1
Parish MissionResearch Methods
Dr Birute BRILIUTE03/07/2010
Research to make a difference to your work
Summary
This part of the session will provide a short introduction to survey research and statistical analysis. It covers sampling, questionnaire design, survey interviewing and questionnaire construction, and takes a brief look at qualitative methods.
It will introduce you to simple tables and tests of significance, and analysis of tables.
3
Aims
To draw together themes from previous modules To offer a guided study approach to the students in
order to introduce them in to methods in social, pastoral, psychological and religious/spiritual research
To help them construct and conduct a research project (e.g. a survey), which demonstrates the student’s understanding of principles and their practical outworking in Parish life.
4
Learning Outcomes
By the end of this session students should be able to:
outline the range of methods that are used in social and religious research and place the survey style within it;
design a research project on a topic of your own choice in the survey style of research;
discuss the legal and ethical implications of your research;
Learning Outcomes
You will learn to: extract and present information from
published Church/parish research statistics; carry out a brief literature review for it; carry out tabular analysis of a data set; summarize and present results in a variety of
formats
6
Why to do a Survey in the Parish?
Before starting a research you have to ask yourself few important questions:
What I want to achieve with it?
Are my research goals moral and ethical?
Will it not harm/offend anyone?
Will this work make any difference in my parish?
Am I ready to face possible difficulties in my work?
Do I seek to offer recommendations for a better serviceIn the parish?
What are my other motives to do the research?
8
What do you want from your research?
What context/situation needs examining?
What is the background in existing thinking (literature review etc.)
What information do you want to find out?
What learning are you seeking?
What questions do you need to ask?
How do you need to ask them?
Am I trying to explore the deeper meaning….by
….talking with each
other about
all these things
that had happened…..
What are you discussing with each other while you walk along?’
‘Are you the only stranger in Jerusalem who does not know …..
Listening & hearing what they say… Leaving my own ‘agenda’ behind…. Is my starting point is theirs starting point?… Am I ready to follow them ?…
That the Church lives in a pluralistic and secularised world
Different forms of unbelief and religious indifference
Vibrant expressions of religious pluralism
Cultural pluralism Will my work bring to the
people: A Catechesis or Evangelization impregnated with the spirit of the Gospel?
‘language adapted to the times and to the hearers.’
General Directory
for catechesis, 193-194
Looking at our situation, am I ready to face:
Looking at our situation
Pick and mix societyWhat do you think are two of the major problems with a ‘pick and mix’
approach to Catholicism and what opportunities for a new approach might they present?
We stand on thresholdsName three attitudes (not actions), which we need to develop if we are to
meet people as they stand on various thresholds.
Don’t be afraid of: Searching for God on the
boundaries Counter values to the gospel Positive and negative aspects of
the media Mobile physically and mentally An individualistic society
Open your eyes to the world….
Get my children to a good school?
Deal with my boss?
Find a companion/wife/husband…
Cope with my loss…
To adopt a child or to have my own
To help my aging parents
To deal with my teenagers
Can your Church help me?
Looking at our situation: be ready to face difficult questions:
With my mortgage
Feed my kids
Get a job
Find the place to live
What is your faith about?
Do not start with your doctrines!
Show me the way to contentment, integrity and fulfilment…
Show me the meaning in my life
Yes, our Church can help you with all of that. I will be a companion
on your journey…
Embrace the realityDo not close your eyes…
Deal with it…
These people are hungry to hear a Good News…
Ask yourself: How can we help people to see where God is active in our world?
‘The fundamental importance is the dialogical approach which, while recognising that all are called to the obedience of faith, (Rom 1:5), respects the basic freedom and autonomy of adults and encourages them to engage in an open and cordial dialogue. In this way they can make known their needs and participate, as they should, as subjects or
agents in their own catechesis and that of others.’ Adult Catechesis in the Christian Community: Some principles and Guidelines, 57
What might God be saying?‘The joy and hope, the grief and anguish of the men
of our time, especially of those who are poor or afflicted in any way, are the joy and hope, the grief and anguish of the followers of Christ as well.’
Vatican II The Church in the Modern World, 1
Discover where God is at workFinding the right sort of approachEntering the brokenness and tension of people’s livesResponding to uncertaintyHow we might be asked to change
Our attitude‘Faith is a gift destined to grow in the hearts of believers. Adhering to Jesus Christ, in fact, sets in motion a process of continuing conversion, which lasts for the whole of life.’
General Directory for Catechesis, 56
We cannot teach everything Mature catechesis – respecting differences
Letting go in faith Accepting brokenness Respect God’s catechetical activity Journeys which meet Affirming what is known Looking for the good
Challenging in love Letting go Leave the door ajar We learn after the event
Do not be afraid…
Do not feel inadequate…
Looking at our situation
Feel strong in your own faith…
20
Research methods
Qualitative vs Quantative research methods
Quantative How many parishioners (how often) attend the Sunday Eucharist?
QualitativeWhat are the views of parishioners from various social and economical as well as cultural backgrounds?
21
Quantative versus Qualitative Key Differences
Quantitative Research Information. Typified by...
Qualitative Research Information. Typified by...
Larger samples Smaller samples
Statistically valid Directional findings
Analyses numbers – how many think what? Analyses thoughts and feelings
Closed questioning techniques (less opportunity to ask ‘why?’)
Open questioning techniques
Who thinks what? (Measuring) Why do people think/behave as they do?
(Explaining)
Analyzed in aggregate
Allows us to provide anecdotal type information – for example (with permission of the respondent), we can highlight case study examples for ‘interesting’ understanding of liturgy/parish culture, etc.
