Description of the Business
Introduction to Nestle
Name of Company: Nestlé S.A.
Nestlé AG
Nestlé Ltd.
Nestlé Caribbean Inc.
Nestlé Trinidad and Tobago Ltd.
Motto: Good Food, Good Life
Brief History
The Multinational Corporation known globally as Nestlé Limited was founded
in 1866 by Henri Nestlé and is today the world's biggest food and beverage
company. In 1905 Nestlé, the Swiss infant formula producer merged with the
Anglo-Swiss Condensed Milk Company and by 1914 the company was operating
factories in the United States, Britain, Germany and Spain. Finally, in 1957 the
1
Nestlé and Anglo-Swiss Condensed Milk Company (new name after merger)
commenced its operations in Picton Street, Port of Spain, Trinidad.
In 1962 the Anglo-Swiss Condensed Milk Company founded the Trinidad and
Tobago Food Products Ltd. and has made many breakthroughs since then. Up
until 1991 the Anglo-Swiss Condensed Milk Company changed its name to
Nestlé Trinidad and Tobago Ltd. Since 1866 Nestle has established 495 branches
to date and Nestlé Trinidad and Tobago Ltd. ranks within the first 10 in the
Nestle worldwide rankings. In conclusion Nestlé Worldwide Ltd. is a private
limited multinational corporation with Sales of CHF 98.5 billion, with a net
profit of CHF 9 billion. It employs around 265,000 people and has factories or
operations in almost every country in the world
2
Report
Analysis
Multinational Corporations
Nestlé Ltd. is a Multinational Corporation, “…A company that operates
globally through branches with their headquarters in one country” (Stimpson&
Singh, 2007, p.65). This is made possible through Globalization and Trade
Liberalization which encourages companies to expand globally with fewer
restrictions. Internal Factors that have led to Nestlé’s global growth are;
Nestlé continues to maintain its commitment to follow and respect all
applicable local laws in each of its markets.
Nestlé has positioned itself as a company promoting health and dietary
preference to its consumers.
Nestlé acquires dependable worldwide brands to build up its product
range.
3
The Multinational Corporation chosen to be assessed is Nestlé Trinidad and
Tobago Ltd. (NTTL), a branch of the Nestlé Worldwide Corporations with its
head office in Switzerland and regional office in Dominica (Nestle Caribbean
Inc.). Decentralization will occur in NTTL operating in Trinidad and Tobago
because according to their International Corporate Business Principles
located in appendix #2, it states that “Nestle as a consumer driven company it
allows the countries local, cultural desires to reflect the products and
services they provide”. Resulting in different decisions to be made by the
manager of NTTL compared to other regional managers.
The selection of ‘host countries’ is important because the head office will
want to maximize productivity and obtain a thriving global market share. The
factors that led to Nestlé Caribbean establishing a base of operations in
Trinidad and Tobago are;
Demand for products that catered to nutrition and dietary preference
among consumers
Geographical growth of the region
Local market and the purchasing power held by the consumer
Economic stability because of petroleum base
Liberalized Economy
Productive capacity
4
Natural resource over ability
Firstly, like most economies operating in the Caribbean region, Trinidad and
Tobago is a mixed economic system. Meaning there is both private and
governmental influence on economic activity in the country resulting in
significant fluctuations in the level of economic activity. Reasons for
Multinational Corporations establishing bases of operations in Trinidad and
Tobago are; to establish a thriving world market share and because of its natural
resources.
According to Questionnaire and interview information, go to appendix #1,
operating within Trinidad and Tobago’s mixed economic environment NTTL
experiences several problems. These problems are centralized around the
competition that a mixed economy allows from imported products. This causes
NTTL to be more efficient in terms of pricing; the price must be right, effective
and competitive, and productive efficiency must be right. This problem is a
result of Secondary companies who because of an open market are able to export
goods at a lower price and escape high labour cost. This also benefits NTTL
because as part of the Nestlé Worldwide group they use the liberalized
environment to import their products and sell at competitive prices.
