10
Understandings from the Process : - Namita Singh QuickTime™ decompre are needed t How does PV affect the agency of women?

Critiquing Participatory Video

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

This presentation critiques Participatory Video and questions some underlying assumptions about the emancipatory nature of the video-making process. Do ask for the full paper if you are interested

Citation preview

Page 1: Critiquing Participatory Video

Understandings from the Process:

- Namita Singh

QuickTime™ and a decompressorare needed to see this picture.

How does PV affect the agency of women?

Page 2: Critiquing Participatory Video

How and Where: The lens and its focus

• PV - my Practice and Research

• Ground Zero - Akshara in Mumbai and Mahita in Hyderabad, India

• The PV Projects - For local social change

• The freedom and critical perspective equation - through young

women participants

• Factors I explore - Viability and sustainability

Page 3: Critiquing Participatory Video

Methodology: How I did, what I did (last

summer!)

• Participatory Observation

• Interviews

• Focus Groups

• Participatory Video

Page 4: Critiquing Participatory Video

Agency in Context: It all makes Sen’s…!

• Citizen’s participation and agency

• Amartya Sen’s Capability Approach

• The ability ‘To do’ and ‘To be’

Page 5: Critiquing Participatory Video

The Video-Making: Shoot to skill…

• Representation

• Raising Issues

• Engagement with Communities

Page 6: Critiquing Participatory Video

Representation: Mirror, mirror on the wall…

• Is Representation essentially empowering?

• What about Reality and Aspirations?

• Resisting and Accepting Gender Norms

• Multiple performative identities

Page 7: Critiquing Participatory Video

Raising Issues: What say you…?

• How to balance support and domination?

• Need to choose between product quality and participants’ agency?

• The freedom and critical perspective equation

Page 8: Critiquing Participatory Video

Being with Communities: The Engagement Ring

• From harassment to respect

• From hostility to trust

• Community engagement as a source of agency

• The focus - wide angle or community oriented?

Page 9: Critiquing Participatory Video

PV in Research: Shooting from my lip…

• Representation: Balancing reality and aspirations, resistance

and acceptance of gender norms

• Raising Issues: Treading between research agendas and

participants’ objectives

• Being with communities: ‘My’ audience; ‘Their’ audience

Page 10: Critiquing Participatory Video

The Understanding : To be or not to be…

• Agency as the focus - understanding the contribution of

participatory processes in development

• Video or participants - choosing between the product and the

process

• PV as Technique or PV for Sustaining Agency - focusing on

furthering change