[WORLD BANK ORGANIZATION]
2015Hailey College of Commerce
MC13-091MC13-062
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
WORLD BANKThe World Bank is a United Nations international financial institution that provides loans to
developing countries for capital programs. The World Bank is a component of the World Bank Group,
and a member of the United Nations Development Group. The World Bank's official goal is the
reduction of poverty. According to its Articles of Agreement, all its decisions must be guided by a
commitment to the promotion of foreign investment and international trade and to the facilitation of
capital investment.
Motto of the World Bank
Working for a World Free of Poverty
Profile of the World Bank
Formation July 1944 (70 years ago)Type International Financial OrganizationLegal Status TreatyPurpose CreditingHeadquarters Washington D.C., United StatesCo-ordinates of Geo Tagging 38.53° North ; 77.02° WestRegion of Operation WorldwideMembership 188 Countries (IBRD) 172 countries (IDA)Languages Arabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian, SpanishPresident Jim Yong KimMain Organ Boards of DirectorsParent Organization World Bank Group
World Bank GroupThe World Bank is not to be confused with the United Nations World Bank Group, a member of
the United Nations Economic and Social Council, and a family of five international organizations that make leveraged loans to poor countries.
(i) International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD)(ii) International Development Association (IDA)(iii) International Finance Corporation (IFC)(iv) Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA)(v) International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID)
Page 2
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
HistoryLord Keynes (right) and Harry Dexter White are the "founding fathers" of both the World Bank
and the International Monetary Fund (IMF). The World Bank was created at the 1944 Bretton Woods Conference, along with three other institutions, including the International Monetary Fund (IMF). The World Bank and the IMF are both based in Washington, D.C., and work closely with each other.
The Gold Room at the Mount Washington Hotel where the IMF and World Bank were established although many countries were represented at the Bretton Woods Conference, the United States and United Kingdom were the most powerful in attendance and dominated the negotiations.
1944–1968Before 1968, the reconstruction and development loans provided by the World Bank were
relatively small. The Bank's staff was aware of the need to instill confidence in the bank. Fiscal
conservatism ruled, and loan applications had to meet strict criteria.
The first country to receive a World Bank loan was France. The Bank's president at the time,
John McCloy, chose France over two other applicants, Poland and Chile. The loan was for US$250
million, half the amount requested, and it came with strict conditions. France had to agree to produce a
balanced budget and give priority of debt repayment to the World Bank over other governments. World
Bank staff closely monitored the use of the funds to ensure that the French government met the
conditions. In addition, before the loan was approved, the United States State Department told the
French government that its members associated with the Communist Party would first have to be
removed. The French government complied with this diktat and removed the Communist coalition
government. Within hours, the loan to France was approved. When the Marshall Plan went into effect
in 1947, many European countries began receiving aid from other sources. Faced with this competition,
the World Bank shifted its focus to non-European countries. Until 1968, its loans were earmarked for
the construction of income-producing infrastructure, such as seaports, highway systems, and power
plants that would generate enough income to enable a borrower country to repay the loan.
1968–1980From 1968 to 1980, the bank concentrated on meeting the basic needs of people in the
developing world. The size and number of loans to borrowers was greatly increased as loan targets
expanded from infrastructure into social services and other sectors. These changes can be
attributed to Robert McNamara, who was appointed to the presidency in 1968 by Lyndon B.
Johnson. McNamara imported a technocratic managerial style to the Bank that he had used as
United States Secretary of Defense and President of the Ford Motor Company. McNamara shifted
bank policy toward measures such as building schools and hospitals, improving literacy and
agricultural reform. McNamara created a new system of gathering information from potential
Page 3
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
borrower nations that enabled the bank to process loan applications much faster. To finance more
loans, McNamara told bank treasurer Eugene Rotberg to seek out new sources of capital outside of
the northern banks that had been the primary sources of bank funding. Rotberg used the global
bond market to increase the capital available to the bank. One consequence of the period of
poverty alleviation lending was the rapid rise of third world debt. From 1976 to 1980 developing
world debt rose at an average annual rate of 20%.In 1980, the World Bank Administrative Tribunal
was established to decide on disputes between the World Bank Group and its staff where allegation
of non-observance of contracts of employment or terms of appointment had not been honored.
1980–1989In 1980, McNamara was succeeded by US President Jimmy Carter's nominee, A.W. Clausen.
Clausen replaced many members of McNamara's staff and instituted a new ideological focus. His 1982
decision to replace the bank's Chief Economist, Hollis B. Chenery, with Anne Krueger was an indication
of this new focus. Krueger was known for her criticism of development funding and for describing
Third World governments as "rent-seeking states." During the 1980s, the bank emphasized lending to
service Third-World debt, and structural adjustment policies designed to streamline the economies of
developing nations. UNICEF reported in the late 1980s that the structural adjustment programs of the
World Bank had been responsible for "reduced health, nutritional and educational levels for tens of
millions of children in Asia, Latin America, and Africa".
