PSERC
Supporting University Research as an Engineering Workforce
Education Strategy
Dennis Ray, Ph.D.Executive Director
Power Systems Engineering Research Center
Prepared for the 2007 Electric Power Conference
2
PSERCThe Aging Utility Workforce
Nu
mb
er
of
Em
plo
ye
es
Employee Age Group
Now 5 years out 10 years out
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
18-25 26-30 31-35 36-40 41-45 46-50 51-55 56-60 61-65 65+
Source: Ray, Dennis and Bill Snyder. "Strategies to Address the Problem of Exiting Expertise in the Electric Power Industry." Proceedings of the 39th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences. January 2006.
3
PSERC
Our industry is coming to the realization that recruiting and retaining the best people is top priority.
Wanda Reder, President-Elect, IEEE PES, VP, S&C Electric, in “Meeting the Twin Challenges of Education and an Aging Workforce in the Electric Power Industry.” The CIP Report. Nov. 2006.
4
PSERC
IOUs and municipal utilities rank the reliability of electric service and the aging workforce as two of their top three primary concerns.
Strategic Directions in the Utility Industry Survey. Black & Veatch. 2006.
5
PSERC
Every leader and executive in Canada knows that our nation is on the verge of a serious talent shortage that is expected to last for decades… One of the hardest hit will be the energy and resources industry.
2006 Energy & Resources Talent Pulse Survey Report. Deloitte
6
PSERC
The most significant challenges created will be the loss of knowledge due to retirements, the difficulty finding replacements, and the lack of bench strength within the organization.
Work Force Planning for Public Power Utilities. American Public Power Association. 2005.
7
PSERC
The reliability of the North American electric utility grid is dependent on the accumulated experience and technical expertise of those who design and operate the system. As the rapidly aging workforce leaves the industry over the next five to ten years, the challenge to the electric utility industry will be to fill this void…
2006 Long-Term Reliability AssessmentNERC
8
PSERC
The electric utility industry as a whole has not…established the needed cooperative programs with academia to reinvigorate the power engineering education in North America.
2006 Long-Term Reliability Assessment. NERC
9
PSERC
Today, the power engineering education system in the United States is at a critical decision point. Without strong support for strategic research in power systems engineering and without qualified replacements for retiring faculty, the strength of our Nation’s university-based power engineering programs will wane, and along with them, the foundation for innovation in the power sector to meet our energy challenges in the 21st century.
Workforce Trends in the Electric Utility Industry, U.S. DOE, August 2006.
10
PSERC
To provide the electric power industry with a sufficient supply of well-trained engineers, there is a critical need to sustain electric power engineering programs at U.S. universities. Just like the industry, our power faculty are “graying” and there is no guarantee that when they retire, their positions will be filled by new faculty in the power area.
Professor Vijay Vittal, Director, Power Systems Engineering Research Center in filed comments to FERC in RM06-16, July 2006.
11
PSERC
[In Australia] the number of power engineering academics is decreasing. The average age of all power academics is 50 years. The present university environment and research funding priorities do not attract a sufficient number of young academics to replace retirements.
Assessing Future of Electrical Power Engineering: A report on electrical power engineering manpower requirements in Australia. Institute of Engineers, Australia 2004
12
PSERC
Few senior executives in the electric utility industry make the connection between the education – workforce gap and much more robust research funding.
Wanda Reder, President-Elect, IEEE PES, VP, S&C Electric, in “Meeting the Twin Challenges of Education and an Aging Workforce in the Electric Power Industry.” The CIP Report. Nov. 2006.
13
PSERC
Without a sizable research portfolio, it is not possible for a disciplinary area such as electric power to get new faculty positions or resources.
Professor Vijay Vittal, Director, Power Systems Engineering Research Center in filed comments to FERC in RM06-16, July 2006.
14
PSERC
University administrations need to know there is a long term commit-ment to university research in the area. The students need to know there are high paying, interesting jobs.
