JOHN CRADDOCK, Macalester CollegeKARL WIRTH, Macalester College
CAMERON DAVIDSON, Carleton College
Craddock et al., 2006. 19th Annual Keck Symposium; http://keck.wooster.edu/publications
PRECAMBRIAN EVOLUTION OF MINNESOTA
120
PROJECT SUMMARY
This project was organized to address outstanding geologic problems in the mid-continent region (Minnesota, Wisconsin and Michigan) using Macalester College as a base for field and lab studies June 14-July15, 2005. Following a regional field trip through the geology of northern Minnesota, students selected projects on igneous geochemistry, magnetic fabrics in igneous rocks, the provenance of clastic sedimentary rocks using detrital zircons, or a combination of the above. Following individual sample collection (Figs. 1 & 2), all students processed 2-3 clastic sediments for their zircon populations at Macalester. All students also used anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility (AMS) to measure strain (sandstones or quartzites) or a magmatic fabric (rhyolites, granites, diabase) at the Institute for Rock Magnetism (IRM) at the University of Minnesota. Magnetic separation of zircons continued in the fall at Macalester, and Prof. Davidson traveled to Pullman in December, 2005 to mount, polish, and scan (SEM-EDS and CL images) the pucks for laser analysis. Five students traveled to Washington State University, Pullman, WA in January, 2006 with Profs. Wirth and Craddock to use the laser ablation-mass spectrometer (LA-ICPMS) system to obtain U-Pb ages on igneous and detrital zircon populations. One granite (n=20 zircons) and sixteen sedimentary units (n=2000 zircons) were analyzed over ~3 weeks of lab time in Pullman.
Keweenaw Rift Rhyolite (Dhiren Patel, Ryan Porter)
The Keweenaw rift province was magmatically active for a brief period (1.1-1.06 Ga; Davis and Green, 1997) as a back-arc continental spreading center in-board of the convergent Grenville orogen (1.4-0.9 Ga). The rift produced a thick sequence of intrusive and extrusive igneous rocks, dominated by basalt (~70%) and rhyolite (~15%) and lesser bi-modal components including gabbro, granophyre, anorthosite, and lamprophyre. The rhyolites are found near the top of the igneous stratigraphy and are <30 m in thickness; some preserve no obvious layering while other flows contain contorted flow folding at the base and tops. Dhiren Patel and Ryan Porter selected four flows (Figs. 1 & 2) where oriented samples could be collected from the base, middle and top of a flow and ~20 oriented equant cores (or cubes) could be extracted for magnetic analysis.
