Where are we on some current trade-related issues?
Presentation by Geoffrey Wynne
Partner, Sullivan & Worcester UK LLP
on 15 December 2016
At Pinners Hall, 105-108 Old Broad Street,
London, EC2N 1EX
14835
“We live in interesting times…….!”
2016, a year of surprises
Brexit
Brexit +++
European landscape
World problems
Does this affect potential for (or actual) trade finance deals?
› Opportunities remain
› Same reluctance to commit
So what about the specifics?
2
14835
What this talk will cover
Article 55 (Bail-in) – at last some light?
Where are we on US issues?
› Dodd Frank
› FATCA
Current status of treatment of trade debt – another threat to trade?
Developments affecting capital requirements in a trade context
How is the sanctions landscape?
Money laundering and the rest
Industry documentation developments in trade finance business
Pointers from client transactions (good and bad)
3
14970
Article 55 BRRD (bail-in)
What is bail-in?
› Enforced write down of liabilities on a bank restructuring
› Obligation to include in contracts governed by law of a third country
Wide scope of liabilities
› Some have no practical possibility of being affected by bail-in
Difficult to comply with
Current ideas focused on relying on “impractical” to meet
Proposed amendments to the rule
4
14970
What is the new bail-in rule?
Allow authorities to apply proportionality
Waiver for liabilities not counting towards minimum requirement for own funds (MREL)
Based on determination
› Legally, contractually or economically impractical to include
But still in discretion of authorities
Good news!
Corrects poorly “worded” Article 55
› Has it gone far enough?
5
14970
What is coming from the US?
The usual…!
› Dodd Frank
› FATCA
US view on sanctions
› Iran and snap back
OFAC – fines and reputation risk for banks
6
14970
Dodd Frank Act (Development)
Enacted in July 2010
› 398 required rules to implement
› Only around 70% achieved
Many comments made and meetings held
› Nearly one million comments
› 23,000 pages of rules
Donald Trump and DFA
› Promise to dismantle
› Not on 100 day list
› Alternative higher bank capital ratios in exchange for freedom to conduct full range of banking
7
14970
What concerns about DFA?
Title VII and Volker
› Interpretation of participations as derivative contracts
› Particular concern on risk participations in funded transactions
S&W view on the concerns
› Identified banking products exemption
Can you safely proceed?
8
14970
FATCA
Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act
› What is it to do with me?
› Wide ranging effect – extra territorial
Some provisions in effect
› Live issues
Relates to US source interest
Applies to
› FFIs (foreign financial institutions)
› NFFE(non-financial foreign entities)
› Reviewing US source payments
Insert wording allowing party to make deductions required by FATCA with no gross up obligation
9
14970
The treatment of trade debt
The original “true trade” debate
› What is true trade debt – determined by reference to how it arose
› Debt incurred for purchase of assets in course of trading would be trade debt
Abengoa and the mood of Moodys
› Reverse factoring has debt-like features
Moodys view that trade payables held by bank should be finance debt not trade debt
Who is affected by this?
10
14970
Trade debt as finance debt
Not just balance sheet question
Auditors need to appreciate effect
Why should holder of “debt” (invoice) determine what sort of debt it is?
What problems
› Requirement to do trade debt transactions only
› What about insurers?
› What about rescheduling?
› What about liquidation?
What could be affected
› All supply chain finance?
› All forfaiting transactions?
A work around?
› Make sure variations and payment period is in the original invoice/payment obligation
11
14970
Developments affecting capital requirements in a trade context A year of promise but hopes dashed
Mixed message for 2017 and beyond
What will “Basel IV” contain?
Harder line in bank liquidity for
› Increase in leverage ratio
› Limit on banks using internal calculations
But some respite
› Determination of Net Stable Funding Ratio (NSFR)
Better treatment for export finance
Better treatment for “self liquidating products”
12
14970
A little more detail
Exposure covered by ECA guarantees to have 0% leverage ratio
Required stable funding (RSF) as applied to trade products
› Short term commitments
› Can it apply to longer term?
Other proposals by EBA (European Banking Authority)
› Assets shorter than six months (like letters of credit, factoring and forfaiting)
13
14970
Sanctions landscape Changes but clear what is covered?
