07/02/2014 1
STRUCTURALIST THEORY
“The Signifier is Superior to the
Signified”
© Dr. Francis Adu-Febiri, 2014
INTRODUCTION:
SIGNIFIER AND SIGNIFIED
• According to Lecan (1977, p. 154), the
signifier and the signified are never unified
and the signifier is superior to the signified
because the signified is the secondary and
passive effect of the signifier
– (Cited in Choi, Jongryul. 2004. Postmodern
America Sociology: A Response to the
Aesthetic Challenge (Pages 57 and 58)
07/02/2014
07/02/2014 3
INTRODUCTION:
THE IRONY
• The notion of “social structure” or “structure” is central to sociology. Yet, the concept of structure is only vaguely theorized. Attempts to theorize “structure” in sociology are evident in the works of
– structural sociologists:
• Karl Marx, Emile Durkheim, Georg Simmel, Louis Althisser, Nicos Poulantzas, Maurice Godelier, Pierre Bourdieu and Anthony Giddens.
• Structuralism, however, has been very much theorised by linguists and anthropologists such as Ferdinand de Saussure, Claude Levi-Struass, and Radcliffe-Brown
PIONEER PROPONENTS OF
STRUCTURALISM
• Ferdinand de Saussure
• Claude Levi-Strauss
07/02/2014 4
07/02/2014 5
GENESIS AND EVOLUTION OF
STRUCTURALISM
• The structuralism that swept through
French social thought in the 1960s was a
reaction against humanistic philosophy
that people are not subject to or
determined by any social laws.
• This structuralist theorizing focused first
on LANGUAGE but was later extended
to CULTURE and SOCIETY.
THE MAIN THEORY OF STRUCTURALISM:
The Iceberg Metaphor
07/02/2014 6
MAIN THEORY
07/02/2014
X
Y
Sig
nif
ier
(Ob
jecti
ve S
oci
al
Str
uct
ure
)
Invis
ible
Mac
ro S
oci
al F
orc
es
Signified (Subjective Social Action)
Human Behavior, Condition, Experience, Activity, and Agency
MAIN THEORY
• The signifier or centralized underlying,
invisible, objective structure determines the
signified, that is, surface or visible reality.
– Whatever the surface substance and content of social relations, there is a deep underlying form or structure.
– That is, a given surface phenomenon is explained in terms of some structure that lies beneath our conscious or perceptual awareness of the phenomenon in question. This structure causes the surface phenomenon to exist or operate, or conditions it strongly in some way.
07/02/2014 8
MAJOR CONCEPTS
• SIGNIFIER = Social Laws or Social
Structure: OBJECTIVE STRUCTURES
• SIGNIFIED = Human Experience, Activity,
and Agency: SUBJECTIVE ACTION
07/02/2014 9
PARADIGM SHIFT
• Contrary to the humanistic philosophy,
people (and their behaviors, experiences,
actions, conditions) are subject to or
determined by social laws.
07/02/2014 10
07/02/2014 11
FERDINAND DE SAUSSURE’S
STRUCTURALIST THEORY
• MAIN THEORY: The mind, people and ultimately the social world are shaped by the structure of language, specifically langue rather than parole.
• Surface or Visible Phenomenon?
• Mind, people and the social world including Parole:
• Deeper or Invisible structure?
• Langue
07/02/2014 12
SAUSSURE’S STRUCTURALIST
THEORY
• MAIN CONCEPTS:
• Langue: The formal, grammatical system of language
• Parole: Speech—subjective ways in which language is used by actors).
07/02/2014 13
LEVI-STRAUSS’S
STRUCTURALIST THEORY
• MAIN THEORY: The structure of the mind determines language, kinship systems and society.
• Both phonemic system and kinship system are but a surface manifestation of fundamental code lodged in the neuroanatomy of the brain (the unconscious, logical structure of the mind) and existing before the material and cultural structure of society.