Anisotropy of magnetic susceptibility (AMS) is a technique used to measure a magnetic fabric ellipsoid as a proxy for strain (sediments) or magmatic flow. Patel and Porter hypothesized that the tops and bottoms of flows would preserve a chaotic (random) AMS fabric and the flow interiors would preserve a magnetic fabric with K
max parallel to layering and trending
NW-SE, normal to the rift axis. In thin section, some of the rhyolites contain glass shards and tridymite pseudomorphs that are aligned parallel to bedding and normal to the rift. The petrofabric and AMS results for the rhyolite
121
Craddock et al.,2006. 19th Annual Keck Symposium; http://keck.wooster.edu/publications
N S
EW
050
100
25
Kilo
met
ers
Lake
Sup
erio
r
Can
ada
Min
neso
ta
MinnesotaWisconsin
Wis
cons
in
Mic
higa
n
05K
P-3
05K
P-4
05K
P-1
0
05K
P-1
6
05K
P-1
05K
P-2
205K
P-2
105
KP
-23
05K
P-3
6
05K
P-3
005
KP
-32 05
KP
-21
05K
P-4
005K
P-4
2
05K
P-2 S
t.P
aul
05K
P-4
5
Nor
thfie
ld
Dul
uth
Ow
r
Ow
r
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
Om
u
Om
u
Om
u
Om
u
Oum
Op
Op
Op
Op
Cu
Cu
Cu
Olu
Olu
Olu
Olu
Olu
Olu
Oa
Osi
Om
Osi
Su
Op
Cu
Cu
Cu
Oa
Cm
Cm
Yor
Yn
Yn
Yj
Yj
Yf
Yf
Yfc
Ydi
Yc
Yc
Ych
Yfl
Yhi
Yc
Yc
Ypl
v
Ypl
vY
plv
Ypr
Ypv
Ynv
Ynv
Ynv
Ynv
Ycv
Ycv
Ycv
Ycv
Yk
Ykr
Yh
Ydt
Ydt
Ydt
Ybb
Ybb
Ys
Ys
Yhf
Yw
e
Ygp
Ygr
Yhp
Yw
a
Yw
a
Yw
b
Yw
m
Yw
r Yw
wg
Yw
g
Yw
g
Yw
ap
Yw
nYw
s
Yss
Ygb
Yo
Xm
iv
Xm
q
Xag
Xag
Xag
Xag
Xag
Xnr
Xm
v
Xm
v
Xm
sa
Xm
sa
Xm
sa
Xlf
Xsq
Xm
b
Xgd
Xgd
Xgd
Xgd
Xgd
Xgd
Xop
Xop
Xpp
Xgr
Xgr
Xgr
Xgr
Agn
Agn
Agn
Agn
Agn
Agn
Agn
Wsm
Wsm
Wm
i
Wm
i
Wm
i
Wm
i
Wgd
Wgd
Wgd
Wgd
Wgd
Wgd
Wgd
Wgd
Wgd
Wgd
Wst
Wgr
Wgr
Wgr
Wgr
Wgr
Wgr
Wgr
Wgr
Wgr
Wgr
Wgr
Wgr
Wgr
Wgm
Wgm
Wgm
Wqz
Wm
m
Wm
m
Wm
m
Wm
m
Wm
v
Wm
v
Wm
v
Wm
v
Wm
vW
mv
Wm
v
Wm
v
Wm
v
Wm
s
Wm
s
Wm
s
Wm
s
Xai
Xai
Yl
Xvs
Xq
Xv
Xgr
s
Xqd
Xm
g
Xm
g
Xga
Xga
Xg
Xg
Xg
Xgg
Xgg
Xgg
Xgg
Xgt
Xgn
Xgc
Xga
t
Xgr
Xgr
Xr
Xm
c
Xm
i
Xm
i
Xm
i
Xh
Xf
Xbc
Xm
v
Xm
v
Xm
v
Xm
v
Xba
Xb
Xpu
Xm
Xm
Xam
Xm
u Xch
Xsv
Xbq
Wv
Wv
Wt
Wm
g
Wga
Wgn
Wgn
Agn
Agn
Agn
Agn
Agn
Wd
Wif
Xm
d
XA
f
Xtg
Wgw
Wp
Xt
Xe
Xi
Ws X
cX
mn
Xpi
XgpXgp
Xft
Xgg
r
Xgb
Xgb
Xgb
Xgt
Xgt
Xgg
n
Xdv
g
Xdv
g
Xrg
Xgr
Xrh
d
Wps
Wps
Wps
Figure 1: Geologic map of the upper midwest including parts of Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Michigan (modified from Cannon et al., 1997).
