12/2/2016 Pierpont's lament: The rabble (those pesky investors) are taking over | afr.com
http://www.afr.com/business/mining/pierponts-lament-the-rabble-those-pesky-investors-are-taking-over-20161130-gt1bnt 1/6
Home / Business / Mining
Dec 1 2016 at 2:30 PM Updated Dec 1 2016 at 2:35 PM
Pierpont's lament: The rabble (those pesky investors) are takingover
Save Article Print License Article
Pesky shareholders are making life difficult for a few troubled miners. Robert Rough
Today's column is being written as a warning to directors that the
rabble are winning.
As an ancient director of Blue Sky Mines, Pierpont enjoys a life of
high fees, long lunches and little responsibility, all paid for by that
rabble known as shareholders who – just because they put money
into the company – are under the delusion they have some rights
over what it does.
So your correspondent views with alarm the trend in recent annual meetings. Take
the situation in Kasbah Resources as an example.
As Pierpont mentioned in September, Kasbah owns the Achmmach (pronounced
"Arshmarsh") tin deposit in Morocco. Kasbah was a market darling in 2010, raising
$30 million when the tin price was $30,000 a tonne.
To cut a long story short, the tin price fell, production was delayed and Kasbah's share
price has been crushed. Kasbah has established a reserve of 6.5 million tonnes
averaging 0.85 per cent tin at Achmmach, but although the company has spent $64
million on the project it still needs another $US65 million to bring it into production.
by Trevor Sykes
Advertisem
ent
search the AFR
STREET TALKNEWS BUSINESS MARKETS REAL ESTATE OPINION TECHNOLOGY PERSONAL FINANCE LEADERSHIP LIFESTYLE ALL
Today's Paper Videos Infographics Markets Data BRW Lists Login Subscribe
12/2/2016 Pierpont's lament: The rabble (those pesky investors) are taking over | afr.com
http://www.afr.com/business/mining/pierponts-lament-the-rabble-those-pesky-investors-are-taking-over-20161130-gt1bnt 2/6
1076 Hay Street WEST PERTH WA Offices 235m²
6 Chifley Drive MENTONE VIC Industrial / Warehouse 8,002m²
Glencore to resume paying dividends
Glencore to reinstate dividends in 2107
Rio confirms US probe over
Mozambique project
Coal powers Rio's iron ore premium
Paladin shares slump on mine sale
delay
Related articles
26 mins ago
Man grabs $2m pot of
gold off armoured
truck
29 mins ago
Putin bridges gap
between rivals
31 mins ago
France's Hollande
won't seek 2nd term
Latest Stories
More
This year the Toronto-listed Asian Mineral Resources (AMR) appeared as a white
knight, proposing a reverse takeover in which Kasbah shareholders would get 52 per
cent of the merged entity.
But AMR was in little better financial condition than Kasbah. AMR's main asset has
been the Ban Phuc nickel mine in Vietnam, but that is now on care and maintenance
thanks to low nickel prices and Pierpont is not sure whether it should be classified as
an asset or a liability.
Mineral firm struggling
AMR made a $C3 million loss in FY16 and had only $C1 million left in the bank by
June. (The Canadian dollar is close to parity with the Australian dollar.)
AMR is effectively controlled by its 72 per cent shareholder Pala Investments, which is
wholly owned by a German-born Russian billionaire named Vladimir Iorich.
The Kasbah-AMR merger was approved by shareholders at a Kasbah meeting in Perth
on November 23. The meeting was enlivened by proxy and shareholder asking
questions.
They inquired whether any of the board had met Vladimir. The answer was "no
comment": not too surprising because Vlad is notoriously reclusive.
Then they asked why Kasbah's independent expert, BDO, had used the spot tin price
of $US17,830 on March 18 when valuing the company. As the price has since risen to
more than $US21,000 that meant Kasbah was undervalued in the merger document.
The directors said the shareholders should ask BDO.
The shareholders asked if anyone from BDO was present at the meeting and were told
no. That was rather amusing, because the meeting was being held in BDO's office.
Kasbah's chairman and managing director were equally uninformative at the AGM on
November 30.
Hurdles to jump
The directors still have a few hurdles to jump, because the merger still has to be
approved by Judge Neil McKerracher of the Federal Court of Western Australia at a
court hearing on December 6. In a preliminary hearing, the judge was quite interested
in the basis of the BDO valuation of Kasbah at 3.3¢ to 3.9¢ a share.
Under the merger, the shareholders of Kasbah will receive no cash because AMR
doesn't have any to spare. Instead, Kasbah shareholders are now being offered AMR
shares and warrants.
If everything is approved, the present shareholders of Kasbah will emerge with about
half of AMR. To Pierpont's rheumy eyes, this does not appear any great win. AMR has
little cash, its only mine is closed and it owes Pala $1 million.
