slide 1
Integration of Mobility Management in land use planning:
Outputs
Janina Welsch (ILS), Roberto. De Tommasi (synergo), Tom Rye (TRI, ENU), Aljaz Plevnik
(Uni Maribor)
(on behalf of whole MAX WPD Team)ECOMM 2009, Donóstia San Sebastian,
15 May, 2009
slide 2
WP D topic: Integration of MM and planning
• Planning and building permission process – great potential to integrate MM with:
– Plan-making – so sites have a choice of transport modes
– Building permission – so new developments have MM plans and measures in place from Day 1
• WP D: research, practice and guidance to encourage integration
slide 3
Today’s session
• Introduction to the guidelines and tools developed by WPD (20 Minutes)
• Planning simulation workshop in Slovenia - process and results (20 Minutes)
• Training course in smaller groups looking at hypothetical new development s and how MM might be included in building permission process (30 Minutes)
• Discussion of the findings from smaller groups, in a final plenary session (10 Minutes)
slide 4
Output of WP D on 3 levels
TOOLS / INSTRUMENTSTOOLS / INSTRUMENTS
PART D:Awareness raising
PART D:Awareness raising
RECOMMENDATIONSRECOMMENDATIONS
PART E:Recommendations
PART E:Recommendations
SPIN -
OFF
SPIN - OFF
PART A:Introduction
PART A:Introduction
PART B:Integration of LUP
with SUTP
PART B:Integration of LUP
with SUTP
PART C:Integration of MMin planning and
buildingpermit process of new
buildings
PART C:Integration of MMin planning and
buildingpermit process of new
buildings
Annex B:examples of existingpolicies and cases
Annex B:examples of existingpolicies and cases
Annex C:examples of existingpolicies and cases
Annex C:examples of existingpolicies and cases
GUIDELINESGUIDELINES
slide 5
Output of WP D on 3 levels
TOOLS / INSTRUMENTSTOOLS / INSTRUMENTS
PART D:Awareness raising
PART D:Awareness raising
RECOMMENDATIONSRECOMMENDATIONS
PART E:Recommendations
PART E:Recommendations
SPIN -
OFF
SPIN - OFF
PART A:Introduction
PART A:Introduction
PART B:Integration of LUP
with SUTP
PART B:Integration of LUP
with SUTP
PART C:Integration of MMin planning and
buildingpermit process of new
buildings
PART C:Integration of MMin planning and
buildingpermit process of new
buildings
Annex B:examples of existingpolicies and cases
Annex B:examples of existingpolicies and cases
Annex C:examples of existingpolicies and cases
Annex C:examples of existingpolicies and cases
GUIDELINESGUIDELINES
slide 6
Introduction (Part A): What do they cover and what not? (Chapter 1.2)
• Guidelines give practical advice to planners on– how to integrate transport planning and land use planning
(Part B)– how integrating MM into the land use planning / building
permission process can work (Part C)
• Input approach:– show policies existing in practice and applications of them
(Annexes to B and C)
• Transferability of existing policies– not treated in detail– readers have to judge if policy works in “their situation”
slide 7
Output of WP D on 3 levels
TOOLS / INSTRUMENTSTOOLS / INSTRUMENTS
PART D:Awareness raising
PART D:Awareness raising
RECOMMENDATIONSRECOMMENDATIONS
PART E:Recommendations
PART E:Recommendations
SPIN -
OFF
SPIN - OFF
PART A:Introduction
PART A:Introduction
PART B:Integration of LUP
with SUTP
PART B:Integration of LUP
with SUTP
PART C:Integration of MMin planning and
buildingpermit process of new
buildings
PART C:Integration of MMin planning and
buildingpermit process of new
buildings
Annex B:examples of existingpolicies and cases
Annex B:examples of existingpolicies and cases
Annex C:examples of existingpolicies and cases
Annex C:examples of existingpolicies and cases
GUIDELINESGUIDELINES
slide 8
Integration of land use with transport planning (Part B): Content
• What this integration is
• Why it is important for MM
• Policies and practice to achieve integration, including first steps
• Some examples for policies and practice, e.g.:– PPG13 from England– highly-frequented sites in Switzerland
slide 9
