Emil Voiculescu 1
Single-mode Operation of LMA Fibers
by using a new profile structure
Emil Voiculescu
Technical University of Cluj, RO
Madeira, 3 – 5 Sep 2008
Emil Voiculescu 2
Previously Reported
Les Houches : ► Index Depression helps with high-order mode
discrimination
Naples : ► The LMA fiber having a High-index Ring in the cladding,
also having been reported at the Photonic West Conference 20081,
► The Moat-fiber having a lower refractive index in the cladding, presented by M Hotoleanu in Naples.
They work up to 20 – 25 m of core diameter.
Berlin : ► Results Intercomparison :
High RI better than Lower RI (Voiculescu), both can be used
(S Selleri3 ), Lower RI is preferable ( J Olszewski6 )
Emil Voiculescu 3
Madeira, Sep 2008
► Newly developed solution solves the problem of higher
order modes rejection concurrently with magnifying the light
coverage of the core (effective area in the fundamental mode/
MFD)
► The method can be applied to larger-core fibers, up to
40m and more
► The doping can be flat, there is no need to diminish the
peripheral doping to help with higher-order modes attenuation
Emil Voiculescu 4
Short Recap
in order to explain how the idea
has been developed
Emil Voiculescu 5
Take the best result reported in Berlin :
Single ring having a higher refractive index than the core
Emil Voiculescu 6
And the conclusions
as they have been reported there A passive ring in the cladding is of great help in rejecting the higher-order modes, and this method can be applied to a large range of LMA fibers. Best results are achieved for core diameters in the range from several microns to 20-25μm.
By slightly sliding the ring toward the cladding ( or toward the fiber axis) significant changes take place :
► A ring closer to the core provides a higher effective area,
► A more distant ring increase the higher order modes rejection, but that comes at the price of lower effective area.
Anyway, the coverage of the core area is 1.6 times higher than the one obtained with the lower index ring.
Emil Voiculescu 7
For the moment the new arrangement cannot be publicized, however :
The newly-developed model works okay, meaning it virtually operates single-mode in certain conditions, all superior modes being substantially attenuated, and
The effective area can be sufficiently magnified
This way a new structure has been conceived
Emil Voiculescu 8
The setup used for simulation
• Chosen Ytterbium Doped fibers : 25μm- and 30μm-core, double-clad fibers, code Yb 1200 -25 -250DC, provider Liekki–nLight, experimental
larger-core fibers of 40μm and more, up to 80μm
• Other data : λs = 1.064μm, Ps = 300 mW, λP = 976 nm, Pp = 30 W
• Simulator Used : Liekki Application Designer LAD 3.3
Emil Voiculescu 9
Example of the novel Yb LMA Fiber
Index profile for a 30 m-core fiber leading to drastic attenuation of higher-order modes despite the flat doping used ( right-side figure)
Geometry of the profile – cannot be disclosed yet
Emil Voiculescu 10
Main result showing a 12.9 dB attenuation
of all unwanted modes
NB : Because of the flat doping a strand of only 1.5m of doped fiber is sufficient to reach the maximum gain
Emil Voiculescu 11
Side view of the fundamental mode
shows the core coverage
MFD/ 2a = 59.2%, Aeff /Acore = 35.4%
Emil Voiculescu 12
Side view of the M2 power distribution along
the fiber axis shows radial spreading of M2
Emil Voiculescu 13
Cross-section of M2 power distribution shows M2 peaks outside the core
(evanescence of M2 obvious)
Power density in M2
0
0,05
0,1
0,15
0,2
0,25
0,3
0,35
0,4
-138,159 -82,8954 -27,6318 27,6318 82,8954 138,159
Emil Voiculescu 14
Intercomparison :
Similar behavior obtained by Mircea Hotoleanu
Emil Voiculescu 15
► In order to optimize the index profile, many
parameters had to be varied concurrently.
► Finding the optimal single-mode operation is a
tough job as it regards almost all the
parameters in the index characteristic.
Emil Voiculescu 16
► Anyway, a systematic approach has been carried out and the previous experience
with LMAs helped to shorten the try-and- error procedure
► The basic (expected) functionality seems to relate the high-order mode rejection mainly with the outer portion / layer, and the core coverage mostly with the inner structure
Emil Voiculescu 17
► For this class of fibers, and for the following 40m-core fibers, only the flat doping has been considered. This is one of the great advantages that the new topology offers : to emulate a virtual single-mode fiber we don’t have to decrease the peripheral doping. One also can get a larger gain with a shorter strand of fiber this way.
General remarks
Dopant concentration : 1.56 • 1025 / m3
Emil Voiculescu 18
More than that :
► A significant attenuation of the higher-order modes can be reached without taking special measures. Usually a ≥10dB attenuation of the total power in the higher-order modes can be accepted.
