1 | P a g e
The Great Battle of Instant Noodles in India: Case Study
*Shelendra K. Tyagi*
Background:
Nestle has been in India for a hundred years now. It began life in the country in 1912 as The Nestle
Anglo-Swiss Condensed Milk Company (Export) Limited, importing and selling finished products in
the Indian market. It has now grown as India's largest food company with seven manufacturing
facilities: Moga in Punjab (in 1961), Choladi in Tamil Nadu (1967), Nanjangud in Karnataka (1989),
Samalkha in Haryana (1993), Ponda and Bicholim in Goa (1995 and 1997, respectively) and
Pantnagar in Uttarakhand (2006).
The brands in its portfolio are: Maggi (instant noodles, sauces, soups and spices), KitKat, Bar One,
Munch, Nescafe, Milkmaid, Nestea and Polo. Nestle is also the largest maker of milk substitutes and
infant foods, though it does not advertise or promote these products. The biggest brand in Nestle's
portfolio is Maggi (it overtook Nescafe about ten years ago): its market share is almost 75 per cent.1
Class of Goods Gross Sales (FY 2012)
Quantity (in MT) (in millions)
Milk Products and Nutrition 140,386 38,593.90
Beverages 25,353 11,227.30
Prepared dishes and cooking aids 236,554 24,301.50
Chocolates and confectionery 47,745 11,691.10 (Source: Nestle India Ltd Annual Report 2012)
Nestl India Ltd. (NIL), the Indian subsidiary of the global FMCG major, Nestl SA, introduced the
Maggi brand in India in 1982, with its launch of Maggi 2 Minute Noodles, an instant noodles product.
With the launch of Maggi noodles, Nestle created an entirely new food category - instant noodles -
in the Indian packaged food market. Because of its first-mover advantage, Nestle successfully
managed to retain its leadership in the instant noodles category even until the early 2000s.
Over the years, Nestle extended the Maggi brand to a variety of culinary products like soups, sauces
and ketchups, and cooking aids among others. However, these product extensions were not as
successful as the instant noodles. In 2005, Nestle started offering a range of new 'healthy' products
under the Maggi brand, in a bid to attract health-conscious consumers.
*Prof Shelendra K. Tyagi is Associate Professor in the area of marketing at Lal Bahadur Shastri Institute of Management, New Delhi 2013 by the Lal Bahadur Shastri Institute of Management, Delhi. Cases are developed solely as the basis for
class discussion. Cases are not intended to serve as endorsements, source of primary data or illustration of
effective or ineffective management.
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
2 | P a g e
Packaged Food Industry:
Are two-minute noodles your idea of breakfast when in a hurry? Do you buy ready-to-eat paneer
curry for dinner because your cook is absent?
If yes, you are a part of Indias 82% workforce from metro cities which prefers to eat packaged food
to eating outside, as per a survey done by Association of Chamber of Commerce and Industry of
India (Assocham).2The survey, which was conducted in 2,000 households of Mumbai, Delhi, Kolkata,
Chennai, Bangalore and other tier A cities, shows that ready-to-eat (RTE) food is preferred by nuclear
families, where both husband and wife are working professionals, bachelors who want to avoid hotel
food, and people who do not have the time, patience or expertise to cook at home.
At present, the market size of the packaged food sector in India stands at $15 billion and is likely to
double to $30 billion by 2015 on the back of arrival of multinationals in the sector and modern retail
trade, as per industry body Assocham. Indian packaged food industry is growing at a CAGR of about
15 to 20 per cent annually. 2
The main categories of packaged food are bakery products, canned/dried processed food, processed
dairy products, frozen ready-to-eat foods (RTE), diet snacks, processed meat and pro-biotic drinks.
Some key players in this industry are Hindustan Unilever, Nestle, PepsiCo and Haldiram. Strong
desire among consumers to maintain a healthy lifestyle is driving the functional foods and beverages
market. Consumption of such products is much higher in the urban areas, especially metros, where
life is fast-paced and stressful. The report says urban areas contribute to almost 72% sale of such
products, with the North and West responsible for 2/3 of the sale.
Region-wise sale of packaged foods in 2011
(Source: Workforce in metros prefers packaged food to eating outside)
Further, according to another survey named, 'Rising prices of fruits and vegetables', [conducted by
the Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India (Assocham) under the aegis of
Assocham Social Development Foundation (ASDF)] 3 over 58% of middle and low income group have
switched over to pre-cooked and ready-to-eat (RTE) food items due to steep rise in prices of fruits
and vegetables in order to keep the kitchen budget intact. The survey polled 5,000 people to
21%
28% 21%
30% East and Northeast
North
South
West
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
3 | P a g e
evaluate the impact of rise in price of fruits and vegetables. Published in the first week of July 2013,
the survey was conducted in major cities such as Pune, Mumbai, Delhi-NCR, Kolkata, Chennai,
Ahmedabad, Hyderabad, Chandigarh, Dehradun and Bengaluru. The maximum impact was felt in
Delhi, followed by Mumbai, Ahmedabad, Kolkata, Chennai, Hyderabad and Pune.