More sanctions continue
Iran remains the “unknown” - Trading future
OFAC in US giving some help
OFSI, part of HMT established in March 2016
› Powers to impose monetary penalties and determine level of penalty from April 2017
› Serious breaches could be fined the higher of £1m or 50% of breach
› Details of serious breaches to be published
› Over 100 suspected breaches to financial sanctions dealt with by HMT last year
› Consultation launched in December on approach to imposition of fines
Reputation risk
Fines can be imposed on banks, countries, groups and businesses
Policing and Crime Bill currently going through Parliament
14
14970
Money Laundering etc.
Joint Committee of the three European Supervisory Authorities
› Final guidelines on the charteristics of a risk-based approach to anti-money laundering and terrorist financing supervision;
› The identification of ML/TF risk factors, whereby competent authorities obtain information on both domestic and foreign ML/TF threats affecting the relevant markets;
› The risk assessment, whereby competent authorities use this information to obtain a holistic view of the ML/TF risk associated with each credit or financial institution (‘firm’), or group of firms, including the inherent risk to which the firm or group of firms is exposed and the risk mitigants a firm or group of firms has in place;
› The allocation of AML/CFT supervisory resource based on this risk assessment, which includes decisions about the focus, depth, duration and frequency of on‐site and off‐site activities, and supervisory staffing needs, including technical expertise; and
› Monitoring and review to ensure the risk assessment and associated allocation of supervisory resource remains up to date and relevant
15
14970
Anti-Money Laundering – 4th Money Laundering Directive Transposition – June 2017
Proposed amendments following “Panama Papers” leak
Consultation on transposition into national law opened 15 September 2016 and closed on 10 November 2016
What are the issues?
› More transactions will be caught
› Greater emphasis on customer due diligence (CDD)
› Entities to be aware of and update ownership information in central registries
› Modification of meaning of ultimate beneficial owner
› Greater need for risk based approach
› Blanket exemption allowing use of simplified CDD removed
› New proposals include virtual currency exchange platforms
16
14970
Anti-Money Laundering – 4th Money Laundering Directive - Aims MLD4 aims to:
Provide a proportionate means of deterring money laundering and terrorist financing activity whilst balancing the burdens on businesses
Improve cooperation between Financial Intelligence Units
Take into account the Financial Action Task Force's (FATF) standards
Help ensure consistency across global AML policies
Increase transparency of ownership
Include previously unregistered entities – “obliged entities”
Increase number of firms complying with principles such as CDD
Include previously “Designated Non-Financial Business and Professionals”
Widen scope of “transfer of funds” transactions exceeding EUR 1,000
17
14970
Anti-Money Laundering – 4th Money Laundering Directive - Consultation LMA submitted a response to consultation in support of the aims
of proposals but seeking clarification on points to ensure reporting requirements would not be overly burdensome:
› When would it be necessary to report beneficial ownership – want to avoid disrupting entities who legitimately use such structures
› People with significant control regime (PSC) – would a security agent holding more than 25% of shares satisfy the first of the specified conditions to be considered a PSC or will they be exempt?
Joint arrangements and joint interests – will they be caught?
Interaction with financial collateral arrangements
The reasonable steps duty – are there circumstances where a borrower would be required to issue a “restrictions notice”?
What information will need to be provided from financial trusts – will requirements go beyond those imposed by CDD in Directive?
18
14970
Industry Documentation Development
BAFT and its MRPAs
Remember the difference between English and New York law BAFT
What could be changed
› updating to cover US law changes like FATCA
› reflect current issues causing problems like restructuring and whether consultation or prior agreement before changes
› others?
No wholesale rewrite
How to implement changes?
19
14970
Supply Chain and its Definitions
New Standard Definitions
› Joint industry product – variety of banks and stakeholders took part
What has changed, some examples:
“Buyer-led” “Buyer-centric”
“Supplier-led” “Supplier-centric”
“Double-funding” “Double financing”
Will changes make supply chain and receivables financing easier?
Aim is that market standard definitions will assist in establishment of legal precedents and consistency across geographic regions
20
14970
The Industry Standards
UCP 700
› There currently will not be one
URBPO
› Will 2013 rules be updated?
What else should change?
What about Insurance policies post Insurance Act 2015?
What about other credit risk mitigants?
Any ideas for industry guidelines?
21
14970
Pointers for Client Transactions
Keep Confidential (of course)
Are standards slipping?
› Effect of industry standard forms
› Documents not always fit for purpose
Are documents flexible enough (or too flexible)?
› Control of goods
› Control of funds
Back to basics
› Have basics been forgotten?
22
14970
Problems with Payees
Letters of credit and discrepancies
SWIFT payments and the fraudsters
Are the rules tight enough?