Then, if we can provide more, why not decrease the attenuation, until the Mode-Field Diameter reaches a maximum ? This strategy has been applied for sizing the considered fibers ( 30m- and 40m-core fibers).
► In order to obtain the largest effective area, i.e. maximum MFD, a thin moat resulted.
Because of that, all other geometries are less performant.
Emil Voiculescu 19
The Etalon
►As the coverage of the core with light should be as high as possible one need a comparison criterion. By taking a reference step-index fiber with the same core-diameter (and same cladding diameter), and assuming the same flat doping, we might say that reaching the same effective area in the fundamental mode can be accepted.
►In fact, that coverage is well surpassed every
time, usually by 1.5 times.
Emil Voiculescu 20
1. Core Diameter 30 m
Significant Results
Emil Voiculescu 21
First index profile Power distribution among modes
Attenuation of the most powerful mode ( M9) is : 10log(P1/Pmax) = 10.2dB
MFD/2a = 63.7%
Aeff/Acore = 40.6%
Emil Voiculescu 22
Second Index Profile Power distribution among modes
10log(P1/Pmax) ≈ 9 dB
10log(P1/Ptotal) ≈ 10log(P1/P9+P6)= 10log(17000/2950) ≈ 8 dB
MFD/2a = 77.9% ≈ 80%
Aeff/Acore = 60.7%
Emil Voiculescu 23
MFD/2a = 63.7%
Side view of the fundamental mode
demonstrates the improved core coverage
Emil Voiculescu 24
Also the top view of the fundamental
mode confirms core coverage
Emil Voiculescu 25
What we got ?
► 10 dB of higher-order modes
attenuation or so, which will do with practical
applications, so we may indulge in trading the
attenuation for a larger effective area
Emil Voiculescu 26
Top-view picture proves that the most powerful mode leaks out of the core ( in between –15m and +15m → red, i.e. zero Watts )
Emil Voiculescu 27
2. Core Diameter 40 m
Emil Voiculescu 28
The reference model (the etalon) first
Step-index fiber Flat doping
Mode power distribution along the fiber shows the usual mode
’scrambling’ as no measure for counteracting that has been taken
Emil Voiculescu 29
The fundamental mode
MFD / 2a = 51.7 %
Aeff / Acore = 26.7 %
Side view
Cross section
Emil Voiculescu 30
The proposed fiber
Emil Voiculescu 31
And the results
Attenuation of the most powerful mode : 10 log(P1/P9) = 10.98 dB
Attenuation of all superior modes : 10 log (P1/PTotal) = 9.33 dB
Emil Voiculescu 32
Mode field diameter and Effective area
MFD / 2a = 65.4 %
Aeff / Acore = 42.7 %
Emil Voiculescu 33
Conclusions► The novel fiber structure presented here solves the key problem
associated with LMA fibers : the beam quality.
► This way we can modify a multimode fiber in a quasi-single mode one.
► Compared with the previously developed single-ring fibers, this one offers an extra degree of freedom
► The structure works fine with 40 m cores. It cannot be easily applied to experimental 80m-core LMA fibers or thicker core fibers. Going beyond
25 m of core diameter makes single-mode operation problematic.
► If the experimental results will confirm the simulation results, then such fibers will be manufactured. It is very likely that some samples will be tested soon. A round-robin to confirm performance by measurement could naturally follow the modelling/simulation activity.
Emil Voiculescu 34
References 1. Improving the beam quality in LMA fibers. E Voiculescu, M Hotoleanu, Csipkes G,
Photonic West Conference 6896, San Jose, CA, Jan 23 2008.
2. Study regarding the Index and Doping profiles in LMA fibers for maximum optical power in the fundamental mode. Graduation Thesis 2008, B Ghete, Technical University of Cluj, RO.
3. Moat fiber finite element method. F Poli, D Passaro, A Cicinotta, S Selleri, University of Parma, COST Presentation, Berlin, Jan 29 2008.
4. Single-mode regime in large mode area moat fiber. D. Passaro, F. Poli, A. Cucinotta, S. Selleri, submitted to ECOC 2008.
5. Large mode area optical fibers for high power amplification. S Selleri, A Cucinotta, F Poli, D Passaro, COST Presentation, Madeira, 2008.
6. Modes in moat fiber. Numerical modeling. J Olszewski, Wroclaw University of
Technology, COST Presentation, Berlin, 2008.
Acknowledgement
I am grateful to student Bogdan Ghete for his work to the topic
through his graduation thesis that I advised, and which got the
maximum score and the ‘Cum Laudae’ apreciation from the
Graduating Board June 2008.
I am grateful to Dr M Hotoleanu and Liekki– nLight for revising
this material, providing me with the fiber data needed, and with
the LAD 4.1 software.
Emil Voiculescu 36
Thank you !