53
!"#$"%&'( *+$,,',& -./ "$("'($+ ',,01$"'0, 23456748 !9::48 '.;<5954 =-8/> ?488@:-. A9.4 BCD BEFB

Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Strategic planning and tactical choices are essential considerations in effective civil resistance. This session offers a strategic framework with which to analyze civil resistance movements. It also examines numerous tactics available to civil resisters, and explores issues involved in tactical choice, success and failure.

Citation preview

Page 1: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

!"#$"%&'()*+$,,',&)-./)

"$("'($+)',,01$"'0,)

23456748)!9::48)'.;<5954)

=-8/>)?488@:-.)

A9.4)BCD)BEFB)

Page 2: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

*84;4.5-<G.)[email protected])

FH  "74)#G34)GI)!58-54J>)

BH  "-6<6;)

KH  L7-5)?-M4;)"-6<6;)%N46<O4P)

Page 3: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

*-85)FQ)

"=%)#0+%)02)!"#$"%&R)

Page 4: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

$)S4T.@<G.)GI)!58-54J>)

$)U3-.)GI)-6<G.)G8)UG3@6>)/4;@J.4/)5G)-67@4O4)-)

:-VG8)G8)GO48-33)-@:H)!58-54J>)@;)574)@/4-)GI)7GW)-)

[email protected]);589JJ34);7-33)/4O43GUD)-./)7GW)@5;)

;4U-8-54)6G:UG.4.5;);7-33)X4)TY4/)5GJ45748)5G)

6G.58@X954):G;5)-/O-.5-J4G9;3>)5G)-67@4O4)@5;)

GXV46<O4;H)'5)-3;G)6GG8/@.-54;)-./)/@8465;)-33)

-UU8GU8@-54)-./)-O-@3-X34)84;G9864;)Z79:-.D)

UG3@<6-3D)46G.G:@6D):G8-3D)456H[)GI)574)J8G9U)5G)

-Y-@.)@5;)GXV46<O4;)@.)-)6G.\@65H))

Page 5: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

$)S4T.@<G.)GI)"-6<6)

$)3@:@54/)U3-.)GI)-6<G.)X-;4/)G.)-)6G.64U<G.)GI)

7GWD)@.)-)84;58@654/)U7-;4)GI)-)6G.\@65D)5G)9;4)

4N46<O43>)574)-O-@3-X34):4-.;)GI)-6<G.)5G)-67@4O4)

-);U46@T6)3@:@54/)GXV46<O4H)"-6<6;)-84)@.54./4/)IG8)

9;4)@.)@:U34:4.<.J)-)W@/48);58-54J>)@.)-)U7-;4)GI)

574)GO48-33)6G.\@65H))

Page 6: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

L-@5D)/G4;);58-54J>):-Y48P)

Page 7: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

!"#$%"$#&'(#')*&+%,-'

Page 8: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

!58965984;](G./@<G.;)

•  $:G9.5)GI)GU4.)UG3@<6-3)

;U-64)@.)-);G6@45>)

•  0UU84;;G8 ;̂)W@[email protected];;)5G)9;4)[email protected]])84U84;;@G.)

•  '.548.-<G.-3]4_548.-3);9UUG85)IG8)GUU84;;G8)G8)

:GO4:4.5)

•  %/96-<G.-3)34O43)GI)574);G6@45>)

•  *GO485>)34O43)GI)574);G6@45>)

•  *84;4.64)GI)-):@//34)63-;;)

•  *84;4.64)GI)@./4U4./4.5):4/@-)

•  ,-5984)GI)574)UG3@<6-3)43@54;)@.)-)6485-@.)6G9.58>)

•  $)6G9.58> ;̂)6935984)•  *G3@<6-3)7@;5G8>)GI)-)6G9.58>)•  &4GUG3@<6-3).4@J7XG87GG/)•  S4J844)GI)@.548.45)I844/G:)

Page 9: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

!M@33;]$J4.6>)

•  [email protected])-)9.@I>@.J)O@;@G.)

•  [email protected]);58-54J>)-./)6-:U-@J.;)

•  !4346<.J)-67@4O-X34D);U46@T6)GXV46<O4;)

•  !4346<.J)-UU8GU8@-54)5-6<6;)

•  "-6<6-3)@..GO-<G.)-./);4`[email protected])

•  (G.64.58-<.J);584.J57;)

•  (84-<.J)4N46<O4)6G::9.@6-<G.;)

•  '/4.<I>@.J)W4-M.4;;4;)•  a9@3/@.J)6G-3@<G.;)•  b./48;5-./@.J)U4GU34 ;̂)

3G>-3<4;)5G)574);5-59;)`9G)

-./)5-8J4<.J)57G;4)

3G>-3<4;)

Page 10: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

!58-54J>)?-Y48;)

!58-54J>)@;)-);[email protected])-./)-.)-85H))a95)57484)@;).G)

IG8:93-H)

!58-54J>)6-.)743U)-):GO4:4.5)GO486G:4)

-/O48;4)6G./@<G.;H)

Page 11: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

!58-54J>)S@-J8-:)

"7844)+4O43;)GI)!58-54J>)

1@;@G.)

