8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
1/37
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
2/37
lk|gj{hdo jok qydfd{hdo hw ollklk/ Fdoh{dyhom d` {el qj{hlo{w hbbolwwlw qydmylwwhdo jok
ylho`dyghom hfqdy{jogl d` `dbbd} |q jyl jbwd hfqdy{jo{ lblflo{w d` gjyl ho {elwl 9 blplbw/
Bll" @yhlkfjo" G|ndy jok Jelyo %9117( gdfflo{lk {ej{ {lblgdff|ohgj{hdow {lgeodbdmx gjo
loejogl z|jbh{x d` eljb{e gjyl wlyphglw/ Ilwhklw" ilhom ljwhbx jgglwwhibl yd|ok {el gbdgn jok h{ hw
jibl {d qydphkl" qj{hlo{&wqlgh`hg ho`dyfj{hdo" wlb`&elbq {ylj{flo{" ylho`dyglflo{ jok w|qqdy{ do
ylz|lw{/ Ho {el qylwlo{ wh{|j{hdo ho Oj{hdojb Eljb{egjyl Myd|q qdbxgbhohgw" {el o|ywlw jyl jbyljkx
qyd&jg{hplbx gjbbhom {el qj{hlo{w {d qydphkl eljb{e ho`dyfj{hdo> wlb`&elbq {ylj{flo{" khwljwl
fdoh{dyhom" jok lplo gbhohg `dbbd} |q ylfhokly gjbbw/ [el fjho khwjkpjo{jml hw {el bjyml o|fily
d` qj{hlo{w {elx jyl gjyhom `dy }ehge {e|w ylz|hylw j gly{jho o|fily d` fjoqd}ly {d qyd&jg{hplbx
gjbbhom {el qj{hlo{w/ Wlgdok" {elyl hw {el khwjkpjo{jml d` od{ ilhom jgglwwhibl 9; ed|yw j kjx/
HPYW dy j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol wlyphglw fhme{ il {el wdb|{hdo `dy il{{ly fjojmlflo{ d` qj{hlo{w
}h{e jqqydqyhj{l |wl" k|l {d {el jpjhbjihbh{x d` {el wlyphglw" jok {el jihbh{x {d {jhbdy {d bjyml
qdq|bj{hdo o|filyw }h{ed|{ {el gly{jho fjoqd}ly ylz|hylflo{/
Ho {ehw qjqly" {el lphklogl d` `dy {el l``lg{hplolww d` {el HPYW dy j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol wlyphglw
do hfqydphom qj{hlo{w flkhgjb gdokh{hdow ho {el d|{qj{hlo{ wl{{hom }hbb il lujfholk/ [el
qj{hlo{w }h{e flkhgjb gdokh{hdow ho {ehw ylphl} jyl fjhobx qj{hlo{w }h{e [xql 9 khjil{lw"
exqly{lowhdo jok exqlybhqhklfhj/ [el diclg{hpl d` {ehw jwwhmoflo{ hw {d lw{jibhwe {el |wl`|bolww
d` jkc|og{ j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol gjyl jw jo jb{lyoj{hpl {d |w|jb `jgl {d `jgl qj{hlo{ gjyl dobx/
L``lg{hplolww ho {ehw ylphl} }hbb il hokhgj{lk ix qexwhdbdmhgjb d|{gdflw d` gjyl" gejoml d`
eljb{e ilejphdyw" qwxgedbdmhgjb d|{gdflw" wj{hw`jg{hdo }h{e gjyl" jok lgdodfhg fljw|ylw/ [el
z|lw{hdow }hbb il3
%:( Hw {elyl j kh``lylogl ho hfqydphom qexwhdbdmhgjb d|{gdfl hokhgj{dyw il{}llo jkc|og{
j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol gjyl jok |w|jb gjyl ho qj{hlo{w }h{e geydohg khwljwlw" fjhobx [xql 9
khjil{lw" exqly{lowhdo jok exqlybhqhklfhj ho d|{qj{hlo{ wl{{hom4
