Suzlon Energy GmbH
The Use of Simpack in Wind Turbine Development
Florian Stache Suzlon Product Development Hamburg, 26.09.2012
1
Suzlon Energy GmbH Introduction
• Increasing market requirements in terms of wind turbine reliability as well as long term field feedback ask for more detailed investigations in the design practice for the subsystems of a wind turbine (i.e. Pitch, Yaw, drive train…)
• Load assumptions for subsystems are often based on global load simulation models without considering the subsystem behavior itself (i.e. blade actuator model in Flex5 or GH Bladed)
• Influence of subsystem on global loads is for some Design Load Cases insufficient (i.e. Pitch overload, Yaw slippage…)
SIMPACK is therefore increasingly used at SUZLON
2
Suzlon Energy GmbH Overview
• Subsystem load simulation
• Global load models
• Integration of SIMPACK into the new product development process
3
Suzlon Energy GmbH Subsystem load simulation
Global WTG behavior
Subsystem behavior
Post Processing (same for global and subsystem)
• Apply global load results in form of time series on detailed subsystem models (similar to substructuring in FEA)
• Applicable if the subsystem has no influence on the global loads and only target is to obtain more precise subsystem loads
Validated load simulation (Flex5)
• detailed model in SIMPACK
• test bench validation
• LDD • RFC • MinMax
Suzlon Energy GmbH Pitch system load simulation
5
pitch angle from FLEX5
blade position or position sensor feedback
motor speed
motor torque
detailed motor and inverter
model
Pitch Inverter controler (position and speed control)
Blade bearing friction model
Blade root bending moment from Flex5
MATSIM or user routine
Suzlon Energy GmbH Pitch system load simulation
6
Suzlon Energy GmbH Pitch system loads post processing • Rainflow count results are showing a very much different behavior when
comparing to the very simple Flex5 pitch model
• Opens new design verification methods:
– Analysis of tooth forces at critical operating point
• Enables optimization of pitch system behavior (i.e. blade positioning control)
• Global load requirements verification in terms of positioning accuracy and time constants
7
Suzlon Energy GmbH Drive train simulation
• Use for internal resonance analysis as well as for certification
• Identification of potential vibration and tonality issues during the turbine design process or in RCA
• Challenges:
Accuracy in higher frequency ranges
Verification through measurements
Agreement with Gearbox supplier on model/input sharing
8
Suzlon Energy GmbH Drive train model
9
Gear pair with simple spring/damper element
or FE-225
Flexible mainframe using ANSYS interface
Flexible blades imported from Flex5
Suzlon Energy GmbH Typical results using modal analysis
10
Suzlon Energy GmbH Global loads
• SIMPACK to be used when the limits of Flex5 is reached
Requirements for additional dof (advanced blade models)
Interaction of global loads with a subsystem (Pitch, Yaw, Drive Train)
At the moment used only in dedicated load cases because of license costs, computation time and stable existing process using Flex5
• Ability to migrate Flex5 model to SIMPACK
• Subsystem component database for enhancement of Flex5-like model
11
Identify critical DLC from FLex5
results
Migrate to SPCK and enhance
with subsystem details
Simulate DLC in SPCK
Compare result to Flex5 and substitute
Suzlon Energy GmbH Global load model
12
Flex5 like turbine model (same dof)
• Aerodynamic routine taken from Flex5 including wind fields and all features (i.e. dyn. Stall)
• Pitch and torque control using Matlab dll generated with MATSIM target
Suzlon Energy GmbH Model verification
13
• An extensive model validation was carried out through comparison to Flex5
• Step by step switching on the dofs and aerodynamic features
• Small differences due to some differences in structural modeling approach are remaining but explained and almost negligible
Suzlon Energy GmbH
Extension to yaw system
14 Factory testbench
SPCK yaw-model
Subsystem Verification
Flex5 Model
SPCK WT-model
WT model Verification
Utilization of advanced model
results
Integrated yaw in WT
model
Suzlon Energy GmbH
Integration of drive train into full turbine model
15
• Simulation of dedicated load cases (LVRT, short circuit)
• Electrical system model from Simulink • Used for run up and frequency sweep
Suzlon Energy GmbH Component database / configuration management
• Automatic model transfer from flex5 to SIMPACK
• quick model implementation of components/subsystems from database
– Gearbox variants or from different supplier
– Coupling
– Pitch system
– Yaw system
– Structural components (i.e. mainframe) as SID files
• Well defined interfacing points for model integration
• Turbine configurator and automatic model generation for plug-and-play
16
Suzlon Energy GmbH Model migration
17
DLC generator
FLEX5
Load analyser
SIMPACK
FLX2SPCK
Suzlon Energy GmbH Summary
• SIMPACK is integrated into our simulation environment with pre-defined parameterized model topologies in order to enable load simulation engineers concentrate on product optimization
• Challenges:
– Validation of detailed models
– Improvements in strength analysis methods to enable optimal use of these new results
– Computation time
– Licensing for parallel computation
18
Suzlon Energy GmbH
19
Suzlon Energy GmbH
Thank You