(-:U-@J.;)

"-6<6;)

Page 12: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

!58-54J>)S@-J8-:)

"7844)+4O43;)GI)!58-54J>)

1@;@G.)

(-:U-@J.;)

"-6<6;)

Page 13: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

,G)!58-54J>)

b.6GG8/@.-54/)1@;@G.D)(-:U-@J.;D)-./)"-6<6;)

Page 14: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

,G)!58-54J>)

b.6GG8/@.-54/)1@;@G.D)(-:U-@J.;D)-./)"-6<6;)

“Tactics without strategy is the noise before defeat.”

-- Anonymous

Page 15: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Campaigns: Montgomery bus boycott

Downtown Nashville boycott

Page 16: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

(-:U-@J.;Q)

*G85)%3@c-X457)aG>6GYD)!G957)$I8@6-D)Fdef)

Page 17: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

(-:U-@J.;Q)

"74)!-35)?-867)GI)FdKE)

•  !-35)?-867)

•  #4U3-64:4.5)34-/48;)-g48)-884;5)

•  !59/4.5;)W@57/8-W)I8G:)JGO48.:4.5);67GG3;)

•  *@6M4<.J)3@`9G8);5G84;)

•  !G6@-3)XG>6GY;)

•  #4U3-64:4.5)34-/48;)-g48)-884;5)

•  [email protected])5G);-35)/4UG5;)

•  !-35)8-@/;)

•  aG>6GY)GI)a8@<;7)63G57)

Page 18: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

*-85)BQ)

"$("'(!)

Page 19: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation
Page 20: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation
Page 21: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

What is Civil Resistance?

Page 22: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

L7-5)@;)(@O@3)#4;@;5-.64Ph)

(@O@3)84;@;5-.64)@;)-)W->)IG8)U4GU34)5G)W@43/)UGW48)

W@57G95)9;@.J)[email protected]))'5)6G.;@;5;)GIQ)

) )-H)-65;)GI)6G::@;;@G.i)

) )XH)-65;)GI)G:@;;@G.i)G8)

) )6H)XG57)

a-;4/)G.)574)/4T.@<G.)GI)j,[email protected])$6<G.k)@.Q))

&4.4)!7-8UD)"74)*G3@<6;)GI),[email protected])$6<G.D))

aG;5G.Q)*G8548)!-8J4.5)*9X3@;748;D)FdlK)

Page 23: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

L7-5)@;)(@O@3)#4;@;5-.64Ph)

(@O@3)84;@;5-.64)@;)-)W->)IG8)U4GU34)5G)W@43/)UGW48)

W@57G95)9;@.J)[email protected]))'5)6G.;@;5;)GIQ)

) )-H)-65;)GI)6G::@;;@G.i)

) )XH)-65;)GI)G:@;;@G.i)G8)

) )6H)XG57)

a-;4/)G.)574)/4T.@<G.)GI)j,[email protected])$6<G.k)@.Q))

&4.4)!7-8UD)"74)*G3@<6;)GI),[email protected])$6<G.D))

aG;5G.Q)*G8548)!-8J4.5)*9X3@;748;D)FdlK)

Page 24: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

!7-8U ;̂)(3-;;@T6-<G.)GI)"-6<6;)

FH  ,[email protected])U8G54;5)-./)U48;9-;@G.))BH  ,G.6GGU48-<G.)•  !G6@-3)

•  %6G.G:@6)

•  *G3@<6-3)

KH  ,[email protected])'.548O4.<G.)

Page 25: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

FH)*8G54;5)-./)*48;9-;@G.)

%_-:U34;Q)*4<<G.;D)8-33@4;D)34Y48;D)7-./@.J)G95)

3@548-5984D)/@;U3->@.J);>:XG3;D);@[email protected]);G.J;D);58445)

574-584D)O@J@3;D)U9X3@6);5-54:4.5;D)!?!):4;;-J4;D)

W4X;@54;D)456H)

•  0g4.)574)T8;5)-./):G;5)I84`94.53>)9;4/)GI)5-6<6;)

•  ?->)X4)@.;[email protected])X>)574:;43O4;)5G)W@.)-J-@.;5)

5G9J7)GUUG.4.5;)

Page 26: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

BH),G.6GGU48-<G.)