Change in economic climate can greatly affect the size and growth of
businesses operating within the environment. Inflation has been fluctuating
within the Trinidad and Tobago economy. Presently Trinidad and Tobago is in
an economic “Boom” due to the rising prices of oil, natural gas, petroleum and
5
also its investment into infrastructure but it experienced a recession in the late
1980’s and medium 1990’s. Nevertheless, NTTL has been operating within
Trinidad and Tobago since 1957 and has continued to fortify its growth locally
through the expansion of its manufacturing facility and its product range shown
in appendix #3.
NTTL’s growth has been exceptional despite the many problems associated
with operating as a Multinational Corporation within Trinidad and Tobago.
These problems include environmental legislations that are forced on
Multinational Corporation’s to regulate their activity, the lack of skilled labour
and the lack of technology within Trinidad and Tobago. These cause many issues
for new Multinational Corporations’ looking to invest in the Trinidad and
Tobago business environment.
6
Globalization and Trade Liberalization
An assessment of how Globalization and Trade Liberalization affect the
decision-making process and growth of Multinational Companies in Trinidad and
Tobago cannot be made without first defining the terms. Globalization is defined
as “…The integration of economic, cultural, political, religious, and social
systems reaching the whole world and practically all human beings”.
(WorldTradeOrganization.org, 2007, Globalization). Also, Trade Liberalization
can be defined as “…A market model in which trade in goods and services
between or within countries flow unhindered by government-imposed
restrictions to trade like taxes, legislation, tariff and non-tariff trade barriers ”
(WorldTradeOrganization.org, 2007, Free-trade).
Firstly, the effect of Globalization and Trade Liberalization on the Trinidad
and Tobago economy causes changes in governmental policies, consumer wants
and competition among businesses.
Trade Liberalization removes environmental protectionist policies placed
by the government of Trinidad and Tobago, and where the laws are present
it is difficult to enforce them.
Consumer wants change drastically because of the wider range of goods
offered from foreign suppliers causing consumers to live above their
means.
7
Local businesses are forced to increase the quality of goods and services
that they provide due to foreign competition. This will increase their cost
of production and may eventually lead to closure of the business.
These changes in The Trinidad and Tobago economy brought upon by
Globalization and Trade Liberalization will affect NTTL as a Multinational
Corporation operating in the business environment. In relation to economic
changes NTTL operates on a ‘survival of the fittest’ policy. In accordance to
this policy NTTL has continued to improve its, quality, productivity and
competitiveness since its manufacturing facility opened in St.Augustine in 1962.
An example of this can be seen in their production methods implemented since
1972. The process is called the UHT (Ultra high Temperature) which allows
dairy and juice products to be stored without freezing for long periods of time.
Other processes used are Tetra Packing; this is a cheap, lightweight, efficiently
sealed container. NTTL was the pioneer of these processes in the Caribbean
region and it allowed NTTL to produce at a greater scale.
As a result of Globalization and Trade Liberalization commercial economies of
scale occurs and large organizations like NTTL can benefit from the cost
reduction per unit it offers when it produces large outputs . This in turn makes
NTTL more competitive and can import the products the consumer wants.
Recent changes in consumer wants caused by the rapid exchange of free
information which Globalization allows is a cause of concern for Multinational’s
in Trinidad and Tobago, particularly NTTL. Being a supplier of food and
beverage, NTTL has to be conscious of both the ageing and growing population.
8
Consumers today are more health conscious than they were 20 years ago so more
focus would be held on products that contain dietary fiber and anti-oxidants
(Medical healthJournals.com, 2008, Conclusion section, para. 1). In remedy to this NTTL has
added to their Corporate culture,’ innovate and renovate’, this meaning a
continual research and development of their products to suit changing consumer
interests. This led to the creation of their Skim milk brand and other health
awareness products, which can be found in appendix #3.
NTTL has a “stable” approach to the policies imposed by the Government of
Trinidad and Tobago, meaning NTTL has an agreement with the government to
produce its goods with few or little restrictions and regulations. Trinidad and
Tobago’s economy is developing due to Multinational involvement so
Government policies will aim to satisfy all four macroeconomic objectives and
maximize taxation according to Dearden (1994). Therefore only environmental
policies like the Consumer Protection Act (amended 1998) will affect how NTTL
does business because they have been responsible for years of wealth to the
local economy.
