20
Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments Emma Turner, Special Counsel 11 June 2014 #Insert FileSite Doc ID

Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Emma Turner, Russell Kennedy Special Counsel, explores the developments in the characterisation of instruments ‘of a legislative character’, challenges to the validity of instruments, and the relevance of rights in the scrutiny and interpretation of instruments.

Citation preview

Page 1: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

Emma Turner, Special Counsel

11 June 2014

#Insert FileSite Doc ID

Page 2: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

We will explore

• developments in the characterisation of instruments ‘of a legislative character’,

• challenges to the validity of instruments, and

• the relevance of rights in the scrutiny and interpretation of instruments.

Outline

Page 3: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

An instrument in writing:

• that is of a legislative character; and

• that is or was made in the exercise of a power delegated by the parliament.

(s5(1) LI Act)

See also sections 5-10 LI Act and section 15AE AI Act.

What is a legislative Instrument

3

Page 4: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

• Roche Products Pty Ltd v National Drugs and Poisons Schedule Committee (2007) 163 FCR 451 at 451-60 [1]-[41]

• Section 5(3) LI Act – an instrument that is registered is taken to be a legislative instrument

‘of a legislative character’

4

Page 5: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

Matters relevant to the distinction include:-

•Whether the decisions determined rules of general application or whether there was an application of rules to particular cases

•Whether there was Parliamentary control of the decision

•Whether there was public notification of the making of the regulation

•Whether there has been public consultation and the extent of any such consultation

•Whether there were broad policy considerations imposed

•Whether the regulation could be varied

•Whether the power was of executive variation or control

•Whether provision exists for merits review.

Legislative v administrative character

5

Page 6: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

Sea Shepherd Australia Ltd v Western Australia [2014] WASC 66

6

Page 7: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

Seafish Tasmania Pelagic Pty Ltd v Burke, Minister for Sustainability, Environment, Water Population and Communities (No 2) 2014117

Page 8: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

ADCO Constructions Pty Ltd v Goudappel [2014] HCA

• Accrued rights and retrospectivity

• Henry VII clauses

• Beneficial interpretation

8

Page 9: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

Can attract Parliamentary scrutiny

Can affect interpretation and validity

• Evans v NSW (2008) 168 FCR 576 cf. Harbour Radio v ACMA [2012]

Constitutional limits

• Can result in reading down

Relevance...

9

Page 10: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

• Constitutional rights

• Fundamental common law rights and liberties

• International human rights

Sources of rights

10

Page 11: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

• Express rights

• Implied freedom

• s15A AI Act applies – should be read down so as to be constitutionally valid (s 13(1)).

Constitutional rights

11

Page 12: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

see

• Levy v Victoria

• Coleman v Sellars [2001]

• Meyerhoff v Darwin City Council (2005)

• Attorney-General (SA) v Corporation of the Adeliade City Council [2013] HCA

Constitutional validity of delegated legislation

12

Page 13: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

• Senate Standing Committee on Regulations and Ordinances

• Pearce and Geddes [5.36] rights recognised by the courts

• Momcilovic v The Queen [2011] HCA 34 at [444] useful list of rights and liberties in judgment of Heydon J

Fundamental common law rights

13

Page 14: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

• fundamental rights cannot be overridden by general or ambiguous words: see Sargood Bros v Cth (1910); Melbourne Corporation v Barry (1983); Plaintiff S157/2000 v Cth of Australia (2003)

• Al-Kateb (2004)

• Al-Masri (2003)

• Momcilovic (2011)

Principle of legality

14

Page 15: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

• Human Rights (Parliamentary Scrutiny) Act 2011

• Grounds for invalidity? Wasantha v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] and Ashton v Commonwealth [2003]

International instruments

15

Page 16: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

• Absolute and non-derogable rights

• Internal limitations

• International standard for assessing compatibility

• Proportionality as ground in review of legislative instruments

Limits on rights

16

Page 17: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

Tips for reviewing and drafting instruments

Page 18: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

18

QUESTIONS

Page 19: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

The information contained in this presentation is intended as general commentary and should not be regarded as legal advice. Should you require specific advice on the topics or areas discussed please contact the presenter directly.

Disclaimer

19

Page 20: Current issues in drafting and interpreting legislative instruments

Emma TurnerSpecial Counsel

Telephone: +61 3 8602 7223Email: [email protected]

20