Describing and exploring data

TARUN GEHLOT (B.E, CIVIL) (HONOURS)

Describing and Exploring Data

Once a bunch of data has been collected, the raw numbers must be manipulated in some fashion to make them more informative. Several options are available including plotting the data or calculating descriptive statistics

Plotting Data

Often, the first thing one does with a set of raw data is to plot frequency distributions. Usually this is done by first creating a table of the frequencies broken down by values of the relevant variable, then the frequencies in the table are plotted in a histogram

Example: Your age as estimated by the questionnaire from the first class

TABLE 2.1

Age Frequency

18 3

19 10

20 14

21 10

22 5

23 2

24 1

25 1

26 2

Note: The frequencies in the above table were calculated by simply counting the number of subjects having the specified value for the age variable

Histogram


Grouping Data:

Plotting is easy when the variable of interest has a relatively small number of values (like our age variable did). However, the values of a variable are sometimes more continuous, resulting in uninformative frequency plots if done in the above manner. For example, our weight variable ranges from 100 lb. to 200 lb. If we used the previously described technique, we would end up with 100 bars, most of which with a frequency less than 2 or 3 (and many with a frequency of zero). We can get around this problem by grouping our values into bins. Try for around 10 bins with natural splits

Example: Binning our weight variable

TABLE 2.2

Weight Bin Midpoint Frequency

100-109 104.5 6

110-119 114.5 10

120-129 124.5 6

130-139 134.5 10

140-149 144.5 5

150-159 154.5 3

160-169 164.5 4

170-179 174.5 1


180-189 184.5 0

190-199 194.5 2

200-209 204.5 1

Histogram

Here's a live demonstration of binning

Stem & Leaf PlotsIf values of a variable must be grouped prior to creating a frequency plot, then the information related to the specific values becomes lost in the process (i.e., the resulting graph depicts only the frequency values associated with the grouped values). However, it is possible to obtain the graphical advantage of grouping and still keep all of the information if stem & leaf plots are used....These plots are created by splitting a data point into that part associated with the `group' and that associated with the individual point. For example, the numbers 180, 180, 181, 182, 185, 186, 187, 187, 189 could be represented as:

18 001256779

Thus, we could represent our weight data in the following stem & leaf plot:Stem & Leaf10 057788


11 000123555812 00155513 000224455514 0000515 00516 225517 01819 0520 0Stem & leaf plots are especially nice for comparing distributions:

Males Stem Females

8 10 0577811 000123555812 0015555440 13 002255 00 14 005 00 15 5 522 16 5 0 1718 50 19 0 20

Terminology Related to Distributions:

Often, frequency histograms tend to have a roughly symetrical bell-shape and such distributions are called normal or gaussionExample: Our height distribution


Sometimes, the bell shape is not semetricalThe term positive skew refers to the situation where the "tail" of the distribition is to the right, negative skew is when the "tail" is to the leftExample: Pizza Data

See the text for other terminology

NOTATION

Variables


When we describe a set of data corresponding to the values of some variable, we will refer to that set using an uppercase letter such as X or YWhen we want to talk about specific data points within that set, we specify those points by adding a subscript to the uppercase letter like X1

For example:

5, 8, 12, 3, 6, 8, 7

X1, X2, X3, X4, X5, X6, X7Summation

The greek letter sigma, which looks like , means "add up" or "sum" whatever follows

it. Thus, , means "add up all the Xi's". If we use the Xis from the previous example, Xi = 49 (or just X)Note, that sometimes the has number above and below it. These numbers specify the range over which to sum. For example, if we again use the theXis from the previous example, but now limit the summation: Xi = 34

Nasty Example:

Antic Real

TABLE 2.3

Student Mark #1 Mark #2

- X Y

1 82 84

2 66 51

3 70 72

4 81 56

5 61 73

Double Subscripts

Sometimes things are made more complicated because capital letters (e.g., X) are sometimes used to refer to entire datasets (as opposed to single variables) and multiple subscripts are used to specify specific data points

TABLE 2.4

Student Week 1 Week 2 Week 3 Week 4 Week 5


1 7 6 4 2 2

2 3 4 4 3 4

3 3 4 5 4 6

X24 = 3X or Xij = 61

Measures of Central Tendency

While distributions provide an overall picture of some dataset, it is sometimes desirable to represent the entire dataset using descriptive statisticsThe first descriptive statistics we will discuss, are those used to indicate where the centre of the distribution lies

There are, in fact, three different measures of central tendencyThe first of these is called the modeThe mode is simply the value of the relevant variable that occurs most often (i.e., has the highest frequency) in the sampleNote that if you have done a frequency histogram, you can often identify the mode simply by finding the value with the highest barHowever, that will not work when grouping was performed prior to plotting the histogram (although you can still use the histogram to identify the modal group, just not the modal value).

