Upload
natashas7
View
1.323
Download
1
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Competitive Differentiation through Supply ChainManagementBy Klaus VenusLogiChem 2011 will be the event's tenth anniversary and an opportunity for the most senior chemical supply chain & global logistics directors from the European chemicals community to come together once again share experiences, make new contacts and benchmark the latest chemical supply chain initiatives. Not only will LogiChem 2011 be a chance for the chemical industry to reminisce about the last ten years but an opportunity to shape the next decade. To celebrate a decade of LogiChem, there will be an exciting three day programme filled with networking opportunities in our new location, Antwerp.
Citation preview
Competitive Differentiation through Supply Chain Managementg
Klaus Venus, Head of Supply Chain ManagementM di E & I t ti lMondi Europe & International21st of April 2010
Agenda
Mondi Uncoated Fine Paper – Supply Network
2003 Supply Chain Analyse – Vision & Program
Key Initiatives implementedKey Initiatives implemented
Business Case – Service Improvements
Discussion
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 1
Mondi Group
Key Figures Mondi Group
2009 2008
Mondi is an international paper andpackaging group and had revenues of EUR5.3 billion in 2009.
Revenue € 5,257M € 6,345M
Its key operations and interests are inwestern Europe, emerging Europe, Russiaand South Africa.
EBITDA1
EBITDA
€ 645M € 814M
and South Africa.
Mondi has production operations in around31 countries and about 31,000 employees.
EBITDA Return
Capital Employed
12.3%
€ 4,314M
12.8%
€ 4,367M
Mondi is a dual-listed company at theLondon Stock Exchange (LSE) andJohannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE).
ROCE2 7.6% 9.5%
Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE).
The corporate headquarters are located inJohannesburg.
Europe & International PresentationFebruary 23, 2010 Page 2
1 EBITDA is operating profit of subsidiaries and joint ventures before special items, depreciation and amortisation.2 Group ROCE is the underlying operating profit including share of associates’ net earnings divided by average trading capital employed (excluding capital employed on the major strategic expansion projects in Russia and Poland).
Business Structure Mondi Group
Europe & International (E&I) South Africa
Merebank
Richards BayInternational (E&I)
Forests
Corrugated Bags & SpecialitiesUncoated Fine Paper
Bag Converting
Kraft Paper
AylesfordAylesfordNewsprint Newsprint
ContainerboardUncoated Fine Paper
50%Corrugated Packaging
EuropapierEuropapier
Mondi Mondi ShandukaShandukaNewsprintNewsprint
Coatings
Consumer Flexibles
100%
50%
Europe & International PresentationFebruary 23, 2010 Page 3
Mondi Packaging Mondi Packaging South AfricaSouth Africa
70%
Around 80 Production Sites in 30 countries
Uncoated Fine PaperUncoated fine paper millNewsprint mill
ContainerboardCorrugatedContainerboard
Recycled containerboard millVirgin containerboard mill
Corrugated PackagingCorrugated box plant
Bags & Specialities
Kraft paper mill
Bag converting plant
Kraft Paper
Bag Converting
Release liner plantExtrusion coating plant
S i lt l ti fil l t
Coatings
Consumer Flexibles
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 4
Specialty plastic films plantConverted flexible packaging plant
The Mondi Diamond
Sustainable DevelopmentOperational Excellence p● Health and safety● Protection of environment● Sustainable forestry● Social responsibility
● Continuous productivity increases● High OEE and machine efficiency● Waste reduction● Low working capital● Low overheads
People Development● Development and
Customer Focus● Flawless service
training of employees● Talent management● Leadership● Employer brand
● Delivery accuracy● Market and customer intelligence● CRM
Cutting Edge Products● Building brand awareness● Incremental product development● Highest quality and functionality
Europe & International PresentationFebruary 23, 2010 Page 5
● Highest quality and functionality
Uncoated Fine Paper Products
Multifunctional Paper Colour Laser PaperColor Copy guarantees brilliant colour copies and perfect print results.
