04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
1
NGWA 2004Microbial GWQ Interest Group
Introduced Coliform Bacteria during Pump
Replacement and Well Service: Diagnosis
Prevention and Decontamination
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
2
ByMichael L. Vaught
EGIS441 Northside Dr
Chapel Hill, NC 27516
9199298363 or [email protected]
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
3
Two Wells that Became Coliform Positive after Pump Service
Calvary Baptist Daycare – Piedmont granitic rock aquifer– Salisbury, NC
Orchard at Altapass– Blue ridge gneiss rock aquifer– Altapass, NC (Blue Ridge Parkway)
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
4
History of Clean Tests
Calvary Baptist Daycare– Owners memory
Drilled in 1987 Daycare started in 1996 Tested clean until pump pulled
– Public Water records NCDENR Public Water Supply since 1996 Coliform positive = pump service in August, 20003
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
5
History of Clean Tests
Orchard at Altapass– Owner/ operators memory
Drilled in 1976 Tested clean until pump pulled Coliform positive = pump service in October, 20003
– Public Water records Available since Feb 2004 Owners records
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
6
Fractured Rock Aquifers
Partially Cased Open Rock Wells Unconfined Water Table Topography and elevation head Tectonic (Dikes, Faults, Emplacements) Borehole Stability Shallow Fractures = Less Filtration Time? Grout Seal Casing/Conduit
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
7
Downhole Video & Pumping
Observe All Three Stages– Static rest.– Pumping stress.– Recharge.
Characterize well.– Construction (leaky casing?)– Borehole stability (geology)– Biofouling– Water zones
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
13
Salisbury Field Project– Well Data
Calvary Baptist Daycare– 21’ of 6.25” galvanized casing- tight– 16’ to 170’ Slight biofouling– No shallow exposed water zones– 87’ slowly recharging water level– 170’ downward walls clean– 340’four inch standard submersible pump– 415’ significant water producing fracture– 455’ drillers well tag “Bottom of the Well”.
(well yield 17 gpm)
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
14
Altapass Field Project– Well Data
Orchard at Altapass– 30’ Water level. Walls are clean.– 55.5’ Bottom of the 6.25’galv csg. – tight.– 74’ Weathered fracture yielding 2 gpm– 155’ Major water bearing rock fracture zone– 273’ four inch standard submersible pump– 304’ “Bottom of the Well” from video.
(well yield about 10 gpm)
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
15
1st Failed attempt to disinfect
Salisbury– First ever Pump replacement in August– 8/14/03 coliform present in regular test– Well Super chlorinated and recirculated
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
16
2nd Failed attempt to disinfect
Salisbury– 8/27/04 coliform present in repeat tests– Well Super chlorinated and recirculated
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
17
3rd Failed attempt to disinfect
Salisbury– 10/06/04 coliform present in repeat tests– Well Super chlorinated and recirculated– 11/13/04 coliform present in repeat tests
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
19
Source of Introduced Coliform
Diagnosis by Downhole Video Survey – Construction (Ridgewood – Leaky Csg?).– Shallow water.– Space below the pump.– Grass and debris in the well
Pump service work – Salisbury is playground with wood chips– Altapass surrounded by apple orchard (Oct.)
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
21
Eliminating Introduced Coliform
Salisbury well– Extend pump to within four feet of the bottom– Draw the well down and back flush; cycles– Raise pH to 11 and recirculate overnight– Draw the well down and back flush– Create a 200 ppm chlorine solution in the well– Maintain pH of 6 with the chlorine at 200 ppm– Recirculate solution at least 4 hours– Apply positive head by back flushing– End of second day restore service, chlorinated water
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
22
Eliminating Introduced Coliform
Altapass well– Extend pump to within four feet of the bottom– Draw the well down and recirculate– Pulled the pump assembly onto wooden deck– Add chlorine tablets and gravel– Reinstall pump with sleeve to the bottom– Create a 200 ppm chlorine solution in the well– Maintain pH of 6 with the chlorine at 200 ppm– Recirculate solution overnight– Cyclic Draw down and recirculation– End of second day restore service, chlorinated water
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
23
Prevention
Pump service work – Ground cover or reel system– Clean & disinfect drop-pipe and wire– Replace twisted wire– Remove and replace tape– Rubber gloves– Work clean– “… Prevention is Worth a Pound of Cure”
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
26
Summary
Avoid repeat chlorinations Verify Well construction and condition Flow sleeve for pumps. Disinfection depends on distribution. Efficient chlorination (pH & ppm) Wells remain clean
04/19/23 EGIS, Well Video & Geophysical Services: 919-929-8363
27
References
Mansuy, N. (1999) Water Well Rehabilitation: a practical guide to understanding well problems and solutions, Lewis Publishers
Smith, S. A., Borch, M. A., and Noble, L. N. (1993) Evaluation and Restoration of Water Supply Wells, AWWA Research Foundation
Schnieders, J.H. (1999) Chemicals Used In Water Well Rehabilitation, U.S. Filter, Johnson Screens