Copyright © Buchanan 2008
This PowerPoint presentation on Stigma was originally presented at a Scottish Drug Forum Conference on
Drug Use and Stigma
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
People who may suffer stigma• A person with disability• A person from Black Minority Ethnic Group• A Gay/Lesbian person• A person with a drug problem • A person with mental health difficulties• A person from a religious minority• A person who is HIV+• Any person who is defined as ‘different’
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
What is Stigma?The concept of stigma refers to negative
stereotypes assigned to a people when their attributes are considered both different from or inferior to societal norms.
For Goffman stigma was about the social
interactions between ‘stigmatized’ and ‘normal’ persons in society.
The process of stigma is deeply discrediting.(Goffman 1963)
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Processof stigma
– involves severe social disapproval of a persons characteristics or their beliefs which at the time are considered to be unacceptable to dominant cultural norms
stereotypes&
labels
roles&
expectations
diminishedopportunities
STIGMA
Internalised& reinforced
tainted identity
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Impact of StigmaIsolation – lack of social capitalRejection – reduced life opportunitiesHostility – even violence (e.g. Stephen Lawrence)Marginalised – face discrimination and exclusion
Restricts a person's ability to develop their potential and impact negatively upon:
– Relationships– Housing– Health– Employment– Insurance– Education– Travel
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Stigma reflects cultural shifts in norms• What was acceptable in the past may be
unacceptable today.
• What was unacceptable in the past may be acceptable today.
• What is unacceptable today may be acceptable in the future.
• What is acceptable today may be unacceptable in the future.
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Smoking was once an
approved and
promoted cultural norm
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Smoking is no longer an approved cultural norm
Smoking now attracts stigma
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Thestigmatization
oftobacco
users
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
In the UK opium was once a socially acceptable and widely used
drugfor recreational as well as medicinal
purposes.
The Lakeland poets were a distinguished group of opium users
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Samuel Taylor ColeridgeLaudanum, a solution of
opium and alcohol
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Opiate use today carries considerable stigma and is
presented as an evil in our society
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Drugs & Drug Users - the Enemy?‘hardly a family is unaffected by the evil of drugsevil of drugs… Drug-related
crimecrime blights our communities. It destroys familiesdestroys families and young lives and fuelsfuels a wide range of criminal activity, including burglaryburglary and robberyrobbery….. We won’t tolerate the menacemenace of drugs in our communities – it causes miserymisery and costs livescosts lives…. This new money will enable agencies to step up their fight against drugsagainst drugs and the crime it breedsbreeds. It will get drug dealers off our kids’kids’ backs and into prison and help safeguard our communities’
HM Treasury Press Release, 49/01 09 April 2001
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Drug use is portrayed in the media as the key causal factor in violent
and abhorrent crimes
- as if taking an illicit substance turns people into monsters
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Demonizing drugs and drug users
Government Voices– ‘Drug misuse can ruin individual lives, tear open families and
blight whole communities with the menace of dealers and crime driven by drug abuse… more drug dealers – people who profit in the misery of others – behind bars… more addicts into treatment…further powers for police to drug test suspected addicts on arrest… vicious circle of drugs and crime …dealers will face harsher sentences where they prey on children …Drugs are a scourge on the world’ (2005)
Media Voices– ‘Cannabis caused a 14-year-old to kill’ …. ‘Woman murdered was
deliberately run down by suspected drug addicts’
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Demonizing drugs and drug users (2)
Community Voices– ‘there’s always junkies … they fight people are
aggressive, do dealing in houses, break-ins and steal from cars …..get rid of all the junkies…nuke the junkie scum’
Drug User Voices– ‘They look down on me as scum of the earth and
as someone not to be associated with’ another said ‘They see me as a drug addict, a smackhead and they think I’d rob them’
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
The Drug Divide
Buchanan J (2009 forthcoming) Understanding and misunderstanding problem drug use, in R. Carnwell & J. Buchanan (eds) Effective Practice in Health, Social Care & Criminal Justice: A partnership approach, Second edition, Open University Press, Maidenhead.
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
The Barrier of Exclusion
‘it is evident that the anti-drug campaigns over the past 20 years have added to the isolation and marginalization of the discarded working-class youth …. In addition to having to overcome their addiction, one of the biggest hurdles they have to face is breaking through the barrier of social exclusion.
JULIAN BUCHANAN & LEE YOUNGThe War on Drugs -a war on drug users?Drugs: education, prevention and policy, Vol. 7, No. 4, 2000
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
House of Commons Science and Technology Committee: Evidence 2006: Ev 114
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Problem drug users‘The motivations for using illegal drugs are largely the same as the motivation for using legal drugs – a pleasurable habit, to be social, to relax and generally enjoy the affect of the drug. However, a small proportion of people who use drugs (legal and illegal substances) develop serious drug problems (UNODC 2007). The vast majority of drug users are recreational users who use drugs in a controlled manner without incurring significant social, psychological and/or physical problems to themselves or others around them. In contrast the minority who develop problems sometimes referred to as ‘problem drug users’ become socially, psychologically and/or physically dependent and this lack of control tends to have a detrimental impact upon their social, psychological and/or physical well-being, and is likely to have a negative impact upon those around them.’
Buchanan J (2009 forthcoming) Understanding and misunderstanding problem drug use: working together, in R Carnwell & J Buchanan (eds) Effective Practice in Health, Social Care & Criminal Justice: A partnership approach, Open University Press, Maidenhead.