MAGGI Brand:
(Source: http://www.nestle.in/brands/pdca)
It's the last man standing, a survivor, and a brand that created and dominated a category throughout
its existence. Along the way, it lost a few of its launch flavours like Capsica, and even made a few
disastrous missteps like the 'sweet' noodles and the change of flavour in the flagship for a brief
period in the mid-90s. But in the near two decades of its existence, Maggi has been the only show in
town when it comes to noodles. Even today, it leads the pack with >75% share.1The brand has now
been successfully extended into sauces, soups and pasta. It has built its brand equity on the bas do
minute promise, which actually meant riding on the convenience factor and became the generic
name to define the category in the absence of competition for years.
In 2005, Nestle came out with Maggi atta (whole-wheat flour) instant noodles. All over the country,
atta is considered healthier than maida or refined flour which the company was using from day one.
This helped the company take the health platform. It was then that it added the tagline, 'health bhi,
taste bhi' (health as well as taste). Maggi's properties were expanded from convenience alone to
include taste and health as well. That was also the time when Nestle was repositioning itself
worldwide as a health and wellness company.
Through its long history, Maggi has burnt through a wide range of positioning lines and statements.
When Maggi entered the country, Nestle used TV heavily to familiarise consumers with the brand.
Its initial campaign 'Fast to Cook, Good to Eat' became a catchphrase and '2 Minutes' gesture of the
Maggi mom was widely imitated. The 25th anniversary campaign around the theme 'Mein aur Meri
Maggi' acknowledged a generation that has grown up on the brand and which is now poised to
include it in the diet of its children.
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
4 | P a g e
Brand Journey over the Years:
1997: changes the formulation of Maggi noodles, which proves to be a mistake as consumers do not like the taste of new
noodles
1999: Maggi reintroduces the old formulation, which helps revive sales
2000: In early 2000s, Maggi is the leader in instant noodles space
2009: Maggi celebrates 25 years of Maggi Noodles with 'Me and Meri Maggi' interactive campaign. Launch of Maggi Pazzta
2012: Amitabh Bachchan is the new brand ambassador for Maggi4
2012: For the second year in a row MAGGI in 2012 was rated amongst Indias Top 10 ''Most trusted Brands'' by Economic
Times Brand Equity5
2012:MAGGI Masala-ae-Magic was recognised as one of the ''Most trusted Brands of 2012'' in the Readers Digest awards5
2012: In the annual ICMR study on Indias most valuable brands, MAGGI was ranked No.1 amongst FMCG Food Products,
and a separate ranking by Nielsen for Social Media Brand Equity ranked MAGGI as No.1 Food Brand. 5
(Source: http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-11-07/news/34970808)
Moreover, as per a new survey from industry analysts Kantar Worldpanel,6 published on May 2,
2013, Nestls Maggi is the food brand purchased most regularly around the world. It gives a brand's
"consumer reach points", which measures for the first time how many households around the world
are buying a brand (its penetration) and how often (the number of times shoppers acquire the
brand). Kantar Worldpanel analysed data from 32 markets. Maggi was sixth on the list, chosen
1.58bn times a year. Unilever's Knorr was the next highest food brand at eight, with households
purchasing the brand 1.29bn times a year. PepsiCo's Lay's brand was in at nine. Some 1.14bn
households put that brand in their baskets a year.
5 | P a g e
Nestls Maggi has been synonymous with instant noodles in India for a long time now. So despite
the entry of Hindustan Unilever (Knorr Soupy Noodles), IndoNissin (Top Ramen), GlaxoSmithKline
(Horlicks Foodles)and ITC (Sunfeast Yippie), the Swiss major has remained the undisputed king with
around >75 per cent share in the Rs 2,500 crore branded noodles market that is growing at 20-25
per cent annually1. Category penetration of 40%+ indicates noodles widespread acceptance as a
regular grocery item for many Indians. Noodles per se have become accepted by Indians it can be
seen in its various avatars as street food and food you serve to guests, give your children to take to
school.
Competition:
Late 2009 Now
The market has seen more activity in three years than it has seen in the previous twenty. All of a
sudden companies have figured out that noodles is 'the' market to be in. Horlicks launched Foodles,
then Hindustan Unilever brought Knorr Soupy Noodles, then ITC came up with Sunfeast Yippee!
Seeing the buzz, Top Ramen has also re-branded itself last year by getting a new pack and a new
brand ambassador (Saina Nehwal). Maggi, which has dominated the instant noodles market for
nearly three decades, is now being challenged by aggressive new entrants such as ITC's Sunfeast
Yippee, GlaxoSmithKline's Horlicks Foodles and Hindustan Unilever's Knorr Soupy Noodles. Other
brands that may not have the huge money power of the multinational giants but which are
piggybacking on the opportunity afforded by modern trade are Ching's Secret and Smith & Jones
from Capital Foods and the Future Group's private label brand Tasty Treat. Also present in certain
pockets for nearly a decade are the likes of Wai Wai and Top Ramen.
Many experts still believe that none of the other players are yet a real threat to Maggi, though
collectively, they would have chipped away some share from it. Thats reason enough for Nestle
executives to be supremely confident. A Nestle India spokesperson says, exact market shares are
irrelevant because Maggi virtually denotes the instant noodles category.7That might be so till now.