• Surface or Visible Phenomenon?
• Phonemic and kinship systems.
• Deeper or Invisible Structure?
• Neuroanatomy of the brain.
07/02/2014 14
LEVI-STRAUSS’S
STRUCTURALIST THEORY
• MAJOR CONCEPTS:
• Phonemic System: Parole-- Speech—subjective ways in which language is used by actors.
• Kinship System: Descent
• Neuroanatomy of the Brain: The unconscious, logical structure of the mind.
• STRUCTURAL SOCIOLOGY
07/02/2014 16
MAIN THEORY
Y S
oci
al R
elat
ions
Str
uct
ure
of
Thought
Material and Sociocultural Arrangements of Society X
Configuration of Interaction
PROPONENTS OF
STRUCTURAL SOCIOLOGY
• 1. Karl Marx
• 2. Emile Durkheim
• 3. Georg Simmel
• 4. Pierre Bourdieu
• 5. Anthony Giddens
07/02/2014 17
07/02/2014 18
STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS IN KARL
MARX’S THEORIES
• MAIN THEORY: Contradictions in material arrangements of society determine patterns of social/cultural relations.
• Surface or Visible Phenomenon?
• Patterns of social/cultural relations.
• Deeper, invisible structure?
• Contradictions of material social arrangements—symbolic, material, and political resources that actors have and use in their encounters: competition, inequality and conflict.
• Material social arrangements contain patterns of social relations that are self-transforming…That is, over time the underlying contradictions of capitalism produce conflictual social relations—a revolution by workers—that change and transform the nature of social relations and, hence, the social structure.
07/02/2014 19
EMILE DURKHEIM’S
STRUCTURAL SOCIOLOGY
• MAIN THEORY: Structures of the mind reflect the collective material and cultural structure of society
• Specifically, society is the unique whole to which everything else is related. Thus logical hierarchy is only another aspect of social hierarchy, and the unity of knowledge is nothing else than the very unity of the collectivity, extended to the social universe.
• Surface or Visible Phenomenon?
• The mind: Logical hierarchy (structure of thought) and knowledge.
• Deeper or Invisible Structure?
• Collectivity: cultural and material structure of society.
07/02/2014 20
SIMMEL’S FORMAL
STRUCTURALISM
• MAIN THEORY: Social structure is the configurations of interaction that undergird and make possible the wide variety of substantive activities of individuals.
• Surface or Visible Phenomenon?
• Substantive activities of individuals.
• Deeper or Invisible Structure?
• Configurations of interaction.
07/02/2014 21
PIERRE BOURDIEU’S CULTURAL
STRUCTURALIST THEORY
• MAIN THEORY: Interaction is embedded in existing cultural-structural system, and this cultural structure determines what is possible.
• Structure and habitus exist independently of agents and guide their practice; yet they also create options, possibilities, and paths for creative actions and for the construction of new and unique cultural and social phenomena.
• There exists within the social world itself and not only within symbolic systems (language, myth, etc.), objective cultural structures independent of the consciousness and will of agents, which are capable of guiding and constraining their practices or their representations…Although people use their capacities for thought, reflection, and action to construct social and cultural phenomena, they do so within the parameters of existing cultural structures.
07/02/2014 22
PIERRE BOURDIEU’S CULTURAL
STRUCTURALIST THEORY
• Surface or Visible Phenomenon?
• Consciousness and will of agents as well as their practices and representations such as taste, speech, clothing, and manner.
• Deeper or Invisible Structure?
• Field and Habitus:
• Field (External Constraints): Structured social space and connected social relations: Class position--Upper and Lower social classes and other external constraints that impinge on actors.
• Habitus (Internal Constrains): Character and way of thinking; internalized cultures.
07/02/2014 23
ANTHONY GIDDEN’S
STRUCTURATION THEORY
• MAIN THEORY: The creative aspect of human action—the individual side of the duality—makes impossible structural causation which will explain the determination of social action in general.
