Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Allan Shackelford Attorney/Consultant [email protected]
1
y
Margaret Wiedenhoeft, Ph.D. Associate Director Center for International Programs at Kalamazoo College [email protected]
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
After this webcast, you will be able to assess your study abroad risk management preparedness and
improve your operations accordingly.
2
Academic Impressions 1
3
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Session OverviewSession Overview
• Understanding the state of study abroad today
• Seven steps to manage study abroad risk
• Lessons learned from Japan and Egypt
• Additional resources
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
4
UNDERSTANDING THE STATE OF STUDY ABROAD TODAY
Academic Impressions 2
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
• Student participation• Student participation
• More institutions offering programs
• Change in destinations
5
• What students do abroad
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
6
SEVEN STEPS TO MANAGE STUDY ABROAD RISK
Academic Impressions 3
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
STEP #1
7
DEVELOP POLICIES
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
8
Academic Impressions 4
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 5
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Sending Students Abroad Is a Unique Business Venture
In contrast to other higher education programs and activities, risk is increasing with the number of students traveling to
9
with the number of students traveling to developing parts of the world.
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Sending Students Abroad Is a Unique Business Venture
Program organization ‐‐ or disorganization ‐‐and emerging trends in program duration have increased related risk factors.
10
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 6
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
An Evolving Legal and Risk Landscape for Both • The times they are a changin’
• Rapid and continuous growth
• Proliferation of federal laws and regulations
11
• Changing student demographics
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Higher Education Was Once a
• Traditionally, few legal requirements
• Colleges regulated themselves
• Anthony v. Syracuse
Protected Industry
12
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 7
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Now Treated Like Any Other Business • By judges, juries and creative plaintiffs’ attorneys
• Colleges and universities – and, in ti l d i
13
particular, revenue producing programs ‐‐are now viewed as “ordinary commercial enterprises.”
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
The Trend Regarding Legal DutyThe Trend Regarding Legal Duty
• Courts moving away from “no duty”
• Focus on:
‐“reasonableness”
14
‐“foreseeability”
‐“special relationship”
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
ReasonablenessReasonableness
• The reasonable person standard
• A person has acted negligently if he or she has departed from the conduct expected of
bl d t ti d
15
a reasonably prudent person acting under similar circumstances
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
ForeseeabilityForeseeability
• Reasonable anticipation of the possible results of an action
16
Academic Impressions 8
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 9
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Special RelationshipSpecial Relationship
Courts determine if, under the particular circumstances, there is a special relationship between the student and the institution that establishes a “duty”
17
institution that establishes a duty
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Concepts Have Been Applied to Study Abroad Program Lawsuits • There has not been a lot of litigation over study abroad related legal claims
• Many controversies have been settled b f th h d th t
18
before they reached the courtroom
• However, study abroad cases have followed the trend away from “no duty”
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 10
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Grisar v. St. Mary’s College Prince George’s County Cir. Ct. 2001
The College “knew or should have known” that the Pacific Highway was “extremely dangerous …”
“They hired a bus with the word ‘turismo’ on it
19
– They hired a bus with the word turismo on it … [which] lacked a cellphone, two‐way radio, or other means of calling for help.”
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Fay v. Thiel College 2001 WL 1910037 (Pa.Comm.Pl. 2001) • The court determined that a “special relationship” existed between the College and the student and that this special relationship created a duty
20
relationship created a duty.
• Court inferred “special relationship” from waiver of liability/consent form.
To protect the health, safety and welfare f f lt d t ff
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Model Policies, Procedures and Protocols Are Necessary:Protocols Are Necessary:
To protect the health, safety and welfare of students
21
of faculty and staff
To protect the health, welfare and reputation of our colleges and universities
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Risk management is the art and science of anticipation.