But Maggi is all set to face its toughest challenge yet from Sunfeast Yippie, which has already
grabbed around 10 per cent (Double Digit) market share in just a few years of its launch. In the
process, Yippie has become the second largest player ahead of Top Ramans 5 per cent1. Though,
others are still scraping the bottom of the barrel.
Horlick Foodles: 'Noodles' without the NO
(Source: http://themarkmanager.blogspot.in/2011/11/brand-story-horlicks-foodles.html)
AmanHighlight
6 | P a g e
Since Foodles is endorsed by Horlicks, it was launched in South (where mother brand Horlicks is
strong) in late 2009. It was extended to East India in March 2010 (East is also Horlicks stronghold)
and finally rolled out to the rest of India by July 2010. Foodles was launched with an aim to gain 6-
10% share in one year. Explaining the decision, Shubhajit Sen, VP - marketing, GSK says, "Horlicks
was always sweet, even the biscuits and cereal bar. We wanted to extend the brand into a savoury
or salty kind of product and Foodles was an opportunity to do that."8
First year sales stood at 32 crores and they ended the year with 4% share. The launch ad created a
lot of awareness in the market.
The launch advertisement shows a mother who is not happy with her son eating noodles. The tug of
war is a continuous clash of interests between the mother and her son. This is the situation all
mothers are in, and there appears Foodles. A healthy noodle made of four grain. So the mother can
now let her son eat and enjoy noodles freely.
Positioning
The company positioned Foodles on the health, taste and convenience plank. In the case of Foodles,
nutrition is the differentiator, remaining consistent with the plank already occupied by Horlicks. "We
are targeting those consumers who may have hesitated from participating in this category because
of any lingering doubts. We have positioned Foodles as the more nutritious noodles," says Sen. 8 So
besides the regular flavour, Foodles is also available in a multi-grain option. While health is a big
concern, Nestle's own Dal Atta variant was not well accepted due to the difference in taste.
Advertisement Round II
After one year of launch, Foodles broke its second campaign. 'Bhaskar ki kahani'. This ad talks about
why Foodles is more nourishing. The same reason to believe the claim - four grain noodles. The
packaging and story are different but the message is the same.
(Source: http://themarkmanager.blogspot.in/2011/11/brand-story-horlicks-foodles.html)
Foodles did also try to get trials by tying up with the movie 'Kung Fu Panda 2'. Initially Foodles was
available only in single-pack sizes which account for 28-29 per cent of the market. Later on it rolled
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
7 | P a g e
out the larger family packs of eight and four strips. It is also priced at a premium, in line with the
mid-premium image of its mother brand Horlicks. Its multigrain variant costs Rs 15 for 80 gm
compared to Maggis Rs 10 for 80 gm.
Ching's Secret has a long, hoary history trying to take on the might of Maggi nearly a decade and a
half ago with a more traditional Chinese noodle offering. While this found no takers, it is still part of
the arsenal at Capital Foods. The company is fielding both Ching's Secret as well as Smith & Jones,
with the former aimed at a more youthful demographic. The masala flavour is being keenly
contested by Captial Foods as well via its Smith & Jones brand. Ching's Secret is aimed at youth
between ages 16-25, where there is a demand for something spicier.
Ajay Gupta, CEO, Capital Foods suggests there's enough room for everybody: "Maggi has not just
established the category, but grown the market as well. There are a lot of consumers entering the
category, which is seeing a 20-25% growth year on year." "Maggi was the leader for kids, but as they
grow up their needs change and that is the space we have tried to occupy with Ching's Secret," says
Gupta8.
Sunfeast Yippee! instant noodles
Yippee! Magic Masala
Yippee! Classic Masala
Yippee! Chinese Masala
(Source: www.itcportal.com)
ITC launched Sunfeast Yippee! instant noodles in December 2010, and differentiated it on product
attributes. In the branding of noodles, Sunfeast has adopted an endorsing structure where Sunfeast
brand will endorse the Noodle brand "Yippee ". The look of the brand says that it is positioned as a
happy, vibrant, fun loving brand. ITC Foods Divisional Chief Executive Chitranjan Dar says, "It has
taken us a while to launch but we wanted to ensure we had a differentiated product.9 ITC started
working on instant noodles a couple of years back. Pasta preceded noodles as it gave the brand a
head start with hardly any competition around. It continues to be a small section of the instant foods
market as pasta is yet to establish itself as a mainstream food option in India.
Launch campaign for Yippee! ITC has depicted a kid questioning conventions based on these
product attributes so that people are compelled to rethink what instant noodles should be. ITC also
went to large format stores and supermarkets with large scale sampling of the cooked noodles. For
instance, it was showcased at Future Group's Big Bazaar, a petri dish for Maggi-challengers such as
Future Group's private label Tasty Treat and Capital Foods' Ching's Secret and Smith & Jones.
The market response for Yippee! was good and ITC, which had hoped that its plant in Pune would be
enough to cater to the demand for the next 15 months, is already running at full capacity. The
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
8 | P a g e
company is not only expanding the capacity in this plant but is setting up two new plants in the north
and east to meet the demand surge.
ITC gains market share
ITC studied the behaviour of consumers of Maggi and other competing products for two to three
years just to understand whether there was some disconnect about the products in consumers
mind. The company found three things: one, some of the noodles in the market become sticky if
they are not consumed early. Two, children prefer to slurp noodles while eating and therefore prefer
a longer noodle than what was available in the market. And three, many kids add sauce to enhance
the taste and look of noodles.
