Africa's Health Care Worker Crisis

Views from the Ground

Nurses outside of a clinic in Luwero, Uganda

The statistics are stark.• Africa suffers a shortage of approximately 1.5 million health

workers; some estimates are even higher.• African countries lose 20,000 skilled health workers per year,

with up to 60% of doctors trained in some countries migrating within two years of graduation.

• Africa suffers 24% of the global burden of disease but has only 3% of the global health workforce.

• Despite being the epicenter of the HIV/AIDS pandemic, less than 1% of the world’s health funding is spent in Africa.

A health worker displays the entire drug supply at a clinic in central Kampala, Uganda’s capitol city.

DENOSA, the national nursing union in South Africa, predicts that more than 300 specialist nurses leave the country every month.Source: The Joint Learning Initiative 2004

Above: A child sleeps in a hospital bed in Karamoja, one of the poorest and most underserved areas in

Uganda.

Senegal has 6 doctors per 100,000 people, the equivalent of having 36 doctors for the entire city of Boston.

Ask any African doctor or nurse, any relief worker or international health official working in Africa--the continent’s health worker shortage is a catastrophe.

It is caused by many factors: small government health budgets, recruitment by Western countries and research projects, and even the welcome availability of AIDS treatment, which is flooding clinics not unequipped to deal with so many people. But there are solutions.

“I want to become a doctor because there is so much suffering here. Africa is known as the sick continent, with more illness than anywhere else. I really want, in my small way, in my small area, to help Africa.

If year after year, we all go away, the Ugandan system will continue to crumble. What about our kids? What about the future of the country?”

--Stella Oolo, a Ugandan Medical Student

“Our overwhelming finding to date is that all life-saving programs, no matter how simple and obvious their potential implementation may seem, suffer from the enormous global deficit in skilled healthcare workers. The World Health Organization estimates there is currently a critical deficit of 2.4 million doctors, nurses and other healthcare professionals, meaning that people are already suffering and dying for lack of this pool of talent.”

--Laurie Garrett, member of the Global Health Program of the Council on Foreign Relations, June, 2007

Health workers are the engine that drive health systems.

A broken ambulance in Gulu, Uganda

What Causes the Health Worker Crisis in Africa?

#1 Low salaries and benefits#2 Severely limited training

and career opportunities#3 Shattered health systems#4 Inadequate occupational

safety#5 Migration to wealthy

nations#6 The impact of HIV/AIDS

Many factors contribute to the health workforce crisis in Africa. Most African health workers want to stay and practice medicine in their own country. However, a variety of challenges make it very hard for doctors and nurses to stay:

“I very much want to stay in Uganda but there is a big temptation to work abroad. We are offered peanuts in Uganda, and huge salaries in other countries.

Ugandan doctors make $250 a month—I have a relative in UK who makes 50 pounds PER HOUR. He makes as much in 4 hours as I would make in a month. Another friend’s uncle, a psychiatrist in the UK, makes 8,000 pounds per month.

Students have a passion to help their own people, but we need money.”

--Ronnie Kiweewa, a Ugandan Medical Student

Challenge #1: The Impact of Low Salaries

Ronnie (far right) and a group ofmedical student activists in front of Mulago Hospital in Uganda

We have almost 2 months off for Christmas holiday. I don’t want to stay home and do nothing, but there are no opportunities for us to do research so we can gain new insights and new skills.

We need activities that are free of charge and productive to expand our expertise.

--Ronnie Kiweewa, Makerere Medical School Student, Uganda

We do not have the information resources we need to learn.

We need new textbooks that are not old and outdated. We have no E-learning system—there are not enough computers.

--Nixon Niyonzima, Makerere Medical School Student, Uganda

Challenge #2: Severely Limited Training and Career Opportunities

Empty supply shelves in Rakai, Uganda

Challenge #3: Shattered Health Systems

Some hospitals have no hand soap, no disinfectant to clean operating rooms, no latex gloves, no masks, and limited essential medications. In some cases there may be only one health worker for an entire clinic, who is on call seven days per week.

A 2002 study by the Uganda Ministry of Health found fewer than 20% of clinics surveyed had electricity, only 66% had an on-site water source, only 40% had infection control provisions like sharps containers in place, and many lacked properly trained staff.

“The heath system is shattered.

Patients came to the clinic where I worked looking for medicine, but the only lab tech was gone. We could not send their samples for tests, so could only diagnose using clinical guidelines.

We can’t properly serve our patients this way, which is discouraging.”

--Nelson Igaba, a Ugandan School Student

“There is also the obvious problem of protection—we have not had access to Hepatitis B vaccinations or PEP (and) there is no guarantee of safety—no gloves, no drugs, no vaccines.”

--Nixon Nixonzima

Ugandan Medical Student

US and Ugandan health workers present a potential campaign on occupational safety and gloves for health workers at a symposium in Kampala

Challenge #4 Inadequate Occupational Safety

Challenge #5: Health Worker Shortages in Wealthy Nations

Developed countries have their own health workforce shortages, which are exacerbated by a lack of investment by these countries in health worker training. Many of these developed countries depend in part on African countries to subsidize their own health worker shortfalls.

This high demand, combined with high salaries and better facilities, is important to many health workers who want to both have access to cutting-edge technology to heal patients and earn enough to support their families and build a life.

A Western Union Billboard in Kampala Uganda shows a health worker in a developed country, with the latest medical equipment, sending money home to her family in Uganda--a common occurrence across the continent.

Left: A small clinic in Uganda administers drugs for opportunistic infections to a man whose daughter is dying of AIDS and was too sick herself to come to the clinic.

AIDS is exacerbating the health workforce crisis:

•The epidemic has put a major strain on already overburdened health systems and health workers, leading to stress and fatigue. •Across Africa, AIDS has killed thousands of health care workers. In South Africa, 16% of the current health workforce is HIV positive, and the Malawian government estimates they will lose nearly 3% of their workforce each year to the disease.

Challenge #6: The Impact of HIV/AIDS

While daunting, the health workforce crisis in Africa can be solved.

Innovative programs across the continent are helping alleviate health worker shortages:

• The COBES program in Uganda brings medical students to rural areas to teach and learn from the community, making it more likely student will work in rural areas upon graduation.

• In Swaziland, HIV positive health workers often forgo AIDS services at the same facilities as their patients, fearing a loss of trust and authority. As a result, a Wellness Center has been created to provide integrated and comprehensive services for about 6,000 health workers and their immediate families.

• In Ghana, the concentration of health workers in urban centers means there are almost no doctors in rural areas. With the help of the community, a mobile health professional is placed at a rural health center, greatly increasing health services, and other positive health outcomes.

YOU CAN HELP.

Support the Global HEALTH Act of 2010

The Global HEALTH Act of 2010 responds forcefully and comprehensively to health systems that are broken, with the health workers who are at the core of these systems often missing.

At the bill’s own core is a new Global Health Workforce Initiative to support a comprehensive approach to meeting their health workforce needs, including developing and implementing national

health workforce plans.

The Initiative would initially include at least 12 countries, with the bill authorizing $2 billion over five years to help countries recruit, train, retain, equitably distribute, and increase the effectiveness of

their health workforce.

Above: Medical students from Physicians for Human Rights and the American Medical Students Association demonstrated at the Toronto International AIDS conference in 2006 in solidarity with their African colleagues. Empty white coats symbolized the doctors and nurses missing from African countries.

Contact us to help!

For more information, contact PHR National student Program coordinator Hope O’Brien at hobrien@phrusa.org.