1989–presentBeginning in 1989, in response to harsh criticism from many groups, the bank began including
environmental groups and NGOs in its loans to mitigate the past effects of its development policies that
had prompted the criticism. It also formed an implementing agency, in accordance with the Montreal
Protocols, to stop ozone-depletion damage to the Earth's atmosphere by phasing out the use of 95% of
ozone-depleting chemicals, with a target date of 2015. Since then, in accordance with its so-called "Six
Strategic Themes," the bank has put various additional policies into effect to preserve the environment
while promoting development. For example, in 1991, the bank announced that to protect against
deforestation, especially in the Amazon, it would not finance any commercial logging or infrastructure
projects that harm the environment.
In order to promote global public goods, the World Bank tries to control communicable
disease such as malaria, delivering vaccines to several parts of the world and joining combat forces. In
2000, the bank announced a "war on AIDS", and in 2011, the Bank joined the Stop Tuberculosis
Partnership. Less recently, a project in Seychelles to promote local tourism by the name of project
MAGIC was launched in 2010. Its successor project TIME was scheduled to be launched in 2012.
Page 4
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
Traditionally, based on a tacit understanding between the United States and Europe, the
president of the World Bank has always been selected from candidates nominated by the United
States. In 2012, for the first time, two non-US citizens were nominated. On 23 March 2012, U.S.
President Barack Obama announced that the United States would nominate Jim Yong Kim as the next
president of the Bank. Jim Yong Kim was elected on 27 April 2012.
Organization and Structure:The organization of the bank consists of the Board of Governors, the Board of Executive
Directors and the Advisory Committee, the Loan Committee and the president and other staff
members. All the powers of the bank are vested with the Board of Governors who are supreme
policy is making body of the bank. The board consists of one Governor and one Alternative Governor
appointed for five years by each member country. Each Governor has the voting power which is related
to the financial contribution of the Government which he represents.
The Board of Executive Directors consists of 21 members, 6 of them are appointed by the six
largest shareholders, namely the USA, the UK, West Germany, France, Japan and India. The rest of
the 15 members are elected by the remaining countries. Each Executive Director holds voting power
in proportion to the shares held by his Government. The board of Executive Directors meets
regularly once a month to carry on the routine working of the bank. The president of the bank is
pointed by the Board of Executive Directors. He is the Chief Executive of the Bank and he is
responsible for the conduct of the day-to-day business of the bank. The Advisory committees
appointed by the Board of Directors. It consists of 7 members who are expects in different branches
of banking. There is also another body known as the Loan Committee. This committee is consulted
by the bank before any loan is extended to a member country
MembershipThere are 184 member countries that are shareholders in the IBRD, which is the primary arm of
the WBG. To become a member, however, a country must first join the International Monetary Fund
(IMF). The size of the World Bank's shareholders, like that of the IMF's shareholders, depends on the
size of a country's economy. Thus, the cost of a subscription to the World Bank is a factor of the quota
paid to the IMF.
There is an obligatory subscription fee, which is equivalent to 88.29% of the quota that a
country has to pay to the IMF. In addition, a country is obligated to buy 195 World Bank shares
(US$120,635 per share, reflecting a capital increase made in 1988). Of these 195 shares, 0.60% must be
paid in cash in U.S. dollars while 5.40% can be paid in a country's local currency, in U.S. dollars, or in
non-negotiable non-interest bearing notes. The balance of the 195 shares is left as "callable capital,"
Page 5
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
meaning the World Bank reserves the right to ask for the monetary value of these shares when and if
necessary. A country can subscribe a further 250 shares, which do not require payment at the time of
membership but are left as "callable capital." (Learn more about the IMF in An Introduction to the
International Monetary Fund.)
The president of the World Bank comes from the largest shareholder, which is the United States, and
members are represented by a Board of Governors. Throughout the year, however, powers are delegated to
a board of 24 executive directors (EDs). The five largest shareholders - the U.S., U.K., France, Germany and
Japan - each have an individual ED, and the additional 19 EDs represent the rest of the member states as
groups of constituencies. Of these 19, however, China, Russia and Saudi Arabia have opted to be single
country constituencies, which mean that they each have one representative within the 19 EDs. This
decision is based on the fact that these countries have large, influential economies, which requires that
their interests be voiced individually rather than diluted within a group. The World Bank gets its
funding from rich countries as well as from the issuance of bonds on the world's capital markets.
Capital Resources of World Bank:The initial authorized capital of the World Bank was $ 10,000 million, which was divided in 1
lakh shares of $ 1 lakh each. The authorized capital of the Bank has been increased from time to time
with the approval of member countries. On June 30, 1996, the authorized capital of the Bank was $
188 billion out of which $ 180.6 billion (96% of total authorized capital) was issued to member
countries in the form of shares. Member countries repay the share amount to the World Bank in the
following ways:
1. 2% of allotted share are repaid in gold, US dollar or Special Drawing Rights (SDR).
