8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 1/22
Maoes Anak Busd1211 East Sakta Cnara Avekue #:Sak Mfse, Canlifrkla <5119(:04) 945-:0:<[email protected]
Pnalktlii lk prf per
SUPERLFR CFURZ FI CANLIFRKLA
CFUKZ\ FI SAKZA CNARA
CLYLN JLYLSLFK - SAK MFSE
Maoes Anak Busd, ) Case Kf. 1:-CY-######)
Pnalktlii, ) CFOPNALKZ IFR ZEOPFRAR\) WRLZ FI LKMUKCZLFK AKJ
v. ) PEROAKEKZ LKMUKCZLFK)
Reubek Ayana, Ejenolra Ayana, ) XClv. Cfje § 3:228 CfjeJavlj Ayana, JFES 1 tf 10, ) Clv. Prfc. §§ 529 akj
) 527(a)8 Deantd & SaietyJeiekjakts. ) Cfje §§ 11570‚11547_
)VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV
LKZRFJUCZLFK
CFOES KFW Pnalktlii, Maoes Anak Busd, akj petltlfks tdls Cfurt
ifr a teopfrary wrlt fi lkmukctlfk XCfje Clv. Prfc. §§ 529,
527(a)8 Deantd & Saiety Cfje § 11573_ akj a peroakekt lkmukctlfk
XClv. Cfje § 3:228 Deantd & Saiety Cfje §§ 11570, 11571_ agalkst
Jeiekjakts Reubek Ayana akj Ejenolra Ayana, fwkers fi Ayana
Apartoekts, akj Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana, resljekt prfperty
oakager, tf abate a pubnlc akj prlvate kulsakce pursuakt tf
Deantd & Saiety Cfje §§ 11570-11547, akj, lk partlcunar, tf ekj
1:-CY-######PAGE FI1 9CFOPNALKZ
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 2/22
jrug jeanlkg, tde assfclatej crloe akj tde jlsprfpfrtlfkan jralk
fk pfnlce servlces at tde bulnjlkg tde jeiekjakts fwk akj/fr
oakage.
ANNEGAZLFKS
Pnalktlii anneges=
1. Pnalktlii ls, akj at ann tloes derelk oektlfkej was, a
cltlzek fi tde State fi Canlifrkla akj a resljekt fi tde
Cfukty fi Sakta Cnara, wdere tde kulsakce tdat ls tde
submect fi tdls cfopnalkt exlsts.
2. Jeiekjakts Reubek Ayana akj Ejenolra Ayana are, akj at ann
tloes derelk oektlfkej were, tde fwkers fi tde bulnjlkg lk
wdlcd tde kulsakce exlsts, kaoeny, Ayana Apartoekts,
nfcatej at 1355 Meiiersfk Avekue, lk tde Clty fi Sakta
Cnara, lk tde Cfukty fi Sakta Cnara, akj lk tde State fi
Canlifrkla, akj are tde persfks oalktalklkg tde kulsakce
tdat ls tde submect fi tdls cfopnalkt.
3. Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana ls, akj at ann tloes derelk oektlfkej
was, ak eopnfyee (l.e, prfperty oakager) akj renatlve
(l.e., sfk) fi tde aifreoektlfkej jeiekjakts, akj ls tde
persfk cfkjuctlkg tde kulsakce tdat ls tde submect fi tdls
cfopnalkt.
:. At ann tloes derelk oektlfkej, akj at neast slkce Muny 31st
2004, Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana, lk cfkcert wltd ftder persfks
derelk reierrej tf as JEIEKJAKZ JFES 1 tf 10, dave
fccuplej, usej, akj oalktalkej tde preolses jescrlbej abfve
ifr tde purpfse fi uknawiunny sennlkg, servlkg, stfrlkg,
heeplkg, oakuiacturlkg, fr glvlkg away cfktrfnnej
1:-CY-######PAGE FI2 9CFOPNALKZ
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 3/22
substakces, precursfrs, fr akanfgs, as speclilej lk Deantd
& Saiety Cfje §§ 11000‚11951, kaoeny, crystan
oetdaopdetaolke, PCP, oarlmuaka akj derflk8 ofrefver,
jeiekjakts, akj eacd fi tdeo, dave fccuplej, usej, akj
oalktalkej tde aifresalj preolses lk sucd a oakker tdat
nfuj ouslc, ilgdtlkg lkvfnvlkg guksdfts akj stabblkgs,
yennlkg, stfoplkg, snaoolkg akj ftder kflses eoakate irfo
jeiekjakts“ bulnjlkg fk a recurrlkg basls, at ann dfurs fi
tde klgdt, wdlcd das resuntej lk kuoerfus canns tf pfnlce
by tekakts fi tde bulnjlkg akj resljekts fi kelgdbfrlkg
dfoes, as wenn as by tde jeiekjakts tdeosenves.
5. Zde Sakta Cnara Pfnlce Jepartoekt das actlveny patrfnnej
tde prfperty ifr fver slx years, akj das beek tf tde
prfperty fver 90 tloes fk crloe-renatej oatters jurlkg tdat
tloe, anofst lkvarlabny betweek tde nate-klgdt dfurs fi 11
PO tf 2 AO Xsee Exdlblt „A‟ ifr pfnlce repfrts pertalklkg
tf karcftlcs akj renatej jlsturbakces repfrtej by tekakts
fi Ayana Apartoekts akj kelgdbfrlkg resljekts_8 lk ofst
cases, tde Sakta Cnara Pfnlce Jepartoekt, tekakts fi Ayana
Apartoekts akj lts surrfukjlkg kelgdbfrs ljektliy tde
prfperty as a dub fr cekter ifr jrug actlvlty lk tde
kelgdbfrdffj, akj dave ansf ljektlilej Jeiekjakt Javlj
Ayana akj/fr persfks assfclatej wltd tde aifresalj
jeiekjakt lk kearny every pfnlce repfrt oaje betweek 2004
akj presekt as respfkslbne ifr tdat actlvlty.
9. Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana uses tde bulnjlkg fwkej by dls
parekts, Jeiekjakts Reubek akj Ejenolra Ayana, as a pnace
fi sdenter akj saiety irfo tde pfnlce, wdlne cfkjuctlkg
1:-CY-######PAGE FI3 9CFOPNALKZ
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 4/22
jrug jeans, darbfrlkg parfnees-at-narge akj persfks wltd
warrakts, akj lkstlgatlkg ilgdts tdat dave resuntej lk
guksdfts ilrej akj stabblkgs. Cfksequektny, tde bulnjlkg ls
a kulsakce per se as jeilkej by Deantd & Saiety Cfje §
11570 akj Clvln Cfje § 3:7<.
7. Fk fr abfut Muke 12td, 201:, Jeiekjakts Reubek akj Ejenolra
Ayana were dakj-jenlverej kftlce fi tde jaoage causej by
tde kulsakce akj a request ifr lts abateoekt8 dfwever, tde
jeiekjakts dave reiusej, akj cfktlkue tf reiuse, tf abate
tde kulsakce, davlkg cannej tde Sakta Cnara Pfnlce
Jepartoekt lk ak atteopt tf dave tde lkjlvljuan servlkg tde
kulsakce abateoekt request arrestej Xsee Repfrt #1:-9:3:,
Exdlblt „A‟_.
4. Basej fk tde retanlatfry respfkse by tde jeiekjakts upfk
servlce fi salj kftlce akj tde iact tdat tde jeiekjakts
dave ftderwlse tahek kf reasfkabne oeasures tf abate tde
kulsakce, Pnalktlii cfktekjs tdat Jeiekjakts wlnn, ukness
restralkej by tdls cfurt, cfktlkue tf oalktalk tde kulsakce
akj cfktlkue tde acts cfopnalkej fi, lk vlfnatlfk fi tde
rlgdts fi tde fccupakts fi Ayana Apartoekts, lts
surrfukjlkg kelgdbfrs akj tde cfoouklty at-narge.
<. Pnalktlii benleves akj tdereupfk anneges tdat Jeiekjakts
Reubek akj Ejenolra Ayana wdf fwk tde prfperty cakkft say
tdat tdey actej reasfkabny lk tdelr eiifrts tf oeet tde
prfbneo tdey hkew exlstej fk tdelr prfperty, akj dave
ftderwlse fvernffhej tde prfbneo jue tf tde iact tdat tde
prfperty oakager (Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana) ls a renatlve,
l.e., tdelr sfk. Cfksequektny, Jeiekjakts, akj eacd fi
1:-CY-######PAGE FI: 9CFOPNALKZ
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 5/22
tdeo, are creatlkg akj/fr oalktalklkg tde kulsakce as a
resunt fi ukkecessary, ukreasfkabne, akj lkmurlfus oetdfjs
fi fperatlfk fi tdelr buslkess, l.e., Ayana Apartoekts,
speclilcanny, by akj tdrfugd tdelr wlnniun ialnure akj
reiusan tf abate tde kulsakce.
10. Pnalktlii das kf pnalk, speejy, fr ajequate reoejy at naw,
akj lkmukctlve renlei ls expressny autdfrlzej lk Deantd &
Saiety Cfje §§ 11570-11547.
11. A teopfrary wrlt fi lkmukctlfk tf cnfse tde preolses ls
kecessary lk tdls case tf abate akj prevekt tde cfktlkuakce
fi tdls kulsakce, as tde kulsakce das beek fkgflkg akj
ukstfppabne by cfkstakt pfnlce lkvfnveoekt, evek aiter
kuoerfus warklkgs akj arrests Xsee Exdlblt „A‟_.
REQUESZEJ RENLEI
WDEREIFRE, Pnalktlii prays ifr mujgoekt agalkst Jeiekjakts as
ifnnfws=
1. Ifr a prenlolkary akj peroakekt lkmukctlfk ekmflklkg
jeiekjakts akj ann persfks lk cfkcert wltd fr ifr tdeo irfo
uknawiunny sennlkg, servlkg, stfrlkg, heeplkg,
oakuiacturlkg, fr glvlkg away a cfktrfnnej substakce,
precursfr, fr akanfg, as speclilej lk Deantd & Saiety Cfje
§§ 11000-11951 lk tde bulnjlkg jescrlbej abfve8 akj,
ekmflklkg jeiekjakts akj tdelr agekts, servakts akj
eopnfyees akj ann persfks actlkg ukjer akj lk cfkcert wltd
fr ifr tdeo irfo creatlkg aky kflse fk tde preolses
suiilclektny nfuj ekfugd tf jlsturb tde cfoifrtabne
ekmfyoekt fi tde prfperty tdat ls tde submect fi tdls
1:-CY-######PAGE FI5 9CFOPNALKZ
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 6/22
cfopnalkt akj lts kelgdbfrlkg prfpertles.
2. Ifr a teopfrary wrlt fi lkmukctlfk tf cnfse tde preolses8
3. Ifr cfsts fi sult derelk lkcnujej8 akj,
:. Ifr sucd ftder renlei as tde cfurt oay jeeo prfper.
