58
Developing Educational Practice Lindsay Jordan Centre for Learning and Teaching in Art and Design

Developing Educational Practice #1

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Visual aids and prompts for Day One of the Developing Educational Practice course at the University of the Arts London.

Citation preview

Page 1: Developing Educational Practice #1

Developing Educational Practice

Lindsay JordanCentre for Learning and Teaching in

Art and Design

Page 2: Developing Educational Practice #1

Overview of the course

• Day 1• Personal theories and metaphors

– How do we understand learning and teaching?• Context– What is Higher Education for?– Why is Higher Education like this?

• Practice– How do people learn?– How can teaching enable learning?

Page 3: Developing Educational Practice #1

Overview of the course• Day 2• Reflection– Why is reflection so central to teaching and learning?

• Designing the curriculum• What are we trying to achieve?• How do we support student-centred learning?

• Practice– Teaching 1:1, small groups, large lectures– Managing crits

Page 4: Developing Educational Practice #1

People bingo!

Page 5: Developing Educational Practice #1

In pairs

Who is this?What have they brought with them?What are they hoping to leave with?

Page 6: Developing Educational Practice #1

What is learning?

• Take about 5 minutes to write down what you think learning is or should be

Page 7: Developing Educational Practice #1

What is teaching?

• Take about 5 minutes to write down what you think teaching is or should be

Page 8: Developing Educational Practice #1

What we think learning is will shape how we approach learning

What we think teaching is will shape how we approach teaching

Page 9: Developing Educational Practice #1

Conceptions of teaching

• Think about the teaching staff you’ve encountered – one’s you’ve liked and/or ones you’ve had difficulty with - how would you describe their beliefs about teaching?

Page 10: Developing Educational Practice #1

Conceptions of teaching (Richardson, 2005)

• Teaching as imparting information• Teaching as transmitting structured knowledge• Teaching as an interaction between the teacher

and the student• Teaching as facilitating understanding

on the part of the student• Teaching as bringing about conceptual

change and intellectual development in the student

Page 11: Developing Educational Practice #1

Teachers’ approaches(Richardson, 2005)

Disciplinary Characteristics

Conceptions of Teaching

Perceptions of the teaching environment

Situational Factors

Approaches to Teaching

Page 12: Developing Educational Practice #1

Conceptions of learning

• Think about the students you’ve encountered – those you’ve enjoyed working with and/or those you’ve had difficulty with – what do you think their beliefs about learning are?

Page 13: Developing Educational Practice #1

Conceptions of learning (Richardson, 2005)

1. Learning as the increase of knowledge2. Learning as memorising3. Learning as the acquisition of facts or procedures4. Learning as the abstraction of meaning5. Learning as an interpretive process aimed at the

understanding of reality6. A conscious process, fuelled by personal interests

and directed at obtaining harmony and happiness or changing society

Page 14: Developing Educational Practice #1

Students’ approaches (Richardson, 2005)

Demographic Characteristics

Conceptions of Learning

Perceptions of academic context

Contextual Factors

Approaches to studying

Page 15: Developing Educational Practice #1

Ways of understanding learning and teaching

• Some big words:– Constructivism– Social learning theory– Transformative learning– Threshold concepts– Experiential learning– Deep, surface & strategic

Page 16: Developing Educational Practice #1

TEA!

Page 17: Developing Educational Practice #1

Higher Education Context

• What is Higher Education and what is it for?– Discuss in groups of 3 and come up with a list of at

least 3 things that your group believes to be the purpose of Higher Education

– You will have 10 minutes to do this and then you will present your list to the big group and explain why you think those 3 things are important

Page 18: Developing Educational Practice #1

Higher Education

• Meaning-making• Critical thinking• Reflection• Analysis and evaluation• “deep” versus “surface” learning

Page 19: Developing Educational Practice #1

Higher Education?

• What are the factors that have shaped the HE system we work in today?

– Discuss in groups of 3 for 10 minutes

– Present your conclusions to the group

Page 20: Developing Educational Practice #1

Massification

• Enormous increase in HE participation in relatively short time

• In 1962 there were 125,000 students at 25 Universities

• In 1996 there were over 1,000,000 students at over 100 universities

• Today the figure is over 2,000,000

Page 21: Developing Educational Practice #1

Massification

• What are the likely consequences of a mass higher education system?