Finally, CARICOM (Caribbean Community) and the introduction of the CSME
(Caribbean Single Market and Economy) would have affected NTTL’s
operations. CARICOM promotes locally manufactured products when companies
use local inputs in its production. Without Globalization and Trade
Liberalization, CARICOM and the CSME’s function would not be possible.
When NTTL sponsors activities in Trinidad and Tobago like their annual
aerobics competitions or endorses local dairy farms to improve their level of
9
activity the government provides NTTL with tax breaks for their assistance in
the local economy.
Complying with the many effects and changes brought upon by Globalization
and Trade Liberalization NTTL continues to maintain quality, innovative and
positions itself as the number one food and Nutrition Company locally and
globally.
10
Decision Making Process
In accordance to the Globalized and Liberalized market in which Trinidad and
Tobago operates, NTTL has to make decisions to uphold and further develop
Nestlé’s worldwide market share. These decisions must be accurate, timely,
relevant and cost effective based on internal and external business information
gathered. The branch manager for NTTL has to make decisions in accordance to
the vision Nestlé Worldwide has set for its companies.
NTTL engages in the decision making process and has to follow the stages
involved in decision making, these are;
1. Problem Analysis
2. Data Collection
3. Analysis and Evaluation of Data
4. Formulate and Test Alternative Strategies
5. Implement The Decision
6. Evaluate The Decision
Following the decision making process will benefit NTTL when making future
important, strategic decisions. NTTL’s objective is to ‘think local, get global’,
since the organization is decentralized from its head office in Switzerland, this
method of decision-making makes the act of decision-making slower as it will
take time to run through the department heads. In the event that an important
structural change happens, NTTL carries out that decision in a structured and
11
systematic manner and communication comes after according to questionnaire
information, go to appendix #1.
Also, operating within the Trinidad and Tobago economy there are other
factors which affects how NTTL makes its decisions. NTTL makes its decisions
by looking at the long-term benefit of these decisions. A factor affecting
decision-making in Trinidad and Tobago will be the lack of Technology
available for mass production. This affected NTTL until they decided to upgrade
to Tetra packing in 1972, this was costly, but it increased production to 20,000
quarter-litres tetra packs per hour. This decision resulted in a future of large
scale production for NTTL.
Another factor affecting decision-making in NTTL is the social and cultural
constraints of Trinidad and Tobago. According to the Nestlé Corporate Business
Principles, go to appendix #2, NTTL supports the United Nations Global Compact’s
two guiding principles on human rights. Therefore NTTL supports the protection of
human rights within Trinidad and Tobago. These human rights laws forces NTTL’s
employees to comply with the laws Trinidad and Tobago. This therefore impacts on
the social and cultural decisions made by their Human Resource Department as
NTTL’s recruitment and selection methods must be in compliance with the tradit ions
of Trinidad and Tobago but to maintain standards of other Nestlé’s operating
worldwide.
NTTL is aware that increasing globalization is leading to the development of
more international recommendations to ‘developing countries’. These
recommendations are addressed to governments; they inevi tably have an impact
on a firm’s decision-making. Trinidad and Tobago’s government in an attempt to
12
cure unemployment increased spending in the areas of construction, education
and healthcare in the past few years. This results in an increase in wages and
higher national income. This is beneficial to NTTL because of the income
elasticity of demand for the goods that they provide within Trinidad and Tobago.
The manager has to make strategic decisions to supply goods that cater to
consumers increasing income and spending patterns. NTTL has maintained its
low income elasticity through its attempts to sustain a competitive price
therefore making it ‘recession proof’ to allow for clearer planning and steady
growth.
Questionnaire data has concluded, go to appendix #1, that NTTL’s manager
uses various decision-making tools, these include;
Critical Path analysis (CPA); This assesses the shortest possible time in
which a product can be completed
Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) - a measure of the costs paid alongside with
the benefits gained of completing a product.
Decision Trees- a quantitative decision-making approach of tracing the
alternative outcomes of any decision.