Color Copy is the number 1 colour
Our office paper meets all demands of modern office communication –whether for laser inkjet py
laser brand in Europe printing. whether for laser, inkjet or copy applications.
OffsetPre Print Offset Pre-Print
Our pre-print paper fits the needs of different printing technologies.
Our offset paper exhibits very good surface characteristics to ensure a perfect print result
Available in all standard formats.a perfect print result.
Available in folio & reels in a wide range of grammages.
December 1, 2009 PAGE 6Europe & International Presentation
Agenda
Mondi Uncoated Fine Paper – Supply Network
2003 Supply Chain Analyse – Vision & Program
Key Initiatives implementedKey Initiatives implemented
Business Case – Service Improvements
Discussion
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 7
What about is Supply Chain Management?
SupplierSupplierDelivery
ManagementOrder
ManagementConsumer
ManagementProduction & Warehouse Supplier
ManagementCatalogue
ManagementInventory
ManagementCustomerCustomer
M fl
SupplierSupplierManagementManagementManagement Management ManagementManagement ManagementCustomerCustomer
Money flowe.g. Customer payment, transaction accounting, supplier settlement
Information flowe.g.Customer forecast, delivery to address, product availability promise
Physical flowe.g. Manufacture, store, pick, pack, ship, deliver, return
The Dynamics of a Supply Chain si
ze
End User
Ord
er End User
Distrib torTrade Order
Production Order
DistributorOrder
time
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 9
Quelle: Tom Mc Guffry, Electronic Commerce and Value Chain Management, 1998
Trends in Supply Chain Management
Supply Chain Management has evolved rapidly over recent years and Supply Chain Pioneers are starting to move towards a synchronised supply chain
AcrossAlliance Synchronised
hip With
Customers
AlliancePartners
y
elat
ions
h
Between
& Suppliers Step 3: Synchronisation of Process, Technology & Organisation with an Orchestrated Vision
cope
of R
e
Withi
BusinessFunctions Step 2: Collaborate with key
suppliers and customers
Sc WithinBusinessActivities
Optimised Integrated Collaborative Synchronised
Step 1: Integrate functions of the internal supply chain
Optimised Integrated Collaborative Synchronised
Nature of Relationship
Mondi Uncoated Fine Paper Supply Chain
ProductionSourcing DistributionFinishing
Formates
Wood Pulp Paper mill Reels
Finished Reels
Merchants, Distributors, Customers
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 11
Mondi UFP Supply Chain Organization
Supply Chain Management
Sales & O ti
Supply & DemandPl i Supply Chain Supply ChainOperations-
PlanningPlanning -Operative
Supply ChainManagement
Supply Chain Processes
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 12
2003 Supply Chain Analysis
OutputQuantitative & Qualitative
Interviewed key supply h i l t
Benchmark vs. NAG
006,007,00
Channel Strategy & Management(CS&M)
Quantitative & Qualitative AssessmentInterviews chain personnel to
understand current issues
0,001,002,003,004,005,00
Strategic Customer Managemen
Operations Planning, Execution C t lSupply Chain Configuration
Order Fulfillment Operations
Surveys
Supply Chain Value Assessment
Supply Chain Capability AssessmentCompany / Division: Current ClientSupply Chain Process: Strategic Customer ManagementSub-process: 1.0 Strategic Customer Service
The locations do not have a strategic perspective on customer service; customer service operations are informal with no clear supporting organizational structure,
Customer service focuses on the simple administration of accounts with emphasis on completing order transactions; service is largely reactive to service complaints or
Operating locations engage in standard maintenance of customer accounts and some tailoring of services to meet requirements; dedicated service resources are
Strategic account management principles are applied, such as tailoring service offerings based on profitability and criticality of customer segments; key
Criticality Score (0-9): 9.00 Highly Critical Practice EnabledPractice Score (0-9): 9.00 Pioneering
Non-existent / poor Common Practice Progressive Practice Pioneering Practice
Enable Practice
Save
Developed and distributed supply chain & customer surveys to understand current performance and
Business Case &
Control
Supply Chain Planning
Supply Chain Configuration