%9( Hw {elyl j kh``lylogl ho wlb`&gjyl ilejphdyw il{}llo jkc|og{ j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol gjyl jok
|w|jb gjyl qj{hlo{w }h{e {el 7 geydohg khwljwlw4
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
3/37
%7( Hw {elyl jo hfqydplflo{ ho {el qwxgedbdmhgjb d|{gdflw ho {el myd|q |okly jkc|og{ j|{dfj{lk
{lblqedol gjyl4
%;( Hw {elyl j ehmely blplb d` wj{hw`jg{hdo }h{e gjyl ho {el myd|q |okly jkc|og{ j|{dfj{lk
{lblqedol gjyl4
%
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
4/37
Eljb{e gbhohgjb m|hklbholw }liwh{lw jok M|hklbholw Gbljyhom Ed|wl }liwh{lw ejpl illo wljygelk
i|{ {d od jpjhb/
Jo hoh{hjb wljyge w{yj{lmx `yjfl}dyn %[jibl :( ejw illo klwhmolk {d `hok jox q|ibhgj{hdow jid|{
j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol wlyphglw jok |wlk h{ {d wljyge {el jidpl kj{jijwlw/ [el wljyge `yjfl}dyn hw
jqqydqyhj{l `dy id{e Q|iFlk jok Gdgeyjol kj{jijwl/ J kh``lylo{ wljyge w{yj{lmx ejw {d il
lfqbdxlk }elo wljygehom Wghlogl Khylg{ kj{jijwl/ J `hojb wljyge w{yj{lmx {jibl }h{e {el o|fily
d` wljyge ylw|b{w hw wed}o ho [jibl 9/ [el `|bb wljyge w|ffjyx {jibl }h{e o|fily d` ylw|b{w `ydf
ljge wljyge jok {el `hojb o|fily d` jy{hgblw di{jholk hw `d|ok ho Jqqlokhu J:/
[el `dbbd}hom hogb|whdo jok lugb|whdo gyh{lyhj jyl |wlk {d bhfh{ {el hoh{hjb wljyge `hokhomw {d
qd{lo{hjb jy{hgblw `dy ylphl}/
Hogb|whdo gyh{lyhj hogb|kl3
%:( {lblflkhghol hopdbphom {lblqedol jw jo ho{lyplo{hdo ho %j( khwljwl fjojmlflo{ ho geydohg
khwljwlw bhnl khjil{lw [xql 9" exqlybhqhklfhj jok exqly{lowhdo %i( {lblqedol eljb{e lk|gj{hdo
mhplo ho {lyfw d` wfdnhom glwwj{hdo jok khl{jyx ejih{w/ [el yljwdo `dy hogb|khom {el hogb|whdo
gyh{lyhj d` wfdnhom glwwj{hdo jok khl{jyx ejih{w hw {ej{ {elwl 9 jyl hfqdy{jo{ lblflo{w ho khwljwl
fjojmlflo{ d` {el 7 geydohg khwljwlw/
%9( [el w|iclg{ qdq|bj{hdow d` ho{lylw{ ho {el w{|khlw jyl `ydf flkhgjb glo{lyw dy d|{qj{hlo{
gbhohgw/
Lugb|whdo gyh{lyhj `dy {el w{|khlw hogb|kl3
%:( qdq|bj{hdow d` ho{lylw{ ho w{|khlw }ehge jyl edwqh{jbhslk qj{hlo{w dy qj{hlo{w ylglo{bx
khwgejymlk `ydf edwqh{jbw
%9( w|ymlyx" yjkhj{hdo" ho`lg{hdo gdo{ydb" jkkhg{hdo" mxolgdbdmx" diw{l{yhg" qlkhj{yhg" jok oldoj{jb
w{|khlw
%7( ky|m jok ibddk losxfl {yhjbw
%;( idkx }lbbolww qydmyjf w{|khlw
%
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
5/37
%0( geydohg eljy{ `jhb|yl qdq|bj{hdow jyl lugb|klk jw {el o|fily d` qj{hlo{ }h{e geydohg eljy{
`jhb|yl ho qdbxgbhohgw |okly o|ywhom gjyl fjojmhom jyl od{ ho bjyml o|filyw gdfqjylk {d {el