Finding the mode:

Create a nongrouped frequency table as described previously, then identify the value with the greatest frequencyFor Example: Class Height


TABLE 2.5

Value Frequency Value Frequency

61 3 69 3

62 4 70 2

63 4 71 4

64 4 72 4

65 3 73 0

66 7 74 0

67 5 75 0

68 4 76 1

A second measure of central tendency is called the medianThe median is the point corresponding to the score that lies in the middle of the distribution (i.e., there are as many data points above the median as there are below the median)To find the median, the data points must first be sorted into either ascending or descending numerical orderThe position of the median value can then be calculated using the following Formula:

For Examples:

If there are an odd number of data points:

(1, 3, 3, 4, 4, 5, 6, 7, 12)

If there are an even number of data points:

The median is the item in the fifth position of the ordered dataset, therefore the median is 4Finally, the most commonly used measure of central tendency is called the mean (denoted for a sample, and for a population)The mean is the same of what most of us call the average, and it is calculated in the following manner:


For example, given the dataset that we used to calculate the median (odd number example), the corresponding mean would be:

Similarly, the mean height of our class, as indicated by our sample, is:

Mode vs. Median vs. Mean In our height example, the mode and median were the same, and the mean was fairly close to the mode and median. This was the case because the height distribution was fairly symetrical However, when the underlying distribution is not symetrical, the three measures of central tendency can be quite differentThis raises the issue of which measure is best?

Example: Pizza Eating

TABLE 2.5

Value Frequency Value Frequency

0 4 8 5

1 2 10 2

2 8 15 1

3 6 16 1

4 6 20 1

5 6 40 1

6 5 - -

Mode = 2 slices per weekMedian = 4 slices per weekMean = 5.7 slices per weekNote that if you were calculating these values, you would show all your steps (it's good to be prof!)Measures of Variability

In addition to knowing where the centre of the distribution is, it is often helpful to know the degree to which individual values cluster around the centre. This is known as variability. There are various measures of variability, the most straightforward beingthe range of the sample:Highest value minus lowest valueWhile range provides a good first pass at variance, it is not the best measure because of its sensitivity to extreme scores (see section in text)

The Average Deviation


Another approach to estimating variance is to directly measure the degree to which individual datapoints differ from the mean and then average those deviations

That is:

However, if we try to do this with real data, the result will always be zero:

Example: (2,3,4,4,4,5,6,12)

The Mean Absolute Deviation (MAD)

One way to get around the problem with the average deviation is to use the absolute value of the differences, instead of the differences themselvesThe absolute value of some number is just the number without any sign:

For Example,

Thus, we could re-write and solve our average deviation question as follows:

The dataset in question has a mean of 5 and a mean absolute deviation of 2

The Variance

Although the MAD is an acceptable measure of variability, the most commonly used measure is variance (denoted s2 for a sample and for a population) and its square root termed the standard deviation (denoted s for a sample and for a population)The computation of variance is also based on the basic notion of the average deviation however, instead of getting around the "zero problem" by using absolute deviations (as in MAD), the "zero problem" is eliminating by squaring the differences from the mean

Specifically:


Example: Same old numbers

(2,3,4,4,4,5,6,12)

Alternate formula for s2 and s

The definitional formula of variance just presented was:

An equivalent formula that is easier to work with when calculating variances by hand is:

Although this second formula may look more intimidating, a few examples will show you that it is actually easier to work with (as you'll See in assignment 2)

Estimating Population Parameters

So, the mean and variance (s2) are the descriptive statistics that are most commonly used to represent the datapoints of some sampleThe real reason that they are the preferred measures of central tendency and variance


is because of certain properties they have as estimators of their corresponding population parameters; andFour properties are considered desirable in a population estimator; sufficiency, unbiasedness, efficiency, & resistanceBoth the mean and the variance are the best estimators in their class in terms of the firstthree of these four properties

Sufficiency

A sufficient statistic is one that makes use of all of the information in the sample to estimate its corresponding parameter

Unbiasedness

A statistic is said to be an unbiased estimator if its expected value (i.e., the mean of a number of sample means) is equal to the population parameter

Explanation of N-1 in s2 formula

Efficiency

The efficiency of a statistic is reflected in the variance that is observed when one examines the means of a bunch of independently chosen samples

Assessing the Bias of an Estimator

The bias of a statistic as an estimator of some population parameter can be assessed by

defining some population with measurable parameters

taking a number of independent samples from that population

calculating the relevant statistic for each sample

averaging that statistic across the samples

comparing the "average of the sample statistics" with the population parameter

Using the procedure, the mean can be shown to be an unbiased estimator (see pp 47)However, if the more intuitive formula for s2 is used:

it turns out to underestimateThis bias to underestimate is caused by the act of sampling and it can be shown that this bias can be eliminated if N-1 is used in the denominator instead of NNote that this is only true when calculating s2, if you have a measurable population and you want to calculate , you use N in the denominator, not N-1

Degrees of Freedom


The mean of 6, 8, & 10 is 8If I allow you to change as many of these numbers as you want BUT the mean must stay 8, how many of the numbers are you free to vary?The point of this exercise is that when the mean is fixed, it removes a degree of freedom from your sample -- this is like actually subtracting 1 from the number of observations in your sampleIt is for exactly this reason that we use N-1 in the denominator when we calculate s2 (i.e., the calculation requires that the mean be fixed first which effectively removes --fixes -- one of the data points)

Resistance

The resistance of an estimator refers to the degree to which that estimate is effected by extreme valuesAs mentioned previously, both and s2 are highly sensitive to extreme valuesDespite this, they are still the most commonly used estimates of the corresponding population parameters, mostly because of their superiority over other measures in terms sufficiency, unbiasedness, & efficiency

Education

Describing and exploring data