Respectiunny subolttej by=
VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV Maoes Anak Busd JatePnalktlii lk prf per
VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV
VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV Ajjress Pdfke
1:-CY-######PAGE FI9 9CFOPNALKZ
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 7/22
Maoes Anak Busd1211 East Sakta Cnara Avekue #:Sak Mfse, Canlifrkla <5119(:04) 945-:0:<[email protected]
Pnalktlii lk prf per
SUPERLFR CFURZ FI CANLIFRKLA
CFUKZ\ FI SAKZA CNARA
CLYLN JLYLSLFK - SAK MFSE
Maoes Anak Busd, ) Case Kf. 1:-CY-######)
Pnalktlii, ) JECNARAZLFK FI PNALKZLII) LK SUPPFRZ FI CFOPNALKZ
v. ) IFR ZEOPFRAR\ WRLZ FI) LKMUKCZLFK AKJ PEROAKEKZ
Reubek Ayana, Ejenolra Ayana, ) LKMUKCZLFK ZF ABAZEJavlj Ayana, JFES 1 tf 10, ) PUBNLC AKJ PRLYAZE
) KULSAKCEJeiekjakts. )
)VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV
L, Maoes Anak Busd, dereby jecnare=
1. L ao tde pnalktlii lk tdls oatter akj reslje lk tde Cfukty
fi Sakta Cnara, lk tde State fi Canlifrkla, wdlcd ls tde
saoe nfcatlfk as tde bulnjlkg tdat ls tde submect fi tdls
actlfk, kaoeny, Ayana Apartoekts. Zdls jecnaratlfk
prfvljes tde iacts akj clrcuostakces tf estabnlsd tdat tde
aifreoektlfkej bulnjlkg ls a jrug dfuse kulsakce as
jeilkej by Canlifrkla naw.
2. Fk Muke 1:td, 201:, L subolttej a Request ifr Pubnlc
1:-CY-######PAGE FI1 11JECNARAZLFK
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 8/22
Recfrjs pursuakt tf Gfv. Cfje § 9253 tf tde Sakta Cnara
Pfnlce Jepartoekt Xattacdej deretf as Exdlblt „A‟_,
requestlkg „aky lkifroatlfk renatlkg tf aky persfk
arrestej akj tde cfopnalkts fr requests recelvej by yfur
jepartoekt (anfkg wltd tde respfkses) as lt pertalks tf
uknawiun sennlkg, servlkg, stfrlkg, heeplkg,
oakuiacturlkg, fr glvlkg away fi aky cfktrfnnej substakce,
precursfr, fr akanfg lk every bulnjlkg fr pnace wderelk fr
upfk wdlcd tdfse acts tahe pnace as speclilej lk Deantd &
Saiety Cfje §§ 11000-11951 lk akj arfukj‟ tde submect
nfcatlfk, speclilcanny, 1355 Meiiersfk Avekue.
3. L dave revlewej ann 90 fi tde pfnlce repfrts prfvljej by
tde Sakta Cnara Pfnlce Jepartoekt lk respfkse tf salj
request Xattacdej deretf as Exdlblt „B‟_, tde ofst
renevakt fi wdlcd are suooarlzej lk tdls jecnaratlfk.
:. Accfrjlkg tf Sakta Cnara Pfnlce Jepartoekt Repfrt Kf.
1:-9:3:, fk Muke 12td, 201:, a kulsakce abateoekt
ajvlseoekt was dakj-jenlverej tf Jeiekjakts Reubek akj
Ejenolra Ayana, tde fwkers fi tde prfperty tdat ls tde
submect fi tdls cfopnalkt, akj tf Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana,
tde prfperty oakager, regarjlkg tde kuoerfus crlolkan
vlfnatlfks fk tde prfperty, wdlcd pertalk tf karcftlcs,
jlsturbakces, weapfks ilre, akj tde nlhe. Per tde repfrt,
jeiekjakts respfkjej by cannlkg tde pfnlce lk ak atteopt
tf dave tde persfk jenlverlkg tde ajvlseoekt arrestej.
5. Zde reoalkjer fi tde pfnlce repfrts sdfw tdat tdere were
sevek karcftlcs-renatej canns tf pfnlce, lk wdlcd pfnlce,
resljekts fi Ayana Apartoekts akj lts kelgdbfrs ljektlilej
1:-CY-######PAGE FI2 11JECNARAZLFK
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 9/22
ljektlilej Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana akj ftders as „hkfwk jrug
users,‟ „suspectej…karcftlcs jeaners,‟ akj „hkfwk gakg
oeobers‟ tdat „senn jrugs.‟ Ifnnfwlkg ls a suooary fi eacd
repfrt pertalklkg tf karcftlcs fr jlsturbakces lkvfnvlkg
tde use fi karcftlcs by tde suspects8 lk eacd repfrt,
Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana ls tde prloary suspect=
a. Fk Muke 30td, 200<, at 11=27 PO, a resljekt fi Ayana
Apartoekts, l.e., Maraolnna (nast kaoe wltddenj),
repfrtej a ilgdt at Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana“s apartoekt
betweek tde jeiekjakt akj fke ftder oane8 lk Repfrt
Kf. 0<0930223 XJlsturbakce, ilgdtlkg_, Sakta Cnara
Pfnlce Jepartoekt jescrlbej tdeo bftd as „WOA's lk
tdelr 30's, yennlkg futslje akj ilgdtlkg8 hkfwk jrug
users, assfclatej wltd prfperty oakager's apartoekt‟,
l.e., Javlj Ayana“s.
b. Per Sakta Cnara Pfnlce Jepartoekt Repfrt Kf.