d{ely 7 geydohg khwljwlw
/
J {d{jb d` 5; qd{lo{hjb jy{hgblw }lyl `d|ok j`{ly hoh{hjb wl{{hom d` hogb|whdo jok lugb|whdo gyh{lyhj/
Ed}lply" dobx
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
6/37
yglw
J`{ly
wl{{hom
bhfh{w
Qd{lo{hjb
Jy{hgblw
%Wgyllohom
{eyd|me
jiw{yjg{w(
Jy{hgblw
Di{jholk
Flk
': 6 {lblgdff|ohgj{hdow ^FLWEV DY
{lblgdff|ohgj{hdow ^{lu{}dykV DY )j|{dfj{lk
{lblqedol) ^jbb `hlbkwV DY {lblflkhghol ^FLWEV DY
{lblflkhghol {lu{}dykV %9500
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
7/37
Klwgyhq{hdo d` W{|khlw
D|{ d` {el :1 jy{hgblw ylphl}lk" < jy{hgblw jyl wxw{lfj{hg ylphl}w" ; jyl yjokdfhslk gdo{ydbblk
{yhjbw jok {el bjw{ : hw j odo&luqlyhflo{jb z|jo{h{j{hpl }h{e j z|jbh{j{hpl gdfqdolo{ w{|kx/ [el
`|bb w|ffjyx d` jbb {el jy{hgblw gjo il `d|ok ho Jqqlokhu J7/
Jbb d` {el wxw{lfj{hg ylphl}w {ej{ jyl gyh{hz|lk ejpl j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol jw dol d` {el fjho
{lblflkhghol gj{lmdyhlw |okly lujfhoj{hdo/ ; d|{ d` < jy{hgblw bddnlk wqlgh`hgjbbx ho{d gdfqjyhom
{el l``lg{hplolww d` {lblflkhghol lh{ely jw jo jb{lyoj{hpl fdkl d` gjyl dy jw jo lu{lowhdo d` gjyl
plyw|w `jgl {d `jgl qj{hlo{ gjyl jbdol/ Jbb d` {elwl ; jy{hgblw lujfholk gdfqjyhwdo w{|khlw
il{}llo 9 fdkjbh{hlw d` gjyl luglq{ Bhww" Mb|lgnj|` jok Lgnb|ok&Cdoeowdo %9119( ejk j
gdfqdolo{ d` gdfqjyj{hpl w{|khlw gdfqjyhom 7 dy fdyl fdkjbh{hlw d` gjyl/ [el whfhbjy d|{gdfl
hokhgj{dy |wlk ho {elwl ; w{|khlw {d klfdow{yj{l l``lg{hplolww }jw ylqdy{lk hfqydplk d|{gdflw d`
gjyl `ydf hokhphk|jb w{|khlw/ Ed}lply" jbb ; w{|khlw gj{lmdyhslk {elhy `hokhomw kh``lylo{bx"
G|yylbb" \ym|ejy{" ]jho}yhme{ jok Bl}hw %9111( |wlk d|{gdfl fljw|ylw jw gj{lmdyhlw" Elywe l{
jb %911:( |wlk gbhohgjb wqlghjb{x" Ydhol" Dehofjj jok Ejhblx %911:( jok Bhww" Mb|lgnj|` jok
Lgnb|ok&Cdeowdo %9119( id{e |wlk gj{lmdyhlw d` jqqbhgj{hdow/ W{hbb" {el gdogb|whdo `dy jbb {elwl ;
wxw{lfj{hg ylphl}w ejk whfhbjy gdogb|whdow/ %:( Lphklogl d` {el l``lg{hplolww d` {lblflkhghol hw
bhfh{lk/ %9( Bjymly wjfqbl whslw jok `|y{ely ylwljyge jyl olglwwjyx/ %7( Gdw{&l``lg{hplolww ho
{elwl w{|khlw }jw od{ }lbb&jojbxslk/
Ylplyl jok K|oijyw %911:( wxw{lfj{hg ylphl} bddnlk j{ {el l``lg{hplolww d` gdfq|{ly&
mlolyj{lk d|{qj{hlo{ eljb{e ilejphdy ho{lyplo{hdow }ehge hogb|klk qyho{ gdff|ohgj{hdow bhnl
jqqdho{flo{ bl{{lyw" ylfhokly wbhqw" `llkijgn ylqdy{w l{g/ }ehge hw od{ gdowhklylk |okly {el