22
Academic Impressions 11
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
NACUBO and URMIA Define Ri kRisk:
23
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Risk Can Be…
24
Academic Impressions 12
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Responses to Risk
25
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Benefits of Risk ManagementBenefits of Risk Management
• Proactive, not reactive
• Safe, healthy, secure programs
• Assets preserved
26
• Reputation intact
• Saves money, time, stress (and possibly litigation)
Academic Impressions 13
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 14
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Effective Risk Management Is a Study Abroad Program Mandate • Acknowledges that some programs and activities have inherent risk
• Not isolated from comprehensive planning
27
• Risks may be know and obvious ‐ or not
• Students, faculty and staff must be educated
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
From a Macro PerspectiveFrom a Macro Perspective
Study Abroad program policies, procedures and protocols must: – Anticipate and manage risk and threats
Anticipate and manage legal iss es and
28
– Anticipate and manage legal issues and liabilities
– Protect everyone, including the institution
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 15
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
From a Micro Perspective, Risk Management Needs to Include: • Prescreening of students
• Training for faculty and staff
• An infrastructure to respond to
29
emergencies and student conduct issues
• A chain of command and communication channels for the expected and unexpected
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
And, in Today’s Environment, Perhaps Much More: • Internal or external database to track travel itinerary of students, faculty and staff
• Kidnapping and ransom insurance
30
• Emergency health care and evacuation resources and/or insurance
• Comprehensive intercultural training
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 16
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
For the institution, this means:For the institution, this means:
• Policies that determine how new programs are developed
• Application, selection, and enrollment li i f t d t
31
policies for students
• Clear expectations for faculty, staff, and students that are involved
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
How are policies developed?How are policies developed?
• Committee review
• Involve multiple constituencies
• Should parallel campus policies (with some
32
obvious exceptions)
_ _ _ _
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
What does this look like?
Example of Kalamazoo College study abroad handbook –
https://reason.kzoo.edu/cip/assets/SA_Handb ook_2012_2013_with_FAQs.pdfp
33
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
STEP #2
34
TRAIN STAFF AND ORIENT STUDENTS
Academic Impressions 17
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 18
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Faculty/ Staff: Start with the basicsFaculty/ Staff: Start with the basics
• This isn’t amateur sport!
• Job description – clear expectations
• Enforcing policies before and during
35
program – and how to document
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Faculty/ Staff: On the road…Faculty/ Staff: On the road…
• Recognize when students are in trouble
• Role in emergency/crisis response
• Communication – who, what, when, how
36
• Provide way for them to contact campus
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 19
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Faculty / Staff: In the event of a crisis…
• On‐site orientation: – Local emergency numbers
– Faculty cell phone numbers
B dd t d h t
37
– Buddy system and phone tree
– Primary and secondary meeting place
– Safety reminders
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Faculty / Staff training ‐ Topics Faculty / Staff training Topics
• Counseling Center
• Campus Health Center
• Emergency and Crisis: Student Support and
38
College Expectations
• Legal Issues and study abroad
• Roundtable discussions, case studies
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 20
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
As for the students…As for the students…
• Bring expectations closer to reality
• Reinforce academic, behavior, and cultural expectations – and the consequences‐ if
t f ll d
39
not followed
• Best to provide in a session, provide in written format (or web) and then once again on‐site
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Students need to be told…Students need to be told…
• How to access physical and mental health resources on program
• Cultural information – including ti f US A i t d t
40
perceptions of US American students
• Alcohol and drugs – focus on behavior
• Local resources on site
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Students should also know…Students should also know…
• Emergency procedures
• Safety information – including traveling during breaks
41
• Responding to physical and sexual assault
• When parents will be contacted
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Student Orientation Orientation Session Topics Covered
Region Specific Academic credits, role of RD or on‐site staff, emergency procedures; housing, local transportation
Site Specific University culture, Role of on‐site staff, emergency procedures, housing
Health and Safety Student responsibilities, Physical and emotional health, d li ith lt h k d f t i ( lt
42
dealing with culture shock and safety issues (assault, drugs, and alcohol)
Identity Shifts and SA Cross‐cultural expectations, stereotypes, gender relations
Past participant session Meet with past participants – topics are open!