2. Every member country is free to repay 18% of its capital share in its own currency.
3. The remaining 80% share deposited by the member country only on demand by the World
Bank.
Objectives:The following objectives are assigned by the World Bank:
To provide long-run capital to member countries for economic reconstruction and
development.
To induce long-run capital investment for assuring Balance of Payments (BoP)
equilibrium and balanced development of international trade.
To provide guarantee for loans granted to small and large units and other projects
Page 6
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
of member countries.
To ensure the implementation of development projects so as to bring about a smooth
transference from a war-time to peace economy.
To promote capital investment in member countries by the following ways;
Page 7
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
a) To provide guarantee on private loans or capital investment.
b) If private capital is not available even after providing guarantee, then IBRD
provides loans for productive activities on considerate conditions
FUNCTIONS AND ROLE OF WORLD BANK
Sustainable GrowthThe World Bank's studies indicate that approximately 1.4 billion people live on $1.25 or less a
day. With the rising food prices exacerbated by civil conflict, hunger and disease plagues many of these
nations, making it hard for them to develop sustainable growth programs. Through its International
Development Association, the World Bank is funding agricultural production programs and developing
power, transportation, water, and information and communication technologies.
Post-Conflict and Fragile StatesConflict generated through war has afflicted many of the world's poorest countries. An
estimated 80 percent of the world's 20 poorest countries have experienced a major war in the past 15
years. Even when those wars end, the fragile state of peace can end at any time, plunging the countries
back into chaos. The World Bank recognizes that conflict-prevention and reconstruction support are
among the most effective ways of fighting poverty. In Rwanda, for example, the World Bank helped fund
the Rwanda Demobilization and Reintegration Program to provide assistance to ex-soldiers on both
sides of the Rwandan conflict to reintegrate into society through job programs and education.
Middle Income CountriesThough middle-income countries don't have all the challenges associated with the poorest
nations, they do have concentrations of poverty especially among indigenous ethnic populations.
The World Bank invests in infrastructure and essential services to help these countries reform
policies and provide development education for their poorest citizens. In Brazil, the World Bank's
Bolsa Familia Program reaches 46 million low-income people by providing funds to buy food,
school supplies and clothes for children.
Knowledge and LearningPoor countries rely on the World Bank to help them evaluate their development knowledge
through reports, analytical tools, data, conferences and the Internet. The World Bank is developing
an online data platform that will allow countries to access information. One example is the World
Bank's 2008 report on how technological progress since the 1990s has helped pull millions of people
out of poverty. The report cited the use of mobile phones, computers and the Internet as easy-to-use
Page 8
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
technologies that can be set up in poor countries with private investment, whereas older
technologies required government funding.
The Arab WorldThe World Bank believes that to properly take advantage of potential for growth and
development, the Arab world must learn to better integrate itself into the global economy. The region
suffers from lack of economic diversity, conflict and water scarcity, and in an effort to combat some of
these issues, the World Bank and the League of Arab States has founded the Arab World Initiative.
This initiative has three key components: infrastructure projects, enterprise development, and human
development through improving the quality of education. The World Bank has committed $100
million as initial funding for micro, small and medium enterprises, lending money directly to people in
Arab countries to start and sustain their own businesses.
Adapting to the TimesAs mentioned earlier, the main function of the WBG is to eliminate poverty and to provide
assistance to the poor by offering loans, policy advice and technical assistance. As such, the countries
receiving aid are learning new ways to function. Over time, however, it has been realized that
sometimes as a nation develops, it requires more aid to work its way through the development
process. This has resulted in some countries accumulating so much debt and debt service that
payments become impossible to meet. Many of the poorest countries can receive accelerated debt
relief through the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries scheme, which reduces debt and debt service
payments while encouraging social expenditure
Global Partnerships and InitiativesThe World Bank has been assigned temporary management responsibility of the Clean
Technology Fund (CTF), focused on making renewable energy cost-competitive with coal-fired power as
quickly as possible, but this may not continue after UN's Copenhagen climate change conference in
December 2009, because of the Bank's continued investment in coal-fired power plants. Together with
the WHO, the World Bank administers the International Health Partnership (IHP+). IHP+ is a group of
partners committed to improving the health of citizens in developing countries. Partners work together
to put international principles for aid effectiveness and development cooperation into practice in the
health sector. IHP+ mobilizes national governments, development agencies, civil society and others to
support a single, country-led national health strategy in a well-coordinated way.
Climate ChangeWorld Bank President Jim Yong Kim said in 2012 that:
Page 9
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
“A 4 degree warmer world can, and must be, avoided – we need to hold warming below 2 degrees ....