122
Craddock et al.,2006. 19th Annual Keck Symposium; http://keck.wooster.edu/publications
Ajib
ikan
dS
iam
oF
orm
atio
ns
alka
li-fs
gran
ite
Anc
ellG
roup
Ath
elst
ane
Qua
rtz
Mon
zoni
te
Bad
wat
erG
reen
ston
e
Bar
ron
Qua
rtzi
te
basa
ltic
brec
cia
Bea
ver
Bay
Com
plex
bim
odal
volc
anic
s
biot
itesc
hist
biot
itesc
hist
Biw
abik
,Gun
flint
,Pok
egam
a
Bla
irC
reek
For
mat
ion
Cam
bria
nun
divi
ded
Che
ngw
atan
aV
olca
nics
Che
quam
egon
San
dsto
ne
Che
roke
eG
rani
te
Cho
cola
yG
roup
Cop
per
Har
bor
Con
glom
erat
e
Cop
psF
orm
atio
n
Cre
tace
ous
sedi
men
tary
rock
s
daci
tean
dgr
ayw
acke
Dev
ilsIs
land
San
dsto
ne
Dic
kins
onG
roup
Dul
uth
Com
plex
Em
pero
rV
olca
nic
Com
plex
fels
icvo
lcan
ic
fels
icvo
lcan
ics
folia
ted
tona
lite
Fon
ddu
Lac
For
mat
ion
Fre
daS
ands
tone
Fre
dasa
ndst
one-
cglm
embe
r
gabb
ro
gabb
ro
gnei
ss
gnei
ss
gnei
ssan
dam
phib
olite
gnei
ssan
dgr
anite
gnei
ss-a
mph
ibol
ite
gnei
ssic
gran
ite
gran
ite
gran
ite
gran
itean
dto
nalit
e
gran
ite-r
ich
mig
mat
ite
gran
itic
gnei
ss
gran
itic
rock
s
gran
itic
rock
sun
divi
ded
gran
odio
rite-
tona
lite
gran
ophy
re
gray
wac
ke
Hem
lock
For
mat
ion
Hig
hF
alls
Gra
nite
Hin
kley
San
dsto
ne
iron-
form
atio
n
iron-
form
atio
n
Iron
woo
dIr
on-F
orm
atio
n
Jaco
bsvi
lleS
ands
tone
Che
ngw
atan
aV
olca
nics
Cop
per
Har
bor-
volc
anic
mem
ber
Hag
erR
hyol
ite
Kal
land
erC
reek
Vol
cani
cs
Kal
land
erC
reek
-rhy
olite
late
tect
onic
intr
usio
ns
late
tect
onic
intr
usio
ns
Littl
eF
alls
For
mat
ion
Loga
nIn
trus
ions
Low
erO
rdov
icia
nse
dim
enta
ryro
cks
maf
icm
etav
olca
nic
maf
icm
etav
olca
nic
rock
s
mag
netic
unit
Maq
uoke
taF
orm
atio
n
Men
omin
eean
dC
hoco
lay
Gro
ups
Men
omin
eeG
roup
(Pal
ms)
met
abas
alt
met
adia
base
met
agab
bro
met
agab
bro
met
ased
imen
tary
and
met
avol
cani
c
met
ased
imen
tary
rock
s
Mic
higa
mm
eF
orm
atio
n
Mic
higa
mm
e-vo
lcan
icm
embe
r
Mid
dle
Ord
ovic
ian
sedi
men
tary
rock
s
Mill
ador
eV
olca
nics
mix
edm
etav
olca
nic
rock
s
myl
onite
Neg
aune
eIr
on-F
orm
atio
n
Non
esuc
hF
orm
atio
n
Nor
thR
ange
Gro
up
Nor
thS
hore
Vol
cani
cG
roup
oliv
ine
gabb
roO
rient
asa
ndst
one
Pai
ntR
iver
Gro
up
para
gnei
ss
Pea
vyP
ond
Com
plex
porp
hyrit
icgr
anite
Por
tage
Lake
Vol
cani
cs
post
tect
onic
intr
usio
ns
post
-tec
toni
cgr
aniti
cro
cks
post
-tec
toni
cm
afic
intr
usio
ns
Pra
irie
duC
hien
Gro
up
Pur
itan
Qua
rtz
Mon
zoni
te
quar
tzdi
orite
quar
tzite
rhyo
lite
rhyo
lite
rhyo
lite
and
daci
te
Riv
erto
nIr
on-F
orm
atio
n
rock
sof
mag
netic
quie
tzon
e
Rov
e,V
irgin
ia,T
hom
son
Sag
anag
aTo
nalit
e
schi
st-r
ich
mig
mat
ite
Por
cupi
neV
olca
nics
Por
cupi
neV
olca
nics
-rhy
olite
Por
tage
Lake
Vol
-rhy
olite
Por
tage
Lake
Vol
cani
cs
Sie
men
sC
reek
Vol
cani
cs
Silu
rian
undi
vide
d
Sin
nipp
eeG
roup
Sio
uxQ
uart
zite
Spi
keho
rnC
reek
Gra
nite
synt
ecto
nic
gran
itic
rock
s
synt
ecto
nic
intr
usio
ns
Cam
bria
nun
divi
ded
Mun
isin
gF
m
Tro
utLa
ke,D
enha
m
tuff
brec
cia
Tyle
rF
orm
atio
n
Upp
er&
Mid
dle
Ord
ovic
ian
sed.
rock
s
volc
anic
rock
sun
divi
ded
volc
anic
-sed
imen
tary
unit
volc
anic
sun
divi
ded
Win
nipe
gan
dR
edR
iver
Fm
s.