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
The USA & UK War on Drugs - locking up drug users?
In 1996 the US prison population was 1.6m Today it exceeds 2.3m
In 1985 the UK prison population figure was 47,500 Today it exceeds 83,000
Many prisoner have severe social and psychological problems: reading, writing, numeracy, mental health, dyslexia, drugs, no
qualifications, poor family support
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Institutionalised stigma has invited widespread
discrimination
Discrimination involves those in positions of power exercising prejudicial beliefs, actions, or judgments and
using their power against the less powerful. The discrimination is based on difference and serves to maintain division and power by drawing upon and reinforcing stigma
and stereotypes.
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Discrimination – more than just being rude
DISCRIMINATION =
POWER + DIFFERENCE + PREJUDICE
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
PCS ModelThompson, N. (2006) Anti-Discriminatory Practice, Palgrave
• Personal• Cultural• Structural CP C S
Discrimination occurs at three distinct levels
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Damaged identities
‘The constant experience of this marginalization has led many problem drug users to internalize their problems and blame themselves for their plight. This loss of self-esteem then becomes a serious debilitating factor as they feel isolated and excluded from society.’ (p.394)
Buchanan J (2004) Missing Links: Problem Drug Use and Social Exclusion, Probation Journal Special Edition on Problem Drug Use Vol 51 No.4 pp.387-397
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Mixing with ‘Non’ Drug Users‘I feel a bit beneath them, they make you feel like that’
‘I used to avoid them like the plague’
‘I’ve got to watch what I say so I don’t land myself in it. They blame smack heads for everything.’
‘I feel labelled … like they thought I was dirt’
‘Most people look down their noses if drugs are mentioned’
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Stigma & discrimination worse than the drugs?
‘In an environment frightened with powerful moral and legal reactions to the use of drugs, the stigma attached to drugs may come to be a more important factor than the biology of addiction. The demonization of drugs and the criminalization of the drug user (i.e. the war on drugs) could be more damaging to the individual and society than drug use or addiction’ (p.31)
Drucker, E. (2000) ‘From Morphine to Methadone: Maintenance Drugs in the Treatment of Opiate Addiction’, in J.A. Incardia and L.D. Harrison (eds) Harm Reduction National and International Perspectives, pp. 27–45. London: Sage.
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Impact of drug users‘I’m sick of it. I see people with their own houses, family and friends. I’d like friends who don’t
use’
‘I’ve been wanting to change for five years’
‘I want to be drug free, get a job and lead a normal life’
‘It is difficult you feel divorced from the mainstream. I want to get back into it’
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Arguably the biggest hurdle a recovering long term problem drug user has to
overcome is not physical addiction, nor psychological cravings - but trying to break through the ‘wall of exclusion’ that keeps
them in a drug ghetto. This makes it extremely difficult for them to acquire new routines, friendships, skills, hobbies and
lifestyle. They are often ostracised, criticised
and distrusted.
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
The struggle for re-integration
Adapted from Buchanan J (2004) Tackling Problem Drug Use: A New Conceptual Framework, pp117-138, in Social Work in Mental in Health, Vol. 2 No 2/3, Haworth press Free article download from http://epubs.newi.ac.uk/siru/1/
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Re-integration or integration‘When considering treatment and rehabilitation it must be recognised that
many problem drug users have had such limited options in life, that they lack personal resources (confidence, social skills and life skills) and have limited positive life experiences to lean upon or return to.
This client group need social integration not social reintegration, they need habilitation not re-habilitation – it seems that many have never really been able to get started in life in the first place. This makes living without drugs a very tough option indeed.’ (p.397)
Buchanan J (2004) Missing Links: Problem Drug Use and Social Exclusion, Probation Journal Special Edition on Problem Drug Use Vol 51 No.4 pp.387-397
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Challenging Stigma & Discrimination
• Must happen at all three levels: personal, cultural and structural.
• Requires an ongoing public campaign to challenge existing stereotypes and promote positive images.
• Requires a challenge to existing language, notions and images used to make sense of drugs.
• Require education and training to inform people.
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Challenging Discrimination
Personal Cultural Structural
Degree of Influence
It is easier to have impact at tackling personal
attitudes and behaviours but tackling cultural and
structural discrimination (institutional) is much more
difficult.
high
low
Thompson, N. (2006) Anti-Discriminatory Practice, Palgrave(Thompson N 2006)
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
A different way of seeing?
We are all drug users
Low risk High risk
‘All drug taking presents a degree of risk and some legal drugs will pose greater risk than some illegal drugs. It is argued then that rather than consider legal drugs as safer and illegal drugs more harmful, and rather than assess drugs according to a hierarchical table of risk posed by different drugs, there is a need for a comprehensive individual assessments to be made for each person according to the nature and context of the drug taking and this is best placed upon a broad continuum of risk which is applicable for all {legal user and illegal users alike] … it should be remembered then that virtually everyone uses drugs, and all drug taking presents some risk’ .
Buchanan J (2009 forthcoming) Understanding and misunderstanding problem drug use: working together, in R Carnwell & J Buchanan (eds) Effective Practice in Health, Social Care & Criminal Justice: A partnership approach, Open University Press, Maidenhead.
Copyright © Buchanan 2008
Home page:http://julianbuchanan.wordpress.com/
PLEASE NOTE:
Feel free to use any of this material just make sure you reference.If you want more information do contact me.
thanks