Masterclass for the Restructured Electricity Industry 24-26 August 2005 © CEEM, 2005
Wind Energy in the National Electricity Market
2Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
OutlineWind energy as intermittent generationIntermittent generation- definition & issuesTrends in wind farm installations in AustraliaPlanning issuesNetwork-related issues Power variability issues– Forecasting; spot & derivative markets
Commercial viability of wind farms in the NEM
3Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Wind energy as intermittent generation
Renewable energy fluxes are time-varying:– Solar, wind, hydro (tidal), biomass, geothermal, wave
Wind & solar are non-storable:– Can be described as intermittent
4Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Intermittent generation (NEC)National Electricity Code (NEC) definition of intermittent generation:– “A generating unit whose output is not readily
predictable, including, without limitation, solar generators, wave turbine generators, wind turbine generators and hydro generators without any material storage capability”
Issues identified by NEMMCO:– Forecasting; Frequency Control Ancillary Services
(FCAS); voltage control; management of network flows
5Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
The power in the wind
Doubling the wind speed increases the power eightfoldbut doubling the turbine area only doubles the power.
6Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Australian wind resource(Estimate of background wind (m/s) – AGO)
7Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Antarctic vortex strengthening & shrinking, taking
rainfall south(ABC TV, 18/9/03)
The drought risk: rainfall in Australia, 2002 What about wind? (WMO Annual Report 2002)
8Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Comparing AusWEA forecast (www.auswea.com.au) & readily acceptable (RA) wind capacity for Australia
8900500500500220031002100RA MW
193010028012003008013Total MW
132067220800207620App MW
6102967400921713Inst MW
AusWATasSAVicNSWQld
9Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Australian wind farm planning
AusWEA best practice guidelines:– www.auswea.com.au
State handbooks & planning protocols:– NSW (SEDA); Victoria (SEAV):
Project-based, some variations between states
Stages in the process (AusWEA):– Site selection; feasibility; detailed assessment,
development application; construction; operation; decommissioning
10Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Australian wind farm planning experience to date
Limited experience to date:– Some strong support, some strong opposition
Mixed federal, state & local government approvals process lacks coherence:– Project based - may not manage cumulative issues &
interactions wellOther industries have a comprehensive planning framework, eg:– Strong, state-based planning framework for the
minerals industry
11Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Network issues for wind farms #1Networks are shared, centrally planned resources:– Must limit network disturbances caused by wind farms– Wind farms must survive disturbances from the network
Renewable resources are often distributed differently from fossil fuel resources:– Weak network conditions likely to be more common in
Australia & New Zealand than Europe or North AmericaNetwork must be built to carry peak flows:– Want good estimates of aggregation & seasonal effects
Benefits of staged development of wind resources:– Network savings; reduced voltage & frequency impacts
12Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Network issues for wind farms #2Wind turbine starting & stopping transients:– Severity can be alleviated by soft-start &
high wind-speed power-managementSome wind turbine designs:– May cause voltage distortions:
Harmonics &/or transients
– May have poor power factor, eg:Uncompensated induction generator
– May not ride-through system disturbancesTemporary voltage or frequency excursions
13Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Wind turbine type comparison(Slootweg & Kling, 2003, http://local.iee.org/ireland/Senior/Wind%20Event.htm)
14Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Size of wind turbines used by Western Power (www.wpc.com.au)
15Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Wind turbine starting transients for Esperance 2 MW wind farm 9 x 225 kW turbines with squirrel cage IGMagnetisation inrush current may cause a voltage dip - starts should be spaced out
(Rosser, 1995)
16Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Network connection issues & examples
Approximate ability of a transmission line to accept a wind farm:– 66kV ≤ 20MVA– 132kV ≤ 100MVA– 330kV ≤ 200MVA– Constraints may be determined by several factors:
Thermal, voltage, fault clearance, quality of supplyThermal ratings depend on line temperature & wind speed
Relevant wind farm rating is its maximum output, not the sum of turbine rated powers:– Coincident output of the connected wind turbines
17Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Connection costs to 330kV(Transgrid, 2002)
15028.32004
18017.71002
65012.9201
2,50012.751
Conn.cost$/kW
Conn. cost $MTotal wind MW
Wind farm number
Important to capture economies of scale of grid connection
18Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Wind resource & network issues in South Australia
Map: ESIPC, 2002
Good wind resources along entire coastline including:
• Eyre Peninsula• Yorke Peninsula• Fleurieu Peninsula• Kangaroo Island• South-East
Sites available for up to 2000MW
19Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Eyre Peninsula Backbone network upgrade to support 500MW wind
(Meritec, 2002)
Estimated cost of 275kV backbone upgrade: $140M or $280/MW assuming equally shared by 500MW of wind.
Wind may not have to pay full cost of backbone upgrade.
20Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
NEMMCO concerns about wind energy (NEMMCO, 2003)
Frequency control in normal operation:– Frequency regulating service costs ~5 $/MWH
Security control - largest single contingency– Will wind farms ride-through disturbances?
Interconnection flow fluctuations:– Exceeding flow limit may cause high spot price
Forecast errors due to wind resource uncertainty:– Five minute dispatch forecast (spot price)– Pre-dispatch & longer term (PASA & SOO) forecasts
21Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Western Power’s proposed wind penalty charge (c/kWh) (Western Power, 2002)
22Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Demand forecast errorsSouth Australia,2004 Q4 (NECA, 04Q4 Stats, 2005)
23Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Spectral analysis of Danish long-term wind data (17 years of data)
Spectral gap between weatherand local turbulence phenomena
(Sorensen, 2001, Fig 2.110, p194)
24Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Forecasting the output of wind farms30 minute horizon (FCAS & spot market):– Turbulence spectrum - likely to be uncorrelated for
turbines spaced > 20 km:Then % power fluctuations ~ N-0.5
– eg for 100 identical wind farms spaced >20 km apart, %fluctuation in total power ~ 0.1x%fluctuation for 1 farm
30 minutes to ~3 hours:– ARMA model best predictor of future output
> 3 hours - NWP model best predictor:– Key issue: predicting large changes in output of
appropriate groups of wind farms
25Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
2-hour prediction for Lake Benton wind farm, USA138 turbines, 103.5MW, hourly data (Hirst, 2001)
Two-hour ahead prediction of wind power:MWPred(T+2) = 2.7 +0.9xMW(T) + [MW(T) - MW(T-1)]
26Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Combined output of 2 wind farms 80 km apart (Gardner et al, 2003)
27Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Cross-correlation function between the output powers of 2 wind farms 80 km apart (Gardner et al, 2003)
28Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Cross-correlations between measured power outputs of German wind farms
(Giebel (2000) Riso National Lab, Denmark)
29Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Cross-correlations between 34 years of 12-hourly data for all grid points
(Giebel (2000) Riso National Lab, Denmark)
30Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Wind energy duration curve for Northern Europe (normalised to average)
(Giebel (2000) Riso National Lab, Denmark)
31Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Predicting the output of a wind turbine 6, 12, 18, 24, 36 & 48 hours ahead (Focken et al, 2002)
48 & 36 hr predictions: Front timing ok but not magnitude
48 & 36 hr predictions: Front timing later than actual
32Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Wind power scenario forecasting(Jende, 2005)
Actual: ----
Aust Govt is spending $15m ona wind power forecasting system to facilitate high levels of wind power penetration
33Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
CSIRO WindscapeTM model (www.clw.csiro.au/products/windenergy)
Windscape derives location-specific wind forecasts from a Numerical Weather Prediction model
(Steggle et al, CSIRO, March 2002)
34Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
• Windscape predictions of annual mean wind speed at 65 m, showing nested model results
• More rapid changes in colour probably imply higher local turbulence
(Steggle et al, CSIRO, March 2002)
35Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
SEDA NSW Wind atlas(www.seda.nsw.gov.au)
36Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Hampton Wind Farm, NSW (2x660 kW Vestas, connected to different 11 kV feeders)
3 Second data being collected
Turbulence probably fairly high at this site
Induction generatorsmay not ride throughvoltage dips well.
37Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Issues for NEM spot marketWind farms will operate as “price takers”:– Generate whenever wind is blowing
NEM spot market prices are volatile with a “rectangular” price distribution:– Prices are usually low, sometimes high– Timing of high prices not easily predicted
Value of wind energy in the spot market:– Will depend on how regularly wind farms are
producing when spot prices are high
38Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Price-demand plots for NEMregionsNSW (top) & SA (bottom)Jan-Mar 2004
($/MWH vs MW)(NECA, 04Q1 Stats, 2004)
39Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Smoothed NEM Regional Ref Prices (RRPs) since market inception (NECA, 04Q4 Stats, 2005)
40Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Annual average RRP flat contract prices (NECA, 04Q4 Stats, 2005)
41Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Forward prices for wind energyWind farms may have to accept a lower price than “flat contract” due to uncertainty in production: – Daily– Seasonal, – Annual
(Giebel (2000) Riso National Lab, Denmark)
42Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Renewable Energy Certificate Prices (A$/MWH) (Offer, 2003)
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
43Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
Wind farms marginal at $70/MWH(PWC, 2002)
44Wind energy in the NEM © CEEM 2005
ConclusionsIntermittent generation:– Brings new challenges for electricity industry
restructuring (technical, market design, regulation)Wind energy:– The first significant form of “intermittent generation”– Network connection issues:
often distributed differently to traditional resources
– Planning issues - visual & bird impacts:Regional, rather than project specific
– Forecasting & system security issues– Often not cost-competitive on electricity price alone