Academic Impressions 21
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
STEP #3
43
IMPLEMENT STRATEGIC ARTICULATION AGREEMENTS
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Models for Study Abroad ProgramsModels for Study Abroad Programs • Institutional
• Consortium
• Agreement with domestic or foreign institution
C t t id
44
• Contract program provider
• Permissive
• Blended
Academic Impressions 22
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Each Model Raises QuestionsEach Model Raises Questions • Which and whose policies, procedures and protocols apply and control?
• Who is responsible for risk and threat assessment – and crisis management?
45
assessment and crisis management?
• Who is the ultimate “decider”?
• Have all the bases been covered?
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Do MOUs and Contractual Agreements Fully Address Possible Issues:Fully Address Possible Issues: • Regarding their students who are participants in your program(s)?
• Regarding your students who are participants in their program(s)?
46
their program(s)?
• Disclosure of specific, and to the best of the institution’s ability, the foreseeable risks associated with the particular programs?
Academic Impressions 23
o otect ou st tut o :
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 24
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Holes Are Most Often Discovered When: • A health or safety emergency arises
• A serious misconduct situation or disciplinary issue exists
47
• Unanticipated and unforeseen resources are needed
• Common sense goes missing
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
To Protect Your Institution: • Clearly articulate each party’s legal obligations and responsibilities.
• Allocate risk and legal liabilities and specific insurance requirements.
48
q
• Use appropriate waivers and indemnification provisions.
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
When selecting a partner, consider:
• Relationships, not transactions
• Is it a good academic fit?
• What is student support like?
49
• How will the program be structured?
• Who will be responsible for the components of the program? (orientation, logistics)
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
STEP #4
50
INVOLVE THE ENTIRE CAMPUS
Academic Impressions 25
51
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Who should be involved?Who should be involved?
• During application process
• During orientation and pre‐departure
• During an emergency/crisis
• After the resolution
Stage in Study Abroad Process Who Should Be Involved
Application process • Student development • Academic advisor • Campus judicial board • ADA officer
Orientation and pre‐departure • Student Health Center • Student Counseling Center• Student Counseling Center • Study abroad office • Faculty (if applicable) • Campus insurance provider
Emergency/crisis situation • On‐campus crisis management team • Higher administration • Student development • Security/campus police • Public relations
52
• Public relations •Insurance provider
After the resolution • On‐campus crisis management team • Student development • Counseling Center • Public relations
Academic Impressions 26
54
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
STEP #5
53
RESPOND TO DOS TRAVEL WARNINGS AND ALERTS
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
U.S. Department of StateU.S. Department of State
• Country specific information
• Travel Warning
• Travel Alerts
• Worldwide Caution
Academic Impressions 27
• Gives general information and history
• Specific information about crime, road safety, access to medical facilities
• Read before you design a program!
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Country Specific Information A il bl f t• Available for every country
55
• Read before you design a program!
• Available here: – http://travel.state.gov/travel/cis_pa_tw/cis/cis_4965 .html
DOS Warning/Alert
What It Is When Issued How To Respond
• Issued in response to short‐term situations
• Election‐related violence
Alert/Warning/Caution Guide
TRAVEL ALERTS • Most have 90‐day expiration dates
• Regional sporting events
• Share this information with students, parents and faculty/staff on‐site
• Remind them what a travel alert, travel warning or WWC is – a reminder, not a reason to panic!
E d i
TRAVEL WARNINGS
• Protracted, long‐term situations where it is deemed unsafe for US citizens to travel
•Suspension of consular
• May be prompted by evacuation of non‐essential U.S. DOS personnel and families
56
•Encourage students to sign up for alerts at the DOS website: https://travelregistration.state .gov/ibrs/ui/
Suspension of consular operations
WORLDWIDE CAUTION
• Issued to alert U.S. Citizens around the world to be alert and aware of their security
• Response to terrorist threats
Academic Impressions 28
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 29
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Also consider… • Does your institution know more than the DOS?
