66
Moving my own goal posts Ashley Casey University of Bedfordshire Dcysiv Moment's Flickr photostream

Moving goal posts

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

A presentation on my reflective journey as a teacher of physical education made to the 16th International Reflective Practice conference, University of Bedfordshire, June 2010.

Citation preview

Page 1: Moving goal posts

Moving my own

goal posts

Ashley CaseyUniversity of Bedfordshire

Dcysiv Moment's Flickr photostream

Page 2: Moving goal posts

About me

Page 3: Moving goal posts

ellenmac11’s Flickr photostream

Teacher

Page 4: Moving goal posts

Geri-Jean’s Flickr photostream

Page 5: Moving goal posts

TeacherTeacher Educator

Page 6: Moving goal posts

AuthorAuthor

Geri-Jean’s Flickr photostream

Page 7: Moving goal posts

Reflective Practitioner

Page 8: Moving goal posts

Journal Writer

NG71’s Flickr photostream

Page 9: Moving goal posts

BLOGGER

Page 10: Moving goal posts

Twee

ter

Page 11: Moving goal posts

My

Reflective

aim

Page 12: Moving goal posts

I sought to change, or at least challenge, the underlying theory of teaching that I inherited from my profession.

Trevira’s Flickr photostream

Page 13: Moving goal posts

A brief

History

Page 14: Moving goal posts

We learn because we do and subsequently undergo the consequences of our doing.

Biesta (2007, p.14)

Omar Junior’s Flickr photostream

Page 15: Moving goal posts

noqontrol’s Flickr photostream

the complex processes I underwent as I set about making pedagogical and curricular changes in my teaching.

Page 16: Moving goal posts

teaching in physical education is limited to instruction in technique for the betterment of inter-school sport.

Peter Edmund’s Flickr photostream

Page 17: Moving goal posts

the dominant pedagogy hasn’t noticeably changed for half a century (Kirk, 2010)

UNO Criss Library’s Flickr photostream

Page 18: Moving goal posts

“dominant competitive, aggressive, not-too-bright individual … (the) companionable ‘man (sic) of action’, but not someone with whom to engage in professional dialogue”Whitehead & Hendry (1976, p.75)

RinkRatz's Flickr photostream

Page 19: Moving goal posts

reflective practice has had little to do with teachers’ continued professional development.

Page 20: Moving goal posts

that innocence in teaching meant that, as teachers, we believed that we knew what we are doing and how we were affecting our pupils

(Brookfield, 1995)

dgray_xplane’s Flickr photostream

Page 21: Moving goal posts

practice is lagging well behind the needs of the 21st Century (Lawson, 2009).

Old Shoe Woman’s Flickr photostream

Page 22: Moving goal posts

It is through the process of knowing ourselves

that the gap between our personal theories and personal practice is noticed.

Phantom_snapper's Flickr photostream

Page 23: Moving goal posts

As a ‘man of action’ I finally began to develop my personal knowledge and understanding of my own practices.

Tinker*Tailor's Flickr photostream

Page 24: Moving goal posts

I adopted a non-traditional approach to teaching and learning as a result of my self-reflections.

Page 25: Moving goal posts

Through the ‘stories’ of a reflection diary that I wrote daily for nearly two years I experienced a number of “‘aha’ moments of ‘oh, I see’ (Bolton, 2005, p. xv).

alexhd57's Flickr photostream

Page 26: Moving goal posts

The idea is that of an educational science in which every classroom is a laboratory, each teacher a member of the scientific community.

Stenhouse (1977, p. 142)

Research functions not as a distraction from practice but as a development of it.

Schön (1983, p. ix)

Lady-bug's Flickr photostream

Page 27: Moving goal posts

My classrooms were private places where the only valued contributions were mine

Smart Went Crazy.'s Flickr photostream

Page 28: Moving goal posts

Board of Education (1902)

The teacher should carry a staff, a barbell, or dumb-bells, according to the instruction which the class is receiving; he should teach as much as possible by illustration; and he will be careful, in order to stimulate the intelligence and interest of the children, to explain clearly, in simple terms, the reason for every movement and formation.

Botrash‘s Flickr photostream

Page 29: Moving goal posts

By replacing the barbell with a rugby ball this image of didactic delivery became a familiar and significant part of my education

Spyros_Tav‘s Flickr photostream

Page 30: Moving goal posts

the selective traditions of curriculum construction and pedagogical practices

(Lingard, 2007, p. 246)

Hulikal’s Flickr photostream

Page 31: Moving goal posts

I was able to employ reflective practice

to examine the ways in which I taught

Page 32: Moving goal posts

I was most definitely one of those teachers who “worked hard for continuity without knowing it, in the sense that [I was] frightfully conservative, never made a move and was resistant to change”

(Briault, 1974, p. 6).

idogu’s Flickr photostream

Page 33: Moving goal posts

My dominant

voice

Page 34: Moving goal posts

I felt that I had learnt some significant lessons about the type of teacher that I wanted to be and was a good way towards achieving this goal.