The tin market appears to be improving and there are few tin projects coming on
stream around the world, so Achmmach could have a bright prospect. But AMR is in
no better position to fund Achmmach's development than Kasbah.
Pala is the key to Achmmach's future. Pierpont's research on Pala has been slight, but
it is said to hold 43 per cent of Nevada Copper and used to control the Australian gold
miner Alacer.
$295sqm pa
For Lease
Please contact agent
For Lease
12/2/2016 Pierpont's lament: The rabble (those pesky investors) are taking over | afr.com
http://www.afr.com/business/mining/pierponts-lament-the-rabble-those-pesky-investors-are-taking-over-20161130-gt1bnt 3/6
So the Kasbah board has pushed the merger on the grounds that Pala could provide
the finance for Achmmach.
Shareholders at risk
If Pierpont were a Kasbah shareholder, he would be happier if Pala had explicitly
guaranteed the funding. If it has not then there's another possible scenario.
If AMR is unable to repay its debt to Pala (and right now that looks doubtful), one
possibility is that Pala could exercise its rights as the major creditor and put AMR into
liquidation. If that occurred, the shareholders of AMR (including the present
shareholders of Kasbah) could be wiped out.
Speculative, of course, but if Kasbah does have an ironclad guarantee from Pala it
might be worth mentioning it to the judge on December 6.
The second annual meeting Pierpont wanted to cite was that of Jervois Minerals on
November 24. At this one, the rabble entirely routed the board, raising the chilling
spectre that in future the directors will have to buy their own lunches.
Readers with long memories may recall that Pierpont mentioned Jervois in his
November scribblings. For the benefit of those who didn't stay awake, your
correspondent will recapitulate a little of the history.
Pierpont is a great admirer of Jervois, which has survived for several decades on the
boards as a junior explorer. Being chronically lazy, Pierpont has not dug through its
records for all those years, but it must have reported very few profits and he doubts it
has ever paid a dividend.
Over the past 10 years it has raised $26 million by flogging shares to optimistic
punters, but it still doesn't hold any mineral prospect close to production and by the
end of September had only $219,000 left in the till.
Push for new team
Jervois was in the hands of the executive chairman Duncan Pursell and two other
directors, but the rabble were getting restive. The disgruntled shareholders were led
by Richard Karn, who wanted to toss out the board and put a new team in charge.
Over the years, Jervois has had several main assets. One was the Bullabulling gold
prospect near Coolgardie. That was sold in 2010 to Auzex Resources, which was taken
over by Norton Gold Mines in 2014.
Jervois stands to collect $30 per ounce from any production up to 400,000 ounces and
$20 an ounce beyond that. Bullabulling is a potential bonanza, because the Chinese-
owned Norton has found an indicated and inferred resource totalling 95 million
tonnes averaging just over 1 gram per tonne, and is planning to get it into production.
Bullabulling would best be operated on large scale, indicating the royalty could be
quite valuable in future. Duncan reckons Jervois could receive $80 million.
With Bullabulling gone, Jervois' main asset was the Flemington scandium deposit
near Fifield. For the benefit or readers who've never heard of the stuff, scandium is
present in most uranium and rare earth compounds.
12/2/2016 Pierpont's lament: The rabble (those pesky investors) are taking over | afr.com
http://www.afr.com/business/mining/pierponts-lament-the-rabble-those-pesky-investors-are-taking-over-20161130-gt1bnt 4/6
Scandium is only produced from three mines (in the Ukraine, China and Russia) at
about 10 tonnes a year. It is mainly used in the car industry to strengthen aluminium
alloys with as little as 0.5 per cent scandium.
Scandium demand is growing. Bloom Energy in the US reckons it is going to need
30tpa, for instance. Jervois reckons Flemington contains 2085 tonnes of scandium at
grades around 430 parts per million.
Jervois discovered the Flemington deposit in 2013 and Richard, as chief executive
office of Scandium Developments International (SDI), was getting impatient at the
slow pace of its development.
Relations turn hostile
It would be wearying to retrace the history of the dispute between Richard and
Duncan, which Pierpont gave in some detail last month. Suffice to say that relations
between the two soured and eventually became downright hostile.
Richard wrote to shareholders seeking support to sack the board. Duncan threatened
him with defamation.
Richard gained the support of 30 per cent, giving him the chance to win a second
strike against the remuneration report, which would have forced the Jervois board
into a re-election.
Richard called an extraordinary meeting for November 24 to sack the board. Then on
October 10, Jervois announced it had optioned the Flemington project to Australian
Mines for a total of $6 million to be paid over time.
Australian Mines was quite happy to take Flemington, but its priority is development
of the Sconi scandium resource (near the Plutonic gold mine in WA) at a cost of $212
million.
Meanwhile Jervois fought desperately to stop Richard. Jervois issued 8 million shares
on November 4 and another 4 million on November 22 to muster support for the
board.