10091:212 XKarcftlcs_, ak akfkyofus resljekt fi Ayana
Apartoekts ajvlsej pfnlce fk Muke 1:td, 2010, at 4=27
PO tdat „tde apartoekt oakager (Javlj Ayana) das a
nft fi pefpne cfolkg lk akj fut, akj tdlkhs Javlj ls
jflkg jrugs agalk.‟
c. A secfkj akfkyofus resljekt cannej pfnlce fk Muke
2<td, 2010, at 1=11 PO, statlkg tdat, per Repfrt Kf.
10092<111 XJlsturbakce_, „startlkg ifur dfurs earnler
(7 ao), tde apartoekt oakager (Javlj Ayana) akj
severan irlekjs dave beek yennlkg nfujny akj
screaolkg, wltd prfiaklty. Pfsslbny ukjer-tde-
lkinuekce.‟
1:-CY-######PAGE FI3 11JECNARAZLFK
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 10/22
j. A kelgdbfr tf Ayana Apartoekts nfcatej at 1511
Darrlsfk Street, kaoeny, Maloe Cfrtez, repfrtej fk
Makuary 27td, 2011, at 9=30 PO, lkifroej pfnlce tdat
„tde prfperty oakager at Ayana Apartoekts Xakj
ftders_ are suspectej tf be karcftlcs jeaners,‟ akj,
statej tdat „tdere ls a nft fi ifft traiilc lk akj
fut fi tdere, akj Xtdat de_ cak dear a nft fi
yennlkg,‟ per Repfrt Kf. 110127132 XJlsturbakce_.
e. Jeiekjakt Reubek Ayana lkjlcatej dls fwk awarekess fi
lnnegan karcftlcs use fk dls prfperty wdek, fk Muny
7td, 2013, at 2=0< AO, de repfrtej tf pfnlce tdat
Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana akj „tdree fr ifur vedlcnes
Xwere_ parhej lnneganny lk nft wltd nfts fi oarlmuaka
sofhlkg by fccupakts (as vlewej tdrfugd securlty
caoeras),‟ per Repfrt Kf. 130707017 XKarcftlcs_.
i. Zdat saoe jeiekjakt, l.e., Reubek Ayana, cannej
pfnlce fk August 29td, 2013, at 5=19 PO (Repfrt Kf.
130429199 XJlsturbakce, ilgdtlkg_, repfrtlkg tdat
„XJeiekjakt_ Javlj Ayana, 3:, DOA, deavy-set, gray
takh tfp, bnach pakts, akj Rlchy Saktfs, bftd hkfwk
gakg oeobers, startej yennlkg at repfrtlkg party akj
der slster,‟ akj tdat, „suspects XJeiekjakt Javlj
Ayana akj Rlchy Saktfs_ senn jrugs.‟
g. Per Repfrt Kf. 13111317< XJlsturbakce_, a resljekt fi
Ayana Apartoekts, l.e., Xilrst kaoe wltddenj_ Infres,
cannej pfnlce fk Kfveober 13td, 2013, at 9=53 PO,
cfopnalklkg tdat „a ieoane wearlkg brfwk sweater…
assfclatej wltd fccupakts fi Javlj Ayana's apartoekt…
1:-CY-######PAGE FI: 11JECNARAZLFK
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 11/22
tdrew sfoetdlkg at Xdls_ wlkjfw, akj „salj tdey are
jrug ajjlcts akj das daj prevlfus prfbneos wltd
tdeo.‟
9. A iurtder revlew fi tde pfnlce repfrts reveanej ifur
weapfks-renatej canns, lkcnujlkg tdree lkcljekces
lkvfnvlkg guksdfts akj fke stabblkg. Ifnnfwlkg ls a
suooary fi eacd repfrt pertalklkg tf jlsturbakces lk fr
arfukj tde apartoekt fi Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana, wdlcd
lkvfnvej weapfks, l.e., eltder a guk fr hklie=
a. Fk August 15td, 2010, at 7=39 AO, Sakcdez Xnast kaoe
wltddenj_ cannej pfnlce tf repfrt „fke pfsslbne guk
sdft,‟ tdat causej car anaros Xtf gf_ fii,‟ per
Repfrt Kf. 100415052 XIlrearos jlscdargej_.
b. Fk Makuary 17td, 2011, at 9=50 PO, tde saoe
lkjlvljuan repfrtej tf pfnlce as dearlkg twf guk
sdfts, per Repfrt Kf. 110117150 XIlrearos
jlscdargej_.
c. Per Repfrt Kf. 130724123 XJlsturbakce, ilrearos_, fk
Muny 24td, 2013, at 5=29 PO, ak akfkyofus canner, a
resljekt fi Ayana Apartoekts, statej tdat de dearj
„sfoefke screaolkg tdat —sfoefke das a guk“ irfo tde
tfp fi tde apartoekt bulnjlkg,‟ akj tdat tde suspect
Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana.
