The Conflict Paradox
By Ram Srinivasan
Agile Coach and Trainer
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Who Am I?
• Agile Coach focusing on Enterprise and Leadership Coaching
• Professional Coach – Organizational and Relationship Systems Coaching
• My Interests – System Thinking, Complex Adaptive Systems, Change Management, Gamification, Conflict Management, Neuroscience Based Coaching
• CertificationsPMP, CSM, CSPO, PMI-ACP, CSP, PSM-I, PSPO-I, SAFeProgram Consultant, Innovation Games® Qualified Instructor and facilitator, Level-1 Gamification Designer
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
About This Session
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
How Do You Think About Conflict?
Think about a recent conflict that you experienced
What are some of the words that come to your mind? Share it with others, and as a group, write them down.
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
How Do You Think About Conflict?
Think about a recent conflict that you experienced
What are some of the words that come to your mind? Share it with others, and as a group, write them down.
As a group, classify them as either negative or positive words.
Count the number of positive and negative words
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
What Is A Conflict?
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
- Becoming a Conflict Competent Leader by Craig Runde and Tim Flanagan
“ Any situation in which interdependent people have apparentlyincompatible interests, goals, principles or feelings”
Types of Conflict
Task or Cognitive Conflict
• Focus primarily on ideas and problem solving, not people
• Emotional tone remain neutral or even positive
• Strengthens working relationships, increases creativity and productivity
• Described by positive words
Affective or Relationship Conflict
• Focuses on blaming or proving others wrong, not problem solving
• Heats up quickly, negative emotional tone
• Leads to productivity problems, stress, poor morale, bad decisions
• Described by negative words
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Levels of Conflict
• Polarization (Level 5) – Characterized by severe negative emotions and behaviors with little or no hope for reconciliation
• Discord (Level 4) – Causes difficulties in the relationship of the people involved even when they are not dealing with the original conflict
• Disagreement(Level 3) – People see situation differently, regardless of how well they think they understand other’s position and interest, feel some discomfort
• Misunderstanding (Level 2) – What is understood by those involved are different
• Differences (Level 1) – people see situation differently, understand each other’s position well, feel little or no discomfort
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
The Conflict Process
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Precipitating Event Or
Hot Button
Initiate Conflict(emotions triggered)
Constructive Behavior
Destructive Behavior
Task Focused Conflict• Focus on task and
problem solving• Positive emotions• Tension decreases• Group functioning
improves
Person - Focused Conflict• Focus on personalities• Negative emotions,
flight/fight/freeze response• Tension increases• Group functioning
decreases
Conflict De-escalates Conflict Escalates
The Retaliatory Cycle
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Emotions arise not from thinking about the issue, but from a completely different process – one that emerges more quickly than rational thinking
- Beyond Revenge: The evolution of Forgiveness Instinct by Michael McCullough
Precipitating Event Or
Hot Button
Initiate Conflict(emotions triggered)
Destructive Behavior
Person - Focused Conflict• Focus on personalities• Negative emotions,
flight/fight/freeze response• Tension increases• Group functioning
decreases
Conflict Escalates
Cognitive Skills: Self-Awareness About Dealing With Conflict
• How you currently view conflict?
• What triggers you in the first place?
• How you feel when you are triggered?
• How you behave when you are triggered?
• Your biases and assumptions?
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Exercise: What is Your Trigger?
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
1. Abrasive
Question Score
4
8
12
20
Total
2. Aloof
Question Score
2
6
14
18
Total
3. Self-Centered
Question Score
1
7
10
16
Total
4. Unappreciated
Question Score
5
11
15
19
Total
5. Untrustworthy
Question Score
3
9
13
17
Total
Exercise: What is Your Trigger?
Triggers - Group Discussion
• Why is this a hot-button for me? Why does this trigger me?
• The next time my hot-button is pushed, how do I want to feel? How do I want to respond?
• Why might be the other person be acting this way?
• In what alternate ways do I want the other person to act?
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
• Irritations and annoyances that provoke you into a conflict
• Once triggered, the person experiences negative emotions
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Cognitive Skills: Self-Awareness About Triggers or Hot Buttons
The Origin of Emotions
• Auto-appraisers: Our brain continuously scans for threats and rewards automatically and rapidly
• Negative emotions are our “evolved” flight or fight response from our limbic system
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Breaking the Retaliatory Cycle
Cool Down
Slow Down and Reflect
Engage Constructively
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Cooling Your Hot Buttons
• What is it about these behaviors that makes you angry?
• What aspects of the other person’s behavior irritated you and why?
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
“ Once triggered, the chemical released by my brain surges through my body and I have a physiological experience. Within 90 seconds from the initial trigger, the chemical component of my anger has completely dissipated from my blood and my automatic response is over. If, however, I remain angry after those 90 seconds have passed, then it is because I have chosen to let that circuit continue to run.”