WP
-apl
ite
WP
-Big
Eau
Ple
ine
gran
ite
WP
-Nin
eM
ileS
wam
pgr
anite
WP
-qua
rtz
syen
ite
WP
-Ste
ttin
plut
on
WR
B-a
nort
hosi
te
WR
B-B
elog
nia
Gra
nite
WR
B-P
esht
igo
Man
gerit
e
WR
B-R
edR
iver
Gra
nite
WR
B-W
aupa
caG
rani
te
WR
B-W
olfR
iver
Gra
nite
Sed
imen
tary
and
Med
ised
imen
tary
Ro
cks
Min
neso
taW
isco
nisi
nan
dU
.P.M
ichi
gan
Min
neso
taW
isco
nisi
n&
U.P
.Mic
higa
nM
inne
sota
Wis
coni
sin
and
U.P
.Mic
higa
n
Vo
lcan
ican
dM
etav
olc
anic
Ro
cks
Plu
ton
ican
dM
etap
luto
nic
Ro
cks
Phanerozoic Mesoproterozoic Paleoproterozoic Archean
met
ased
imen
tary
rock
s
Hag
erQ
uart
zP
orph
yry
Cu
Cm
Cu
Yor YnYj
Yfl
Yhi
Yf
Yfc
Ydi Yc
Ych
Olu
Op
Om
u
Oum
Oa
Om
Osi
Ow
r
Su
K
XvsXt
Xm
q
Xq
Xsq
Xv
Xgd
Xgr
s
Xqd
Xop
Xgp
Xpp
Xm
d
Xm
g
Xgg
n
Xga Xg
Xgg Xgt
Xgn
Xgg
r
Xgb Xft
Xgc
Xga
t
Xgr
Xgr
XgrXg
XrgXr
Xrh
d
Xm
v
Xm
c
Xm
b
Xm
i
Xh Xf
Xtg Xe
Xdv
g
Xbc
Xm
v
Xba Xb
Xag
Xpu
Xm
iv
Xi
Xpi
Xnr
Xm
nX
mv
XA
f
Xm
sa
Xm
Xam
Xm
mc
Xm
u
Xlf
XchXc
Xsv
Xai
Xbq
Xm
sa
Wsm
Wv
Wt
Wm
gW
mi
Wgd
Wp
Wst
Wgr
Wgm
Wga
Wgn
Agn
Agn
Wqz
Wm
m
Wm
vW
dW
psW
gw
Wm
s
Wif
Ws
Ypl
vY
s
Ypl
r
Ypl
v
Ypr
Ypv
Ynv
Ycv
Yk
Ykr Yh
Ycv
Ycv
Ydt
Ybb Yl
Ygp Ygr
Ygb Yo
Yhp
Yw
a
Yw
b
Yw
m
Yw
r
Yw
wg
Yw
g
Yhf
Yw
ap
Yw
e
Yw
n
Yw
s
Yss
123
Craddock et al.,2006. 19th Annual Keck Symposium; http://keck.wooster.edu/publications
flows suggest the rhyolite eruptive direction was from the rift axis to the northwest.
Keweenaw Rift Granites (Natalie Juda, Matt Andring)
The central portion of the rift, exposed along the shore of Lake Superior in northeast Minnesota, is defined by the chaotic Beaver Bay igneous complex (Fig. 1). Diabase is the dominant igneous rock that surrounds a host of granitic and anorthositic xenoliths intruded by various mafic dike swarms. We chose two end-member field relations, 1) a granitic xenolith (1 square km), cross-cut by a mafic dike surrounded by diabase (Natalie Juda) and 2) diabase surrounding and surrounded by a swarm of “circular” granitic dikes (Matt Andring).