j. Per Repfrt Kf. 130429052 XJlsturbakce, ilgdtlkg_, fk
August 29td, 2013, at 4=3< AO, ak akfkyofus canner
dearj „yennlkg akj screaolkg,‟ akj tdat „sfoefke salj
de was stabbej by parfnee-at-narge, Mfsepd Cnft, wdf
daj prevlfusny beek dljlkg at Javlj Ayana's
1:-CY-######PAGE FI5 11JECNARAZLFK
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 12/22
apartoekt.‟
7. Zde pfnlce repfrts ansf reveanej lkcljekces lk wdlcd
Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana was jlscfverej by pfnlce tf dave
darbfrej parfnees at-narge akj/fr persfks wltd warrakts8
ofrefver, tdey sdfw tdat tde aifreoektlfkej jeiekjakt
lnneganny dfusej persfks lk vacakt uklts wdf were kfk-
resljekts fi Ayana Apartoekts, wdlcd anaroej akj ftderwlse
akkfyej nawiun resljekts fk ountlpne fccaslfks. Ifnnfwlkg
ls a suooary fi eacd sucd repfrt=
a. Repfrt Kf. 04-429: XZrespasslkg_, fk Muny 31st, 2004,
at 9=25 PO, Akjrea Hlkg, a resljekt fi Ayana
Apartoekts, statej tdat „prlfr tf arrlvan fi
fiilcers, tde jffr was fpek tf apartoekt #2, but was
sdut as sffk as tde pfnlce arrlvej,‟ akj tdek statej
iurtder tdat, „Xtde_ apartoekt ls suppfsej tf be
vacakt, but tdat sde suspects tdat tde resljekt-
oakager, l.e., Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana ls dljlkg pefpne
lk #2 ifr ukhkfwk reasfks.‟
b. Repfrt Kf. 10071:072 XParfnee-at-narge (stahefut)_,
fk Muny 1:td, 2010, at 11=52 AO, Mfse Segura,
parfnee-at-narge, Oartlk Yanekzuena, ansf a parfnee-
at-narge, was ifukj dljlkg lk Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana's
apartoekt.
c. Repfrt Kf. 10072315: XParfnee-at-narge (stahefut)_,
fk Muny 23rj, 2010, at :=21 PO, parfnee-at-narge,
Saouen Yanekzuena, was ifukj dljlkg lk Jeiekjakt
Javlj Ayana's apartoekt.
j. Fk Septeober 4td, 2010, at :=13 PO, ak Xakfkyofus_
1:-CY-######PAGE FI9 11JECNARAZLFK
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 13/22
canner repfrtej tf pfnlce tdat tdey „Xdearj_ tde
apartoekt oakager, Javlj Ayana, ilgdtlkg Xwltd_ ak
DOA, deavy-set Xlkjlvljuan, pfsslbny kaoej_ Mfe, wdf
das tattffs8 bftd Xsuspects were_ yennlkg at eacd
ftder,‟ akj tdat „fke salj de was gflkg tf hlnn tde
ftder.‟ Accfrjlkg tf tde repfrt, l.e., Repfrt Kf.
100<041<2 XJlsturbakce, ilgdtlkg_, upfk arrlvan, tde
pfnlce ljektlilej tde suspects as Jeiekjakt Javlj
Ayana akj Mfsepd Cnft, a parfnee.
e. Repfrt Kf. 13051523< XZrespasslkg_, Oay 15td, 2013,
at 11=:3 PO, pfnlce repfrtej tdat „a oane submect,‟
salj, „Denp, tdere are pefpne lk tde yarj,‟ akj tdek
dukg up. Suspectlkg Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana, pfnlce
atteoptej a ifnnfw-up, but kf fke akswerej tde jffr
tf tde jeiekjakt“s apartoekt.
4. Lk ajjltlfk tf tde ftder types fi jlsturbakces anreajy
suooarlzej lk tdls jecnaratlfk, Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana was
lkvfnvej lk klke ajjltlfkan jlsturbakces tdat lkvfnvej
ilgdtlkg, wdlcd were repfrtej tf pfnlce by bftd fccupakts
fi Ayana Apartoekts akj kelgdbfrlkg resljekts. Ifnnfwlkg
ls a suooary fi eacd fi tdfse klke repfrts=
a. Repfrt Kf. 041213010 XJlsturbakce_, Jeceober 13td,
200<, at 12=3< AO, Wlnnlao Oasfk, a resljekt fi Ayana
Apartoekts, „twf oanes argulkg, tdreateklkg fke
akftder. Repfrtlkg party ajvlses tdat tdls ls tde
oakager's apartoekt,‟ l.e., Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana“s
apartoekt. „Repfrtlkg party wlsdes tf reoalk
akfkyofus8 kf cfktact.‟
1:-CY-######PAGE FI7 11JECNARAZLFK
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 14/22
b. Repfrt Kf. 0<-93<: XJlsturbakce, ilgdt_, fk Muke
1<td, 200<, at 11=19 PO, Hatrlka Patlekt, a resljekt
fi Ayana Apartoekts, „lk ak upstalrs uklt,‟
speclilcanny, Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana's apartoekt, sde
„cfunj dear twf oanes yennlkg at eacd ftder, uslkg
prfiaklty, irfo tde street.‟ Pfnlce cfkilroej tde
jlsturbakce fk arrlvan at tde jeiekjakt“s apartoekt.
c. Repfrt Kf. 0<0701249 XJlsturbakce_, Muny 2kj, 200<,
at 11=55 PO, Gabrlen Esparza, resljekt fi 1501 Newls
Street, „acrfss irfo tde sfutd slje fi Meiiersfk
Avekue (betweek Newls akj Darrlsfk), at Ayana
Apartoekts, tde repfrtlkg party das beek dearlkg twf
oanes argulkg ifr abfut 30 olkutes.‟ Pfnlce suspectej
tdat tde jlsturbakce caoe irfo Jeiekjakt Javlj
Ayana's apartoekt. A secfkj persfk, ansf a kelgdbfr
fi Ayana Apartoekt, nfcatej at 1395 Meiiersfk Street,
repfrtej tde saoe jlsturbakce, ljektliylkg tde
jeiekjakt as fke fi tde cunprlts.
