CAN COASTAL EUROPE INSURE AGAINST CLIMATE CHANGE:
A REVIEW OF EXPERIENCES ON FLOODS AND SHORELINE EROSION
Phoebe Koundouri, Bénédicte Rulleau and Mavra Stithou
Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 2011
Characteristics of Natural Disaster Risks CC expected to increase the frequency and severity of flooding
in certain regions (IPCC, 2007) Damages from natural disasters in Europe rapidly increased over the
past decades, mainly because of the growth of capital accumulated in flood-prone areas
Socio-economic change and climate change “Risk”
2 Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 2011
Severity of Consequences and Economy
Financial &/or technological countermeasures
Disaster loss
Development level
Middle income level economies
Simple economic structures
Complexity of socio-economic structure and interdependency within and across countries increases
Source: Benson and Clay 1998; Lester, 2008; Kellenberg and Mobarak, 2008
3 Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 2011
The Risk & Perceived Risk-Triangles (Crichton and Mounsey, 1997; Priest, 2003)
Flood frequency and magnitude
Extent of flood impact
Cost of damage or loss
It is the varying perceptions of risk rather than reality of risk that must be managed. For these perceptions to be managed, local knowledge must be acknowledged
4 Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 2011
Response of Individuals to Natural Disasters Move out from areas that are at high risk and reallocate in a
safer area Self-protect by building structures less vulnerable to damage Insure by paying a premium in an insurance company
Factors for under-insurance: “this will not happen to me” belief May ignore, knowingly or not, low probability but high consequences
events May be priced out of the insurance market
Highly linked with a recent flood experience
5 Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 2011
Response of Firms to Natural Disasters Same here but impacts also relate to human resources,
physical resources, business continuity and disaster recovery plan Vulnerability of small firms
6 Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 2011
Response of Governments to Natural Disasters Ex ante public program e.g. well-enforced regulations,
mandatory private disaster insurance, building codes in disaster prone areas, incentives through grants and taxes…
Ex post public program e.g. rehabilitation and recovery, reconstruction
Reinsurance, public-private or national-international partnerships, catastrophe bonds
When not possible to find international reinsurance, self-insurance through budgetary allocation
Interrelationship between individual behaviour and structure of government policies
7 Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 2011
Roles of Insurance Assist recovery by
Minimizing death, loss and damage Focusing attention on risk Placing the burden of that risk on the hazard zone dwellers
Reduce vulnerability and sensibility by affecting “perceived risk”
Promote resilience
8 Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 2011
Roles of Insurance But can also help customers affected by weather events such
as floods by: Managing repair process Bringing in supplies and quality assured repairers Providing for temporary accommodation while repairs are undertaken If part of the cover, providing alternative premises for small business to
run out of while repairs are i,n progress
10 Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 2011
Roles of Insurance And can help the society to adapt and become more resilient
(Crichton, 2008): Assistance with identifying areas at risk Catastrophe modelling Economic incentives to discourage construction in flood plain Collection of data on the costs of flood damage to feed into benefit cost
appraisals for flood management schemes Promotion of resilient reinstatement techniques Promotion of temporary defence solutions
11 Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 2011
Types of Flood Insurance
Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 201112
Different countries different home insurance markets where insurance can come bundled with all cover (including flooding), or unbundled (where each component is sold separately) whilst the market may be entirely private, or a state monopoly (Dawson et al. 2011)
Characteristics of Insurance Companies Linked to Natural Disasters Firms may go bankrupt or suffer significant reduction in their
earnings An select to exit a specific area
Increase in the rates charged by insurers Adaptation of the observable patters of natural disasters in
their operational decisions
Challenge in the light of CC = how to deal with a situation where key-epistemological dimension of CC lies in its “never happened before” dimension
13 Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 2011
Case Study Experiences
Bordeaux (France), Varna (Bulgaria), Santander (Spain) and Plymouth (UK)
Objective = to derive initial behavioural patterns and investigate the degree of awareness and knowledge on strategies of hedging natural hazards from questionnaire surveys addressed to insurance companies
14 Biarritz symposium – 18-21 October 2011