Lack of action on climate change threatens to make the world our children inherit a completely different
world than we are living in today. Climate change is one of the single biggest challenges facing
development, and we need to assume the moral responsibility to take action on behalf of future
generations, especially the poorest.”
A World Bank report into Climate change in 2012 noted that: "Even with the current
mitigation commitments and pledges fully implemented, there is roughly a 20 percent likelihood of
exceeding 4°C by 2100." This is despite the fact that the "global community has committed itself to
holding warming below 2°C to prevent 'dangerous' climate change"". Furthermore: "A series of recent
extreme events worldwide highlight the vulnerability of all countries. ... No nation will be immune to
the impacts of climate change."
The World Bank doubled its aid for climate change adaptation from $2.3bn (£1.47bn) in 2011 to
$4.6bn in 2012. The planet is now 0.8 °C warmer than in pre-industrial times. It says that 2 °C warming
will be reached in 20 to 30 years.
Food securityGlobal Food Security Program: Launched in April 2010, six countries alongside the Bill and
Melinda Gates Foundation have pledged $925 million for food security. Till date the program has helped
8 countries, promoting agriculture, research, trade in agriculture, etc. Launched Global Food Crisis
Response Program: Given grants to approximately 40 nations for seeds, etc. for improving productivity.
In process of increasing its yearly spending for agriculture from $4 billion to $6 billion – $8 billion. Runs
several nutrition programs across the world, e.g., vitamin A doses for children, school meals, etc.
Clean Air InitiativeClean Air Initiative (CAI) is a World Bank initiative to advance innovative ways to improve air
quality in cities through partnerships in selected regions of the world by sharing knowledge and
experiences. It includes electric vehicles.
Open Data initiativeThe World Bank collects and processes large amounts of data and generates them on the basis
of economic models. These data and models have gradually been made available to the public in a way
that encourages reuse, whereas the recent publications describing them are available as open access
under a Creative Commons Attribution License, for which the bank received the SPARC Innovator 2012
award.
Page 10
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
Open Knowledge RepositoryThe World Bank hosts the Open Knowledge Repository (OKR) as an official open access
repository for its research outputs and knowledge products.
Other areas of focusAnother issue on which the Bank has recently been focusing has presented itself as an
endangerment to a country's livelihood: support programs for HIV/AIDS. The WBG has also been
focusing on reducing the risk of projects by means of better appraisal and supervision mechanisms as
well as a multidimensional approach to overall development. (This includes not only lending but also
support for legal reform, educational programs, environmental safety, anti-corruption measures and
other types of social development.)
TRAINING WIN
World Bank InstituteThe World Bank Institute (WBI) creates learning opportunities for countries, World Bank staff
and clients, and people committed to poverty reduction and sustainable development. WBI's work
program includes training, policy consultations, and the creation and support of knowledge networks
related to international economic and social development. The World Bank Institute (WBI) can be
defined as a "global connector of knowledge, learning and innovation for poverty reduction". It aims
to inspire change agents and prepare them with essential tools that can help achieve development
results. WBI has four major strategies to approach development problems: innovation for
development, knowledge exchange, leadership and coalition building, and structured learning.
World Bank Institute (WBI) was formerly known as Economic Development Institute (EDI),
established on 11 March 1955 with the support of the Rockefeller and Ford Foundations. The
purpose of the institute was to serve as provide an open place where senior officials from developing
countries could discuss development policies and programs. Over the years, EDI grew significantly
and in 2000, the Institute was renamed as the World Bank Institute. Currently Sanjay Pradhan is the
Vice President of the World Bank Institute.
Global Development Learning NetworkThe Global Development Learning Network (GDLN) is a partnership of over 120 learning centers
(GDLN Affiliates) in nearly 80 countries around the world. GDLN Affiliates collaborate in holding events
that connect people across countries and regions for learning and dialogue on development issues.
GDLN clients are typically NGOs, government, private sector and development agencies who find that
Page 11
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
they work better together on sub regional, regional or global development issues using the facilities and
tools offered by GDLN Affiliates. Clients also benefit from the ability of Affiliates to help them choose
and apply these tools effectively, and to tap development practitioners and experts worldwide. GDLN
Affiliates facilitate around 1000 videoconference-based activities a year on behalf of their clients,
reaching some 90,000 people worldwide. Most of these activities bring together participants in two or
more countries over a series of sessions. A majority of GDLN activities are organized by small
government agencies and NGOs
GDLN Asia PacificThe GDLN in the East Asia and Pacific region has experienced rapid growth and Distance Learning
Centers now operate, or are planned in 20 countries: Australia, Mongolia, Cambodia, China, Indonesia,
Singapore, Philippines, Sri Lanka, Japan, Papua New Guinea, South Korea,
Thailand, Laos, Timor Leste, Fiji, Afghanistan, Bangladesh, India, Nepal and New Zealand. With over 180
Distance Learning Centers, it is the largest development learning network in the Asia and Pacific region.