gj{lmdyx d` {lblflkhghol/ Ed}lply" {ehw wxw{lfj{hg ylphl} hw gyh{hz|lk jok yl{jholk `dy |wl ho
{ehw jwwhmoflo{ k|l {d {el luqbdyj{hdo d` {el l``lg{hplolww ho ylmjykw {d {el eljb{e ilejphdy
fdklb dy `lj{|yl ilehok {el ho{lyplo{hdow/ [el ylphl} ylqdy{lk {ej{ {jhbdylk ho{lyplo{hdow gjo
fdyl qdwh{hplbx j``lg{ eljb{e ilejphdy gejoml {ejo {jyml{lk qlywdojbhslk dy mlolyhg
ho{lyplo{hdow" {ed|me fdyl w{|khlw }lyl jbwd ollklk {d gdfqjyl {el kh``lylo{ qyd{dgdbw }h{e ljge
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
8/37
d{ely/ [ehw ho`dyfj{hdo hw |wl`|b }elo }yh{hom j m|hklbhol {d hoh{hj{l dy hfqblflo{hom {el
j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol wlyphgl/
[el z|jbh{hlw d` {el < wxw{lfj{hg ylphl}w jyl jwwlwwlk |whom {el WHMO Fl{edkdbdmx Gelgnbhw{ `dy
Wxw{lfj{hg Ylphl}w jok Fl{j&jojbxwlw %Jqqlokhu I:(/ J iyhl` w|ffjyx d` {el < wxw{lfj{hg
ylphl}w diclg{hplw" gdogb|whdow jok ho{lyojb pjbhkh{x gjo il `d|ok ho [jibl 7/
[el ; yjokdfhslk gdo{ydbblk {yhjbw %YG[w( jyl whfhbjy ho gdfqjyhom {el l``lg{hplolww d`
j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol gjyl jw jo lu{lowhdo {d |w|jb gjyl }h{e {el |w|jb gjyl jbdol/ 7 d` {el w{|khlw
qdq|bj{hdow d` ho{lylw{ jyl qldqbl }h{e khjil{lw dobx" jok {el d{ely dol hw lbklybx qldqbl }h{e
exqly{lowhdo/ [el w{|khlw ix Qhl{{l l{ jb %9111( jok Qhl{{l" ]lhoilymly jok Fgqell %9111( }lyl
{el wjfl w{|kx |whom {el wjfl ho{lyplo{hdow jok gdo{ydb jok jojbxshom {el wjfl wjfqbl whsl
ylw|b{w i|{ id{e qjqlyw ejk ylqdy{lk kh``lylo{ d|{gdfl hokhgj{dyw/ Qhl{{l l{ jb %9111( luqbdylk {el
l``lg{w d` j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol gjbbw ho hfqydphom wlb`&gjyl jok mbxglfhg gdo{ydb" }elyljw Qhl{{l"
]lhoilymly jok Fgqell %9111( lujfholk {el hfqjg{ d` {el j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol gjbbw ho qj{hlo{&
glo{lylk d|{gdflw bhnl qwxgedbdmhgjb d|{gdflw" wlb`&l``hgjgx" wj{hw`jg{hdo }h{e gjyl jok z|jbh{x
d` bh`l/ Qhl{{l" ]lhoilymly" Nyjlfly jok FgQell %911:( khk jod{ely w{|kx |whom {el wjfl
ylwljyge fl{edkdbdmx" }h{e {el wjfl ho{lyplo{hdo jok gdo{ydb" do jod{ely myd|q d` qj{hlo{w `ydf
j kh``lylo{ wh{l/ [elwl w{|khlw }lyl ijwlk do \oh{lk W{j{lw/ @yhlkfjo l{ jb %:880( khk {el w{|kx
do j myd|q d` lbklybx qj{hlo{w }h{e exqly{lowhdo bddnhom ho {d flkhgj{hdo jkelylogl jok {elhy
ibddk qylww|yl gdo{ydb ho Lombjok/ [el bdgj{hdo d` w{|khlw kdol hw jo hfqdy{jo{ gdowhklyj{hdo
}elo jojbxshom {el kh``lylogl ho lgdodfhg ilol`h{w k|l {d {el kh``lyloglw ho eljb{e gjyl `hojogl
