8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 1/17
SSA2211:Evolution of a
Global City-StateRevision Lecture
Semester 1, AY2011-2012
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 2/17
This module…
• Challenged you to examine the arguments for and against
1819 as the ‘traditional’ starting point for Singapore’s history.
• Challenges you to QUESTION your assumptions on Singapore’s
development and history.
• Explored the role conflict and trade has played in this island’searly modern and modern history.
• Explored the tensions between Singapore as a nation state
and its evolution as a Global city state.
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 3/17
How have we explored Singapore’s
History?
1. Idea of the Longue Duree…seeing this Island’s history from a
longer perspective.
2. Moving away from the ‘heroes and big events’ approach?
3. Exploring globalisation in terms of idea of trade, conflict and
culture.
4. From a history of ‘nation building’ to that of a global city?
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 4/17
.Duree…seeing this island’s
history from a longerperspective.• Temasek era through to the present-day…do we see
patterns emerging?
• We can see that larger forces been important in shapingthe history of Singapore.
• CAN WE SEE CONTINUITY??? Taking a longer view allows usto better trace potential connections from past to present.
Some questions:
• Has the island always been externally-oriented? Why?
• Has a plural society always been a feature of the port city?
• CAN Singapore ever afford to IGNORE the global market?
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 5/17
• BUT how do we account for ‘gaps’ in Singapore’s story ( ie
the ‘sleepy fishing village’ image) when we take thelongue duree?
What can CHANGE?• From a bustling emporium (Temasek) to a Orang Laut
base (and Johor Sultanate territory), a colony,
battleground and now trading hub…
• How strategic/successful has the Island been at different
stages in its history?
• How has the state/society/economy changed to meet
new challenges?
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 6/17
2. Moving away from the
‘heroes and big events’approach?
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 7/17
• We should consider that human agency IS important in
determining Singapore’s development/fate.
• Luck and opportunity often also meant risk and potential
danger…
• Consider the 4-way struggle for the Straits of Melaka: Singapore
became too risky for any group to ‘claim’.
• Raffles defied EIC instructions and risked conflict with the Dutch
by securing an agreement to use Singapore as a trading base.
• Does post-1965 Singapore also fit this picture??The Accidental
Nation?
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 8/17
3. Exploring globalisation in
terms of trade, conflict andculture.
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 9/17
• Idea of CYCLES of trade and conflict affecting Temasek, Singapura,
colonial Singapore and present-day Singapore.
--This island was successful at times, at others it was subordinate,
and it has also been sidelined.
Is is possible that sometimes the waters around Singapore were
more important than the island?
• Has the island always been externally-oriented? Why?
• Has a plural society always been a feature of the port city?
•
CAN Singapore ever afford to IGNORE the global forces/market?
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 10/17
TRADE: TEMASEK
• Trading Emporium
• Tapping regional trade and the China trade
• Monsoonal trade winds
• Gateway for goods of the Riau Archipelago and South Johor
hinterland. Indian Ocean, Southeast Asian and Chinese
products also brought to the port.
• Distinguished by high-quality products.
• --success was relatively short-lived due to CONFLICT in theregion. Melaka became the predominant trading centre in the
Melaka Straits.
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 11/17
TRADE: Singapore as a colonial
entrepot
Patterns of trade
Commodities
Communities
The characteristics of a
colonial port city
NEW??? OR a
revival of trade?
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 12/17
CONFLICT: From Pax-Sinica to
Pax-Americana• As an independent Nation-State, “no one will defend us if we
do not defend ourselves!”
• Longue Duree: “Singapore often defended as part of a larger
entity”
• Chinese dynastic cycles & rise and fall of dominant powers in
maritime Southeast Asia.
• European powers: Portuguese, Spanish, Dutch
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 13/17
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 14/17
CULTURE: Port city mix?
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 15/17
COSMOPOLITAN Singapore
• Cosmopolitan society in a global city…is this new to
Singapore?
• The Straits Chinese are examples of hybridized culture and the
advantages which can be gained from acting as a ‘go-between’
in multi-racial trading hubs.• Language as unique? Singapore English? Singlish? Can or not?
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 16/17
4. From a history of ‘nation
building’ to that of a global
city?• Do we start at 1819? Or earlier?
• The End of Empire has been traditionally viewed as a turning point
in Singapore’s history.
• Counter argument: this was just a ‘speed bump’ in a 700 yearhistory, Singapore grew even as Empire declined
• Decolonisation and Independence.
•Singapore lost its natural hinterland.
• Tensions emerge between Malayan vs Singaporean identity.
• A Nation state and a global city emerges simultaneously?
8/3/2019 SSA2211 Revision Lecture
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/ssa2211-revision-lecture 17/17
Summing up:
• Singapore was not always a sleepy fishing village before
1819.Nor was Singapore always a strategic place.
• Singapore’s evolution has been affected by larger forces of
trade and conflict over a span of centuries.
• Global trade and a multi-ethnic society is not a newdevelopment in Singapore’s history.
• Examining Singapore’s history over a 700 year span provides
us with a richer understanding of Singapore’s place in the
region and can help us to understand WHY and HOW
Singapore has evolved as a global city.