This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 649829.
M&V why, what, and how? M&V platform SMIV
Mia Dragović, Energy Institute Hrvoje Požar
July 21, 2016
• Intro to MultEE project and useful resources • Lessons learned from Croatian case
o Data collection o SMIV
• Problems, misconceptions • Conclusions
Further feedback à [email protected]
Content
7/21/2016 www.multEE.eu/
How?
What?
M&V why, what and how?
Why - the point?
7/21/2016 www.multEE.eu/ M&V why, what and how?
Monitoring, measurement and verification!
M&VM&
Monitoring is crucial and it pays off!
1. Zero step 2. Mind the Footprint 3. Limited financing
What do me monitor? • Bottom-up vs. top-down • Scope – national vs. local / double-counting • Actual or factual measurement:
1. Deemed or ex-ante à consistency! 2. Metered or ex-post à benefits beyond energy savings (e.g. sensitivity
towards en. poverty) 3. Scaled 4. Surveyed
What is the purpose? • EU Directives, legislative requirements • Actual savings as incentive for savings • ESCOs and EPCs
What is the cost? • Accuracy vs. cost
Misconseptions, work in progress…
7/21/2016 www.multEE.eu/ M&V why, what and how?
Aims to improve the consistency and quality of energy efficiency policy planning and implementation through:
• Innovative monitoring and verification schemes
• Improved coordination between different administrative levels
Deliverables:
1. European best practices for M&V schemes and coordination mechanisms - Why do countries without an established centralized structure implement more efficient M&V schemes? Which countries have introduced more efficient coordination mechanisms, and what are their functioning structures?
2. Report on General Formulae of Bottom-Up Methods - a comprehensive report with a variety of methods to calculate energy savings from single energy efficiency measures.
3. Synthesis report on M&V schemes and coordination mechanisms in EU countries - results of the mapping of the existing M&V schemes and coordination mechanism in the 28 Member States plus the FYR of Macedonia.
4. Analytical framework for mapping and analysis
MultEE H2020 project 2015 - 2017
7/21/2016 www.multEE.eu/ M&V why, what and how?
Partners adopting M&V platform (localized): • Lithuania, Latvia, Sovakia, Macedonia, Greece Partners with already implemented M&V platform: • Austria, Croatia Partners and beneficiaries who did not opt for M&V platform: • Germany – has local implementation and TD approach • Denmark – has developed system for monitoring EEOs Others through GIZ: Ukraine, Moldova
MultEE partner-countries’ status:
7/21/2016 www.multEE.eu/ M&V why, what and how?
• List of BU measures suggested by country‘s official Methodology
• Translation of all terms and expression used in MVP • Check and input of reference values in MVP code-table
according to country‘s recommendation
• Transfer to local server
• MVP administrator training
If your country is interested… ask!
Adaptation for countries‘ specific requirements
7/21/2016 www.multEE.eu/ M&V why, what and how?
• Croatia still struggles with EE, but…
Example from Croatia
7/21/2016 www.multEE.eu/ M&V why, what and how?
Measured TD 11,96 PJ
Le# to be achieved to 2016. 7,81 PJ
Croa:a’s EE target a=er 2nd NEEAP
2nd NEEAP: 38% of savings or 23% of our target measured BU!
2015: Ar. 5 200% 40% of our target measured BU!
• In line with the Croatian NEEAP • Measures targets under EED (bootom-up):
Article 3 ü Article 5 ü Article 7 targets ü Avoided double counting ? Manageable number of obligated parties
• M&V started as a project in cooperation with GIZ in 2008 • Has become an official Croatian M&V tool through the new
EE Act (OG 127/2014)
How? SMIV - System for Monitoring, Measurement and Verification of Energy Savings
7/21/2016 www.multEE.eu/ M&V why, what and how?
Public sector • Planning • SMIV • EMIS
Distributors
• Planning
Including all sectors
7/21/2016 www.multEE.eu/ M&V why, what and how?
Large companies, industry
• Energy audits
SMEs • Eco Fund
Financial Institutions
• Planning
Residential • Eco Fund
Carrots • Eco fund –34% • Operational Programme
Competitiveness and Cohesion
Sticks • Obligatory data monitoring
and delivery: Companies providing energy service contracts Public sector Subsidy providers
• Fines for physical person responsible (e.g. mayor, prefect, minister) and the public body
~ 1000 – 80.000 €
Motivation mechanisms
7/21/2016 www.multEE.eu/ M&V why, what and how?
When planning EE measures, funding needs to be ensured in the local budget!
• Competition among local governments
• ~ 7000 measures registered so far, 5000 are insulation • 30 local EE plans entered into SMIV • Savings verified in 2015.: cca 0,61 PJ • 80 educated users
SMIV - status
7/21/2016 www.multEE.eu/ M&V why, what and how?
LocationEnergy savings
CO2 savings (t)
Measure cost
subvention (kn) Sector Group
Splitsko-‐dalmatinska 9.438.889 2.520 68.140.514 23.018.658 ZGRADARSTVO USLUŽNI JAVNIGrad Zagreb 1.947.450 456 62.478.120 15.736.404 ZGRADARSTVO KUĆANSTVAGrad ZagrebZagreb-‐Maksimir1.478.701 405 3.526.493 1.410.597 ZGRADARSTVO USLUŽNI JAVNIKrapinsko-‐zagorskaKrapina 1.311.855 265 2.698.973 729.865 ZGRADARSTVO KUĆANSTVAGrad ZagrebZagreb-‐Maksimir1.216.532 333 2.526.603 1.010.641 ZGRADARSTVO USLUŽNI JAVNIZagrebačkaZagreb-‐Maksimir1.121.828 227 2.850.618 760.185 ZGRADARSTVO KUĆANSTVAKoprivničko-‐križevačkaKoprivnica 1.016.830 205 1.533.374 613.350 ZGRADARSTVO USLUŽNI JAVNIKoprivničko-‐križevačkaKoprivnica 904.045 183 2.190.287 876.115 ZGRADARSTVO USLUŽNI JAVNISisačko-‐moslavačka 807.796 221 609.897 243.959 ZGRADARSTVO KUĆANSTVAKarlovačkaKarlovac 761.097 203 2.268.031 907.212 ZGRADARSTVO KUĆANSTVA
No double-counting!
Additional information:
7/21/2016 www.multEE.eu/ M&V why, what and how?
More about SMIV: http://cei.hr/en/smiv-system-measuring-and-verifying-energy-savings/
More about MultEE M&V platform:
GIZ & Open regional funds for South-East Europe – Energy Efficiency https://www.giz.de/en/worldwide/31746.html
Please, ask!