w{y|g{|yl/
[jibl ; wed}w {el iyhl` w|ffjyx d` {el ; YG[w jok {el whfhbjyh{hlw d` d|{gdfl hokhgj{dyw
fljw|ylk {d klfdow{yj{lk l``lg{hplolww d` {el j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol wlyphglw jw jo lu{lowhdo d`
gjyl/ [el z|jbh{hlw d` {el YG[w jyl jwwlwwlk |whom WHMO Fl{edkdbdmx gelgnbhw{ `dy Yjokdfhslk
Gdo{ydbblk [yhjbw %Jqqlokhu I9(/
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
9/37
J|{edy$ [h{bl$[xqlw d` W{|khlw Hogb|klk
Diclg{hplw $
D|{gdfl Hokhgj{dyw@hokhomw Wxo{elwhw Gdogb|whdow#
##Wlg{hdo
:3
Ho{lyojb
Pjbhkh{x
###Wlg{hdo 93
Dplyjbb Jwwlwwflo{
G|yylbb" \yz|ejy{"
]jho}yhme{ jok Bl}hw
%9111(
[lblflkhghol plyw|w `jgl{d `jgl qj{hlo{ gjyl3 l``lg{
do qyd`lwwhdojb qyjg{hgljok eljb{e gjyl d|{gdflw
Jwwlww {el l``lg{hplolww d`
{lblflkhghol jw jo jb{lyoj{hpl {d `jgl
{d `jgl qj{hlo{ gjyl/
Kh``lyloglw ho3%:( D|{gdflw d` gjyl%9( Lgdodfhg gdowlz|loglw d` gjyl%7( Jgglq{jihbh{x d` gjyl `ydf qj{hlo{
jok qydphkly qdho{ d` phl}%;( Qyd`lwwhdojb qyjg{hgl k|yhomklbhplyx d` gjyl%
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
10/37
J|{edy$ [h{bl$[xqlw d` W{|khlw Hogb|klk
Diclg{hplw $
D|{gdfl Hokhgj{dyw@hokhomw Wxo{elwhw Gdogb|whdow# ##Wlg{hdo
:3
Ho{lyojb
Pjbhkh{x
###Wlg{hdo 93
Dplyjbb Jwwlwwflo{
Elywe" Elb`jok"
]jbbjgl" Nyjlfly"
Qj{yhghj" Wejqhyd jok
Myllobhgn %911:(
Gbhohgjb d|{gdflwylw|b{hom `ydf
{lblflkhgholho{lyplo{hdow3 jwxw{lfj{hg ylphl}/
Lpjb|j{l {el l``lg{hplolww d`
{lblflkhghol ho{lyplo{hdow `dy eljb{e
d|{gdflw ho 9 gbjwwlw d` jqqbhgj{hdo3
edfl&ijwlk jok d``hgl$edwqh{jb&
ijwlk/
D|{gdfl hokhgj{dyw3
Ylqdy{lk gbhohgjb gjyl d|{gdflw `ydfhokhphk|jb w{|khlw
Whfhbjyh{hlw jok
kh``lyloglw ho {el
w{|khlw }lyl gdfiholk
ix {el gj{lmdyhlw d`
gbhohgjb wqlghjb{x
[el w{ydomlw{ lphklogl `dy
l``hgjgx d` {lblflkhghol ho
gbhohgjb d|{gdflw `ydf edfl&
ijwlk {lblflkhghol ho jyljw d`
exqly{lowhdo" geydohg khwljwl
fjojmlflo{ jok JHKw/
:/: JJ
:/9 ]G
:/7 ]G
:/; QJ
:/< ]G
9/: .
9/9 [el bjgn d` ho`dyfj{hdo do }
ed} fjox o|fily d` ylphl}l
gyh{hz|hom {el jy{hgblw jbbd} ydd
ihjwolww {d}jykw j qjy{hg|bjy kh
d` {el fl{j&jojbxwhw/
Bhww" Mb|lgnj|` jok
Lgnb|ok&Cdeowdo %9119(
Ylwljyge do [lbleljb{ejok Geydohg FlkhgjbGdokh{hdow3 Gyh{hgjbYlphl}" Nlx Hww|lw" jok@|{|yl Khylg{hdow
Lpjb|j{l {el hfqjg{ d`
{lblgdff|ohgj{hdo&ijwlk
ho{lyplo{hdow dy qlywdow }h{e
geydohg khwjihbh{hlw
9 fjho ho{lylw{w3 qlyglhplk |{hbh{x jok
gdw{&l``lg{hplolww d` {lbl&eljb{e
ho{lyplo{hdow