These decision-making tools are a quantitative approach as NTTL focuses more
on profit based objectives. The manager of NTTL also believes that there isn’t
one way of doing things and applies contingency theories to his decision-making
focusing at the micro and macro economic elements aiming at both market and
consumer interests.
13
Evaluation
Based on objective one outlined earlier in the internal assessment on
Multinational Corporations, NTTL has done a considerable amount in the
development of Trinidad and Tobago’s food and nutrition industry; see NTTL’s
timeline of important events in Appendix #4.The timeline shows how NTTL has
continued to fortify its size, growth and profitability as it became one of the
worlds largest Multinational Corporations and the largest food and beverage
company by maintaining its standards worldwide. NTTL continues to uphold its
customer protection, labour and an environmental standard stated in its
Corporate Business Principles, go to appendix #2, and is one of the most ethical
companies operating on the global market.
Compared to other Multinational Corporations operating within Trinidad and
Tobago NTTL has grown to be a part of the daily life of citizens creating goods
like Orchard, Nestum and Nescafe to satisfy all age and ethnic groups within
Trinidad and Tobago.
Based on objective two on the effects of Globalization and Trade
Liberalization, NTTL has been operating effectively despite the disadvantages
like competition associated with free trade. NTTL reaps the benefits of
economies of scale allowing it to produce a lower unit cost compared to other
small organizations operating within Trinidad and Tobago.
14
Based on objective three in this internal assessment on Decision-Making NTTL
continues to make important strategic decisions which help it operate on the
long-term and consumer-market based interests. This can be seen when NTTL
upgraded to Tetra Packing in 1972. NTTL also continues to make decisions that
benefit Trinidad and Tobago’s economy like the sponsorship of local events,
including the annual savannah run and assistance of local dairy farmers.
In conclusion, based on observations of NTTL being a Multinational
Corporation operating and making decisions in Trinidad and Tobago it has
grown significantly. This is only possible because of the expert decisions made
by the local manager to implement contingencies as remedies to situations which
involve the local and global-liberalized market. This expertise decision making
despite its decentralized nature has led NTTL to achieve a place in Nestlé’s
worldwide top ten rankings. With respect to Globalization and Trade
Liberalization it does more good than harm. The changes encountered in the
social, economical, international and cultural only elevate NTTL’s
competitiveness on the global market.
15
Recommendations
From the analysis and evaluation I have concluded some recommendations
which will help the business to achieve further profitability.
Invite more schools to test out new products, so culture developed
products can be assessed.
Invest further into customer service to satisfy local consumers.
More focus on environmental protection is needed. NTTL has to make
their environmental protection policies more publicized.
Establish environmental objectives, monitor progress, checks results and
define future actions.
Communicate decisions beforehand to employees, when a change is about
to be made.
16
APPENDIX #1
Questionnaire
Thesis: An examination on how Trade Liberalization (TL) and Globalization
(GL) affect the decision making process and growth of Multinational
Corporations (MNC’s) in Trinidad
Business and Economic Systems
1. What type of Company is Nestle?
………………………………………………………………………………………
…
2. How does operating in a mixed economic system affect the production of
Nestlé’s goods?
………………………………………………………………………………………
….
3. Are there any advantages of operating in Trinidad’s mixed economy?
………………………………………………………………………………
18
Also, are there any possible disadvantages to nestle, by operating in a
mixed economy?
…………………………………………………………………………………………...
4. What are some of the advantages and disadvantages of operating in the
Caribbean Business environment?
………………………………………………………………………………………
……..
5. How have the economic practices of Trinidad and Tobago impacted on
Nestle Trinidad in terms of size and growth?
………………………………………………………………………………………
…….
Multinational Corporations
6. What are the reasons that contributed to the growth of Nestle worldwide?
………………………………………………………………………………………
……..
7. Describe the disadvantages associated with Nestle operating on a global
level.
19
………………………………………………………………………………………
……..
8. What are the factors that have influenced Nestle to establish a branch of
operations in Trinidad?
………………………………………………………………………………………
……...