ITC has also leveraged its culinary strengths - chefs from the ITC Welcomgroup hotels to get the right
mix for the product. So one innovation was to offer round-shaped noodles so that the size could be
longer. Secondly, the company decided to have two different flavours within the masala category
Classic Masala and Magic Masala that has a tinge of tomato both in terms of colour and flavour. Kids
who added sauce to the noodles earlier are the obvious target group. The third innovation was
usage of new drying technologies to ensure that the noodles do not go sticky. Research had also
showed that many consumers garnish noodles - so ITC decided to add some vegetable garnishing to
its noodles. In keeping with its policy of not splurging on advertising, Yippie depended on word-of-
mouth and was sampled by over 2 million consumers across the country before its launch. To begin
with, ITC is concentrating on only those towns that have a population of over 100,000. The next
target would be to go to places with a population of 50,000 and above.
Health platform is something Yippie has still not tried. That is because ITC does not want to expand the portfolio too much for the time being. Besides, health-based noodles constitute just 3 per cent of the total market so ITC may look at it later including regional variations in tastes as well. This of course would also mean that Yippie has to go just beyond the two pack sizes which are available for Rs 5 and Rs 10. In the next phase ITC has launched larger pack size like family packs. ITC recently has also launched the third variant of Yippee, called the Chinese Masala in May 2013.10
Knorr Soupy Noodles
(Source: http://www.hul.co.in/brands-in-action/view-brands.aspx)
After GlaxoSmithkline Consumer Healthcares (GSKCHs) entry into the noodles segment, global
FMCG major Hindustan Unilever Ltd (HUL) also entered the category in March 2010. The company
launched Knorr Soupy Noodles in Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala and Tamil Nadu. Launching
noodles under the Knorr brand will help the company grab market share faster, as Knorr has strong
brand equity. It is number one in the soup category, followed by Maggi soups. Known only for soups,
which constitute a minuscule category in India, HUL is betting on the soupy noodles to expand the
footprint of the Knorr brand to areas beyond urban markets. "Noodles in India is about 12 times
bigger than soups and everyone who consumes soup also knows about noodles. A typical Indian
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
9 | P a g e
family has 25-30 packs of noodles in a year, whereas soups are not too popular. It is mostly
consumed by the higher SECs," says Sidharth Singh, VP, packaged foods, HUL.8
For its Soupy Noodles, HUL is occupying a plank that's not dissimilar to what Maggi started with: a
mini meal when children return from school and before they leave for play or tuitions. But HUL
hopes to build traction for the soup habit via the already fairly well established noodle habit. Knorr's
Soupy Noodles presents a chance to accomplish several targets with just one product. It comes with
100% real vegetables & carries the Healthy Choice' Stamp. It is currently available in four
variants: Mast Masala, Tomato Chatpata, Chinese Chow and Yummy Chicken. The powder in Knorr
Soupy Noodles is not simply a tastemaker or spices but actual soup powder, with a taste and
consistency similar to Knorr's flagship product. It is a quick hunger filling snack. Just soup is not a
good for that time and nor do kids find it particularly exciting. But when you give noodles with a
combination of soup they like it. This is our position of strength as well as differentiation," explains
Singh. 8 HUL has roped in Kajol to help push Knorr soupy noodles. Knorrs campaign is based on the
insight that when a kid is given something new to eat he is quite fussy about it. So to engage better
with them and to make the experience fun, HUL has used the route of a game play in the TV
Commercial. The 'Thoda Khao, Thoda Piyo' proposition helped the kids understand how to consume
the product and made it fun at the same time.
Market response for Knorr Soupy Noodles was also good and again it was a case of demand being
more than supply as HUL could not get into more markets because of capacity constraints. Initially
the product was available only in single packs of Rs 10 when the demand for bigger packs was
getting louder (The bigger pack is being demanded by households with children).
Top Ramen has also re-branded itself last year by getting a new pack and a new brand ambassador
(Saina Nehwal). It is yet another attempt to reposition Top Ramen noodles from Indo Nissin, the
Indian unit of Japans Nissin Food Products. It started its innings in India in a partnership with
Hindustan Unilever, which lasted only a few years. It then inked a deal with Marico, which served it
well for seven years. By then Indo Nissin had achieved a critical turnover mass and was keen to set
up its own distribution network in India.
This is not the first time Top Ramen is going through a brand overhaul. Since it entered India in 1991,
the brands journey has not been smooth. It has been changing its product composition and
marketing pitch regularly to click with Indian consumers. Its debut in India was with a product similar
to the Japanese style soupy noodles with a soya flavour, sold in a pillow pack. Sales remained in the
dumps as Indians were used to the taste of Nestls Maggi, which was dry and mostly eaten from a
plate. In 1992, the brand decided to take on Maggi on its turf and relaunched Top Ramen as an easy-
to-prepare snack food. It also launched new flavours like masala and vegetable. However, this did
little to loosen Maggis stranglehold in the Indian market.