The Secretariat Office of GDLN Asia Pacific is located in the Center of Academic Resources of
Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand. GDLN Asia Pacific was launched at the GDLN's East Asia
and Pacific regional meeting held in Bangkok from 22 to 24 May 2006. Its vision is to become "the
premier network exchanging ideas, experience and know-how across the Asia Pacific Region". GDLN
Asia Pacific is a separate entity to The World Bank. It has endorsed its own Charter and Business Plan
and, in accordance with the Charter, a GDLN Asia Pacific Governing Committee has been appointed.
The committee comprises China (2), Australia (1), Thailand (1), The World Bank (1) and finally, a
nominee of the Government of Japan (1). The organization is currently hosted by Chulalongkorn
University in Bangkok, Thailand, founding member of the GDLN Asia Pacific.
The Governing Committee has determined that the most appropriate legal status for the GDLN
AP in Thailand is a "Foundation". The World Bank is currently engaging a solicitor in Thailand to process
all documentation in order to obtain this legal status.
GDLN Asia Pacific is built on the principle of shared resources among partners engaged in a
common task, and this is visible in the organizational structures that exist, as the network evolves.
Physical space for its headquarters is provided by the host of the GDLN Centre in Thailand –
Chulalongkorn University; Technical expertise and some infrastructure is provided by the Tokyo
Development Learning Centre (TDLC); Fiduciary services are provided by Australian National University
(ANU) Until the GDLN Asia Pacific is established as a legal entity tin Thailand, ANU, has offered to assist
the governing committee, by providing a means of managing the inflow and outflow of funds and of
reporting on them. This admittedly results in some complexity in contracting arrangements, which need
Page 12
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
to be worked out on a case by case basis and depends to some extent on the legal requirements of the
countries involved.
The JUSTPAL NetworkA Justice Sector Peer-Assisted Learning (JUSTPAL) Network was launched in April 2011 by the
Poverty Reduction and Economic Management (PREM) Department of the World Bank’s Europe and
Central Asia (ECA) Region. The JUSTPAL objective is to provide an online and offline platform for justice
professionals to exchange knowledge, good practices and peer-driven improvements to justice systems
and thereby support countries to improve their justice sector performance, quality of justice and service
delivery to citizens and businesses.
The JUSTPAL Network includes representatives of judiciaries, ministries of justice,
prosecutors, anti-corruption agencies and other justice-related entities from across the globe. The
Network currently has active members from more than 50 countries. To facilitate fruitful exchange of
reform experiences and sharing of applicable good practices, the JUSTPAL Network has organized its
activities under (currently) five Communities of Practice (COPs):
i. Budgeting for the Justice Sector;
ii. Information Systems for Justice Services;
iii. Justice Sector Physical Infrastructure;
iv. Court Management and Administration;
v. Prosecution and Anti-Corruption Agencies.
PAKISTAN and WORLD BANK
DEVELOPMENT CHALLENGESPoverty remains a serious concern in Pakistan. According to the rebased GDP numbers, the per
capita income comes to US$720; poverty rates, which had fallen substantially in the 1980s and early
1990s, started to rise again towards the end of the decade. Though complete data from the recent
Integrated Household Survey is not yet available, it is evident that a large segment of the population
lives in poverty. More importantly, differences in income per capita across regions have persisted or
widened. Poverty varies significantly among rural and urban areas and from province to province, from
a low of 24 percent in urban Sindh to 51 percent in rural Sindh. Pakistan has grown much more than
other low-income countries, but has failed to achieve social progress commensurate with its economic
growth. The educated and well-off urban population lives not so differently from their counterparts in
other countries of similar income range. However, the poor and rural inhabitants of Pakistan are being
left behind. For example, access to sanitation in Pakistan is 23 percent lower than in other countries
Page 13
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
with similar income. Maternal mortality remains high at 450 per 100,000 live births. Gender gaps
remain in schooling, largely due to the rural areas where only 22 percent of girls above age 10 have
completed primary level or higher schooling as compared to 47 percent boys. While the PSLSMS
indicates an improvement in Net Enrolment Rate (NER), from 42% in 2001/02 to 52 per cent, it still
indicates that almost half of the primary school age cohort is currently out of school. While the NER
shows an insignificant gender gap in urban areas, NER for rural girls at 42 percent trails behind rural
boys’ NER of 53 percent. Meeting the vision embraced in the Millennium Development Goals by 2015
(including the reduction of infant and child mortality by two thirds and maternal mortality by three
quarters and halving the percentage of the population living in poverty) will require renewed efforts in
Pakistan. The World Bank’s assistance strategy is based on measurable outcomes using the MDGs as the
background for its engagement in Pakistan.
WORLD BANK ASSISTANCE TO PAKISTANThe World Bank's strategy is to support implementation of the Government of Pakistan’s own
Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (PRSP) and to provide financing and technical assistance for both
economic and human development. The strategy is built around three main themes which correspond
to the pillars of the PRSP.