Juda showed that the granite xenolith is the by-product of rift magmatism, with a U-Pb zircon age of 1094 ± 11 Ma, and not a floated piece of Archean crust. The major and trace element geochemistry is similar to other rift granites and granophyres, and the lack of an AMS fabric in the host diabase, granite or basaltic dike is representative of the chaos of the intrusion of the Beaver Bay complex for a within-plate, low-potassium granite. Andring determined that the radial granite dikes and adjacent diabase are also geochemically similar to other rift granites and granophyres and the regional diabase composition. The AMS results for the granite dikes and diabase were also inconclusive, preserving random magmatic flow during intrusion and crystallization.
Minnesota Wisconsin-Michigan
Regional Unconformity
Regional Unconformity
Regional Unconformity
Regional Unconformity
Archean Basement (Gneisses 3.6-3.0 Ga; Granite-Greenstone Terranes 2.7 Ga)
Denham Clastics & Volcanics(SV)
Rove Formation (LK) Thomson Formation (LK) Tyler Formation (BL)
Pokegama Quartzite Palms Formation (BL)>2700 Ma
~2000 Ma
~1800 Ma
1110 Ma
~520 Ma
??
Munising Sandstone
Jacobsville Sandstone
Bessemer SandstonePuckwunge Sandstone (EW) Nopeming Sandstone (EW)
Freda SandstoneNonesuch ShaleCopper Harbor Conglomerate
St. Peter SandstoneJordan SandstoneFranconia Sandstone
Hinckley SandstoneFondulac Sandstone (LF-B)
Bayfield Group Sandstones
Interflow sediments
Paleozoic Sandstones
Post-Rift Sandstones
Keweenaw Rift Province
Pre-Penokean OrogenAnimikie & Marquette Supergroups
Rift Rhyolites (RP, DP) & Basalts
Rift Basalts (granite xenolith;NJ & MA)
Regional Unconformity
[E. Central][Northeast]
1094 Ma
1085 Ma
Regional Unconformity
Figure 2: Generalized regional stratigraphic correlation diagram for the mid-continent region in Minnesota and Wisconsin. Student participants are identified by their initials next to their sample interval. Yellow stars indicate a detrital zircon sample completed by a student whereas white stars indicate a clastic unit that was processed for zircons but not reported here.
124
Craddock et al.,2006. 19th Annual Keck Symposium; http://keck.wooster.edu/publications
Detrital Zircon Ages and Provenance (Lee Finley-Blasi, Erin Walker, Laura Kerber, Becky Lundquist, Sarah Vorhies)
The southern Canadian Shield is characterized by a series of NE-trending terranes with radiometric ages of ~2.7 Ga and a few protocontinental terranes with older (3.0-3.6 Ga) gneisses (Southwick and Chandler, 1996; Bickford et al., 2006). Deposited on, and accreted to, the Archean craton are the foreland sediments and thrust sheets of the 1.8 Ga Penokean orogen, followed by the Yavapai (1.75 Ga), Mazatzal (1.65 Ga), and Grenville-Keweenaw (1.4-0.9 Ga) orogens (Karlstrom et al., 1999; Holm et al., 2005). We chose to address the age and provenance of clastic sedimentary units in the adjacent and overlapping Penokean-Animikie and younger Keweenaw sequence where the regional stratigraphy is well-constrained but little is known of the absolute depositional ages or provenance (Fig. 2; Ojakangas et al., 2001).
Lee Finley-Blasi studied the post-Keweenaw Fond du Lac and overlying Hinckley Sandstones. The older Fond du Lac Formation (youngest grain: 1010 Ma) contains a significant population of pre-rift zircons, presumably transported from the Grenville orogen to the east, whereas the younger Hinckley sands (youngest grain: 1052 Ma) contain many older, and locally-derived zircons. At the base of the Keweenaw rift lies the Nopeming (Duluth), Puckwunge (N. Minnesota) and Bessemer (east side of the rift) Sandstones.