The Impact of Trade Liberalization and Globalization on Nestle
10. The impacts of Trade Liberalization and Globalization are as follows,
how do these impacts affect Nestle?
These impacts are:
(a) Changes in the economy
………………………………………………………………………………………
………..
(b) International agreements
…………………………………………………………………………
(c) Changes to governments’ policies
………………………………………………………………………………………
……….
20
(d) Changing consumer tastes and wants
………………………………………………………………………………………
………..
(e) Competition from other Multinational firms
………………………………………………………………………………………
……….
11. Does Nestle export its products to neighboring Caribbean territorities?
Yes NO
12. What major social and economic changes as a result of globalization and
trade liberalization within Trinidad and Tobago, has the company experienced
while operating?
………………………………………………………………………………………………
..
13. What measure has been taken to adapt to these changes?
………………………………………………………………………………………………
..
14. What approaches has Nestle taken to maintain global market share?
21
………………………………………………………………………………………………
..
15. How have CARICOM and the introduction of the CSME affected Nestlé’s
operations?
………………………………………………………………………………………………
..
Decision Making process in Nestle
16. What type of decision making process is used by nestle?
………………………………………………………………………………………………
..
17. List the benefits and drawbacks of the decision making process used?
………………………………………………………………………………………………
..
18. Does nestle practice centralized or decentralized decision making?
19. Are important decisions based upon market interest or consumer interest?
22
………………………………………………………………………………………………
20. How has the decision making process in Nestle Trinidad Limited been
affected by Government (political and Legal)
………………………………………………………………………………………………
23
Appendix#2
Nestlé Corporate Business Principles
Nestlé is committed to the following Business Principles in all countries, taking
into account local legislation, cultural and religious practices:–
Nestlé’s business objective, and that of management and employees at all
levels, is to manufacture and market the Company’s products in such a
way as to create value that can be sustained over the long term for
shareholders, employees, consumers, business partners and the large
number of national economies in which Nestlé operates;
– Nestlé does not favor short-term profit at the expense of successful
long-term business development, but recognizes the need to generate a
healthy profit each year in order to maintain the support of our
shareholders and the financial markets, and to finance investments;
– Nestlé recognizes that its consumers have a sincere and legitimate
interest in the behavior, beliefs and actions of the Company behind
brands in which they place their trust, and that without its consumers the
Company would not exist;
– Nestlé believes that, as a general rule, legislation is the most effective
safeguard of responsible conduct, although in certain areas, additional
guidance to staff in the form of voluntary business principles is beneficial
24
in order to ensure that the highest standards are met throughout the
organization;
– Nestlé is conscious of the fact that the success of a corporation is a
reflection of the professionalism, conduct and the responsible attitude of
its management and employees. Therefore recruitment of the right people
and ongoing training and development are crucial;
– Nestlé operates in many countries and in many cultures throughout the
world. This rich diversity is an invaluable source for our leadership. No
single document can capture every legal obligation that may be required
in each of these countries. Indeed, there may be conflicting legal
requirements. Nestlé continues to maintain its commitment to follow and
respect all applicable local laws in each of its markets. If an
interpretation of anything contained in this document is construed as
contrary to local laws, such interpretation should not be followed in that
country.