Integration of land use with transport planning (Part B): Overview of policies
For each policy:• How the promising policy
supports integration and so the use of more sustainable transport
• Normal situation – and how the promising policy differs from normal
• What changes are needed to put the promising policy into effect, and barriers to implementation
• Framework conditions
Policy guidelinesPolicy guidelines
Policies derived from environmental laws
Policies derived from environmental laws
Policies that are part of the plan-making process
Policies that are part of the plan-making process
slide 10
Output of WP D on 3 levels
TOOLS / INSTRUMENTSTOOLS / INSTRUMENTS
PART D:Awareness raising
PART D:Awareness raising
RECOMMENDATIONSRECOMMENDATIONS
PART E:Recommendations
PART E:Recommendations
SPIN -
OFF
SPIN - OFF
PART A:Introduction
PART A:Introduction
PART B:Integration of LUP
with SUTP
PART B:Integration of LUP
with SUTP
PART C:Integration of MMin planning and
buildingpermit process of new
buildings
PART C:Integration of MMin planning and
buildingpermit process of new
buildings
Annex B:examples of existingpolicies and cases
Annex B:examples of existingpolicies and cases
Annex C:examples of existingpolicies and cases
Annex C:examples of existingpolicies and cases
GUIDELINESGUIDELINES
slide 11
Integration of MM in the planning and building permission process (Part C): Content
• Introduction Chapter 3.1.
• The building permission process – How does it work? Chapter 3.2.
• The Detailed Site Development Plan Chapter 3.3.
• Promising policies supporting the integration of MM Chapter 3.4.
slide 12
Integration of MM in the planning & building permission process (Part C): Introduction (Chapter 3.1.)
• Defines site-based MM, based on MAX definition
• Explains typical building permission process
• Highlights two principal strategies for public authorities to secure MM during the planning & building permission process– setting the adoption of MM as a condition, as a task of
negotiation or as a recommendation and advice – influence of local authority direct or indirect
– influencing the amount of parking spaces at a new development
• Could also take place in context of Detailed Site Development Plan
slide 13
(Part C): Promising policies supporting integration of MM – Overview of policies (Chapter 3.4.)
Promotion of car-free housing
Promotion of car-free housing
Access Contingent Model for regulating car traffic at
multifunctional developments
Access Contingent Model for regulating car traffic at
multifunctional developments
Influencing set-up of MM through environmental
legislation
Influencing set-up of MM through environmental
legislation
Maximum parking standards
Maximum parking standards
Parking pay-off
Parking pay-off
Securing MM through inclusionin the parking regulation
Securing MM through inclusionin the parking regulation
Securing MM through inclusionin planning conditions and
obligations
Securing MM through inclusionin planning conditions and
obligations
MM advice during the planning or building permission process
MM advice during the planning or building permission process
Securing MM through negotiationSecuring MM through negotiation
slide 14
Tools and Instruments (Part D)
• separate documents (PPT and doc), most based on content of guidelines
• useful as instruments for awareness raising of different target groups
D1: Model presentation of MM at the site level
(PPT)
D1: Model presentation of MM at the site level
(PPT)
D2: Model presentation integration of MM in the planning and building permit process (PPT)
D2: Model presentation integration of MM in the planning and building permit process (PPT)
D3: Model training course
D3: Model training course
D4: Model planning simulation workshop as a
method
D4: Model planning simulation workshop as a
method
D5: Compendium of MM measures
D5: Compendium of MM measures
D6: Example of negotiation contracts
D6: Example of negotiation contracts
slide 15
Training exercise 1
slide 16
Training exercise 2