Professor Robert J. Thomas, Cornell University, in “Meeting the Twin Challenges of Education and an Aging Workforce in the Electric Power Industry.” The CIP Report. Nov. 2006
15
PSERC
The need for an adequate, skilled workforce to ensure a reliable supply of electricity in Canada has reached a critical stage … it is clear governments and industry must work together with labor groups and educational institutions to ensure a strong, sustainable electricity workforce.
“The Human Resource Crisis in the Canadian Electricity Sector.” Canadian Electricity Association’s Perspectives. April 2006.
16
PSERCSustaining University
Power Programs
• Student interest is critical.• Declining interest in math, science,
engineering and technology.• Declining enrollment in engineering in
general
• But support of the education infrastructure is critical, too.
17
PSERC
Potential PE Students
Potential PE Faculty
PE StudentsPE Faculty
Institutional Expectations
Research Support
Support of Dean and Faculty
Jobs: Number,
Challenge, Salary,
Interesting work, etc.
Class-room
Projects and Theses
Program Quality,
Curriculum Relevance,
Tuition Cost, Grad. Support
Job in Industry
Keys to Sustaining University Power Programs
18
PSERCDeclining EE Undergraduate Enrollments (Univ. of Wisc.)
515 522563 570
634587
361 377 376350
300262
213215 194
196
168
149
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
Year
CmpE
EE
19
PSERCDeclining EE Graduate Enrollments
(Univ. of Wisc.)
269 270
234 236
258
287
333
383
432
371
296
251
136146
171
143155
114
197
237
261
228
141 137
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
500
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
Year
Total
PhD
MS
20
PSERCMedian E.E. Salaries (IEEE Spectrum 2000)
Solid-state circuits $93,500; Communications $92,900Laser and electro-optics $91,000; Software, aerospace and electronics $89,000; Components manufacturing $88,850; Signals and application $87,000; Antennas and propagation $86,000; Medicine and biology signal processing $85,000; Electronic devices $84,750; Network administration $81,000; Power electronics $80,050; Circuits and systems $80,000; Instrumentation and measurement $76,000Energy and power engineering $73,625
22
PSERC
• Compared to 2001-02 academic year, undergraduate enrollments in elective power classes declined from about 3,500 to 3,300.
• Masters student enrollments also declined from 1,600 to 1,400, but Ph.D. student enrollments rose from 800 to 900.
• International students are now about 59% of all graduate students.
Source: IEEE Power Engineering Education Committee Survey Results for 2005-06 Academic Year.
Power Program Trends
23
PSERC
• Younger (untenured) faculty have declined from 20% in early 90s to 12% of total power faculty.
• Total research funding per institution declined about 18% compared to 2001-02.
• Industry-funded research rose compared to 2001-02, but the rise did not off-set declines in government-funded research.
• Industry funding increased from 23% to about 43% of total research funding.
Power Program Trends
24
PSERC
• Collaborate with universities on research opportunities
• Encourage government support of research• Fund fellowships and scholarships• Create named chairs in university programs • Support new education initiatives in technical
schools, and in 2 and 4 year universities• Facilitate field trips, capstone projects, speakers
Actions to Support Education
25
PSERCActions to Support Education
• Offer mentoring opportunities, support coops and internships
• Provide engineers to teach classes• Donate equipment• Encourage math and science in K-12• Provide seed funding for professional
development programs (on-line, on-site, university) to educate new engineers after they are hired
26
PSERCWhat Success Might Look Like
• Renewed hiring of new faculty• Ample undergraduate and graduate
student enrollments in electrical engineering in general, and power engineering in particular
• Students taking opportunities for fellowships, scholarships, internships, coops, and mentoring
• Universities making financial support commitments to graduate students
27
PSERC
• Curricula that balance core knowledge with opportunities for multi-disciplinary education relevant to the industry
• Innovative research addressing our energy and environmental challenges
• Competitive pay and career opportunities for power engineering graduates
What Success Might Look Like
28
PSERCConclusions
• Research support for universities is fundamental to sustaining education programs for power engineers.
• Decisions on investments in people should receive as high a priority as decisions on investments in the aging physical infrastructure.
• Collaboration among industry, government, and universities is needed to educate the next generation of power engineers.