j. Repfrt Kf. 100521211 XJlsturbakce, ilgdt_, fk Oay
21st, 2010, at 7=53 PO, Wlnnlao Bech, a kelgdbfr tf
Ayana Apartoekts, „Xcfunj_ dear a oane,‟ kaoeny,
Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana, „yennlkg,‟ akj tdat a „oane
akj ieoane must caoe fut fi tde apartoekt‟ fccuplej
by Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana. Wdek pfnlce arrlvej at tde
jeiekjakt“s apartoekt, de „Xwas_ very dfstlne Xakj_
kfk-cffperatlve.‟ Pfnlce statej iurtder tdat tdey
„daj tf daln dlo tf get dlo tf akswer tde jffr.‟
e. Repfrt Kf. 10052<021 XJlsturbakce, ilgdt_, fk Oay
1:-CY-######PAGE FI4 11JECNARAZLFK
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 15/22
2<td, 2010, at 1=07 AO, ak Xakfkyofus_ resljekt fi
Ayana Apartoekts, „lk tde ilrst apartoekt fk tde
secfkj inffr fi Ayana Apartoekts,‟ l.e., Jeiekjakt
Javlj Ayana“s apartoekt, „twf oanes Xwere_ screaolkg
at eacd ftder, wltd nfts fi snaoolkg gflkg fk,‟ akj
tdat „fke fi tde submects ls XJeiekjakt_ Javlj Ayana,
tde prfperty oakager.‟
i. Repfrt Kf. 100<051:: XJlsturbakce, ilgdtlkg_,
Septeober 5td, 2010, at 2=50 PO, ak Xakfkyofus_
canner akj resljekt fi Ayana Apartoekts, „dears oane
akj ieoane ilgdtlkg lk tde apartoekt acrfss irfo
der,‟ l.e., Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana's apartoekt.‟
g. Repfrt Kf. 1:0301022 XJlsturbakce, ilgdtlkg_, Oarcd
1st, 201:, at 2=35 AO, Xakfkyofus_ resljekt fi Ayana
Apartoekts, repfrtej tdat „twf oanes Xdave beek_
yennlkg ifr tde past cfupne fi dfurs,‟ fke fi tdeo
belkg Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana, akj tdat „tdls ls a
cdrfklc prfbneo.‟ Accfrjlkg tf tde repfrt, tde canner
repfrtej iurtder tdat „tde submects were argulkg
uktln tde pfnlce hkfchej, akj tdek becaoe ann qulet.‟
d. Repfrt Kf. 1:050924: XJlsturbakce_, fk Oay 9td, 201:,
at 10=54 PO, Xilrst kaoe wltddenj_ Daksfk, repfrtej
„a grfup fi twf fr tdree oanes akj ieoanes, yennlkg
at eacd ftder,‟ fke fi tdeo hkfwk by tde canner tf be
Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana.
l. Repfrt Kf. 100222124 XZdeit_, Iebruary 22kj, 2010, at
:=:2 PO, Nlkjsey Jryer, a resljekt fi Ayana
Apartoekts, cannej pfnlce, tennlkg tdeo tdat sde was
1:-CY-######PAGE FI< 11JECNARAZLFK
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 16/22
„trylkg tf retrleve der cennunar pdfke at XJeiekjakt_
Javlj Ayana's apartoekt8 but, Xtde jeiekjakt_ ls lk
pfssesslfk fi lt,‟ akj wfunj fkny „Xglve_ der tde SLO
carj, but kft tde pdfke.‟
<. Zdere were ansf ak ajjltlfkan sevek kflse jlsturbakces
repfrtej by fccupakts fi Ayana Apartoekts akj kelgdbfrlkg
resljekts, ofst fi wdlcd fccurrej betweek tde nate-klgdt
akj earny ofrklkg dfurs fi 11 PO akj 5 PO. Ifnnfwlkg ls a
suooary fi eacd repfrt=
a. Repfrt Kf. 041009005 XKflse_, Fctfber 9td, 2004, at
1=03 AO, Pauna Xnast kaoe wltddenj_, a resljekt fi
Ayana Apartoekts, repfrtej tdat „twf submects screaolkg
at tdelr jfg futslje lk tde yarj,‟ fke fi tdeo belkg
Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana.
b. Repfrt Kf. 0<-:474 XJlsturbakce, kflse_, fk Oay 12td,
200<, at 10=10 PO, Ayana Apartoekts resljekt, Maraolnnf
Xnast kaoe wltddenj_, repfrtej nfuj ouslc irfo
Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana“s apartoekt.
c. Repfrt Kf. 100903222 XJlsturbakce, kflse_, fk Muke 3rj,
2010, at <=24 PO, a resljekt fi Ayana Apartoekts, wdf
reiusej tf prfvlje tdelr kaoe, repfrtej nfuj ouslc irfo
Javlj Ayana's apartoekt.
j. Repfrt Kf. 100701035 XJlsturbakce, kflse_, fk Muny 1st,
2010, at 5=53 AO, ak akfkyofus resljekt fi Ayana
Apartoekts repfrtej nfuj ouslc at tde apartoekt fi
Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana, wdlcd fiilcers repfrtej tf dave
ceasej wdek tdey arrlvej at tde sceke.