Neusiedler AGBenchmark
Customer service operations are often relegated to secondary status at operating locations; no formal training or development processes are in place to support the service
Customer service processes / resources are viewed as a necessity but not part of core operations, and are often excluded from planning processes, budget development and
Customer service is viewed as a critical internal function and coordinates resolution on service issues; still seen as staff function and not given leadership role with
Customer service operations act as link in external collaborative supply chain for company; data on performance is gathered, used in customer financial analysis,
Non-existent / poor Common Practice Progressive Practice Pioneering Practice
Enable Practice current performance and identify gaps
D t Conducted to quantify as-Recommendations
• Implement Integrated Supply/Demand Planning Process & Asset Allocation
• Supply Chain Network Optimisation• VMI with Key Pulp & Packaging Suppliers • Roll-out VMI to Key Customers• Mill Direct
Main Initiatives Identified
Cumulated Net Supply Chain Benefits (€ ̀ 000)
43.456
62.991
30 000
40.000
50.000
60.000
70.000
Valu
e
Data Analysis
Conducted to quantify as-is performance and major gaps
• Eliminate Fill Orders with Negative Contribution• Reduce Production Cycle Times• Delivery Accuracy Improvement through better
Time Slot Management• Define & Implement Supply Chain Wide
• Rationalisation of Logistics Providers• Warehouse Structure Optmisation• Product Basket Optimisation• Pilot VMI with 1-2 Key Customers• Align Supply Chain Organisation• Shift smaller Customers to Merchants/OPEC• Implement ABC (Activity Based Costing) Tool to
Support Supply Chain Initiatives
2.0657.969
11.781
26.879
0
10.000
20.000
30.000
1 2 3 4 5 6
Year
V
Workshop
Conducted workshops to verify data analysis, discuss best practices and id tif i t
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 13
• Define & Implement Supply Chain Wide Performance Measures
• Improve Forecast Accruacyidentify improvement opportunities
Importance Factors for Customers
Source: EMGE-Survey 2008 – Mill importance factors
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 14
Supply Chain related factors
Mondi UFPSupply Chain Vision
• Supply Chain
Cost Effective
Flexible, Responsive
Demand Driven
High Performing
• Majority of orders • Accurate forecasts at • Integrated organization andperformance measures aligned to optimize Supply Chain performance
processed and dispatched within 48-72hours to support alternative sales channels2 3 regional warehouses
appropriate level used to minimize lead times and reduce inventory levelsForecasting process
supply/demand planning processused and supported with planning tools to provide optimum supplyperformance
• Detailed ABC (Activity Based Costing) toolimplemented and used
• 2-3 regional warehouses used across Europe to improve customer service levels while minimizing Finished Goods inventory
• Forecasting process supported throughdemand planning toolto improve accuracy and reduce manual
provide optimum supply plan to maximize profits
• Key suppliers integrated in planning process (e.g. VMI,
to support decision making processes about product and customer portfolio
• Effective postponement strategy enables short lead times and reduced stock levels, e.g. 100% mother reel strategy
effort• Collaborative
processes with key customers used (e.g. VMI)
collaborative planning)
mother reel strategy implemented
VMI) • Alternative sales
channels used
Supply Chain Strategy
Sheeting
Timber Pulp Mill Paper Mill Rewinding
Roll
Merchants/
Di t ib tFinishing Distributors/
Customers
PUSH PULL
ProductionSourcing DistributionFinishing
Low
Halbfertigfabrikat Fertigware
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 16
Low Uncertainty
High Uncertainty
Benchmarking 2003 – Gap Evaluation
KPIBest-in-Class
(multiple companies)
2003 Performance GAP
companies)1. Order Lead Time (days)
2. Availability/Order Success Rate (%)Rate (%)
3. Forecast Accuracy (%) (by SKU/Volume)
4. Production Schedule Adherence (%)
5. Inventory Finished Goods (days)
6. Semi-finished Goods in (days)
7. Order fulfill rate (delivery in full on time) (%)
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 17
Tactical vs. Strategic Approach
There is a growing gap in how companies think about their supply chains.