Richard had issued proxy forms for the EGM, but Jervois issued different ones and
circulated a letter to shareholders saying the bad proxy forms wouldn't count at the
meeting but the good ones would. Jervois also moved its registered office in
Melbourne on November 14.
Fate resolved in court
The fate of Jervois was really decided in the Supreme Court of NSW on November 23
by Justice Geoff Lindsay. Richard's Scandium Development International was the
plaintiff and Jervois and its directors were the defendants.
The defendants had claimed the resolutions to be put to the EGM to sack the board
were invalid because less than two months' notice had been given, as required under
the Corporations Act, and so no meeting should be held.
The judge found that the lateness of giving notice was caused largely, if not entirely,
by the actions of the defendants. He thought it just and equitable that the EGM should
proceed even though there had been a technical defect.
12/2/2016 Pierpont's lament: The rabble (those pesky investors) are taking over | afr.com
http://www.afr.com/business/mining/pierponts-lament-the-rabble-those-pesky-investors-are-taking-over-20161130-gt1bnt 5/6
Recommended by
Recommended From Around the Web
He ordered that the meeting should be chaired independently by Dr Bob Austin, a
leading corporations law scholar and a former judge of the NSW Supreme Court.
Finally, Justice Lindsay ordered that the costs of the hearing should be borne by the
three directors and not by Jervois.
Those decisions were lethal to the board's chances.
Interesting times for board
The meeting was held the following day. It was a fairly quiet affair, the old board were
removed and three new directors appointed by roughly 45 million votes to 37 million.
The new board also includes Pierpont's old drinking chum John Byrne and mining
veteran Norm Seckold, so Jervois looks headed for interesting times.
The new board have inherited a few problems, though. Jervois' issued capital is 113
million shares, of which 37 million are hostile. Their best potential asset is the
Bullabulling royalty, which is currently yielding zero.
The Chinese from Norton have quietly picked up 4.9 per cent of Jervois and their
intentions are unknown.
There is some hope Jervois could regain Flemington, because Australian Mines has
only paid $600,000 so far and will be challenged to find the rest of the $6 million.
But right now, all the rabble has taken over is rubble.
Pip! Pip!
Pierpont
(www.pierpont.com.au)
Netflix unveils downloadfeature for offline binge-watching
US economy heats up pre-Donald Trump takeover
Brace for cyber breaches:CyberGym's Ofir Hasontells Aussie…
S&P lumps Aussie bankswith Russia and Brazil
Freedom Insurance makesstrong debut
New Metabolism BoosterTaking Australia by StormCuttingEdgeBiotech
80+ life expectancy meansthere's no off switch inretirementPerpetual
The number one mortgagemistakeCompare Home Loans
1 In 2 Australians UnawareOf Health InsuranceRebateiSelect
Where Would You Invest?Shane Oliver’s Top Tips forSMSFsAMP Capital
12/2/2016 Pierpont's lament: The rabble (those pesky investors) are taking over | afr.com
http://www.afr.com/business/mining/pierponts-lament-the-rabble-those-pesky-investors-are-taking-over-20161130-gt1bnt 6/6
Special Reports
Summer dining: the newbotanicals
Lawyer starts second luxuryhandbag line
Watchmaker Blancpain fundsreal shark tank
How to knock out knock-offs
Luxury gifts with the Midastouch
The Boss-Deloitte LGBTIleaders list 2016
LGBTI executives lead byexample
Where the business crowdmeets in Paris
Why women shouldn't be called'guys'
Stockland's Mark Steinert isupbeat on cities
The best luxury Christmas giftsfor men
5 of the best Australianproperties for sale
Premium spirits for Christmas
Your seafood can be traceable,for a price
Leading men look back at giftsthat meant the most
OPEC seeks to lift oil to $US60mark
Middle class rising andtechnologically literate
Visitor numbers surging
Sometimes no cash allowed inthe new payments world
Economy once again showingits strength
LOGIN
TOOLS
Markets Data
Australian Equities
World Equities
Commodities
Currencies
Derivatives
Interest Rates
Share Tables
FAIRFAX BUSINESS MEDIA
The Australian Financial Review Magazine
BOSS
BRW Lists
Chanticleer
Luxury
Rear Window
The Sophisticated Traveller
CONTACT & FEEDBACK
FAQ
Contact us
Letters to the Editor
Give feedback
Advertise
License Content
ABOUT
About us
Our Events
Digital Subscription Terms
Newspaper Subscription Terms
Site Map
Corporate Subscriptions
CONNECT WITH US
YOUR OPINION IS IMPORTANT TO US
CHOOSE YOUR READING EXPERIENCE
© Copyright 2016 Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd | Privacy | Terms & Conditions of Use
SUBSCRIBE
GIVE FEEDBACK