; Gj{lmdyhlw
%j( ho{lyol{ w{|khlw %i(
w{jokjyk {lblqedol jok
j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol
wxw{lf w{|khlw
%g( phkldgdo`lyloghom
hoplw{hmj{hdow
%k( gdfqjyj{hpl w{|khlw
|whom 7 dy fdyl
fdkjbh{hlw wlypl jw j
`yjfl}dyn `dy
dymjohshom kj{j dy kj{j
wxo{elwhw
Dplyjbb ylw|b{w w|mmlw{lk {ej{ {el
Ho{lyol{" {lblqedol jok
phkldgdo`lyloghom jyl
l``hgjghd|w jok l``hghlo{ fdklw
d` {ylj{flo{ `dy qldqbl }h{e
geydohg flkhgjb gdokh{hdow/
Qjy{hg|bjybx {lbleljb{e
ho{lyplo{hdow {ej{ {jyml{lk
jkelylogl dy eljb{e qydfd{hdo
:/: JJ
:/9 JJ
:/7 QJ
:/; QJ
:/< QJ
9/:
9/9 %j( [el bjgn d` ho`dyfj{hdo
jok ed} fjox o|fily d` ylph
wlblg{hom jok gyh{hz|hom {el jy
jbbd} yddf `dy ihjwolww {d}j
qjy{hg|bjy khylg{hdo d` {el fl{j&
%i( Dobx QwxgeBh{" Q|iFlk
QwxgHO@D ejpl illo wljyge
%g( gj{lmdyhshom {el `hokhomw
kh``lylo{ dyfw d` {lblgdff|oh
jw j `yjfl}dyn gjo ylw|b{ ho
ihjwolww d` ylw|b{w/
bb gdogb|whdow wllJqqlokhu J7 ##" ### WHMO Fl{edkdbdmx Gelgnbhw{ : `dy wxw{lfj{hg ylphl}w jok fl{j&jojbxwhw %Wll Jqqlokhu I: (/ }lbb gdplylk> JJ & jklz|j{lbx jkkylwwlk> QJ qddybx jkkylwwlk> OK od{ jkkylwwlk> OY od{ ylqdy{lk> OJ od{ jqqbhgjibl
ibl 73 Iyhl` W|ffjyx d` Wxw{lfj{hg Ylphl}w Gyh{hz|lk %gdo{(
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
11/37
J|{edyw$ [h{bl Yjokdfhslk
, kydq d|{
Od/ d` w|iclg{w
Ho{lyplo{hdo
jok Gdo{ydb
#
W
G
#
F
Q
#
Q
K
#
Y
W
#
\
W
#
W
]
G
#
Q
W
X
#
W
L
#
E
W
#
Z
D
B
#
G
K
## WHMO Ho{lyojb Pjbhkh{x Gdogb|whdo###
KHJIL[LW
Qhl{{l" ]lhoilymly"
Fgqell" Fje" Nyjlfly
jok Gyjqd
Kd J|{dfj{lk Gjbbw }h{e
O|ywl dbbd}&|q hfqydplwlb` gjyl jok mbxglfhg
gdo{ydb jfdom p|bolyjibl
qj{hlo{w }h{e Khjil{lw4K|yj{hdo3 :9fdo{e
Xlw/
9;5 qj{hlo{w kj{jjojbxslk %58,("
::, kydqqlkd|{/
:9; w|iclg{w ho
ljge jyf/
J|{dfj{lk
{lblqedol"gjbbw d|{&
id|ok }h{e
o|ywl `dbbd}&|q jkc|og{ {d|w|jb gjyl pw
\w|jb gjyl
:/: ]G
:/9 ]G:/7 JJ:/; OJ
:/< ]G:/0 ]G:/= QJ
:/5
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
12/37
J|{edyw$ [h{bl Yjokdfhslk
, kydq d|{
Od/ d` w|iclg{w
Ho{lyplo{hdo
jok Gdo{ydb
#
W
G
#
F
Q
#
Q
K
#
Y
W
#
\
W
#
W
]
G
#
Q
W
X
#
W
L
#
E
W
#
Z
D
B
#
G
K
## WHMO
Ho{lyojb
Pjbhkh{x
Gdogb|whdo###
EXQLY[LOWHDO
@yhlkfjo l{ jb/
J {lblgdff|ohgj{hdowwxw{lf dy fdoh{dyhomjok gd|owlbhom qj{hlo{w
}h{e exqly{lowhdo hfqjg{ do flkhgj{hdo
jkelylogl jok ibddk
qylww|yl gdo{ydb/
K|yj{hdo3 0 fdo{ew
Xlw/
90= %58,(w|iclg{w kj{j
}lyl jojbxslk j{{el lok d` {el
w{|kx
%::, kydq d|{(
Qj{hlo{&
hoh{hj{lkj|{dfj{lk{lblqedol"