Strategic ApproachTactical Approach
• Supply Chain used to:– grow revenues– increase market share
• Supply Chain is a cost center
– create competitive advantage
• Target opportunities for new value added services
• Focus on operational cost control and reduction
added services
• Invest in VERY specific capabilities• Perceive operating efficiency as excellence -- “efficiency trap”
• Create a distinct business model
• Use new capabilities to change the customer relationship
• Lean to the point of starvationcustomer relationship
Supply Chain Management ....need to be considered across the full range of people,
processes and enabling systems
Comprehensive, Flexible,End-to-End approach
Cross Functional Teams withCl A t biliti
Strategy
People Clear Accountabilities
Common Processes
People
Process
Standardised Reports &Metrics Alignment of KPI’sMetrics & KPIs Metrics Alignment of KPI s
Integrated SystemsInformation & Systemsy
(Cohen, Roussel, 2004, p. 230) Strategic supply chain management: the five disciplines for top performers
Agenda
Mondi Uncoated Fine Paper – Supply Network
2003 Supply Chain Analyse – Vision & Program
Key Initiatives implementedKey Initiatives implemented
Business Case – Service Improvements
Discussion
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 20
The supply chain excellence program
To close the gap between our vision and the analysis a program was initiated consisting of 8 projects
Vendor M d
Network Di t ib ti
Supplier M dTransportationManaged
InventoryDistribution
StrategyManaged Inventory
Transportation Consolidation
Performance Organization
Production Cycle Time Reduction
SPEED -Integrated
Supply and D d
Product Basket
OptimizationReduction Demand Planning
Optimization
Paradigm shift from PUSH to PULL
Old WOld WayPush Principle – sell what you make!
Supply driven – production focus
Locally optimized machine efficiency
NEW Model Pull Principle – make what you sell!
Demand driven – customer focus
Group-wide optimized costsp p
Where and when to produce what for whom..… to achieve minimized costs AND increased customer service!
Russia AustriaAustriaIsraelSlovakiaSouth AfricaWarehouses
Allocation
Planning
Allocation
Forecasting
Service Level Agreements
Customer Y / Products
Customer Z / Products
Customer B / Products
Customer A / Products
Customer C / Products
Customer X / Products…
Forecasting & Planning- ProcessesDer Supply Chain steers and chairs the monthly meeting withSales, Marketing, Finance and all Production sites
Logistics & OrderprocessCheck System
ForecastSystem Forecast og st cs & O de p ocess
Forecast Consolidation
Develop final Master Plan and
release it for
Key in Customer demand
Control forecast and finalize
Consolidation release it for execution
Weekly forecast
Weekly forecast
Weekly forecast
Weekly forecast
Control forecast and finalize
Master Plan
Inventory
Supply & DemandPlanning
Block Scheduling
InventoryReplenishment
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 24
Performance Indicators
TransportSemi-
C t
Transport.Costs
Semi-finished
Inventory
Success of
FinishedGoods
Inventory
Costs
Success ofMondi
ProductionA
SalesForecastAccuracy
ProductionSchedulingAdherence
ShipmentAccuracy
Service
Constrained
DeliveryAccuracy
Accuracy
FinishingAccuracy
y
ConstrainedFill Rate
Un-constrained
Fill Rate
y
FinishingSchedulingAdherence
SuccessFactors
KPI’sAdherence
SC-Improvement process
Step I Scheduling Adherence Step II - Delivery Accuracy ex Mill
Fineplanning PM and FLSequencing
Paper availabilityMaterial availabilityStabile aggregates
Frozen periode Capacity planning
Mill Supply Chain Processes:
I t A hImprovement Approach
Finishing cycle timesSafety stock g yPM cycle timesPot closure times
Safety stockDispo stockReplenishment cycles
Step III – Reduce Cycle TimesStep IV – Reduce Inventories
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 27
Collaboration across Business PartnersDeeper collaborative partnerships in order to compete at the supply chain level