Page 22: Developing Educational Practice #1

Widening participation

• HEFCE is “concerned with ensuring equality of opportunity for disabled students, mature students, women and men, and all ethnic groups”

• Attainment, Aspiration, Application, Admission

Page 23: Developing Educational Practice #1

Widening participation

• What are the challenges for HE in focusing on widening participation?

Page 24: Developing Educational Practice #1

Quality (1)

• The `modern’ system of higher education has its roots in the 1950s when it was devised to admit the top 5% of the population. It is now expected to admit the top 30%. Unless our teaching has improved by a tremendous amount or the population’s general level of academic ability has risen considerably, there must be a `dumbing down’.(Senior University Manager A)

• What do you think? If more people do well, does that mean dumbing down or does it mean a fairer, more accessible system?

Page 25: Developing Educational Practice #1

Quality (2)

• People have been moaning about declining standards for the last 30 years. I doubt if it is possible to prove anything either way. The standards themselves are probably changing, but the old standards had a great deal wrong with them so it is just possible that these changes may be for the better. (Senior University Manager B)

• What do you think? What might have been wrong with the old standards?

Page 26: Developing Educational Practice #1

Need to satisfy stakeholders

• Who are the stakeholders in HE today – who do you think should have the right to have a say in what goes on at University?

Page 27: Developing Educational Practice #1

International students

• Currently more than 8% of the total income of UK universities comes from overseas students' fees

• On the one hand it means an injection of much needed funds into the sector, on the other hand there are concerns about reliance in this kind of money.

• Is this model of financing HE sustainable?• Are international students getting a fair deal?

Page 28: Developing Educational Practice #1

Quality assurancehttp://www.qaa.ac.uk

Frameworks for

HE qualifica

tions

Code of practice

Subject benchmark statements Program

me specifica

tions

Academic infrastructure

Page 29: Developing Educational Practice #1

Quality assurance agendas

• Universities need to be accountable to stakeholders

• They need to say what they do – to have predictable measures of achievement

• They need to do what they say – deliver consistency and measurable outcomes

• This drive for consistency, measurability and control is problematic for some academic staff – why do you think that is the case?

Page 30: Developing Educational Practice #1

LUNCH!

Page 31: Developing Educational Practice #1

How do people learn?

Page 32: Developing Educational Practice #1

What do we already know about how people learn?

Page 33: Developing Educational Practice #1
Page 34: Developing Educational Practice #1
Page 35: Developing Educational Practice #1
Page 36: Developing Educational Practice #1

What does our knowledge about how people learn mean for

teaching?

Page 37: Developing Educational Practice #1

Ways of understanding learning and teaching

• Some big words:– Constructivism– Social learning theory– Transformative learning– Threshold concepts– Experiential learning– Deep, surface & strategic

Page 38: Developing Educational Practice #1

Learning changes people

Different theories explain how this happens in different ways, but most

are concerned with some developmental process in the learner

Page 39: Developing Educational Practice #1

Transformative learning theory

Jack Mezirow (1991)

• Recognising limits of existing knowledge• Developing an expanded understanding –

becoming more inclusive, discriminating, integrative

• Acting upon new understanding

Page 40: Developing Educational Practice #1

Transformative learning theory

• In this model, being challenged, stretched, required to defend positions that you don’t necessarily support, being able to understand and engage with conflicting view points, are all important teaching and learning activities.

• The most important idea is that the student’s existing understandings of the subject area are disturbed and have to be newly formed.

Page 41: Developing Educational Practice #1

Challenging within a framework

• Challenging existing viewpoints is important, but new learning has to be structured, supported and scaffolded

• We have to understand who students are, what prior knowledge and experience they bring to the learning situation and how best to enable their learning

Page 42: Developing Educational Practice #1

Constructivism

• We learn by fitting new understanding with what we already know, reorganising, extending and supplanting existing knowledge.