Are the documents tight enough?
Consider some examples
23
14970
Opportunities and the future New obligors coming to the market
› They may well agree better documents
Deals still hampered by issues like stamp duty on security documents
Work outs and what to do if something has gone wrong
EBA priorities: liquidity and leverage ratio; credit risk and credit risk modelling; review of CRR; implementation of total loss absorbing capacity (TLAC)
European Commission “Key Initiatives” for 2017: implementation of the “Digital Single Market Strategy” and of the “Trade for All” strategy and data protection package…
Message is still an upbeat one for 2017
24
14970
Current dates for your diary:
Breakfast seminars 2017 26 January 2017 23 February 2017
23 March 2017 27 April 2017
25 May 2017 21 June 2017
27 July 2017 28 September 2017
26 October 2017 23 November 2017
14 December 2017
25
14970
Geoffrey L Wynne Partner
Geoffrey Wynne is head of Sullivan & Worcester’s London office and also head of its Trade & Export Finance Group. He has extensive experience in banking and finance, specifically trade and structured trade and commodity finance. He also advises on corporate and international finance, asset and project finance, syndicated lending, equipment leasing and workouts and financing restructuring.
Geoff is one of the leading trade finance lawyers and has advised extensively many of the major trade finance banks, multilateral financers and companies around the world on trade and commodity transactions in virtually every emerging market including CIS, Far East, India, Africa and Latin America. He has worked on many structured trade transactions covering such diverse commodities as oil, nickel, steel, tobacco, cocoa and coffee. He has worked on warehouse financings in many jurisdictions and advised on how to structure involving warehouse operators and collateral managers. He has also advised on ownership structures and repos for commodities and receivables financings.
Geoff sits on the editorial boards of a number of publications and is a regular contributor and speaker at conferences. He is also the editor of and contributor to The Practitioner’s Guide to Trade and Commodity Finance published by Sweet & Maxwell and A Guide to Receivables Finance, a special report from TFR published by Ark.
Sullivan & Worcester UK LLP Tower 42 25 Old Broad Street London EC2N 1HQ
T +44 (0)20 7448 1001 F +44 (0)20 7900 3472 [email protected]
26
14970
Awards & Recognition
TFR “Best Law Firm in Trade Finance”
Trade & Forfaiting Review (TFR) named Sullivan & Worcester "Best Law Firm in Trade Finance" in its 2014, 2015 and 2016 TFR Excellence Awards
GTR “Best Law Firm 2015 Poll”
Sullivan & Worcester UK LLP was top ranked firm in the Global Trade Review (GTR) Best Law Firm 2015 poll
The Legal 500 UK 2016
Sullivan & Worcester UK LLP was ranked in the following category in The Legal 500 UK:
› Trade Finance (Tier 1)
Chambers UK 2016
Chambers UK ranked Sullivan & Worcester UK LLP, along with Geoffrey Wynne and Simon Cook in the following area:
› Commodities: Trade Finance (UK-wide)
www.sandw.com
Offices
Boston Sullivan & Worcester LLP One Post Office Square Boston, MA 02109 Tel: 617 338 2800 Fax: 617 338 2880
London Sullivan & Worcester UK LLP Tower 42 25 Old Broad Street London EC2N 1HQ Tel: +44 (0)20 7448 1000 Fax: +44 (0)20 7900 3472
New York Sullivan & Worcester LLP 1633 Broadway New York, NY 10019 Tel: 212 660 3000 Fax: 212 660 3001
Washington, D.C. Sullivan & Worcester LLP 1666 K Street, NW Washington, DC 20006 Tel: 202 775 1200 Fax: 202 293 2275
28
© 2016 Sullivan & Worcester
Sullivan & Worcester is the collective trade name for an international legal practice. Sullivan & Worcester UK LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England and Wales under number OC381549 and is a practice of registered and foreign lawyers and English solicitors. Sullivan & Worcester UK LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (“SRA”). The term partner is used to refer to a member of Sullivan & Worcester UK LLP. A list of the names of all the partners is available for inspection at our registered office, Tower 42, 25 Old Broad Street, London, EC2N 1HQ. Please see sandw.com for Legal Notices, including further information on our professional obligations.
This presentation is not designed to provide legal or other advice and you should not take, or refrain from taking, action based on its content. We are providing information to you on the basis you agree to keep it confidential. If you give us confidential information but do not instruct or retain us, we may act for another client on any matter to which that confidential information may be relevant.
14125