22
Qualitative vs Quantitative Research
• Qualitative research involves analysis of data such as words (e.g., from interviews), pictures (e.g., video), or objects (e.g., an artifact).
• Quantitative research involves analysis of numerical data.
• The personality / thinking style of the researcher and/or the culture of the organization is under-recognized as a key factor in preferred choice of methods.
• Overly focusing on the debate of "qualitative versus quantitative" frames the methods in opposition. It is important to focus also on how the techniques can be integrated, such as in mixed methods research. More good can come of social science researchers developing skills in both realms than debating which method is superior.
Key Points:
23
Some Examples of Quantative Research
Gifts and Talents Survey Questionaire
Part I. Things I Have Done! I have the following skills/talents/experience; these are things I have done! Please mark the ones you are good in:
___ Working with children___ Working with other teens___ Working with adults___ Working with the elderly___ Working with the disabled___ Working with another culture___ Working with the poor/disadvantaged___ Visiting people who are home-bound___ Working with the sick___ Hospitality
24
Some Examples of Quantative Research
Snapshot of the Religious Landscape of the United States: the Results
By all accounts, the United States is among the most religiously active and diverse nations in the world. There are currently over 350,000 congregations in the U.S., spanning the world’s religions and denominations. This snapshot provides a quick picture of American religiosity, faith institution membership, religious-driven giving and volunteering, and regional religious differences. It allows local leaders to reflect on their own community’s religious traditions and identities in relation to the demographics of other communities and the nation at large.
Religiosity: More than 90% of Americans believe in some sort of higher power. Nearly 9 out of 10 Americans consider religion “very important” or “fairly important” in their lives.
Faith Institution Membership: Nearly 7 in 10 Americans are members of a church or synagogue.It has been historically true that between 35 and 40% of Americans have probably participated in their faith community with some degree of regularity
25
Research Methods: the summary
Quantitative Qualitative
Numbers (Quantity) Words, images, ideas
Measurable/Empirical Stories, thoughts, feelings
Closed Questions Open Questions
The stuff you can put in a graph
The things you can best describe in an essay
Statistical analysis Discovery, explanation, directions
26
Which Research Method to chose?
Quantitative: How many RCIA
candidates did you have in 2010?
Qualitative: Why was RCIA good
this year?
Most worthwhile research has elements of both Qualitative and
Quantitative
27
Typical Research process
1. Awareness of area that needs study
2. Possession of some initial questions
3. Review of what is already out there in the field
4. Prepare survey/questionnaire
Draft Pilot
5. Introductory letter (Ethics and legalities)
6. Roll out survey/questionnaire
7. Analyse results8. Qualitative reflection
28
Reading the Data: Understanding qualitative
research and data analysis software
The Qualitive Research: Qualitative research uses unstructured information – like field notes, videos, transcripts and audio recordings, instead of numbers to arrive at conclusions.
For more advanced Qualitative research data analysis you are advised to use NVIVO software:http://www.qsrinternational.com
29
Reading the Data: Understanding qualitative research and data analysis software
Import, sort and analyze audio files, videos, digital photos, Word, PDF, rich text and plain text documents. Work with transcripts or work without them, analyzing material straight from audio and video files. Or create transcripts or text files in the software as you go. Work with material in any language and choose to work with an English, French, German, Spanish, Simplified Chinese or Japanese user interface. Query your data with a powerful state-of-the-art search engine. Graphically display project information, connections and findings using models and charts. Share files and findings with colleagues who don't have NVivo, using HTML web pages. Merge separate projects and still identify which work was completed by each team member.
NVIVO will help you to:
30
Reading the Data: Understanding Quantative research and data analysis software
The Quantative Research: Quantative research uses structured information – like closed or semi-closed questions, numbers to evaluate intensity of the question. It always the numbers that arrive at conclusions.
For more advanced Quantative research data analysis you are advised to use SPSS software:
http://webdb.ucs.ed.ac.uk/eucscourses/co
31
Reading the Data: Understanding Quantative research and data analysis software
You can also use the Microsoft Excel
positive answerknowledge of faith
17%
liturgy1%
morality3%
engagement6%
prayer8%
mission8%
spirit8%
total49%
knowledge of faith
liturgy
morality
engagement
prayer
mission
spirit
total
32
Bibliography
Stephen B. Bevans Constants in Context: A Theology of Mission for Today (Orbis Maryknoll 2004)
Roger P. Schroeder What is the Mission of the Church: A guide for Catholics? (Orbis Maryknoll, 2008)
Philip Knights and Andrea Murray Evangelisation in England and Wales (Catholic Bishops Conference of England and Wales , 2002)
Philip Knights Changing Evangelisation: Themes and Stories from Catholics in local Mission (CTBI, London, 2007
Anne Richards et al Foundations for Mission (CTBI, London 2010)
Recommended weblinks: Qualitative versus Quantitative -
http://www.gifted.uconn.edu/siegle/research/Qualitative/qualquan.htm - a table (similar to above), summarizing characteristics of qualitative and quantitative research in more detail
Qualitative versus Quantitative Design - http://www.kelcom.igs.net/~nhodgins/quant_qual.html - another table (like above)
The Qualitative versus Quantitative Debate - http://writing.colostate.edu/references/research/gentrans/pop2f.cfm - good overview, but the layout is flat and difficult to skim-read
Qualitative vs Quantitative analysis - http://www.ling.lancs.ac.uk/monkey/ihe/linguistics/corpus3/3qual.htm - reasonable overview, with linguistics focus