Upload
susvolans
View
341
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Visit www.being-diligent.com for more detail.
Citation preview
The Importance
of Being Diligent
Graphic Booklet N.3 Petters
Trust, but Verify
• We know the importance of being diligent, but there usually no clear guidance as to how to be diligent.
• Even the professional lie-detectors – lawyers – can do no better than “just look for something unusual.”
• However, detecting something as “unusual” requires experience, which is more often than not subjective and not easily transportable.
• Therefore, these case studies are my attempt at systematizing my experience based on the following principles.
• As President Reagan said: Trust, but Verify.
N. 3: Petters
Profile
• Tom Petters set up Petters Group Worldwide, LLC (“Petters”) in 1988
• Asset Based Lending/Purchase Order Inventory Financing
• Petters and its feeder funds raised over $3.65 billion and lost $3 billion
Fraud Schemes
• Feeder Funds/Complex Scheme
• Fake Performance
• False Sense of Security
Feeder Funds
Fund Operators of Feeder Funds Principals Capital Raised
Lancelot Investment Management LLC Gregory M. Bell $2,000,000,000
Palm Beach Capital Management LP Bruce Prevost & David Harrold $1,000,000,000
Arrowhead Capital Management, LLC James Fry & Michelle Palm $600,000,000
Stewardship Investment Advisors LLC Marlon Quan $450,000,000
• Feeder funds are structured to purchase the notes from subsidiaries or
affiliates of Petters Co. In order to show legitimacy of the scheme, Petters
Co. established bank lock box accounts, or “Escrow” account, over
which Petters Co has no control.
• All payments from the Big Box retailers shall be paid into the accounts.
Each feeder fund had a slightly different scheme, but the fundamentals
are basically the same. The following diagram is the scheme used by
Stewardship.
Layers of Cover-ups
Source: Lancelot Bankruptcy Status Report
Fake Performance
Lancelot Investors Fund, LP August estimated net return rate: 1.16%, YTD: 9.65%
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec YTD CUM.
2001 2.54% 2.54% 2.54%
2002 2.42% 2.51% 2.60% 2.33% 2.24% 2.16% 1.98% 1.92% 2.22% 2.98% 2.14% 2.03% 31.28% 34.61%
2003 2.86% 2.15% 2.10% 2.02% 1.87% 1.72% 1.95% 1.86% 1.42% 1.40% 1.20% 1.26% 24.11% 67.07%
2004 1.19% 1.11% 1.10% 1.08% 1.10% 1.10% 1.30% 1.15% 1.17% 1.26% 1.08% 1.07% 14.60% 91.47%
2005 1.08% 1.16% 1.20% 1.27% 1.16% 1.15% 1.11% 1.16% 1.13% 1.20% 1.20% 1.14% 14.89% 119.98%
2006 1.09% 1.10% 1.09% 1.11% 1.03% 1.05% 1.05% 1.08% 1.06% 1.05% 1.08% 1.15% 13.74% 150.20%
2007 1.30% 1.31% 1.39% 1.16% 1.04% 1.09% 1.22% 1.18% 1.04% 1.07% 1.10% 1.09% 14.92% 187.53%
2008 1.19% 1.10% 1.05% 1.25% 1.34% 1.13% 1.05% 1.16% 9.65% 215.29%
Sharpe
ratio: 9.57
Source: Lancelot Bankruptcy Status Report
Lancelot’s track record shows no negative month over 81 months.
Promissory Note
Source: Lancelot Bankruptcy Status Report
In order to finance this 180-day
period (“purchase order inventory
financing”), Petters issued a short-
term (up to 180-day) promissory
note with a large coupon
payment (from 10 to 18% p.a.) to
at least 20 investors.
This $31 million promissory note
pays 80% p.a. interest (or at legal
max.) over 3 months (from Feb 1
to May 1, 2008), 100% secured by
the capital stock of Polaroid
Holding Company, LLC
False Sense of Security
A Bank Lock
Box gave
investors a
false sense
of security
Source: SEC v. Stewardship (2009)
Ineffective Administrator
Swiss Financial
Services could not
identify the fraud
Source: Lancelot Bankruptcy Status Report
Recommendations
• Conduct extensive background checks on all related parties
• Confirmation on the Big Box retailers and their payments to the lock box accounts
• Confirmation of registration as a Registered Investment Advisor
To read the case study: http://www.being-diligent.com/case-n-3-petters/
Summary
• There are many similarities among hedge fund fraud cases (very stable and too good track records, promissory notes, fake service providers, etc.)
• No matter how clever they are, fraudsters are still human beings and prone to leave traces of their misconducts
• However, you really need to be diligent to find those traces and make informed judgment
For More Information
The Importance of Being Diligent is a blog of hedge fund case studies managed by Sus Volans. Please visit our website and sign up for an e-mail subscription.
http://www.being-diligent.com