ANTHONY GIDDEN’S
STRUCTURATION THEORY
• Surface or Visible Phenomenon?
• Relations across space and over time
07/02/2014 24
07/02/2014 25
ANTHONY GIDDEN’S
STRUCTURATION THEORY
• Deep or Invisible Structure:
• Structuration: the dual processes in which rules and resources are used to organize interaction across time and space and, by virtue of this use, to reproduce or transform these rules and resources.
• Structure: Rules and resources that actors use to create, sustain, reproduce or transform relations across space and over time
• Duality of Structure: Both the activities of a “free agent” and the structural constraints that set limits to free activity.
• POSTSTRUCTURALIST
THEORY:
07/02/2014 26
POSTSTRUCTURALIST
THEORY
• MAIN THEORY
• Poststructuralist Paradigm objects to and
deconstructs centered power/knowledge as
constituent part of organized systems of
economic and political hierarchies that
silence minority. These structured social
relationships that claim human agency and
causality are arbitrary or hyper-real
(Foucault, Lyotard, Bauldrillard, Derrida).
07/02/2014 27
POSTSTRUCTURALIST
THEORY
• MAIN THEORY:
• Poststructuralist Paradigm deconstructs modernist
discourses of binary opposites (culture/nature,
man/woman, speech/writing, reason/emotion,
good/evil) that keep metaphysical or moral centers
in power. The aim of the deconstruction is to
decenter these centers, to show how each center
contains some part of its margins, yet without
putting a new metaphysical structure in its place
(Mann 2008, p. 240).
07/02/2014 28
POSTSTRUCTURALIST
THEORY
• MAJOR CONCEPTS:
• Deconstruction
• Discourse
• Power/Knowledge
• Hyper-reality
07/02/2014 29
POSTSTRUCTURALIST THEORY:
Rejection of Structuralism
• PARADIGM SHIFT #1
• In direct contrast to structuralism's
claims of an independent signifier,
superior to the dependent signified, post-
structuralism views the signifier and
signified as inseparable but not united as
a structure (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-
structuralism).
07/02/2014 30
POSTSTRUCTURALIST
THEORY
• PARADIGM SHIFT #2:
• Anti-Structure
07/02/2014 31
POSTSTRUCTURALISTS:
Anti-structure
• THEORISTS:
• 1. Jean Baudrillard
• 2. Julia Kristeva
• 3. Michel Foucault
• 4. Jacques Derrida
• 5. Jean Francois Lyotard
07/02/2014 32
JEAN BAUDRILLARD:
Death of Structure (the Real and the Fake)
• The media and the entertainment industries have thoroughly saturated the postmodern cultures such that the differences between the real [signifier] and the images, signs, and simulations [signified] have dissolved into hyperreality.
• HYPERREAL (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperreality):
• A copy world that emerges from the ashes of the contestation between reality and fantasy that renders both the real and the representation inexistent – just the hyperreal.
JULIA KRISTEVA:
Rejection of Underlying Structure
• Kristeva rejects any understanding of the
subject in a structuralist sense, instead,
she favors a subject always "in process"
or "in crisis." In this way, she contributes
to the poststructuralist critique of
essentialized structures. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julia_Kristeva
07/02/2014 34
JACQUES DERRIDA
• Anti-structure:
• Uncovering or decentering binary opposites (culture/nature, man/woman, reason/emotion, good/evil, etc.), that is, hierarchies where the first term in the pair is seen as superior to the second…These binary opposites support a variety of metaphysical or moral centres. Deconstruction aims to decentre these centres, yet without putting a new metaphysical structure in its place (Jacques Derrida, cited in Mann 2008, p. 240).
07/02/2014 35
JACQUES DERRIDA
• Rupture of structure:
• Since there are no symbols of constant and universal
significance, the entire premise of structuralism as a
means of evaluating writing (or anything) is hollow
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roland_Barthes).