• Develop a process of review – Form a committee to review DOS travel warnings, travel alerts and world wide caution issuances
• Other sources of information: h d l ( )
57
– The Overseas Advisory Council (OSAC) https://www.osac.gov/Pages/Home.aspx
– Private companies (Red 24; SOS) offer information on a subscription basis
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
STEP #6
58
CREATE FORMAL EVALUATION PROCESSES
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 30
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
As You Prepare The ProgramAs You Prepare The Program
• New program proposals should include information on health and safety – and consider all students who may participate (US passport holders and those with US
59
(US passport holders and those with US student visas)
• Check insurance policies for exclusions
• Use the DOS Country Information Sheets
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Create Formal Evaluation ProcessesCreate Formal Evaluation Processes • Get feedback from students – and review and respond accordingly – If third party program, ask for the evaluations or reports from on‐site staff
60
• Review program locations regularly
• Require on‐site staff/faculty to write a report
62
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Evaluate Emergency Procedures & P t l 4 K StProtocols: 4 Key Steps • Review emergency procedures
• Train all staff on emergency procedures – Drill on a regular basis
Sh d ith id
61
• Share emergency procedures with campus‐wide emergency committee
• Compare with benchmark institutions‐ do they fit industry practices?
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
The DebriefThe Debrief
After responding to an emergency, debrief: – What went well?
– What could have been done better?
Wh t d h ld b h d if ?– What procedures should be changed, if any?
Academic Impressions 31
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
STEP #7
63
REVIEW PROCEDURES
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Policy Assessment and Review Must iBe an Ongoing Process
• Review and incorporate best practices and respond to changing risk scenarios: – NAFSA
64
– Forum on Education Abroad
– URMIA
• Focus on what other institutions are doing
Academic Impressions 32
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Provide Training Opportunities for StaffProvide Training Opportunities for Staff • Regional conferences
• Webinars
• Listservs
• Internal training programs focused on emerging
65
• Internal training programs focused on emerging and trending issues
• Do not allow faculty to escape!
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
66
CONCLUDING THOUGHTS
Academic Impressions 33
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Your Approach Must Be Safety, Security and Solutions Oriented At the end of the day, both you and your college or university’s study abroad programs and related decisions and actions will be judged on whether you made the “right decisions” in the
67
whether you made the right decisions in the best interests of individual students, others involved with the programs and the institution itself.
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
LESSONS LEARNED FROM JAPAN AND EGYPT
68
Academic Impressions 34
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 35
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Lessons Learned from JapanLessons Learned from Japan
• How to reach students during break?
• How to make decisions with multiple sources of (somewhat) contradicting information?
69
• Does the campus have a back up plan when students must return early (or defer participation)?
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Lessons Learned from EgyptLessons Learned from Egypt
• Do not go down to the riot!
• How to make decisions with multiple sources of (somewhat) contradicting information?
70
• Does the campus have a plan for the arrest of a student? Who is responsible?
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
71
QUESTIONS AND DISCUSSION
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
72
ADDITIONAL RESOURCES
Academic Impressions 36
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
Academic Impressions 37
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Resources: NAFSA: The Association of International Educators
http://www.nafsa.org/resourcelibrary/default.aspx?catId=429104
The Forum on Education Abroad
http://forumea.org/standards‐index.cfm
The U.S. Department of State
http://travel.state.gov/
The Overseas Security Advisory Council
73
https://www.osac.gov/Pages/Home.aspx
Association for Safe International Road Travel
http://www.asirt.org/
SAFETI Clearinghouse‐ Center for Global Education
http://www.globaled.us/
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
DisclaimerDisclaimer This program, along with the resource materials provided, was designed and intended to provide accurate and authoritative information regarding the subject matter covered. However, it does not constitute legal or consultative advice. Please consult with your institution's legal counsel and/or other appropriate professional support staff regarding the specific facts and circumstances associated with any related legal question, policy or procedural issue, matter or case.
74
Margaret Wiedendhoeft, [email protected]
Allan Shackelford, [email protected]
Seven Steps for Effective Study Abroad Risk Management
FOR EFFECTIVE STUDY ABROAD RISK MANAGEMENT
Thank you!
Allan Shackelford
Attorney/Consultant
Margaret Wiedenhoeft, Ph.D.
75
Margaret Wiedenhoeft, Ph.D.
Associate Director
Center for International Programs at Kalamazoo College
Academic Impressions 38