Sustaining High and Broad Based Growth, And Improving Competitiveness
Pakistan’s PRSP emphasizes the importance of sustaining rapid and broad-based economic
growth as the principle means of reducing poverty. While significant progress has been made in
reducing state intervention in the economy and improving the regulatory framework for private
business, firms continue to face significant policy, regulatory, and infrastructure constraints. To help
address these constraints and create an environment conducive to healthy private sector growth, the
Bank program will support legal and regulatory reforms to improve the business environment along with
investments in water, power, transport, and other infrastructure sectors.
Improving GovernanceImproving government performance is a central element of Pakistan’s poverty reduction
strategy. The Bank is assisting the government’s efforts in this area by supporting reforms in public
financial management and procurement; restructuring of the tax administration bureaucracy; support
for civil service reforms; and assistance to local and municipal governments to improve their capacity
for delivering public services.
Page 14
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
Improving Lives and Protecting the VulnerableThe World Bank also supports Pakistan’s efforts to improve the lives of its citizens through
efforts to improve access to, and quality of, public services in education, health, electricity, water
supply, and sanitation, with an emphasis on addressing gender disparities. At the same time the Bank is
assisting in efforts to reduce vulnerability and poverty through effective safety nets
DIFFERENCES OF IMF AND WORLD BANKAlthough both IMF and World Bank have shared some common characteristics, however, they
remain distinct. The most obvious distinction is that World Bank is a development institution while IMF
is a cooperative institution (Driscoll, D.D., n.d.). The task that IMF needs to do is to monitor the process
of payments and receipts among its members’ nations. Not only that, each of them has their own
purpose, distinct structure, membership, decision making, tasks, sources of funding, recipients of
funding, IMF and World Bank’s operation.
PurposeThe establishment of IMF contributes to different purposes. In dealing with the unresolved
financial problems, unpredictable changes in the trading of national currencies’ value in which it can be
exchanged for foreign currencies. Besides, IMF also acts as a voluntary and cooperative institution. It
attracts its membership nations by giving up some of the controls towards them. It does not do harm
activities towards the membership nations and maintain the economic welfare of its member nations.
The IMF institution has set up the rule which is in the Articles of Agreement signed by all members;
make up a code of conduct. The guardian of the code of conduct is the IMF. The member nations are
allowed to exchange their currency to foreign currencies without restriction. IMF should be informed of
changes in monetary and financial policies which will bring implications to the economies of its
members’ nations. Stated in the code of conduct, they can modify the policies based on the advice of
the IMF. If its members’ nations are deficit in the funds, they can borrow money from IMF. Besides, it
receives reports on member’s economic policies and prospects. IMF discusses on it so that other
members will respond it in a right way and understand of the way to own their domestic policies.
Furthermore, IMF is required to maintain the orderly monetary system that will sustain economic
growth throughout the world.
World Bank also has different purposes and responsibilities. The international community
assigned World Bank as IBRD [2] (Driscoll, D.D., n.d.). Its primary role and responsibility is for financing
economic development. Besides, the World Bank’s first loan is for the Western Europe to restructure
the economies after the war. After these nations recover to their normal operations, the World Bank
changed its attention to the poorer nation which is developing countries. Moreover, the World Bank
Page 15
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
wants to help the developing countries to enhance the progress of the social and economic
circumstances. It can help to move up the productivity of the developing countries. This can ensure that
their people may live a better life.
Size and StructureThe IMF is small and has no affiliates or subsidiaries. It has only about 2,300 staff members
(Driscoll, D.D., n.d.). Most of them work at headquarters in Washington, D.C. There are three small
offices in Paris, Geneva, and United Nations in New York. The staff members who work for
economists and financial aspects are professional staff members.
However, the World Bank is larger than the IMF and its structure is more complex. It has over
7,000 staff members which are three times larger than IMF. Not only that, it also maintains about 40
offices throughout the world. Most of its staffs work at headquarters which is located at Washington,
D.C. There are different expertise of staffs in the World Bank such as economists, engineers, urban
planners, lawyers, as well as experts in telecommunications, transportation, and education. The World
Bank has two organizations which are IBRD and International Development Association (IDA). World
Bank transfers fund from surplus unit in developing countries to the private enterprises.
MembershipCurrently, IMF has around 182 members throughout the world. The Board of Governors is
the highest authority (IMF and the World Bank, n.d.).Each country has two representatives which are
a Governor and an Alternate Governor. They meet once a year and votes are carried out through
mail. There is 24 member Board of Executive Directors monitors the day-to-day operations of the
IMF. Japan, USA, France, United Kingdom, and Germany are the first five nations that contribute to
the IMF. Each of them appoint one Executive Director, however, the remaining 19 are elected for
several nations. Nevertheless, in the World Bank, there are 187 member countries. If the country is
the member’s nation of the IMF, then it just can be considered the membership of the World Bank.