• In a postmodern society there is no transcendental or
privileged signified and the domain or play of
signification henceforth has no limit. There is erasure
of the radical differences between signifier and
signified; there is not a signifier referring to a signified,
a signifier different from its signified.
07/02/2014 36
MICHEL FOUCAULT:
De-centered Power
• One group does not always has power to use to the disadvantage of others:
• Power is dispersed, multidirectional, can be found everywhere, and is always at work without force or coercion in the state, knowledge, discourse, ideology, and all relationships.
07/02/2014 37
MICHEL FOUCAULT:
De-centered Power
• There is no single locus of great Refusal,
no soul of Revolt, source of all rebellions,
or pure law of the revolutionary. Instead,
there is plurality of resistances, each of
them a special case.
• These pluralities of resistances occur as
ruptures or cracks that unsettle the
smooth operation of disciplinary power
07/02/2014 38
MICHEL FOUCAULT:
De-centered Power
• In the postmodern society power
[signifier] and knowledge and discourse
[signified] are wedded into a new system
of de-centered and multidirectional
heightened surveillance
• Surveillance—acts of observing, recording, and
training—techniques that function without
relying on force or coercion, but capable of
producing docile people.
07/02/2014 39
MICHEL FOUCAULT:
De-centered Power
• http://vids.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseacti
on=vids.individual&videoID=695467423
07/02/2014 40
• POSTMODERN, POSTMODERNISM
07/02/2014 41
POSTMODERNIST PARADIGM
• MAIN THEORY:
• It decries the pre-constituted center and its
accompanying exclusion, marginalization and
oppression that the politics, representation, social
structure, and philosophy of modernity and
modernization-driven globalization produce (Roseman
1992). It is in this context that postmodernist paradigm
highlights and approves the fragmentary,
heterogeneous, and plural nature of reality and
inherently unstable and shifting nature of the subject
and individual consciousness that advanced/Post-
capitalism has produced (Wallace and Wolf 2006).
07/02/2014 42
POSTMODERNIST PARADIGM
• MAJOR CONCEPTS:
• Heterogeneity/Pluralism
– Egalitarian Cultural Pluralism
– Multiculturalism
• Deconstruction & Reconstruction – Cultural Hegemony.
– Modernization-induced globalization
– Advanced/Post-Capitalism
– Truth
– “Simulacra” 07/02/2014 43
POSTSMODERNISTS:
• Michel Foucault
• Jacques Derrida
• Jean Francois Lyotard
• Z. Baumann
• Frederic Jameson
• Daniel Bell
POSTMODERN, POSTMODERNISM
• Poststructuralism is the theoretical logic
of postmodernism.
• There is a major shift in the nature of
contemporary society from modern
capitalist to postcapitalist postmodern.
This shift mediated by the mass media
has killed the Real and the Truth.
07/02/2014 45
POSTMODERN, POSTMODERNISM
• The death of Unitary Reality or Single
Truth:
• There is a societal framework, but this
framework is discursive, nonrational [or
antirational?], fragmented,
heterogeneous, diversified, decentralized,
porous, inherently unstable and shifting,
but constraining.
POSTMODERN, POSTMODERNISM
• The blurring and breakdown of established
cannons (rules and standards), categories,
distinctions, and boundaries…a messier and
more playful world in which standards,
contrasts, groups, boundaries, and identities
are opening up, reaching out, and breaking
down (Kottak and Kozaitis 2004, pp. 42-
43).
07/02/2014 47
POSTMODERN, POSTMODERNISM
• What reigns in contemporary human
society is simulation (“Simulacra”)
represented by intuition, myth, fantasy,
subjectivity, fragmentation, multiple
cultures, micro-narratives, multiple
meanings, playfulness, image, style,
consumerism and the commodification of
culture.
SIMULACRA
• The simulacrum is never that
which conceals the truth--it is
the truth which conceals that
there is none.
07/02/2014 49