67
Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are: Linking Specific Aims & Program Evaluation to the Development of a Marketable Residency Brand Michael A. Gisondi, MD Residency Program Director Medical Education Fellowship Director Department of Emergency Medicine Director, Feinberg Academy of Medical Educators Northwestern University

Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are:

Linking Specific Aims & Program Evaluation to the Development

of a Marketable Residency Brand

Michael A. Gisondi, MDResidency Program Director

Medical Education Fellowship DirectorDepartment of Emergency Medicine

Director, Feinberg Academy of Medical EducatorsNorthwestern University

Page 2: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Disclosures

Credit Jeremy Branzetti, MD from U. Washington for significant portions of this presentation.

Previously co-presented at ACGME 2016 and as a webinar on the ACGME website.

@MikeGisondi@NorthwesternEM

Slides available onwww.slideshare.net

Page 3: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Let’s do an experiment!

Page 4: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 5: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 6: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 7: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 8: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 9: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

A more daring experiment…

Page 10: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Name 3 stereotypes that come to mind about…

Page 11: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Surgeons

Page 12: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Internists

Page 13: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Emergency Physicians

Page 14: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

My answers

Surgeons Internists

1. Act quickly2. Strong Egos3. Disciplined

EmergencyPhysicians

1. Intelligent2. Slow to act3. Rule Oriented

1. Act fast2. Cowboys3. Jack of all

trades

Page 15: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

PERCEPTION = REALITYIN BRANDING

Why does this matter?

Page 16: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Objectives1. Identify your residency program “brand” through creation of

clearly articulated vision/mission statements

2. Write at least one program specific aim for the ACGME self-study process

3. Critically assess the key components of their residency curricula for alignment with stated aims

4. Describe methods for assessing program metric(s) or outcome measures that meaningfully reflect their stated aims

5. Develop a tailored marketing strategy built upon program specific aims

Page 17: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Know Who You Are

Strategies for describing your program's vision, mission statement,

and specific aims

Goals

Page 18: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Be Who You Are

How to match specific aims to an existing residency curriculum and

how to best measure program metrics that directly link to stated aims

Goals

Page 19: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Show Who You Are

Use program outcomes and specific aims as part of a marketing strategy

that differentiates your program from peer institutions

Goals

Page 20: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

“To leave a legacy, you must first build something.”

Page 21: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 22: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 23: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

You…

Are a brand, like it or not

Should control the message rather than be subject to it

Have a target audience that will hear a message no matter what –

make sure it’s your message!

Page 24: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Who are your consumers?

Students Residency Recruitment

Prospective Faculty Searches

Public Patient Satisfaction

Your Chair Allotment of Dept $$$

Your DIO Allotment of Resources

Page 25: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Any of these situations apply?

Page 26: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Are you a New PD?

Page 27: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 28: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 29: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Stamping out rumors every recruitment season?

Page 30: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 31: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Key Elements of Strong Brands

Mission & VisionMessage

LogoMarketing Strategy

Page 32: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Consider a simple activity

1) Everyone with a program mission/vision, raise your hands2) Keep your hands up if you can recite it right now3) Keep your hands up if you think your APDs/Chair can recite it now4) Keep your hands up if you think your trainees can recite it now

Page 33: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Mission/Vision

Vision: Brief, few words, far-reaching, describes an ideal state, should fit on T-shirt• What is the ideal outcome of your program?

Mission: One sentence, grounded, inclusive, actionable, measureable• How do you plan to achieve your vision?

Page 34: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Small Group Activity

5 min

Part 1 Write down:– Your program’s Vision Statement– Your program’s Mission Statement

Part 2 Say Hi to your neighbors:– Name, Program, Administrative Role– Share your Vision and Mission Statements

Page 35: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

PROGRAM SPECIFIC AIMS

Page 36: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

You’ve started growing your

Brand…

Page 37: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Now define it objectively

Page 38: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

ACGME Self Study

Page 39: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

(Just Google “ACGME Self Study”)

Page 40: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

No one is an expert

Perspective

Page 41: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Expect the process to evolve over time

Perspective

Page 42: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Perspective

The ACGME website is a Self-Study “How-to”: 8-step guideWebinar

Self Study template APE templates

Page 43: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

What does it look like when the plan comes together?

• Yearly: Annual Program Evaluation (APE) occurs

• Over time: Serial APE data are accrued

• Self Study Notification: Prompts program to identify Program Aims

• Collected Data: Provides basis for how programs measure progress

Page 44: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 45: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

A (very paraphrased) Guide to Program Aims by Philip Shayne

• Guiding principle: What type of resident/fellow does your program aim to create?

• ACGME goal: Programs pursue continuous self-improvement

• Practical: Aim for both high-minded and low-hanging fruit

• Sweet spot: About 3 aims*

Page 46: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 47: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Clear Message

Know who you are, Be who you are

• Your message is stronger when it’s:– Authentic– Consistent– Clear– Authoritative– Credible– Aligned with the target audience

Page 48: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 49: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Small Group Activity

5 min

Part 1 Write down:• 1 or 2 Program Specific Aims

Part 2 With your neighbor:• Share your program aims• Share how you now measure your

program aims

Page 50: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 51: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Write Down:

Why is your program great?

Describe 3 strengths or unique attributes about your

curriculum.(in 1-3 sentences)

Page 52: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Discuss with your neighbor:

Should you rewrite your vision statement, mission statement, or specific aims based on the last

answer?(Edit as necessary!)

Page 53: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

MATCHING SPECIFIC AIMS TO MEASURABLE OUTCOMES

Page 54: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Program Identity: mission, vision, message

Measurable program Outcomes

Program Aims

Alignment

Page 55: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Disclaimer• Methods of formal program evaluation are outside

the scope of this lecture

• Find a friendly M.Ed. who has a special interest in program evaluation to help you

• Pick one of the several, well-regarded methods of program evaluation and use it as part of your self-study

• The ACGME website has APE and Self Study templates

Page 56: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

MAKE YOUR OWN MILESTONES

How can you create stable, uniform, and familiar Self Study metrics?

Page 57: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 58: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 59: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

LOGO

Page 60: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are
Page 61: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

MARKETING YOUR RESIDENCY BRAND

Page 62: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Marketing Strategy

• Three different marketing strategies required:1. Students or Residents2. Alumni 3. Medical Center – metrics, metrics, metrics!

• Overlap of message reinforces consistency

• All team members must be on board

Page 63: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

NUEM Example

• StudentsStrengths: (1) Critical Care Training

(2) Career Development(3) Job Placement

• AlumniRemind them why their employers love them(Efficiency, billing, patient satisfaction)

• Medical CenterStrive to have our ducks in a rowShare all the outcome measures we can

Page 64: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Small Group Activity

5 min

Part 1 Write down:– What are some elements of your marketing?– Who do you need to market to in 2017 Match?– How?

Part 2 Discuss with your neighbors:– Best Practices from your examples– What are the sticking points for you?

Page 65: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

What (if anything)did we learn today?

Page 66: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Summary

1. You’re a brand, like it or not

2. You can either lead with your message, or be reactive and constantly put out fires

3. Everyone should be on board with your vision, mission, and message – from chair to intern

4. Program ID Self Study Aims Outcome Metrics

5. But most importantly…

Page 67: Gisondi ACGME Know Who You Are, Be Who You Are, Show Who You Are

Know Who You Are,

Be Who You Are,

Show Who You Are!