However, if it is not a member’s nation of the IMF, then it cannot be the member of the World Bank.
Same as the IMF, the World Bank also has Board of Governors. Each country will elect a
representative. They meet once a year. The day-to-day operations are managed by a board of 24
Executive Directors. The overall membership structure of World Bank is much like that of the IMF.
Decision Making PowerIn the IMF, if the member nation wants to make decision, it needs to base on its quota. If it has
higher quota, then it can have higher decision making power. The amount of quota mentioned here is
determined by the reserves, balance of payments and national income of the members’ nation. In
Page 16
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
addition, it also decides the contribution of the nation to the IMF. The decision-making power of the
first five nations that contribute to the IMF and Saudi Arabia is about 40%. Nonetheless, there is less
than 5% of the decision making power of the entire continent of Africa (IMF and the World Bank, n.d.).
In the operations of World Bank, the Governors are delegating the decision making power to
the Executive Directors. The decisions are normally made by consensus rather than formal vote by the
Directors. Therefore, the World Bank policy is considered and decided by the Directors. Besides, the
Directors also approve the credit and loan proposals. They need to show all the reports to the
Governors during the annual meetings.
TasksThe IMF performs the task by prerequisite of short term loans which are reliant on the
structural adjustment programs (SAPs). This task is used for correcting a deficit, eliminating or easing
net export controls and foreign exchange investment, diminishing development in domestic money
supply, demolishing price controls, depreciating the currency, privatizing the firms which are publicly
owned, increasing taxes, reducing government spending, and abolishing subsidies. While performing
the tasks, the World Bank works closely with the IMF. It makes long term loans and repayable within 15
years. They are investing the projects which has viable rate of return. World Bank has used structural
adjustment lending to monitor the economic structure and if there are changes, they can follow up
easily. The World Bank’s plan is to reduce deficiencies that have the accumulating of the specific
country assessments and the strategies which make sure that the support and complement of the
World Bank’s projects and programs of the country.
Source of FundingThe IMF is not a bank and it does not act as intermediate between investors and recipients.
However, it has at its disposal resources which come from quota subscriptions, paid by IMF’s member
countries. They contribute certain amount of money based on their economic sizes and strengths. The
members of the IMF can share the same resources when they are in need, this can show that IMF acts
as a credit union. Even though under high restraining conditions the IMF borrows from official entities,
it relies on its quota subscriptions to carry out its operations. Every five years, the IMF will review the
amount of the resources.
World Bank has different sources from the IMF. The World Bank is an investment bank, acts as
intermediate between investors and recipients. The IBRD issues the bonds which have the greatest
rate to individuals and private institutions through market borrowing to acquire the extra funds. The
funds are used to lend to the financial development. The IDA is supported by agreement from
contributor nations. The major borrower in the capital market is the World Bank. It is also the biggest
Page 17
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
nonresident borrower to all countries that sold issues. It sells bonds and notes to governments and
publics to raise funds. So, it can borrow money to other countries. The money that gets after the
borrowing is lent to developing countries at affordable interest rates to help them to finance their
projects and programs.
Recipients of FundingAll wealthy and poor member nations can have the opportunity to ask financial aid from the
IMF. The stable and arranged international monetary system is maintained and sustained by the IMF to
allow all participants in that system to accomplish their financial obligations to other participants. When
the IMF’s member nations experience a shortage of foreign exchange, they can access temporarily to
the pool of currencies of IMF to account for the balance of payments problem, however, it is not related
to the size of the economy or per capita GNP level. Throughout many years, nearly all IMF’s members’
nations that are from the smallest to the largest industrial countries have shares the same resources to
the IMF. They accepted the financial supports to surge them over the hard and difficult periods. The
money that lent by the IMF must be repaid between three to five years. Interest rates are below than
market rates. The members’ countries have been able to fix the economic policies by using the
resources from the IMF. They also want to re-establish growth without doing the activities that
damaging to other members’ economies.
In contrast, World Bank would not lend the money to neither wealthy countries nor private
individuals. It only lends to the developing nations and helps the governments to maintain their
economies. The worse the economy of the country is, the easier for the World Bank to lend the money
to those countries. The per capita GNP of developing countries exceeds $1,305 may borrow from the
IBRD (Driscoll, D. D., n.d.). The interest rates of these loans are higher than the market rate and the
country must do the repayment between 12 to 15 years. Not only that, only poor developing nations’
governments can borrow the loans that provided by the IDA. Those developing countries must have per
capita GNP less than $1,305 and annual per capita incomes below $865 (Driscoll, D. D., n.d.). IDA loans
are interest free and its maturity dates is 35 or 40 years.