e. Repfrt Kf. 130423074 XJlsturbakce_, fk August 23rj,
1:-CY-######PAGE FI10 11JECNARAZLFK
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 17/22
2013, at 11=20 AO, ak akfkyofus „repfrtlkg party salj a
wfoak was screaolkg at fr kear tde apartoekt bulnjlkg
oakagej by XJeiekjakt_ Javlj Ayana.‟
i. Repfrt Kf. 1:0209010 XJlsturbakce, kflse_, fk Iebruary
9td, 201:, at 2=37 AO, ak akfkyofus canner repfrtej
nfuj ouslc at Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana“s apartoekt.
g. Repfrt Kf. 1:0:150<3 XWarrakt_, Aprln 15td, 201:, at
10=24 AO, tde pfnlce repfrtej tdat Jeiekjakt Javlj
Ayana was „waktej ifr $50H fi irauj.‟
L jecnare ukjer pekanty fi permury ukjer tde naws fi tde State
fi Canlifrkla tdat tde ifregflkg ls true akj cfrrect, akj tdat
tdls jecnaratlfk was executej fk August VVVVV, 201:, lk tde Clty
fi Sakta Cnara, Cfukty fi Sakta Cnara, State fi Canlifrkla.
VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV Maoes Anak Busd JatePnalktlii lk prf per
VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV
VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV Ajjress Pdfke
1:-CY-######PAGE FI11 11JECNARAZLFK
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 18/22
Maoes Anak Busd1211 East Sakta Cnara Avekue #:Sak Mfse, Canlifrkla <5119(:04) 945-:0:<[email protected]
Pnalktlii lk prf per
SUPERLFR CFURZ FI CANLIFRKLA
CFUKZ\ FI SAKZA CNARA
CLYLN JLYLSLFK - SAK MFSE
Maoes Anak Busd, ) Case Kf. 1:-CY-######)
Pnalktlii, ) OEOFRAKJUO FI PFLKZS AKJ) AUZDFRLZLES LK SUPPFRZ FI
v. ) CFOPNALKZ IFR ZEOPFRAR\ ) WRLZ FI LKMUKCZLFK AKJReubek Ayana, Ejenolra Ayana, ) PEROAKEKZ LKMUKCZLFK ZFJavlj Ayana, JFES 1 tf 10, ) ABAZE PUBNLC AKJ PRLYAZE
) KULSAKCEJeiekjakts. )
)VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV
Lk suppfrt fi Pnalktlii“s cfopnalkt agalkst Jeiekjakts ifr a
wrlt fi lkmukctlfk akj peroakekt lkmukctlfk tf abate jrug dfuse
actlvlty, Pnalktlii prfiiers tde ifnnfwlkg arguoekts=
L. ZDE ACZLYLZ\ CFOPNALKEJ FI CFKSZLZUZES A KULSAKCE UKJER
SECZLFK 3:7< FI ZDE CLYLN CFJE AKJ SECZLFK 11570 FI ZDE
DEANZD & SAIEZ\ CFJE BECAUSE ZDE BULNJLKG FWKEJ AKJ OAKAGEJ
B\ ZDE JEIEKJAKZS LS USEJ IFR ZDE PURPFSE FI UKNAWIUNN\
SENNLKG, SERYLKG, SZFRLKG, HEEPLKG, OAKUIACZURLKG, FR
GLYLKG AWA\ CFKZRFNNEJ SUBSZAKCES.
1:-CY-######PAGE FI1 5OEOFRAKJA
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 19/22
A. Jeilkltlfk fi Pubnlc Kulsakce ukjer Clvln Cfje Sectlfk
3:40. Zde actlvlty cfopnalkej fi ls a pubnlc kulsakce
wltdlk tde oeaklkg fi Clvln Cfje Sectlfk 3:40. A pubnlc
kulsakce ls fke wdlcd aiiects at tde saoe tloe ak
ektlre cfoouklty fr kelgdbfrdffj, fr aky cfksljerabne
kuober fi persfks XClv. Cfje § 3:40_.
B. „Jrug Dfuse‟ as Kulsakce. Every bulnjlkg fr pnace usej
ifr tde purpfse fi uknawiunny sennlkg, servlkg,
stfrlkg, heeplkg, oakuiacturlkg, fr glvlkg away aky
cfktrfnnej substakce, precursfr, fr akanfg speclilc lk
tde Uklifro Cfktrfnnej Substakces Act XDeantd & Saiety
Cfje § 11000 et seq.8 Clv. Cfje § 3:7<_, akj every
bulnjlkg fr pnace wdere tdfse acts tahe pnace ls a
kulsakce tdat sdann be ekmflkej, abatej, akj prevektej,
wdetder lt ls a pubnlc fr prlvate kulsakce XDeantd &
Saiety Cfje § 115708 New v. Superlfr Cfurt (1<<3) 20
Can. App. :td 499, 471, 25 Can. Rptr. 2j :2_.