gjbbw jkc|og{ {d|w|jb gjyl pw\w|jb gjyl
:/: ]G
:/9 ]G:/7 JJ:/; OJ
:/< ]G:/0 ]G:/= JJ
:/5 ::,
:/8 JJ:/:1 OJ
9/: .. Ylw|b{w3
:(L``lg{w do jo{hexqly{lowhpl flkhg
jkelylogl3Fljo jkelylogl hfqydplflo{3kh``60,9(L``lg{w d` ibddk qylww|yl3Jkc|w{lk fljo khjw{dbhg ibddk qylw
gejomlw3
[d{jb w{|kx qdq|bj{hdo3 kh``6;/;OdoJkelylo{w|iclg{w3 kh``65/57(Ylbj{hdowehq d` [BG |wl jok
jkelylogl gejoml {d ibddk qylww|ylJkc/ fljo wxw IQ gejoml ho [BG m
:9/=ffEm %hogyljwlk jkelylogl( pw9/
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
13/37
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
14/37
[el Gdowhklylk C|kmflo{ {jibl hw wed}o ho [jibl
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
15/37
x Z|lw{hdo :3 Hw {elyl j kh``lylogl ho hfqydphom qexwhdbdmhgjb d|{gdfl hokhgj{dyw il{}llo j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol gjyl jok |w|jb gjyl ho qj{hlo{w }h{e gljwlw fjhobx [xql 9 khjil{lw" exqly{lowhdo jok exqlybhqhklfhj ho d|{qj{hlo{ wl{{hom4
J|{edy$ [h{bl$ [xql Gdogb|whdowWHMO
Ho{lyojb
Z|jbh{x
Khylg{olww d` jqqbhgj{hdo {d
[jyml{ Qdq|bj{hdo d` M|hklbholGbhohgjb Hfqjg{ Hfqblflo{jihbh{x
G|yylbb" \yz|ejy{"
]jho}yhme{ jok Bl}hw
[lblflkhghol plyw|w `jgl{d `jgl qj{hlo{ gjyl3 l``lg{
do qyd`lwwhdojb qyjg{hgljok eljb{e gjyl d|{gdflw
Wxw{lfj{hg
Ylphl}
:( Odol d` {el hogb|klk w{|khlw
klfdow{yj{lk jox kl{yhflo{jb l``lg{w `ydf
{el ho{lyplo{hdow
9( [elyl hw jbwd bh{{bl lphklogl d` gbhohgjb
ilol`h{w
7( Bjymly wjfqblw ollklk `dy `|y{ely
ylwljyge
.
Ylphl} od{ :11, khylg{bx
jqqbhgjibl {d {el jwwhmoflo{/
W{|khlw hopdbphom jg|{l
flkhgjb gdokh{hdow jyl
hogb|klk ho ylphl}/
Blplb d` jqqbhgjihbh{x3 ;1,
Ydhol" Dehofjj jok
Ejhblx
Jwwlwwhom {lblflkhghol3 jwxw{lfj{hg ylphl} d` {elbh{lyj{|yl
Wxw{lfj{hg
Ylphl}
Lphklogl d` l``lg{hplolww d` {lblflkhghol
ylfjhow bhfh{lk/ Fdw{ d` {el w{|khlw jyl
qhbd{ qydclg{w dy wedy{&{lyf d|{gdflw/
Dobx {yjowfhwwhdo d` LGM jok {lbl&
klyfj{dbdmx ejpl wed}o qydfhwhom
ylw|b{w/
..
Ylphl} od{ :11, khylg{bx
jqqbhgjibl {d {el jwwhmoflo{/
W{|khlw hopdbphom jg|{l
flkhgjb gdokh{hdow d{ely {ejo
geydohg khwljwlw jyl hogb|klk
ho ylphl}/
Blplb d` jqqbhgjihbh{x3 ;1,
Elywe" Elb`jok"
]jbbjgl" Nyjlfly"
Qj{yhghj" Wejqhyd jok
Myllobhgn
Gbhohgjb d|{gdflw
ylw|b{hom `ydf{lblflkhgholho{lyplo{hdow3 jwxw{lfj{hg ylphl}/
Wxw{lfj{hg
Ylphl}
[el w{ydomlw{ lphklogl `dy l``hgjgx d`
{lblflkhghol ho gbhohgjb d|{gdflw `ydf
edfl&ijwlk {lblflkhghol ho jyljw d`
exqly{lowhdo" geydohg khwljwl
fjojmlflo{ jok JHKw/
.