CriticismsThe World Bank has long been criticized by non-governmental organizations, such as the
indigenous rights group Survival International, and academics, including its former Chief Economist
Joseph Stiglitz, Henry Hazlitt and Ludwig Von Mises.[45][46][47] Henry Hazlitt argued that the World
Bank along with the monetary system it was designed within would promote world inflation and "a
world in which international trade is State-dominated" when they were being advocated.[48] Stiglitz
argued that the so-called free market reform policies which the Bank advocates are often harmful to
Page 18
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
economic development if implemented badly, too quickly ("shock therapy"), in the wrong sequence or
in weak, uncompetitive economies.
One of the strongest criticisms of the World Bank has been the way in which it is governed.
While the World Bank represents 188 countries, it is run by a small number of economically powerful
countries. These countries (which also provide most of the institution's funding) choose the leadership
and senior management of the World Bank, and so their interests dominate the bank. Titus Alexander
argues that the unequal voting power of western countries and the World Bank's role in developing
countries makes it similar to the South African Development Bank under apartheid, and therefore a
pillar of global apartheid.
In the 1990s, the World Bank and the IMF forged the Washington Consensus, policies which
included deregulation and liberalization of markets, privatization and the downscaling of government.
Though the Washington Consensus was conceived as a policy that would best promote development, it
was criticized for ignoring equity, employment and how reforms like privatization were carried out.
Joseph Stiglitz argued that the Washington Consensus placed too much emphasis on the growth of
GDP, and not enough on the permanence of growth or on whether growth contributed to better living
standards.
The United States Senate Committee on Foreign Relations report criticized the World Bank and
other international financial institutions for focusing too much "on issuing loans rather than on
achieving concrete development results within a finite period of time" and called on the institution to
"strengthen anti-corruption efforts”. Criticism of the World Bank often takes the form of protesting as
seen in recent events such as the World Bank Oslo 2002 Protests, [53] the October Rebellion, and the
Battle of Seattle. Such demonstrations have occurred all over the world, even amongst the Brazilian
Kakapo people. Another source of criticism has been the tradition of having an American head the bank,
implemented because the United States provides the majority of World Bank funding. "When
economists from the World Bank visit poor countries to dispense cash and advice," observed The
Economist in 2012, "they routinely tell governments to reject cronyism and fill each important job with
the best candidate available. It is good advice. The World Bank should take it." Jim Yong Kim is the most
recently appointed president of the World Bank.
Structural adjustmentThe effect of structural adjustment policies on poor countries has been one of the most
significant criticisms of the World Bank. The 1979 energy crisis plunged many countries into economic
crisis. The World Bank responded with structural adjustment loans which distributed aid to struggling
countries while enforcing policy changes in order to reduce inflation and fiscal imbalance. Some of these
policies included encouraging production, investment and labor-intensive manufacturing, changing real
Page 19
World Bank OrganizationMC13 – 091MC13 – 062
exchange rates and altering the distribution of government resources. Structural adjustment policies
were most effective in countries with an institutional framework that allowed these policies to be
implemented easily. For some countries, particularly in Sub-Saharan Africa, economic growth regressed
and inflation worsened. The alleviation of poverty was not a goal of structural adjustment loans, and the
circumstances of the poor often worsened, due to a reduction in social spending and an increase in the
price of food, as subsidies were lifted.
By the late 1980s, international organizations began to admit that structural adjustment policies
were worsening life for the world's poor. The World Bank changed structural adjustment loans, allowing
for social spending to be maintained, and encouraging a slower change to policies such as transfer of
subsidies and price rises.[60]:70 In 1999, the World Bank and the IMF introduced the Poverty Reduction
Strategy Paper approach to replace structural adjustment loans. The Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper
approach has been interpreted as an extension of structural adjustment policies as it continues to
reinforce and legitimize global inequities. Neither approach has addressed the inherent flaws within the
global economy that contribute to economic and social inequities within developing countries. By
reinforcing the relationship between lending and client states, many believe that the World Bank has
usurped indebted countries' power to determine their own economic policy.
Fairness of assistance conditionsSome critics, most prominently the author Naomi Klein, are of the opinion that the World Bank
Group's loans and aid have unfair conditions attached to them that reflect the interests, financial power
and political doctrines (notably the Washington Consensus) of the Bank and, by extension, the countries
that are most influential within it. Amongst other allegations, Klein says the Group's credibility was
damaged "when it forced school fees on students in Ghana in exchange for a loan; when it demanded
that Tanzania privatise its water system; when it made telecom privatization a condition of aid for
Hurricane Mitch; when it demanded labor "flexibility" in Sri Lanka in the aftermath of the Asian tsunami;
when it pushed for eliminating food subsidies in post-invasion Iraq.
Sovereign immunityThe World Bank requires sovereign immunity from countries it deals with. Sovereign immunity
waives a holder from all legal liability for their actions. It is proposed that this immunity from
responsibility is a "shield which [The World Bank] wants to resort to, for escaping accountability and
security by the people." As the United States has veto power, it can prevent the World Bank from taking
action against its interests.
Page 20