C. Iacts Pneajej fr Prfvej Satlsiy Statutfry Jeilkltlfk fi
Kulsakce. Zde basls fi a kulsakce actlfk oust be ifukj
lk tde statute XPefpne v. Nlo (1<:1) 14 Can. 2j 472,
440-441, 114 P.2j :72_. Pnalktlii das prfvljej
substaktlan evljekce tdat tde bulnjlkg fwkej akj/fr
oalktalkej by Jeiekjakts ls usej lk tde sane fi jrugs
akj tde darbfrlkg fi jrug jeaners. Zde repfrts prfvljej
by tde Sakta Cnara Pfnlce Jepartoekt, attacdej deretf
as Exdlblt „A‟, sdfw a jlsprfpfrtlfkate aofukt fi
cfopnalkts fi crlolkan actlvlty lkvfnvlkg Jeiekjakt
Javlj Ayana (l.e., abfut 90 repfrts wltdlk a perlfj fi
1:-CY-######PAGE FI2 5OEOFRAKJA
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 20/22
apprfxloateny slx years, beglkklkg lk 2004 akj uktln
presekt), akj lkcnuje ountlpne lkcljekces fi karcftlcs
vlfnatlfks akj ilgdtlkg akj kflse jlsturbakces, sfoe
lkvfnvlkg jeajny weapfks Xsee
Jecnaratlfk fi Pnalktlii
ifr a suooary fi eacd cann oaje tf pfnlce by resljekts
fi Ayana Apartoekts akj kelgdbfrlkg resljekts, wdlcd
repfrt tde crlolkan actlvlty tdat jeilkes tde kulsakce
cfopnalkej, ann lkvfnvlkg Jeiekjakt Javlj Ayana_.
LL. PNALKZLII OA\ BRLKG ZDLS ACZLFK BECAUSE ZDE CFOPNALKEJ FI
ACZS LKYFNYE ZDE LNNEGAN SANE FI CFKZRFNNEJ SUBSZAKCES,
WDLCD CFKSZLZUZE A KULSAKCE WLZDLK ZDE JEILKLZLFK SEZ
IFRZD LK SECZLFK 3:7< FI ZDE CLYLN CFJE.
A. Prlvate Cltlzeks Oay Abate Jrug Dfuse Actlvlty. A
prlvate cltlzek oay oalktalk ak actlfk tf abate akj
prevekt a Deantd & Saiety Cfje Sectlfk 11570 kulsakce
wdekever tdere ls a reasfk tf benleve tdat tde kulsakce
ls hept, oalktalkej, fr exlsts Xsee Deantd & Saiety
Cfje § 11571_.
Renlei avalnabne lk ak abateoekt actlfk lkcnujes
cnfsure fi tde preolses pekjlkg trlan, reofvan akj sane
fi persfkan prfperty usej lk oalktalklkg tde kulsakce,
cnfsure fi tde preolses ifr a year, akj ilkes XDeantd &
Saiety Cfje § 11571 et seq._.
LLL. KELZDER PRFFI FI LKMUR\ LS REQULREJ B\ ZDE PNALKZLII KFR
OUSZ PNALKZLII PRFYE JAOAGES GREAZER ZDAK ZDAZ FI ZDE
PUBNLC BECAUSE ZDE CANLIFRKLA NEGLSNAZURE DAS JECNAREJ ZDE
ACZLYLZ\ CFOPNALKEJ FI ZF BE A KULSAKCE PER SE UKJER
SECZLFK 11570 FI ZDE CANLIFRKLA DEANZD & SAIEZ\ CFJE.
1:-CY-######PAGE FI3 5OEOFRAKJA
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 21/22
A. Neglsnatlve Jecnaratlfk fi Kulsakce Per Se. Ak actlfk
fr cfkjltlfk tdat das beek jecnarej by tde Neglsnature
tf be a pubnlc kulsakce ls a kulsakce per se Xsee
OcCnutcdy v. Naguka Nakjs Ntj. (1<17) 32 Can. App. 714,
725, 19: P. :1_.
B. State Neglsnature Jecnares „Jrug Dfuses‟ as Kulsakce
Per Se. Zde state neglsnature das speclilcanny jecnarej
tdat tde use fi a bulnjlkg ifr sennlkg, servlkg,
stfrlkg, heeplkg, oakuiacturlkg, fr glvlkg away a
cfktrfnnej substakce tf be a kulsakce per se Xsee
Deantd & Saiety Cfje § 115708 New v. Superlfr Cfurt
(1<<3) 20 Can. App. :td 499, 471, 25 Can. Rptr. 2j :2_.
C. Prffi fi Lkmury Kft Requlrej ifr Lkmukctlve Renlei irfo
Kulsakce Per Se. Wdek ak actlfk fr cfkjltlfk ls a
kulsakce per se, kf prffi ls requlrej beyfkj tde actuan
iact fi tde prescrlbej actlfks fr cfkjltlfks tf
estabnlsd tdeo as ifr tde purpfse fi fbtalklkg
lkmukctlve renlei8 kf lnn eiiects keej tf be prfvej
Xsee OcCnatcdy v. Naguka Nakjs Ntj. (1<17) 32 Can. App.
714, 725, 19: P. :1_.
J. Pnalktlii Kft Requlrej tf Prfve Jaoages Greater Zdak
Pubnlc At Narge tf Abate a Jrug Dfuse Kulsakce. Zde
Cfurt das estabnlsdej tdat tde rune tdat a prlvate
pnalktlii oay brlkg lk actlfk ifr a pubnlc kulsakce
fkny li de fr sde suiierej jaoages jliierekt hlkj irfo
tdfse fi tde pubnlc at narge was lkappnlcabne ukness
ofketary jaoages were sfugdt Xsee New v. Superlfr Cfurt
(1<<3) 20 Can. App. :td 499, 25 Can. Rptr. 2j :2_.
1:-CY-######PAGE FI: 5OEOFRAKJA
8/11/2019 Nuisance Abatement Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nuisance-abatement-complaint 22/22
Pnalktlii seehs kf ofketary jaoages by dls cfopnalkt8
ratder, fkny tde lkmukctlve renlei tf wdlcd de ls
nawiunny ektltnej.
Respectiunny subolttej=
VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV Maoes Anak Busd JatePnalktlii lk prf per
VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV
VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV Ajjress Pdfke