23
Research with Animals Phil 133 – Ethics in Science San José State University

"Research with Animals" lecture

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Slides for the class meeting on research with animals in Phil 133 ("Ethics in Science") at San Jose State University.

Citation preview

Page 1: "Research with Animals" lecture

Research with Animals

Phil 133 – Ethics in ScienceSan José State University

Page 2: "Research with Animals" lecture

In discussing animal-based research, need to distinguish:

• Scientific issues.• Ethical issues.• Legal/regulatory issues.

Page 3: "Research with Animals" lecture

Ethical issues:

• Do we have ethical obligations to non-human animals? (Always? In special circumstances?)

• Do non-human animals have rights? (Where do rights come from? What follows from having rights?)

• What kind of use or treatment of non-human animals is ethically permissible? Ethically required?

Page 4: "Research with Animals" lecture

Animal rights:

• If animals cannot consent to X, humans cannot do X without violating animals’ rights.

• Rule of thumb: if you couldn’t ethically do X to a human infant, you cannot ethically do X to a human animal.

Page 5: "Research with Animals" lecture

Animal welfare:

• Pain, distress, suffering, boredom or non-human animals ought to be minimized.

• While we have duties to animals’ welfare, animals fall short of having rights.

Page 6: "Research with Animals" lecture

Recognizing the range of positions available, or represented.

Page 7: "Research with Animals" lecture

The challenge: societal views about animals vary widely.

• Some people committed to animal rights.• Some people committed to animal welfare.• Some people committed to neither animal

rights nor animal welfare.

Page 8: "Research with Animals" lecture

Scientific research with animals:

• Aimed at learning more about non-human animals themselves (plus broader issues like comparative anatomy and physiology, evolution, development, genetics, etc.).

• Use of animal models to answer questions about human (and animal) health.

Page 9: "Research with Animals" lecture

Scientific questions:

• What can experiments with organism X tell us about the functioning or response of organism Y in analogous conditions? (How much similarity vs. difference?)

• What counts as an appropriate model organism for a particular research question?

Page 10: "Research with Animals" lecture

Alternatives to research with animals:

• Tissue culture studies (but culture media are animal-derived)

• Computer simulations (but accurate simulation depends on accurate information about the system you’re simulating)

Page 11: "Research with Animals" lecture

Federal regulations:

• Laboratory Animal Welfare Act (1966)• U.S. Dept. of Agriculture rules• AWA Amendments of 1970 and 1985.• Nine U.S. Government Principles for the

Utilization and Care of Vertebrate Animals in Testing, Research, and Training.

Page 12: "Research with Animals" lecture

Also regulations from funding agencies:

• National Institutes of Health Policy of 1971• Health Research Extension Act• Public Health Service Policy

Page 13: "Research with Animals" lecture

At colleges and universities:

• Oversight through Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC).

• IACUC reviews and monitors animal use protocols.

• Assures compliance of institutions animal care program and facilities.

• Investigates animal welfare concerns.

Page 14: "Research with Animals" lecture

IACUC membership:

• Veterinarian with training/experience in laboratory animal science and medicine

• Practicing scientist experienced in research involving animals

• Someone unaffiliated with the institution• Non-scientist (representing interests of the

public)

Page 15: "Research with Animals" lecture

What must be described in protocols?

• Project justification:o Scientific aims of study.o Relevance and value of the research. (Why

does it matter to answer this question?)o How this work is novel (and doesn’t

unnecessarily duplicate previous research).

Page 16: "Research with Animals" lecture

What must be described in protocols?

• Rationale for using animals:o Proper identification of species to be used

(and number of animals).o Appropriate species (in terms of anatomy,

physiology, etc.) for the research question?o Are all the proposed study methods necessary

to obtain valuable results?

Page 17: "Research with Animals" lecture

Reduction, replacement, refinement (the 3 R’s):

• Smallest number of animals to get reliable and statistically significant results?

• Does proposed protocol address whether nonliving tissue or inanimate models can be used to achieve the scientific goal?

• Procedures designed to impose least amount of potential pain, discomfort, stress, morbidity, or mortality on the animal?

Page 18: "Research with Animals" lecture

Must explicitly consider availability of alternatives.

• “For procedures involving more than momentary or slight pain and distress, the principal investigator must provide a written narrative describing the methods and sources used to determine that alternatives to painful or distressful procedures were not available.”

USDA Policy 12

Page 19: "Research with Animals" lecture

Assessing pain and distress:

“Unless the contrary is established, investigators should consider that procedures that cause pain or distress in human beings may cause pain or distress in other animals.”

U.S. Government Principles – Part IV

Page 20: "Research with Animals" lecture

Pain and Distress Categories

• C-1: None anticipated• C-2: Momentary or no pain and discomfort• C-3: Management of mild to moderate pain

(protocol should details plans to relieve suffering, supplement care)

Page 21: "Research with Animals" lecture

Pain and Distress Categories

• C-4: Alleviation of substantial pain or discomfort with analgesics and supportive care.(Research requires physical documentation of actual steps taken to alleviate.)

• C-5: Research where management or alleviation of pain or discomfort is contraindicated.(Requires clear scientific justification.)

Page 22: "Research with Animals" lecture

Animal research as a privilege, not a right.

• Principal investigator must get approval from IACUC to conduct research.

• IACUC does not automatically approve new submissions or annual reviews of previously approved protocols.

• Dialogue between PI and IACUC members to ensure good science while minimizing the ethical cost.

Page 23: "Research with Animals" lecture

Current climate for researchers in larger society:

• Recent history of violent attacks (especially in California).

• Public isn’t always clear on what scientific questions are being pursued, what kind of research is required to answer them.

• Public opinion not uniform (animal lovers, patients in need of cures, those who are both)

• Basic vs. applied research.