A few years later, the company decided to differentiate the brand through the texture of the
product, and said as much with a new slogan, Dont be a noodle, be a smoodle. The word smoodle,
as the sales graph showed, failed to make the connect and Top Ramen continued to languish in a
market driven by taste, convenience, affordability and availability. Then a little emotional play
seemed to open up the Indian market. Top Ramen changed its positioning once again to smooth
noodles and went on to convey the message through advertising that featured a boy lost in the
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
10 | P a g e
jungle, whose mother prepares Top Ramen noodles as a way to find him. The boy reappears, drawn
by the aroma of the noodles, and Top Ramen, in the process, unites the family. Drawing a parallel
with Mowgli, the much-loved fictional character from Rudyard Kiplings short stories, Top Ramen
seemed to finally build a rapport with Indian kids.
Top Ramens current re-branding Campaign
Top Boy is a playful character who never runs out of energy. As ace
shuttler Sania Nehwal picks up a pack of noodles, the super active
Top Boy flies out of the pack challenging her to a game of badminton.
An exciting game follows. Kids watch the duo play, wondering about
the secret behind the energy. The ad closes on the shot of the new
Top Ramen super noodles fortified with vitamin energy.
(Source: www.business-standard.com/article/management/instant-noodles-instant-energy)
Keeping it healthy - In its latest effort, the company is trying to relaunch the brand as super
noodles. Instead of trumpeting the texture of the noodles, it now wants to focus on its health
benefits. We want consumers to notice that we have improved the taste and fortified the noodles
with vitamins, says MNVV Prasad, general manager, marketing, Indo Nissin.11 This comes at a time
when most food brands have cottoned on to health as a differentiator. Maggi has a healthy atta
variant and has recently launched its four-grain noodles.
From the looks of it, Top Ramen means business and is ready to loosen its purse strings. The brands
focus on health in general and energy in particular is apparent from the brands choice of Saina
Nehwal as ambassador. The makeover, orchestrated by its new advertising agency Dentsu, will ride
on a new slogan, Be the Champion, and a new mascot, the Top Boy. The aim is to appeal to kids,
who account for 80 per cent of instant noodle sales in India. 11 The secondary objective of this
campaign is also to appeal to mothers who play a key role in influencing purchase decisions. To
address the two target segments, the television commercial is being aired on childrens and Hindi
general entertainment channels. The repositioning exercise will also manifest itself through its new
packaging, online initiatives and on-ground activations.
However, the biggest challenge for Indo Nissin will be of improving reach something its
competitors have invested heavily in. Unfortunately, the brand has changed hands several times
since its entry into India. Indo Nissins Top Ramen has now also jumped on to the health
bandwagon; but it would do well to remember that it takes time to win over health-conscious
customers.
Wai Wai - Even before HUL and GSK, the Wai Wai has been very popular across the North East and
the East. Wai Wai is built around the USP of being a genuinely instant noodle that can be eaten
directly from the pack unlike Maggi which requires at least two minutes worth of cooking. Wai Wai
will be rolling out its product across the country soon. It has set up manufacturing plants in Sikkim,
Guwahati and Rudrapur to help keep up with the demand. When it moves beyond the North East
into the rest of the country G P Sah, VP and CEO of Choudhary Group thinks TV would be the best
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
11 | P a g e
medium to give them the recognition. "TV is very important to help our brand be recognised across
kiranas and convenience stores. Just being present in modern trade will not give us sustainable
value," he says.8
Choudhary Group which manufactures Wai Wai claims leadership in the North East (65% market
share in West Bengal and the north east), with Mi Mi a smaller variant of Wai Wai at the second
position, and Maggi a distant third. 1 Choudhary Group also claims that Wai Wai is the second largest
noodles seller in India with a 16% share. Wai Wai sells 20 lakh packs of noodles per day. 1
Private Label Brands
Not to be left behind are retailers like Big Bazaar that launched noodles under the Tasty Treat brand.
Future Group too is "betting big" on this category. It has increased the number of Tasty Treat instant
noodles variants from two to five in the past 12 months and is planning to further increase the
number to seven. Tasty Treat is also banking on masala, that offers spicy masala and have flavours
like Punjabi masala and Mumbai masala waiting in the wings to cater to local tastes. According to
Devendra Chawla, head, private brands, Future Group, "In our country where taste and food
preference changes every 200 km, instant noodles has crossed this journey most effectively breaking
the barrier."8
Changing Social Trends:
The growing interest and action in the instant noodles market is not an isolated phenomenon, but is
in fact reflective of a deeper change in the Indian social ethos. Powdered soups, cooking pastes and
purees, instant pasta and ready-to-eat (RTE) foods are recent examples. Whats more, its not just
food habits within Indian homes that are changing. It is estimated that from a single meal eaten in
restaurant in a month a decade ago, the average urban Indian in top eight metros is now consuming
7.8 meals a month in restaurants.12
Many in the younger generation today are facing busier lifestyles, are continuously on-the-go and
need products which offer taste, nutrition and convenience. With changing lifestyles, responsibilities
are increasing and mothers and housewives want to reduce their time in the kitchen, but without
compromising on their role as providers of tasty and wholesome food for their familys wellbeing.
