Mini Paper: Orbital Symmetry Rules for Unimolecular Reactions
Ralph G. Pearson, JACS, 94:24. 1972
__________________________________________________________________________________
To predict the course of a reaction Perturbation theory has been applied rigorously, here the author
has come up with simple symmetry rules, which accounted for several unimolecular reactions shown
here.
To start, The Transition density: changed electron density for the mixing of ground and excited state
wave function in the course of reaction, ρ, is proportional to Фi x Фf where Фi is initial and Фf is final
MO occupied. So reaction path will be chosen by the reactant(s) in where the symmetry of the
reaction coordinate will be same as the Фi x Фf. After reaction begins Q must be totally symmetric.
For Unimolecular reactions this has been discussed as follows:
H2 → 2H
The valence shell orbitals are of σ g (b.) and σu (a. b.) symmetry. The reaction coordinate is totally
symmetric, or Σg+. Dissociation must involve movement of electrons from the σ g to σ u orbitals. The
symmetry rule then requires that the excited state which mixes into the ground state is the doubly
excited configuration, (σ u)2.
CH4 → CH3 + H
Requires a Tz vibration to break the Td point group. This can occur most easily by a (t2) → (a1*)
excitation. After a short extension of the carbon-hydrogen bond, the point group becomes C3v , the
reaction coordinate becomes A1, and the remaining process is that for a heteronuclear diatomic
molecule.
SF4 → SF2 + F2 -allowed
SO2F2 → SO2 + F2 -forbidden
The S-F bonds to be broken in both cases are of a1 and b2, symmetry in the C2v point group. The F-F
bond to be made is of a1 symmetry. In the case of SF4, the remaining new bonds are actually
antibonding, since a π* orbital of b2 symmetry is filled.
In the case of SO2, which has two fewer electrons that SF2, the new orbital that is filled is either an
antibonding σ * orbital of al symmetry, or a π nonbonding MO of a2 symmetry. These two orbitals
appear to have rather similar energies. At any rate, normally there are no electrons in the higher
energy π* orbital of b2, symmetry. Since under the influence of an A1 perturbation (the changing
reaction coordinate), electrons cannot move from a b2, orbital (S-F bonding) into either an a1* or a2*
orbital. The symmetries of the bonds and the reaction coordinate do not match up. Hence the
reaction is forbidden.
C6H10 → C4H6 + C2H4
the bonds that are broken (the 3-4 π bond and the 1-2 and 5-6 σ bonds) are of 2A’ + A” symmetry.
The bonds to be made (the 1-6, 4-5, and 2-3 π bonds) are of the same symmetry.
They concluded, the rule that a reaction is allowed, if the symmetries of the bonds that are made
match up with the symmetries of the bonds that are broken.
__________________________________________________________________________________
-Sujoy Saha
BS-MS
20101095