• A good explanation of constructivism is available at this websitehttp://www.thirteen.org/edonline/concept2class/constructivism/index.html

Page 43: Developing Educational Practice #1

Constructive Alignment

John Biggs (2002, p.1) “The ‘constructive’ aspect refers to what the learner does, which is to construct meaning through relevant learning activities.”

Page 44: Developing Educational Practice #1

Constructive alignment

• Biggs (2001, p.1-2)“The ‘alignment’ aspect refers to what the

teacher does, which is to set up a learning environment that supports the learning activities appropriate to achieving the desired learning outcomes.”

Page 45: Developing Educational Practice #1

Constructive alignment

• Biggs (2002, p.2) “The key is that the components in the teaching

system, especially the teaching methods used and the assessment tasks, are aligned to the learning activities assumed in the intended outcomes. The learner is ‘trapped’, and cannot escape without learning what is intended.”

Page 46: Developing Educational Practice #1

Social learning theory

• Learning is not just about change within an individual learner

• Communities of practice theory (Jean Lave & Etienne Wenger, 1991) argues that learning is a social activity that is just as much a part of everyday life as it is the focus of formal education

Page 47: Developing Educational Practice #1

Communities of practice• The domain– Participants in the COP share an interest in a

particular area of activity• The community– Participants are linked by relationships in which

they help each other, have discussions and share information

• The practice– Participants develop a shared repertoire of

resources, stories, tools, ways of thinking and problem solving

Page 48: Developing Educational Practice #1

Legitimate peripheral participation

• It is Ok to be a beginner: We enter new communities not knowing the rules of the game, not understanding all the terminology and the unspoken codes of behaviour

• Think about communities of practice that you belong to – draw a circle for each one (some may overlap)

• How involved are you in each one?• How did you move from peripheral to full

participation?

Page 49: Developing Educational Practice #1

Communities of practice

Importance for teaching practice:1.Understand that learning is about

relationships between people2.An educator’s role is to cultivate community3.Knowledge and involvement with activity go

together

Page 50: Developing Educational Practice #1
Page 51: Developing Educational Practice #1

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZvOWJjyTpp4

Page 52: Developing Educational Practice #1

Experiential learning

Page 53: Developing Educational Practice #1

Experiential learning

• Kolb’s learning cycle• Concrete experience • Reflective observation• Abstract

conceptualisation• Active experimentation

• Most importantly, the learner is ‘engaged’ – they are personally and directly involved, they can’t be passive.

• They have to reflect on the activity and learn from it.

Page 54: Developing Educational Practice #1

Threshold Concepts

Page 55: Developing Educational Practice #1

Threshold concepts

• Notion of a portal or a gateway – some essential understanding or way of being in a discipline that we must gain in order to progress

• Passing through the threshold is transformational, exhilarating or even distressing

• Can get stuck in a liminal state – leads to mimicry, lack of authenticity

Page 56: Developing Educational Practice #1

Threshold concepts

• Transformative – can lead to shifts in values, feeling or identity

• Irreversible – unlikely to be forgotten and difficult to unlearn

• Integrative – enables connections between different areas of a subject

• Potentially troublesome – e.g. tacit; conceptually difficult; culturally alien; inert

Page 57: Developing Educational Practice #1

What have you learned today

• Take 3 minutes to write down everything you can think of from today

• 30 seconds - feedback to group

Page 58: Developing Educational Practice #1

ReferencesBiggs, J. (2002) “Aligning the curriculum to promote good learning”. Available

at http://www.palatine.ac.uk/files/1023.pdf (Accessed: 27 October, 2009)

Kolb, D. A. (1984) Experiential Learning, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.: Prentice Hall.

Lave, J. & Wenger, E. (1991) Situated Learning. Legitimate peripheral participation, Cambridge: University of Cambridge Press.

Meyer, J & Land, R. (2003) Threshold concepts and Troublesome Knowledge: Linkages to ways of thinking and practising int the disciplines. Available at http://www.etl.tla.ed.ac.uk/docs/ETLreport4.pdf

Richardson, J. (2005) “Students’ approaches to learning and teachers approaches to teaching in hgher education”. Educational Psychology, 25(6), 673-680.