Erin Walker analyzed the zircon populations of the Nopeming and Puckwunge Formations, finding the former to contain a concentration of pre-rift (1.2 Ga) zircons, Penokean-aged zircons (~1.8 Ga) and a group from 2.2-2.6 Ga. The Puckwunge contains many older, Archean populations, but surprisingly no zircons younger than Penokean.
Underlying the rift is the Pre-Penokean Animike basin sequence with the correlative Rove (northern MN), Thomson (Duluth) and Tyler (east, MI) Formations composed of interbedded sand and shale (turbidites). Laura Kerber studied the Thomson and Rove Formations, both of which contain predominant zircon populations of ~1850-2000 Ma and a variety of ages back to 3.5 Ga. The maximum depositional age of the Thomson is 1841 Ma, and 1826 Ma for the Rove.
The Tyler Formation, east of the Keweenaw rift, was studied by Becky Lundquist, has a maximum depositional age of ~1818 Ma, and its zircon population is dominated by Penokean ages and rocks from the underlying 2.7 Ga granite-greenstone belts. Lundquist also analyzed the Palms Formation at the base of the Marquette Supergroup, which contains zircons dating 2.7 Ga, a few at 3.4 Ga and the youngest zircon is 2594 Ma.
In east-central Minnesota, overlying the Archean McGrath gneiss is the locally-exposed and enigmatic Denham Formation (Boerboom and Jirsa, 2001), which was deformed and metamorphosed to amphibolite facies during the Penokean orogeny (Holm and Selverstone, 1990). Sarah Vorhies analyzed the basal, metamorphosed arkosic sandstone and an upper arkose, finding zircon populations between 2.1-3.4 Ga and 2.7-3.4 Ga, respectively. Pillow basalts from the middle Denham Formation yield an alkaline, rift-related geochemical signature.
REFERENCESBickford, M.E., Wooden, J.L., and Bauer, R.L., 2006,
SHRIMP study of zircons from Early Archean rocks in the Minnesota River Valley: Implications for the tectonic history of the Superior Province: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 118, no. 1/2, p. 94-108.
Boerboom , T. J. and Jirsa, Mark A, 2001, Stratigraphy
125
Murphy, J. 2006. 19th Annual Keck Symposium; http://keck.wooster.edu/publications
of the Paleoproterozoic Denham Formation; a continental margin assemblage of basalt, arkose, and dolomite:47th annual meeting, Institute on Lake Superior Geology, p. 6-7.
Cannon, W.F., Kress, T.H., Sutphin, D.M., Morey, G.B., Meints, J., and Barber-Delach, R., 1999, Deposits of the Lake Superior region: U.S. Geological Survey Open-File Report 97-0455.
Davis, D. W., and Green, J. C., 1997, Geochronology of the North American Midcontinent Rift in western Lake Superior and implications for its geodynamic evolution: Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences, v. 34, no. 4, p. 476-488.
Holm, D., and Selverstone, J., 1990, Rapid growth and strain rates inferred from synkinematic garnets, Penokean orogen, Minnesota: Geology, v. 18, p. 166–169, doi:10.1130/0091-7613(1990)0182.3.CO;2.
Holm, D. K., Van Schmus, W. R., MacNeill, L. C., Boerboom, T. J., Schweitzer, D., and Schneider, D., 2005, U-Pb zircon geochronology of Paleoproterozoic plutons from the northern midcontinent, USA: Evidence for subduction flip and continued convergence after geon 18 Penokean orogenesis: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 117, no. 3/4, p. 259-275.
Karlstrom, K.E., Harlan, S.S., Williams, M.L., McLellend, J., Geissman, J.W., and Ahall, K.I., 1999, Refining Rodinia: Geologic evidence for the Australia -Western U.S. connection for the Proterozoic: GSA Today, v. 9, no. 10, p. 1-7.
Southwick, D.L. and Chandler, V.M.,1996, Block and shear-zone architecture of the Minnesota River Valley sub-province: implications for late Archean accretionary tectonics: Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 26, 2145-2158.