%_-:U34;Q)

•  *G3@<6-3Q)84;@J.-<G.;D)W@57/8-W-3)I8G:)JGO48.:4.5)

@.;<59<G.;D)W@577G3/@.J)@.IG8:-<G.)I8G:)574)JGO48.:4.5)

•  %6G.G:@6Q)6G.;9:48)XG>6GYD)845-@3)XG>6GYD);46G./-8>)

XG>6GYD);58@M4D);3GW/GW.D)W-3M)G95D);@[email protected]);5->n-5n7G:4D)

84I9;-3)5G)U->)84.5D)W@57/8-W-3)GI)X-.M)/4UG;@5;D)/@O4;5:4.5)

•  !G6@-3Q)G;58-6@;:D)W@57/8-W-3)I8G:)4O4.5;D);G6@-3)

/@;GX4/@4.64D)-OG@/-.64D);9;U4.;@G.)GI);G6@-3)-6<O@<4;)Z@H4H)

;UG85;D)I4;<O-3;D)456H[)

Page 27: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

BH),G.6GGU48-<G.)

•  #4`9@84):-.>)U4GU34)5G)X4)4N46<O4)

•  ?->)4.5-@3)7@J7)G8)3GW)8@;M)-./)<:4)

@.O4;5:4.5)

•  %.-X34)X8G-/);G6@45-3)U-8<6@U-<G.)X>)/@O48;4)J8G9U;)@.);G6@45>)

•  148>)UGW48I93H))"74>)684-54)-):-VG8)/@;89U<G.)

W74.)4N46<O4)

Page 28: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

KH),[email protected])'.548O4.<G.)

%_-:U34;Q)(@O@3)/@;GX4/@4.64D)684-<.J)U-8-3343)

@.;<59<G.;D);@[email protected])X3G6M-/@.J)X9@3/@.J;)

•  0g4.)/@84653>)/@;89U<O4)-./)6G.I8G.5-<G.-3)•  b;9-33>)6-88>)-)7@J748)34O43)GI)8@;M)•  0g4.)84`9@84);58@65)/@;6@[email protected])•  (-.)X4)4N46<O4)4O4.)@I)-)I4W)U4GU34)/G)574:)

Page 29: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

$)*8GUG;4/)2G9857)(-54JG8>Q)

(84-<.J)$3548.-<O4)'.;<59<G.;)

%_-:U34;Q);67GG3;D)6GGU48-<O4;D)[email protected])@.;<59<G.;D)

V9/@6@-3]6G.\@65)84;G39<G.)@.;<59<G.;D)I-8:;D)

-3548.-<O4)T.-.6@-3)@.;<59<G.;D)6G::9.@5>);48O@64)

G8J-.@c-<G.;D)3G6-3)69884.6@4;D)[email protected]);>;54:;)

•  a9@3/)6-U-6@5>)Z79:-.)-./):-548@-3)84;G9864;D);M@33;D)

6G.;6@G9;.4;;[)

•  a9@3/)-95G.G:>)-./);[email protected])

•  a9@3/)6@O@3);G6@45>)•  !45)574);5-J4)IG8)4-;@48)58-.;@<G.)

Page 30: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

"-6<6;)(3-;;@T6-<G.)X>)0956G:4)

"-6<6;)6-.)-3;G)X4)63-;;@T4/)-66G8/@.J)5G)574@8)@.54./4/)

G956G:4;D)IG8)4_-:U34Q)

"-6<6;)6-.Q)

o  a9@3/)6-U-6@5>)p)@H4H):44<.J;D)6G::9.@5>);48O@64D)

I8-548.@[email protected])4;5-X3@;[email protected]);67GG3;)

o  (G::9.@6-54)p)@H4H);U44674;D)34-\45;D)U84;;)6G.I484.64;D)

.4W;U-U48;D);3GJ-.;)

o  $Y-6M]:GX@3@c4)p)@H4H)U8G54;5):-8674;D)X3G6M-/4;D);58@M4;D)

XG>6GY;D)U@6M4<.JD)6@O@3)/@;GX4/@4.64)

Page 31: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

"-6<6; Classification by Density

(G.64.58-<G. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )))))S@;U48;@G.)

Page 32: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

*-85)KQ)

L=$")?$q%!)"$("'(!)

%22%("'1%P)

Page 33: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

0XV46<O4;)

Page 34: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Objectives

Tactics are more effective when they are used for objectives that are:

•  Clearly defined •  Achievable •  Attract wide support •  Connect to a strategy

Page 35: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Objectives

Page 36: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Objectives

Page 37: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Objectives

Page 38: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

?4;;-J4)

Page 39: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Message

A tactic’s accompanying message can account for 50% or more of the tactic’s success. Effective messages:

•  unite a movement’s supporters •  divide an opponent’s supporters

Page 40: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

2. Messages

Page 41: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

2. How is the Message Conveyed

Focus – How threatening is the message to the status quo? Is the message addressing a political or a non-political issue?