2 L i ti2 L i ti1. Supplier
Collaboration1. Supplier
Collaboration 2. Logistics Collaboration2. Logistics
Collaboration
ProductS li MaterialR M t i l
StoresProduct
Manufacturers
Retail Distribution
Suppliers Inbound OutboundMaterial Converters
Raw MaterialsSupply
Consumers
Di t
3. Customer Collaboration3. Customer Collaboration
3pl Transport Services
Links with other B2B exchanges, e.g.:
3PL Transport Services
Direct ExchangesTransport
Exchanges
5. Industry 5. Industry
4. Exchange
Collaboration
4. Exchange
Collaboration
g g• Transport exchanges
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 28
yStandardisation
Leverage
yStandardisation
Leverage
Key to implementing an effective VMI.. ….solution is to create a win-win relationship where both the customer and Mondi benefits.
Incr. revenue (quantity)Incr. revenue (price)Improved customer service
ILLUSTRATIVE
stom
er
Reducedinventory
Reduced working capital Net Benefit
Customer WIN
Cu
AdminReduced process costs
Overall Net Benefit
VMITransportationReduced internal
transportation
-WIN
Mon
di Improved customer serviceNet Benefit
Mondi
ProductionI d d ti l i
Increased revenue (quantity)
M
AdminAutomated order management
ProductionImproved production planningImplementationReduced
inventory Replenishment planning effortVMI implementation costsReduced working capital
B fit C tTransportation
AdminAdmin Increased transportation effort
Benefits Costs
VMI – Example out of our Web-based tool
Positive downwards trends trend
Agenda
Mondi Uncoated Fine Paper – Supply Network
2003 Supply Chain Analyse – Vision & Program
Key Initiatives implementedKey Initiatives implemented
Business Case – Service Improvements
Discussion
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 31
Project Structure
Q1 - Q4 S
2003 (Level 1) 2004 (Level 2)
Q3 - Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3
2005 (Level 3)
Q1 - Q4
2006 (Level 4)
Q4
Roll out VMI to Key Customers
and Pilot / Implement with Key Suppliers
Pilot VMI with Key Customers (Design &
Build)
SelectIssuStrategic
VMI 1
Transportation
SUPP
Q1
�
�Select
Providers and Implement
Issue
RFP
Strategic Sourcing Approach
Implement Supply Chain Distribution Network Strategy Delayed due to later start
Develop Supply Chain Network Distribution
Strategy
Rationalize external
warehouseI h
Network Dist. Strategy
2Transportation Consolidation
2
LY
C
�
�
Product basket
optimization
s Improve change over
times and processes
Reduce production cycle times Detailed cost analysi
Production Cycle Time Optimization
Complexity Management
3
4
CHAI
�
Complexity Management �
Implementation of real time costing for product basket to optimize contr. changed into sales strategy
Implement Balanced Scorecard & Align SC Organization
Detail SC Scorecard
optimization s
Performance
Management
6
N
LE�
�
Demand & Supply Chain Process & Planning Tool Implementation*Solution Selection
Planning Process Design
Align SC OrganizationScorecard
Program
Integrated Demand & Supply
Organization6
7
EADE
�
Ongoing Resource Planning & Program ManagementProgramSet-up
gManagement R
Assumptions: No further mill integrations requiring IP resources
Development of selected Indicators
Delivery Accuracy InventoryInventorydays Mondi / CEPIInventorydays Mondi / CEPI
25
30
35CEPI Mondi UFP
0
5
10
15
20
3 5 7 9 3 5 7 9 3 5 7 9 3 5 7 9 3 5 7 9
Leadtimes Cost Improvements 2003-2008
2004
0120
040 3
2004
05
2004
0720
0409
2004
1120
0501
2005
0 3
2005
0520
0507
2005
0920
0511
2006
01
2006
0 320
0605
2006
0720
0609
2006
11
2007
0120
070 3
2007
0520
0707
2007
09
2007
1120
0801
2008
0 320
0805
2008
07
2008
0920
0811
Total Improvements SC-Program 2003-2008
48.568
40000
50000
60000
O
4.616
12.943
18.526
28.768
10000
20000
30000
TS E
UR
O
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 33
84801 2 3 4 5 6
Years
Supply Chain Management Awards