Ylphl} hw jqqbhgjibl {d {el
{jyml{ qdq|bj{hdo ho id{e
geydohg khwljwl jok d|{qj{hlo{
fjojmlflo{/
Blplb d` jqqbhgjihbh{x3 =1,
Bhww" Mb|lgnj|` jok
Lgnb|ok&Cdeowdo
Ylwljyge do [lbleljb{ejok Geydohg FlkhgjbGdokh{hdow3 Gyh{hgjbYlphl}" Nlx Hww|lw" jok@|{|yl Khylg{hdow
Wxw{lfj{hg
Ylphl}
Ho{lyol{" {lblqedol jok phkldgdo`lyloghom
jyl l``hgjghd|w jok l``hghlo{ fdklw d`
{ylj{flo{ `dy qldqbl }h{e geydohg flkhgjb
gdokh{hdow/
@|y{elyfdyl" {lbleljb{e ho{lyplo{hdow {ej{
{jyml{lk jkelylogl dy eljb{e qydfd{hdo
%qjy{hg|bjybx j|{dfj{lk qedol
{lgeodbdmx( wed}lk hogylflo{jb mjhow ho
gdfqjyhwdo {d yd|{hol gjyl/
T
Ylphl} hw jqqbhgjibl {d {el
{jyml{ qdq|bj{hdo d` geydohg
khwljwl" ed}lply {el ylphl}
hogb|klw w{|khlw d`
edwqh{jbhslk qj{hlo{w/
Blplb d` jqqbhgjihbh{x3 01,
Bjyml k|l {d {el
bjyml o|fily d`
qj{hlo{w {ehw
j|{dfj{lk
{lblqedol gjyl
}hbb wlypl h`
hfqblflo{lk
%:( Ylwd|yglw3 OEM
Qdbxgbhohgw ejpl j fjho
gjbb glo{ly/ [el fjho bhol
{lblqedol ho{ydk|g{hdo hw
j|{dfj{lk" ho{lyjg{lk }h
{d|ge&{dol qedol qjkw/
%9( Ho Whomjqdyl" fdw{ d
{el ed|wledbkw ejpl
{d|ge&{dol {lblqedolw/
%7( Wl{{hom |q {el wxw{lf
}hbb ylz|hyl jkkh{hdojb
gd|ywl `dy {el qbjoohom
jok {el |wjml d` {el
{lblqedol bholw
%;( [el hfqblflo{j{hdo d
{ehw ho{lyplo{hdo hw od{
c|w{h`hjibl j{ {el fdflo{
k|l {d {el |onod}o gdw{
d` wl{{hom |q {el wxw{lf
gdfqjyhwdo {d {el
ilol`h{w/
ibl
8/14/2019 NUS Systematic Review Assignment
16/37
x Z|lw{hdo :3 Hw {elyl j kh``lylogl ho hfqydphom qexwhdbdmhgjb d|{gdfl hokhgj{dyw il{}llo j|{dfj{lk {lblqedol gjyl jok |w|jb gjyl ho qj{hlo{w }h{e gljwlw fjhobx [xql 9 khjil{lw" exqly{lowhdo jok exqlybhqhklfhj ho d|{qj{hlo{ wl{{hom4
J|{edy$ [h{bl$ [xql Gdogb|whdowWHMO
Ho{lyojb
Z|jbh{x
Khylg{olww d` jqqbhgj{hdo {d
[jyml{ Qdq|bj{hdo d` M|hklbholGbhohgjb Hfqjg{ Hfqblflo{jihbh{x
Qhl{{l" ]lhoilymly"
Fgqell" Fje" Nyjlfly
jok Gyjqd
Kd J|{dfj{lk Gjbbw }h{eO|ywl `dbbd}&|q hfqydplwlb` gjyl jok mbxglfhggdo{ydb jfdom p|bolyjiblqj{hlo{w }h{e Khjil{lw4
YG[
@hokhomw d` {ehw w{|kx ylqdy{lk3
:( Ho{lyplo{hdo myd|q hogyljwl o|fily d`
w|iclg{w }h{e Odyfjb EiJ:G, blplb
9( Ho{lyplo{hdo myd|q ejw j bd}ly fljo
wly|f mb|gdwl blplbw d` ;:fm$kB
@hokhomw od{ mlolyjbhslk {d jbb khjil{lw
qdq|bj{hdo" fjho gejyjg{lyhw{hgw d` qj{hlo{w ho
w{|kx jyl bd}&hogdfl" `ydf \oh{lk W{j{lw
.
@hokhomw gjood{ il khylg{bx
jqqbhlk k|l {d qj{hlo{ `jg{dyw3
kh``lylogl ho l{eohgh{x `jg{dy
jok g|b{|yjb jg{dyw/ Jwhjo
bd}&hogdfl myd|q fhme{ ejplj kh``lylo{ eljb{e bh{lyjgx blplb/
Blplb d` jqqbhgjihbh{x `dy
khjil{lw qdq|bj{hdo dobx3 01,
Qhl{{l" ]lhoilymly"
Nyjlfly jok FgQell
Hfqjg{ d` J|{dfj{lkGjbbw }h{e O|ywl @dbbd}&|q do Khjil{lw [ylj{flo{D|{gdflw ho jKlqjy{flo{ d` Pl{lyjowJ``jhyw Eljb{e GjylWxw{lf j yjokdfhslkgdo{ydbblk {yhjb
YG[@hokhomw d` {ehw w{|kx ylqdy{lk3
%:( W|iclg{w }h{e EiJ:g ? dy lz|jb {d 5,
fljo EiJ:g, klgyljwlk ix 1/