Justification -- Is the movement invoking cultural values, religion, widely held beliefs, patriotism and/or its opponent’s own stated values and laws?

Emotion and Appearance -- Are the participants peaceful, aggressive, angry, steadfast, afraid, concerned, vengeful, threatening, disciplined, reasonable, extreme, confident, strong, clear?

Messenger -- Consider social distance between the messenger and the intended audience.

Page 42: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

"-6<6-3)'..GO-<G.)

Page 43: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

"-6<6-3)'..GO-<G.)

%N46<O4)5-6<6;)-84)Gg4.)@..GO-<O4H)))

"74);-:4)5-6<6):->)X4)/G.4)-5)-).4W)3G6-<G.D)

<:@.JD)U-8<[email protected];D)5-8J45D):4;;-J4D)G8)@.)-)

.4W)W->)

08)-.)4.<843>).4W)5-6<6):->)X4)9;4/H)

Page 44: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

"-6<6-3)'..GO-<G.)

Corporation

Page 45: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

"-6<6-3)'..GO-<G.)

Corporation

Unions/ Workers Management

Financing

Transportation workers/unions

Stores

Consumers

Leaders

Middlemen Distribution

Page 46: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Tactical Innovation

Corporation

Unions/ Workers Management

Financing

Transportation workers/unions

Stores

Consumers

Leaders

Middlemen Distribution

Page 47: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Tactical Innovation

Corporation

Unions/ Workers Management

Financing

Transportation workers/unions

Stores

Consumers

Leaders

Middlemen Distribution

Page 48: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Tactical Innovation

Corporation

Unions/ Workers Management

Financing

Transportation workers/unions

Stores

Consumers

Leaders

Middlemen Distribution

Page 49: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Tactical Innovation

Corporation

Unions/ Workers Management

Financing

Transportation workers/unions

Stores

Consumers

Leaders

Middlemen Distribution

Page 50: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Tactical Innovation

Corporation

Unions/ Workers Management

Financing

Transportation workers/unions

Stores

Consumers

Leaders

Middlemen Distribution

Page 51: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

Lessons Learned?

Corporation

Unions/ Workers Management

Financing

Transportation workers/unions

Stores

Consumers

Leaders

Middlemen Distribution

Page 52: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

j"74)W7G34)4;;4.64)GI)[email protected])-6<G.)@;)

J4r.J)-)3G5)GI)U4GU34)@.OG3O4/D)O-;5).9:X48;)

/[email protected])3@Y34)[email protected];H))'5 ;̂)/@m6935)5G)J45)U4GU34)

@.OG3O4/)@.)-)U@6M45)[email protected])X46-9;4)@5)5-M4;)574@8)

<:4H))a95)-.>)<:4)-)U48;G.)6-.)X4)U48;9-/4/)

.G5)5G)4-5)-)J8-U4)s)57-5 ;̂)@.OG3O4:4.5D)57-5 ;̂)

574):G;5)/@846<G.)-6<G.D)-./)@5 ;̂);45)9U)@.)

;967)-)W->)57-5)4O48>XG/>)6-.)U-8<6@U-54Hk)

s)(4;-8)(7-O4c)

Page 53: Strategic Planning and Tactical Innovation

!G9864;)

SG9J3-;)$H)AG7.;G.D)j"74),44/)IG8),4W)"-6<6;k)@.)!"#$%&'(')$*+$,-.&+$/*012)3$4$/")5-6'"$756$86&'((5+"6)H)[email protected]@;Q)"74)(4.548)IG8)1@6<:;)

GI)"G85984[D)BEEf)

SG9J)?6$/-:D)j"-6<6-3)'..GO-<G.)-./)574)*-64)GI)'.;98J4.6>kD)4."6*'&+$95'*5:50*'&:$/";*"#D)1G3H)feD),GH)t)ZS46HD)FdeK[D)UUH)lKCnlCf)

%34-.G8)?-867-.5D)$867)*9//@.J5G.D)j%[email protected])%.O@8G.:4.5;)IG8)(@O@6)

?GO4:4.5;)-./)574)S>.-:@6;)GI)S4:G68-<6)"8-.;@<G.k)ZL-;[email protected])S(Q)

2844/G:)=G9;4[D)BEEe)

&4.4)!7-8UD)%1"$85:*(')$57$!5+;*5:"+2$4'(5+D)ZaG;5G.Q)*G8548)!-8J4.5)*9X3@;748;[D)FdeK)

=-8/>)?488@:-.)j(-3@IG8.@-)&8-U4)LG8M48;)!58@M4)-./)aG>6GYpFdtCnFdlEk)

@.)&4.4)!7-8UD)<&0*+0$!5+;*5:"+2$926-00:"D)ZaG;5G.D)*G8548)!-8J4.5)*9X3@;748;[D)BEEC)