My Stroke of Insight: A Brain Scientist's Personal Journey by Jill Bolte Taylo
The key to cooling hot buttons is to look inside yourself
Cooling Down During Conflict
• Awareness about getting into a conflict
• Take Deep Breaths• Oxygen to your brain
• Body centering techniques
• Take a short break
• Mindfulness• Pay attention to your body sensations, listen to your triggers
• Look at your thoughts & feelings in a non-judgmental way
• Cognitive Reappraisal – examine facts to look for alternate non-threatening explanations
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Slow Down and Reflect
Reflecting Your Own Experience
• Your Thoughts• Data vs. Interpreting Data
• Our own biases and assumptions
• Reflect on your emotions• What kind of feelings?
• How are you experiencing it?
• Your Interests
Reflecting on Others’ Experience
• Others’ Thoughts• How will he/she be
thinking about it?
• Assumptions and biases
• Reflect on others’ emotions
• Empathy & mirror neurons
• Others’ Interest
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Effect of Suppressing Negative Emotions
• Does not make the negative emotion go away and causes chronic stress
• Usually cannot suppress negative emotions, sometimes they are more aroused trying to do so
• Emotional leakage at unexpected times• Venting is not the answer
• Memory of the event gets impaired, as though focusing on something else
• Suppression takes lot of brain power, leaves fewer resources to pay attention to the moment
• Mirror Neurons - Other people experience the same emotions as you
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Expressing Negative Emotions - Tips
• Identify and discloses feelings in a manner that describes the emotions, rather than overtly behaving emotionally
• “I feel frustrated because ….” instead of showing frustration at the other person
• Affect labeling or symbolic labeling or naming• Finding the right words to identify your emotional state
• Key is to use few words to describe it• Symbolic language, metaphors, similes, weather, news
paper headlines, a song/ movie title
• Uncomfortable to talk? Write it, then tear it off
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Avoid Destructive Behavior, Embrace Constructive Behavior
Cool Down
Slow Down and Reflect
Engage Constructively
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Exercise: Group Behaviors Into One of These 4 Categories
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Active Constructive
Active Destructive
Passive Constructive
Passive Destructive
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
AvoidingPerspective
Taking
Repaid Bids
Winning at all Costs
AdaptingYielding
Reaching Out
Demeaning others
Delay Response
Creating Solutions
Hiding Emotions
Reflective Thinking
Display Anger
Deep Listening
Retaliating
Self-Criticism
Expressing Emotions
Exercise: Group Behaviors Into One of These 4 Categories
Destructive vs. Constructive Behaviors During Conflict
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Active Constructive
Perspective Taking
Creating Solutions
Expressing Emotions
Reaching Out
• Deep Listening• Perspective Taking• Creating Solutions• Expressing Emotions• Reaching Out
Active Constructive Active Destructive
• Winning at All Cost• Displaying Anger• Demeaning Others• Retaliating
Passive Constructive
• Reflective Thinking• Delay Responding• Adapting/Flexibility• Repair Bids
Passive Destructive
• Avoiding (includes “agreeing to disagree”)
• Yielding• Hiding Emotions• Self-Criticizing
Group Exercise
As a group, discuss different strategies that you can use at work to avoid destructive behaviors and to embrace constructive behaviors
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Attitude
Trust
Safety
Behavioral Integration / Collaboration
Emotional Intelligence
Techniques for Staying on Track
Expressing Emotions
Prespective Taking
Listening for Understanding(Deep
Listening)
Reflective Thinking and
Delay Responding
Team Conflict Competencies
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Right Climate
Constructive Communication
Getting on Track – Team Agreements1. Review Team’s Mission and
Context2. Discuss the Desired Climate3. Brainstorm Ideas for Creating the
Desired Climate4. Combine Similar Ideas5. Prioritize Ideas (5 to 10)6. “Behaviorize” Remaining Ideas7. Record and Distribute the
Resulting List for Review8. Review and Finalize Agreements9. Revisit Periodically
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Staying on Track During Conflicts• Time-outs
• Reframing Questions• Clarify or understand what the team
member has said
• Should be genuine and non-threatening
• Intentional Intent• Describe the intent before making a
statement
• Example - “This may not come out right, but what I am trying to communicate is my curiosity about your idea…”
• Use a Neutral Facilitator• Internal or External Facilitator
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
After the Conflict
• Do not simply ignore or avoid
• Revisit Team Agreements periodically
• Feedback – clear and specific• Situation – The context in which the behavior or action
took place
• Behavior – What was said or done
• Impact – The perceived result the behavior had on the observer or others in the situation
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Conflict in Virtual / Global Teams
• Diverse backgrounds, cultures, languages, beliefs, and practices complicate the nature of differences
• Electronic communication does not build trust and familiarity
• Lacks tone, body language, and facial expressions
• Time-zone differences lead to lag in communication which only exacerbate problems
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Ideas for Virtual / Global Teams
• In-person face – to –face meetings build trust and familiarity. Intentionally build relationships
• Withhold making judgments, focus on gaining understanding
• Many cultures focus on relationships, then on tasks, (and vice versa) listen carefully for this distinction
• Be open to changing your personal paradigm, yours may be only one way
• Establish norms for addressing issues that may lead to cultural and background differences
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
Questions
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
What is your ONE take- away from this talk? Share it with your group
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com
What did you like
about this session?
What can I do to
make it better?
Feedback
References
© Ram Srinivasanhttp://ramvasan.com