There are several reasons for this change in Indian food habits: the countrys young demographic
profile, increasing family income, accelerating urbanization, the cosmopolitization of major urban
centers, unprecedented interstate migrations, increasing number of working couples, time
constraints, shortage of household help, global travel, and increasing exposure to global cuisine and
so on.
Busier lifestyles resulting in the demand for convenience products are persistently providing a major
thrust to the growth in the packaged food sector in India. The Indian cooking styles have undergone
considerable changes over the past few years owing to the advent of modern technology and several
other changes such as urbanization, busier lifestyles, increase in female work population and
augmenting nuclear families. People have been increasingly shifting to ready to eat (RTE) food items
in order to save time involved in preparing meals.
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
12 | P a g e
MAGGIs response to competition:
At the first sign of competition heating up, Nestle launched rice noodles targeted at consumers in
the east and south, where rice is a staple food. To outfox rivals, Nestle extended Maggi's distribution
to smaller towns and cities, simultaneously launching Maggi's value-for-money pack (Chottu Maggi)
priced at Rs 5. When Nestle launched the Chottu Maggi the intent was wider reach, company
wanted more consumers to have access to the product and enjoy the Maggi experience. While
Nestle took this step based on insight and market research, other brands today, know the
importance of a smaller SKU in pushing the brand. Wai Wai's variant Mi Mi is in the Rs 5 space. While
the product was largely targeted towards kids, it also helped get more people to sample the product.
Almost 60 per cent of the FMCG volumes in the country currently come from price points below Rs
10. The share of such products for Nestle has improved from 21 per cent some years ago to over 30
per cent now. Maggi, meantime, shows few signs of faltering, launching new variants, one of the
newer ones is Maggi Masala Damdaar and pulling out all stops to cement itself in the consumer
mind space. Maggi is growing consumption by upsizing packs with various combo & multi packs.
It has in its portfolio no fewer than three products and five variants in the instant noodles category
[Exhibit 1]. Most may not contribute much to sales, but they block out several entry points for rivals.
Meanwhile, Nestl strengthened Maggi's position last year [2012] by signing tinsel town superstar
Amitabh Bachchan as brand ambassador and launched an interactive advertising campaign, which
sought to build emotional bonds with consumers.
Customer Engagement
It is to celebrate the unique bond that the brand shares with its ardent users that MAGGI Noodles
has launched its newest campaign: Meri MAGGI 2- minute Mein Khushiyan, thereby
acknowledging that Meri MAGGI gives you the power to create happiness in 2 minutes! The new
Meri Maggi 2 Minutes Main Khushiyan advertising campaign that had Amitabh Bacchan as the
story teller of consumer stories further strengthened the emotional connect MAGGI already had
with customers. The campaign gives MAGGI Noodles fans, the great opportunity to share their
stories & stand a chance to feature in TV commercials & packs. Meri Maggi page is the largest
MAGGI Facebook community with over 1.2 million fans. Share your story and get famous has gained
traction on the digital media. "While masala is still the most popular, the thrilling moments that
people shared with us as part of the 'Mein aur Meri Maggi' campaign has given us ideas to launch a
number of new variants in the coming months," says Hegde.8
While the new entrants sweat it out, Nestle isn't sitting tight. Continuing its efforts of engagement, it
organised a nutrition awareness drive in the largest slum in Asia, Dharavi a few months back. "We
spoke to people about the importance of health, hygiene, micronutrients and gave them an
opportunity to understand the product," explains Shivani Hegde, GM - foods, Nestle India.8 Nestle
also does trade activities involving education of shopkeepers, direct contact programs and initiatives
like the Nestle Minithon to engage with consumers.
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
13 | P a g e
Dealer Engagement
Nestle has started offering aggressive discounts and incentives to retailers on its flagship Maggi
instant noodles, perhaps for the first time in a decade in order to protect its market share against
increasing competition. Nestle is offering incentives to buy company products in bulk in order to
reduces the trade's options of stocking rival brands. Nestle's discount scheme for Maggi noodles is
possibly the first in 10-15 years.
A Nestle India spokesman said Nestle also runs a dealer engagement programme as part of its '2
Minutes Mein Khushiyan' campaign. This Khushiyan campaign includes a unique 'Khushiyon ka
Badshah' engagement program with dealers and the company is running this campaign among all its
stakeholders-consumers, trade, business partners and employees. The idea is to bring all our
partners to be a part of the campaign.13Analysts say Nestle's trade incentive scheme for Maggi
noodles is aimed at reviving its sales volumes, which declined 2% year-on-year in April-June quarter
(2013) as the company focused more on pricing than volumes.13
Distribution Reach
(Source: Nestle Indias Investor Seminar in Shanghai, September 25, 2012)
At present, Nestle reaches around 3.7 million retail stores as it is expanding its distribution network
rapidly (It added approx. 0.5 million outlets in last financial year) in order to grow its share through
market penetration. HUL is also ramping up its retail presence for Knorr Soupy Noodles from the 0.2
million outlets it started with. For its part, ITC targeted a total of 0.5 million outlets initially. While
none of the new players have reached their full distribution strength, Nestle would have to look out
for HUL and ITC's potential spread. HUL covers up to 6.5 million outlets out of a total 7.5 million
outlets in India, according to analysts, while ITC's FMCG arm reaches 2.5 million. Whereas GSK
(makers of Foodles) reaches 1 million (direct plus indirect through wholesale) outlets, with Foodles,
GSK reaches 0.2 million outlets of its total 1 million outlet.