Mondi’s remarkable value creationMondi s remarkable value creationOn October 28th, 2008 Mondi Uncoated Fine Paper was awarded in London with the esteemed European Supply Chain Excellence Award which is organised by Supply Chain Standard in partnershipAward, which is organised by Supply Chain Standard in partnership with PRTM Management Consultants, for the best end-to-end Supply Chain industrial sector solution. In September 2008 Mondi had also been distinguished with theIn September 2008 Mondi had also been distinguished with the Supply Chain Management Award for the best value chain 2008 from PRTM in cooperation with LOGISTIK HEUTE and the Supply Management Institute (SMI) of the European Business School in
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 34
g ( ) pWiesbaden.
The best Supply Chain companies are getting better
Lead of Best-in-Class Companies
getting better…
35
Lead of Best in Class Companies over Average Performing Companies
25
3025+ 25+
30+
15
2020+
Performance Advantage for E h A (%)
5
10
Each Area (%)
0
5
Supply Chain Cost*
Inventory Levels
Fulfillment Cycle Time
Fill Rates
Source: PRTM/AMR Supply Chain Reference* Based on the difference in supply chain cost as a % of revenue … while the rest are falling farther behind.
Agenda
Mondi Uncoated Fine Paper – Supply Network
2003 Supply Chain Analyse – Vision & Program
Key Initiatives implementedKey Initiatives implemented
Business Case – Service Improvements
Discussion
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 36
Discussion
Competitive differentiation through...
Supply Chain Management
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 37
Our Website: www.mondigroup.com
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 38
FORWARD - LOOKING STATEMENTS
It should be noted that certain statements herein which are not historical facts, including, without limitation those regarding expectations of market growth and developments; expectations of growth and profitability; and statements preceded by “believes”, “expects”, “anticipates”, “foresees”, “may” or similar expressions, are forward-looking statements. Since these statements are based on current knowledge plans estimates and projections they involve risks and uncertainties which may cause actual results to materially differ fromSince these statements are based on current knowledge, plans, estimates and projections, they involve risks and uncertainties which may cause actual results to materially differ from those expressed in such forward-looking statements. Various factors could cause actual future results, performance or events to differ materially from those described in these statements. Such factors include in particular but without any limitation: (1) operating factors such as continued success of manufacturing activities and the achievement of efficiencies therein, continued success of product development plans and targets, changes in the degree of protection created by Group’s patents and other intellectual property rights, the availability of capital on acceptable terms; (2) industry conditions, such as strength of product demand, intensity of competition, prevailing and future global market prices for the Group’s products and raw materials and the pricing pressures thereto, financial condition of the customers, suppliers and the competitors of the Group, potential introduction of competing products and technologies by competitors; and (3) general economic conditions, such as rates of economic growth in the Group’s principal geographical markets or fluctuations of exchange rates and interest ratesfluctuations of exchange rates and interest rates.
Mondi does not
a) assume any warranty or liability as to accuracy or completeness of the information provided hereinb) undertake to review or confirm analysts’ expectations or estimates or to update any forward-looking statements to reflect events that occur or circumstances that arise after the date of making any forward-looking statements.
2009/06/17Wettbewerbsdifferenzierung über SCM Seite 39