2
Page 1 of 2 Nevada Open-Records Law Procedures Frank X. Mullen | @FrankXMullen | [email protected] According to NRS 239.0107, government entities will respond to requests for inspection or copying of public books or records, with these actions: 1. Not later than the end of the fifth business day after the date on which the person who has legal custody or control of a public book or record of a governmental entity receives a request from a person to inspect or copy the public book or record, a governmental entity shall do one of the following, as applicable: (a) Allow the person to inspect or copy the public book or record. (b) If the governmental entity does not have legal custody or control of the public book or record, provide to the person, in writing: (1) Notice of that fact; and (2) The name and address of the governmental entity that has legal custody or control of the public book or record, if known. (c) Except as otherwise provided in paragraph (d), if the governmental entity is unable to make the public book or record available by the end of the fifth business day after the date on which the person who has legal custody or control of the public book or record received the request, provide to the person, in writing: (1) Notice of that fact; and (2) A date and time after which the public book or record will be available for the person to inspect or copy. If the public book or record is not available to the person to inspect or copy by that date and time, the person may inquire regarding the status of the request. (d) If the governmental entity must deny the person’s request to inspect or copy the public book or record because the public book or record, or a part thereof, is confidential, provide to the person, in writing: (1) Notice of that fact; and (2) A citation to the specific statute or other legal authority that makes the public book or record, or a part thereof, confidential. Types of Document Requests The person requesting the information may be directed to a state website (for example the Department of Health and Human Services is dhhs.nv.gov), and other state division websites, where many documents are posted online in PDF and/or Word format. However, experience indicates such data often is out-of-date or incomplete. State offices are notorious for long delays in posting reports, inspection data and other documents. When that happens, a call to the public information officer or agency director is in order. The PIOs or directors often will require staff to get a site up to date rather than have their agency be the star of a story about inefficient state government.

Nevada open records law procedures - seven habits of highly effective open-records users - frank x. mullen - las vegas news train - oct. 10-11, 2014

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

A handout from longtime investigative reporter Frank X. Mullen’s discussion on why and how to be an effective open-records hunter, with special emphasis on the Nevada open-records law. This presentation -- Seven Habits of Highly Effective Open-Records Users -- was part of the Las Vegas NewsTrain on Oct. 10-11, 2014. Please see associated handouts: Document Scanners, FOIA Tipsheet from IRE, Nevada Open-Records Law Procedures, Open-Records Resources and True-False on Nevada Public Records Law. NewsTrain is a traveling workshop for journalists sponsored by Associated Press Media Editors. For more information, visit http://www.apme.com/?AboutNewsTrain

Citation preview

Page 1: Nevada open records law procedures - seven habits of highly effective open-records users - frank x. mullen - las vegas news train - oct. 10-11, 2014

Page 1 of 2

Nevada Open-Records Law Procedures Frank X. Mullen | @FrankXMullen | [email protected]

According to NRS 239.0107, government entities will respond to requests for inspection or copying of public books or records, with these actions:

1. Not later than the end of the fifth business day after the date on which the person who has legal custody or control of a public book or record of a governmental entity receives a request from a person to inspect or copy the public book or record, a governmental entity shall do one of the following, as applicable:

(a) Allow the person to inspect or copy the public book or record.

(b) If the governmental entity does not have legal custody or control of the public book or record, provide to the person, in writing:

(1) Notice of that fact; and

(2) The name and address of the governmental entity that has legal custody or control of the public book or record, if known.

(c) Except as otherwise provided in paragraph (d), if the governmental entity is unable to make the public book or record available by the end of the fifth business day after the date on which the person who has legal custody or control of the public book or record received the request, provide to the person, in writing:

(1) Notice of that fact; and

(2) A date and time after which the public book or record will be available for the person to inspect or copy. If the public book or record is not available to the person to inspect or copy by that date and time, the person may inquire regarding the status of the request.

(d) If the governmental entity must deny the person’s request to inspect or copy the public book or record because the public book or record, or a part thereof, is confidential, provide to the person, in writing:

(1) Notice of that fact; and

(2) A citation to the specific statute or other legal authority that makes the public book or record, or a part thereof, confidential.

Types of Document Requests

The person requesting the information may be directed to a state website (for example the Department of Health and Human Services is dhhs.nv.gov), and other state division websites, where many documents are posted online in PDF and/or Word format. However, experience indicates such data often is out-of-date or incomplete. State offices are notorious for long delays in posting reports, inspection data and other documents. When that happens, a call to the public information officer or agency director is in order. The PIOs or directors often will require staff to get a site up to date rather than have their agency be the star of a story about inefficient state government.

Page 2: Nevada open records law procedures - seven habits of highly effective open-records users - frank x. mullen - las vegas news train - oct. 10-11, 2014

Page 2 of 2

A state agency is not required, nor is it obligated, to comply with a request for information that is not compiled or tracked as a standard procedure of the agency, or that is compiled or tracked in a different way by the agency. Further, the agency is not obligated to create new materials to comply with a public-record document request. However existing information can often be massaged into a format that is valuable to the reporter. If they don’t have the data the way you want it, fine; get it in whatever format they do have it.

Costs Associated with Requests

In accordance with NRS 239.055, if a request for copies or inspection of public books or records will require “extraordinary use of personnel or technological resources, including the redaction of personal or other privacy-protected information, a government entity may charge a reasonable fee” to comply with such an extraordinary request. Extraordinary use of personnel time is defined as being anything that requires one hour or more of staff time to comply with requests within a 30-day period. Staff time will also be determined to accompany the requester during his/her time reviewing the documents. State agencies often define “extraordinary requests for copies” as anything over 50 pages within a 30-day period. (For example, the standard fee charged by the Nevada Department of Health and Human Services for “extraordinary requests” includes exact costs to produce the documents, including staff time, but cannot exceed 50 cents per page.) Always negotiate costs and make the agency prove that your request is “extraordinary.” Argue when told you need a “minder” when you examine records, especially if they want to charge you for that person’s time. Such restrictions often are used to make it harder for people to access public documents. Get your editor, company lawyer or the Nevada Press Association involved if an agency seems to be creating unnecessary obstacles to accessing public records.

State agencies note that if the volume of copies requested would result in an “extended delay” if completed by state employees, the agency may have such work completed by a commercial copy service, the cost of which would be billed to the requester. If a fee is to be assessed, the requester will be notified. The Nevada Department of Health and Human Services policies, for example, state that: “Once the estimated fee has been determined, the requester must remit payment for the entire amount, payable to ‘DHHS-Director’s Office’ or to the appropriate DHHS Division completing the request, prior to the request being honored. If the actual fee is less than estimated, as quickly as possible, the requester will be mailed a check for the balance.” Negotiate (and, when appropriate, protest) any such restrictions up front. If there’s no mention of such obstacles, don’t bring them up. Don’t give them any ideas. Always ask for fee waivers because the request is related to the public good.

SOURCES: Nevada Revised Statutes; Nevada Department of Health and Human Services; the Nevada Press Association; and the Nevada Administrative Code.