The other players too are pulling up their socks. In case of Indo Nissin, its earlier tie-ups did help the
company establish a loyal consumer base, but it remains confined to the south and the east of the
country. The brand currently reaches 0.3 million outlets. However, unlike pillow pack noodles, Indo
Nissin is the leader in cup noodles with 65 per cent share of the Rs 36-crore market.11 Nepal-based
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
14 | P a g e
CG Foods, the makers of Wai-Wai, is extending beyond the 0.15 million outlets it reaches now. Over
the next 2-3 years, it is planning to expand in states like Punjab, Jammu & Kashmir and Delhi.
Way Forward:
Maggi so far have dominated the estimated Rs 2,500-crore instant noodles category in the country
with >75% share, 1 but it has been losing share to rivals in recent times, having slipped from more
than 90% market share three years ago.14 The Nestle spokesman said Maggi has anywhere between
80%-90% share and it is growing the size of the market and gaining market share. "When new
products enter the market, they will have a trial phase and create temporary fluctuations in market
shares," he said.13 Maggi now faces not only brand competition but also industry competition from
similar products like Pizzas. Even fast food joints are taking away consumers from the brand. At this
point, the brand needs to stay relevant to the consumers since consumers have a wider choice of
indulgence.
From a snack food targeted at children, instant noodles category has evolved as a mainstay meal
even for grown-ups. Noodles are no longer considered a processed food; it has become mainstream,
a choice rather than a last alternative and has come to be accepted as a part of the regular
household menu. Instant Noodles can be a staple food. An IMRB report says 45 per cent of all
households consume instant noodles.15 At Rs.10 for 75/80g; its a cup of wholesome soup or a meal
for someone. Even two cups of tea will cost more than Rs.10 today. Therefore, Noodles as a product
category measure up well in context of value for money proposition. While it is still early days for the
category, the action in this space promises to get louder. Japan and South Korea are among the
highest consumers, devouring 70 packs per person per year. Thailand's consumption stands at 50
packs per person. In Nepal, thanks to Wai Wai, the consumption is 30 packets per capita, whereas
India's is only four.16There is potential for tremendous growth. The opportunity is indeed huge, what
with instant noodles ceasing to be just a metro phenomenon and become popular in semi-urban and
even rural markets. While the main plank in urban areas is still convenience, people across small
towns are hooked because of the sheer variety available. Single pack sizes are important for
acceptance of the brand in non-urban cities. The aspirations are same, there is a lot more money in
non-urban areas and most of it is going into foods. For a category that is growing at 20% annually,
and in a country in which instant foods are beginning to catch on with India's burgeoning middle
class, you'd expect plenty of action in noodles. As income levels rise and packaged food finds more
takers, experimental users will fragment the instant noodles market further.
Apart from variants and positioning, most players acknowledge that trial is the ultimate moment of
truth. HUL have 'food ambassadors' at modern retails outlets to encourage sampling. Ching's Secret
has gone the college route to get closer to its youth demographic. They have sponsored a large
number of college shows in the country last year and are also targeting the youth aggressively
through Facebook. The Ching's Secret community on Facebook has over 118,000 fans following the
brand.
It is a category that is almost evenly spread across all the four zones in India and cannot depend on
modern trade alone. And the likes of ITC, which has made significant inroads into villages, are well
placed to gain more ground. ITC has a very strong distribution network; hence its noodle brand will
play on this strength. However what will determine success is essentially the quality and taste of the
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
AmanHighlight
15 | P a g e
product. In this category, there is a role for packaging as well, and not just flavour. While Knorr
Soupy Noodles and Horlicks Foodles have opted for the colour green, ITC has differentiated Yippee!
with a generous dollop of red mixed with yellow in its packaging. Yellow (used by Maggi) will
instantly tie Yippee! with the category, the red will hopefully set it apart. Red has been used in the
communication as well as the packaging to communicate vibrancy to a young consumer as well as
differentiate itself from the lead brand. The success of noodles has made way for other ready-to-
cook products like pasta and macaroni. While Maggi has already entered the fray with its offering,
the new entrants are also eyeing this space with great interest. Can homely cooked food ever be
substituted with ready-to-eat meals, only time will tell?
Points of Discussion:
1. For over two decades, Nestle has been able to keep all its competitors behind by a long distance in the noodles market. Can ITC now narrow the gap?
2. How should MAGGI stay relevant to all segments of customers? 3. Critically evaluate MAGGIs choice of Amitabh Bachchan as brand ambassador? 4. Is it time MAGGI should update its positioning and acquire a new micro positioning within
overall health plank?
