
!#,"
$"
-./("0" -./("1" 2*-("0" 2*-("1"
Da 1/100*
C.I
MaleHerm. odr-7 Herm. odr-7 Male
Male
AWCAWA
Da
How male AWA neurons do not sense Da ?
AWAAWA AWC
Herm.
Da
ODR-10
AWA
ODR-10
Chou et al., 2001
Is the ODR-10 expression sexually different ?
Herm. ODR-10
By courtesy of Dr. Hurd (Fisher)
Is the ODR-10 expression sexually different ?
Herm. ODR-10Male ODR-10
By courtesy of Dr. Hurd (Fisher)
Is the ODR-10 expression sexually different ?
Herm. ODR-10Male ODR-10
!"
#"
$!"
$#"
%!"
%#"
&!"
&#"
'!"
$" %" &" '" #"
()*+#&,-./0$!112345"67897+68)"
!"#$"%&'()"
!"#$"*+,&"
no exp.very weak
brightestODR-10::GFP
!"#$"%#&'("
ODR-10 expression is sex-specifically regulated
By courtesy of Dr. Hurd (Fisher)
Herm.
Male
ODR-10::GFPDIC
Herm.
Male
AWA-feminized Male
DIC ODR-10::GFPAWA feminization
Herm.
MaleNeural sex of AWA neurons regulatessexually different ODR-10 expression
AWA-feminized Male
DIC ODR-10::GFPAWA feminization
ODR-10
active tra-1
?
Herm.
ODR-10
Male
inactive tra-1
Neural sex establishes sexually different ODR-10 expression in AWA neurons
ODR-10
active tra-1
?
Herm.
ODR-10
Male
inactive tra-1
Neural sex establishes sex difference in a target gene to generate sex difference in a common behavior
Neural sex establishes sexually different ODR-10 expression in AWA neurons
Summary
• Distinct and characteristic sex differences in C. elegans olfactory behaviors
• Neural sex generates sex differences in a sensory function
• Sexual state of a single sensory neuron AWA establishes sex difference in a target gene expression
- a potential direct substrate of sex difference in a common sensory behavior
Genes
Circuit
Behavior
How do changes in gene expressions modify behaviors?
Sex
Genes
Circuit
Behavior
How do changes in gene expressions modify behaviors?
Sex
Environmental cues
Species
Implications on sex differences in the vertebrate nervous system
Y chromosome specific sex regulators,
the number of X chromosomes
Target genes (neuronal death, dendritic growth, ...)
Sex difference in the brain and behavior
Thank You
Thesis CommitteeRobert S. Freeman
Oliver Hobert (Columbia Univ.)Kathy W. Nordeen
Reagents/suggestionsCori Bargmann (Rockefeller Univ.)
Hillel Schwartz and Robert Horvitz (MIT)Jamie White and Erik Jorgensen (Univ. of Utah)
Caenorhabditis Genomics Center
Interdepartmental Graduate Program in NeuroscienceCenter for Neural Disease and Development
Autism SpeaksNIH (1R01GM086456-01)
Portman LabDouglas S. Portman, Ph.D.Margaret CasazzaDaryl Hurd, Ph.D. (Fisher)Stefani McGregor
Renee Miller, Ph.D.William MowreyNeda MuzaffarEdward VuongRiley O’Neil
Former membersKwi Lee (UB) Adam Mason, Ph.D. (Siena)
.