Page 35: Moving goal posts

I had spoken an incredible

2265 words on 115 separate occasions in a lesson lasting

27 mins and 46sec.

Strep72’s Flickr photostream

Page 36: Moving goal posts

reflection

Page 37: Moving goal posts

the willingness of the practitioner to do something ‘outside the box’ within the context in which they teach

SteveFE’s Flickr photostream

Page 38: Moving goal posts

Location

Location

Location

Page 39: Moving goal posts

the differences in schools are less significant than the similarities they have with other schools (Kirk, 2010)

Page 40: Moving goal posts

The curriculum is a noticeable way through which the academic demands of the school are managed

Page 41: Moving goal posts

There are aspects of school life

that pupils teachers must master

Bob merco’s Flickr photostream

Page 42: Moving goal posts

These institutional demands

require staff and pupils to adopt coping strategies.

Mina Sharif's Flickr photostream

Page 43: Moving goal posts

It’s when you see the curriculum in action that the notion of traditional comes home to roost: certainly from the physical education perspective

Miami U. Libraries – Digital Collection’s Flickr photostream

Page 44: Moving goal posts

A school’s culture is based upon school norms: “shared beliefs, values, principles, and assumptions that guide patterns of behaviour.”

Rovegno and Bandhauer (1997, p. 401)

Joseph_2166’s Flickr photostream

Page 45: Moving goal posts

As seen from the road, the school sits behind several acres of well-maintained fields, cut short to allow the traditional English sports to be played on its not particularly hallowed ground.

Shook Photos’s Flickr photostream

Page 46: Moving goal posts

The school clings to its traditions, although the pupils constantly strive to achieve individuality in the way they wear their ties and blazers.

lovedaylemoin’s Flickr photostream

Page 47: Moving goal posts

(Erik)’s Flickr photostream

A lesson influenced by time. They were late for a 35 minute lesson, cutting down our working time to 16 minutes.

Athletics Unit Diary

Page 48: Moving goal posts

frequentwearisome

annoyed

Page 49: Moving goal posts

The difference between what teachers feel that they could achieve and what they actually ‘pull off’

(Lawson, 1993).

Page 50: Moving goal posts

Refelection

Page 51: Moving goal posts

I needed to find new ways of dealing with the traditions of the school and of education.

soccerrach88's Flickr photostream

Page 52: Moving goal posts

Relocating

myself

Page 53: Moving goal posts

Much of the change in my pedagogy had been about understanding my own teaching by understanding “the curriculum of [my] students”

(Connelly & Clandinin, 1988, p. 31)

ellie,!'sFlickr photostream

Page 54: Moving goal posts

“rapid socialisation into a redundant occupational culture and the obsolete practices it sustains”

Elliott (1991, p. 7).

abluedude's Flickr photostream

Page 55: Moving goal posts

My way out of this institutional socialisation was to explore alternatives to the ‘infallible expert model.’

Elliott (1991)

Page 56: Moving goal posts

Reflection as the glue to theoretically-informed practice

Sam Catchesides''s Flickr photostream

Page 57: Moving goal posts

I started thinking less about the theory of the approaches per se and more about the ways of using them effectively and appropriately in my teaching.

Page 58: Moving goal posts

I had a concomitant ‘quality control system’ from my academic colleagues, my regular reading of theory and my reflective practices.

{tnarik‘s Flickr photostream

Page 59: Moving goal posts

an understanding greater than that expected of

both a teacher and an academic, But more profoundly perhaps for a “not-too-bright individual”

Whitehead and Hendry (1976, p.75).

Page 60: Moving goal posts

This ability to reflectively apply theory to practice allowed me to enhance the teaching, learning and content processes of the school and its participants.

Page 61: Moving goal posts

My teaching has taken a proactive, reflective journey alongside my evolving personal theory.

Page 62: Moving goal posts

Positively interdependent participants with shared goal

New pitch?: New goals to move

{ sheila }‘s Flickr photostream

Page 63: Moving goal posts

ellenmac11’s Flickr photostream

Teacher

Page 64: Moving goal posts

TeacherTeacher Educator

Page 65: Moving goal posts

I continue to de-privatise my classrooms, locating my reflections, my practice and Iwithin my new institution and within the theories that I read and write

buddista's Flickr photostream

Page 66: Moving goal posts

Thank you