16 | P a g e
References:
1. Changing Habits: Finding a New Recipe for Success in India's Food Markets, Published on dated 24th Feb,
2011 in India Knowledge@Wharton12
2. http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2010-08-30/news/27597085_1_noodles-maggi-hul-and-gsk
accessed on 12/08/201314
3. http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-01-12/news/30619732_1_rural-markets-urban-
market-fmcg-companies accessed on 09/05/201315
4. http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-06-10/news/32156152_1_consumer-products-
amitabh-bachchan-campaigns accessed on 13/08/20134
5. http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-08-03/news/33020104_1_nestle-stock-md-antonio-
helio-waszyk-nescafe accessed on 16/08/201313
6. http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-11-07/news/34970808_1_instant-noodles-maggi-
pazzta-maggi-noodles accessed on 05/12/2012
7. http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2012-11-28/news/35408963_1_instant-noodles-category-
knorr-soupy-noodles-maggi-noodles accessed on 17/08/20131
8. http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/nestle-india-ltd/directorsreport/companyid-13330.cms accessed on
04/07/2013 5
9. http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/news-by-company/corporate-trends/chitranjan-dar-itcs-
noodle-man-is-a-patient-leader/articleshow/21791383.cms accessed on 13/08/2013
10. http://m.economictimes.com/features/brand-equity/instant-noodles-rivals-turn-the-heat-on-nestles-
maggi/articleshow/msid-6079650.cms accessed on 05/08/20138
11. http://marketingpractice.blogspot.in/2012/09/brand-update-maggis-2-minute-mein.html accessed on
22/05/2013
12. http://pitchonnet.com/blog/2011/05/15/cover-story-foodles-the-right-formula/ accessed on 10/05/2013
13. http://themarkmanager.blogspot.in/2011/11/brand-story-horlicks-foodles.html#!/2011/11/brand-story-
horlicks-foodles.html accessed on 09/05/2013
14. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/Costly-veggies-push-up-packaged-food-
demand/articleshow/21471805.cms accessed on 19/08/20133
15. http://www.4psbusinessandmarketing.com/28072011/storyd.asp?sid=4710&pageno=1 accessed on
25/07/2013
16. http://www.business-standard.com/article/companies/hul-launches-knorr-soupy-noodles-
110032600086_1.html accessed on 27/07/2013
17. http://www.business-standard.com/article/management/foodles-in-the-noodle-bowl-
110080200051_1.html accessed on 05/07/2013
18. http://www.business-standard.com/article/management/instant-noodles-instant-energy-
111071800011_1.html accessed on 14/08/201311
19. http://www.business-standard.com/article/management/instant-success-in-noodles-
111081700097_1.html accessed on 20/07/20137
20. http://www.dnaindia.com/mumbai/1683808/report-82pct-workforce-in-metros-prefers-packaged-food-
to-eating-outside accessed on 19/08/2013 2
21. http://www.exchange4media.com/51283_sunfeast-yippee-on-ooh-blitz-for-new-chinese-masala-
variant.html accessed on 21/08/201310
22. http://www.itcportal.mobi/newsroom/media-reports/2011/pr-17-jan-11.asp accessed on 20/08/20139
23. http://www.just-food.com/the-just-food-blog/nestles-maggi-the-food-brand-bought-most-often-says-
kantar-worldpanel_id2404.aspx accessed on 09/05/20136
24. http://www.livemint.com/Leisure/bf343hNJmSt06om7NmRVFL/Binod-K-Chaudhary-The-billionaire-from-
Nepal.html accessed on 24/08/201316
17 | P a g e
Exhibit 1 MAGGI Variants
MAGGI Xtra-delicious Magical Masala This new product has a spicy and delicious taste. Couple that with a new and vibrant color and real vegetable bits that are sure to bring smile on customers face.
MAGGI HUNGROOO We all lead a busy life - a life full of activities and lots of action. After all the action, hunger gets bigger. Customers are not just hungry, they become Hungrooo. So, to answer customers call for a bigger hunger, Masala MAGGI now comes in a bigger pack MAGGI Hungrooo, 50% more of Masala MAGGI Noodles.
MAGGI 2-Minute Noodles MAGGI 2-Minute Noodles is one of the largest & most loved food brands that defines the Instant Noodles category in India.
MAGGI Cuppa Mania MAGGI Cuppa Mania offers the taste of MAGGI combined with the convenience of cup noodles! It is an offering for the new generation pressed hard for time trying to juggle multiple roles all at once & can be enjoyed anytime on the go. Available in two variants- Masala Yo! & Chilly Chow Yo!
MAGGI Masala Dumdaar Noodles MAGGI Masala Dumdaar offers Masala taste, with more Masala, Iron fortification and added vegetable bits making it a Dumdaar proposition.
MAGGI Xtra-delicious Chicken Noodles MAGGI noodles have been combined with real chicken bits to create the new MAGGI Xtra-delicious Chicken Noodles. Fortified with Iron & Calcium, the new & improved taste offers a delightful experience that'll leave customer craving for more.
18 | P a g e
MAGGI Vegetable Atta Noodles Vegetable Atta Noodles, an offering that exemplifies the "Taste Bhi Health Bhi" promise of MAGGI. Tasty because it comes packed with everyone's favourite "MAGGI Masala" taste & healthy because it has real vegetables in its garnish and is packed with the goodness of fibre.
MAGGI Vegetable Multigrainz MAGGI Vegetable Multigrainz Noodles offers the multi-'gun' (benefits) of Ragi, Corn, Jowar and Wheat. It is a source of Protein, Calcium and Fibre, and has added vegetables. Available with a delicious "Spice Remix tastemaker.
(Source: http://www.nestle.in/brands/pdca)