25
Appendix #3
Nestlé’s Main Brands
Today Nestlé© is present in different markets with the following main brands:
CoffeeNescafe©, Nespresso,Taster’s Choice, Ricoré,
Ricoffy, Bonka, Zoégas, Loumidis
Water
Poland Spring, Nestlé© Pure Life, Arrowhead,
Vittel, Deer Park, Levissima, Perrier, S.Pellegrino,
Ozarka, Contrex, Ice Mountain, Zephyrhills, Nestlé©
Aquarel, Hépar, Acqua Panna,
Other beveragesNestea, Nesquik, Nescau, Milo, Carnation,
Libby’s, Caro, Nestomalt, Nestlé©
Dairy - Shelf stable
Nestlé©, Nido, Nespray, Ninho, Carnation,
Milkmaid, La Lechera, Moça, Klim, Gloria, Svelty,
Molico, Nestlé© Omega Plus, Bear Brand, Coffee-
Mate
Dairy - ChilledNestlé©, Sveltesse, La Laitière, La Lechera, Ski,
Yoco, Svelty, Molico, LC1, Chiquitin
Ice cream
Nestlé©, Antica Gelateria del Corso, Dreyer's/Edy's,
Drumstick/Extrême, Maxibon/Tandem, Mega,
Mövenpick, Sin Parar/Sem Parar/Non Stop, Delta
Infant nutrition Nestlé©, Nan, Lactogen, Beba, Nestogen, Cerelac,
26
Nestum, Neslac, Guigoz, Good Start
Performance nutrition PowerBar, Pria, Musashi
HealthCare nutrition Nutren, Clinutren, Peptamen, Modulen
Bouillons, soups,
seasonings, pasta, sauces
Maggi, Buitoni, Thomy, Winiary,Torchin, Osem,
Totole, Haoji
Frozen foods (prepared
dishes, pizzas, small
meals)
Stouffers€™s, Lean Cuisine, Hot Pockets, Buitoni,
Maggi, Wagner, La Cocinera
Refrigerated products
(cold meat products,
dough, pasta, pizzas,
sauces, snacks)
Nestlé©, Buitoni, Herta, Toll House, Sabra
Chocolate, confectionery
and biscuits
Nestlé© Crunch, Cailler, Galak/Milky bar, Kit Kat,
Smarties, Butterfinger, Aero, Polo
Nestlé© Professional Chef, Davigel, Minor’s
Pet care
Purina, Friskies, Fancy Feast, Alpo, Gourmet, Mon
Petit , Felix, Dog Chow, Cat Chow, Pro Plan, Purina
ONE, Beneful, Tidy Cats
27
Appendix #4
Nestlé Trinidad and Tobago Timeline
Key dates
1866 Foundation of Anglo-Swiss Condensed Milk Co.
1867 Henry Nestlé’s Infant cereal developed
1929 Merger with Peter, Cailler, Kohler Chocolats Suisses S.A.
1934 Launch of Milo
1938 Launch of Nescafe©
1947 Nestlé© Alimentana S.A. (New name after merger with Maggi)
1957 The Anglo-Swiss Condensed Milk Company commenced its
operations in Picton Street, Port of Spain, Trinidad.
1962 The Anglo-Swiss Condensed Milk Company founded the Trinidad
and Tobago Food Products Ltd
1948 Launch of Nestea and Nesquik
1969 Vittel (initially equity interest only)
1971 Merger with Ursina-Franck
28
1973 Stouffer (with Lean Cuisine)
1974 L’Oreal (associate)
1977 Nestlé© S.A. (new company name)
1985 Carnation (with Coffee Mate and Friskies)
1990 Cereal Partners Worldwide (joint venture with General Mills)
1991 the Anglo-Swiss Condensed Milk Company changed its name to
Nestlé Trinidad and Tobago Ltd
1991 Beverage Partners Worldwide (joint venture with Coca-Cola)
29
Bibliography
References from:
Hall D, Jones R, Raffo C, (2007), Business Studies 3 r d Edition . London:
Causeway Press Ltd.
Stimpson P, Singh K, (2007), Management of Business Unit one . United
Kingdom: Cambridge University Press.
GA Cole, (1997), Management Theory and Practice 5 t h Edition : London:
Ashford Color Press.
Stewart R, (1994), Managing Today and Tomorrow . London: Macmillan.
Dearden C& Foster M, (1994), Organizational Decision-Making.
Singapore: Longman Singapore Publishers Pte Ltd.
Nestle. (2008). Corporate Business Principles. Retrieved January 18,
2008 3:28:48 PM from
http://www.Nestle.com/CorporateBusinessPrinciples.pdf
Free Trade. (2007). Globalization and Trade Liberalization . Retrieved
September 30, 2007, 6:51:24 PM from
http://www.WorldTradeOrganization.org/freetrade.html
Consumers Today. (2008). Modern eating Habits . Retrieved January 18,
2008 3:50:36 PM from http://www. Medicalhealthjournals.com
30