Developments in Health Care in the Czech Republic
in 2010 - 2011
MUDr. Zdeněk Mrozek, Ph.D.Vice-President, Czech Medical Chamber
OutlineMain problems of the Czech Health Care
SystemThank you we are leaving – the biggest and
the most successful campaign of the Czech medical doctors
Health Care ReformConclusions
2
Main problems of Czech health care
Lack of funds
Lack of qualified zdravhealth careprofessionals
3
I am afraid, Dear Colleagues, that this is more serious than we thought!
Injustice in health insurance payments
Not all really pay 13,5 % from their incomes Payments by state for economically non-active population
Payment by the state for 60 % of inhabitants, who consume 80 % of health care, represents only 24 % of health insurance companies incomes
Increase of payments by state is a political decision
5
6
Monthly insurance premium
Employees 2 865,- CZK
Self-employed persons 1 243,- CZK
Persons with no taxable income 1 080,- CZK
Persons whose health insurance is paid by the state
723,- CZK
6
Injustice in health insurance payments
Exodus of Czech doctors
Certificate of Good Standing
Certificate of non-membership
in the CMC
Total
2006 348 3482007 339 3392008 263 50 3132009 272 64 3362010 557 134 691
7
Source: CMC Registry
Physicians leaving the Czech Republic – per age
Age 2008 2009 TotalUp to 30 years 22 37 59 11,0 %
30 – 40 135 135 270 50,5 %40 – 50 67 70 137 25,6 %
50 – 60 31 24 55 10,3 %
Above 60 8 6 14 2,6 %
Total 263 272 535 100,0 %
8
114 university graduates are to be added to the above figures. They left CRin the years 2008 and 2009 without taking employment in CR as physicians.
Practising doctors are aging
Up to 50 years of age
Above 60 years of age
2000 67 % 11,5 %
2007 56 % 16,0 %
9
The share of resp. age groups among practising doctors
Number of foreign doctors working in CR
Number of doctors
2003 8292004 1 0972005 1 1882006 1 6192007 1 8492008 2 0152009 2 129
10
Reasons of dissatisfaction of hospital doctors
Low salaries and economic dependence on overtime work
Overburdening – Labour Code and EWTD are not observed
Worse working conditions in comparison to private doctors
Disintegration of the training systemCorruption The loss of hope for a better future
11
Thank you we are leaving initiative
Demands of doctors formulated in March 2010Increase of salaries for the basic working time to the
level of 1,5 – 3 times the average salary in CR depending on qualification and experience. The same rules valid for all hospitals
A new system of further education of doctors which should be organised by the medical chamber.
Increase of payments from the health insurance companies to all health care facilities.
12
Mass resignations from employment = efficient form of
protest
Genuine strikes are impossible in health care system as doctors have to secure the acute medical care.
Mass resignation from employment is an efficient “strike“, fully legal.Criminal prosecution of participants and organisers of the
movement refused by the courts.
13
Action announced in May 2010Doctors will hand over their resignations from
employment on 31 December 2010 and from that date the two months notice period runs.
Announced prior to elections, when it was not clear which party will form the government.
Politicians were given few months time to fulfil the doctors’ demands.
Doctor’s Trade Union Club gained time to mobilise the doctors and to convince the general public.
14
13 Reasons for the ExodusUnderfinanced health careLow payment for economically not active
persons by the state Personnel devastation in hospitals –
overburdening of remaining doctorsLow salaries of doctors (100 – 200 CZK/hour)Violation of the Labour CodeDestructed system of further education of
doctorsChaotic medical drug policyStrange hospital management – overpriced
supplies and appliancesUnfulfilled promises of politicians…
15
3 830 doctors gave notice to December 31st 2010
Notice from employment was given in total by 22 % of hospital doctors.
Large regional differences in numbers of noticesDifferences according to specialisation:
Mostly anaesthetists, surgeons, neonatologists, obstetricians, neurologists
Doctors from private hospitals involved only in very small numbers. Several university hospitals did not participate, including the biggest one – University Hospital Motol in PragueIntimidation of employees or preventive increase of salaries
19
Compromise has been reached14. 2. 2011
20
On 16th February 2011, the regional Doctor‘s Union representatives accepted the agreement.
Signature of the final memorandum 17. 2. 2011
21
Minister of Health L. Heger and Chairman of Doctors‘ Union M. Engel.The Czech Doctors‘ Union ended the campaign and called on doctors to return to work.On February 23rd 2011, Government approves the agreement as well as the increase of doctors' salaries.
The victoryThe biggest jump in the salary increases of employed doctors‘ in
the past 20 yearsReached at the same time when the government reduced the salaries in the
public sector by 10 %CR accepted the doctors‘ demand for a salary ranging between 1,5
– 3 times of the average national salary depending on their qualification and length of practice.
CR committed itself to reduce the amount of overtime work of doctors and to respect EWTD.
The ministry committed itself to cooperation on the health care reform with the representatives of doctors, including the Czech Medical Chamber and Doctors‘ Trade Union.
22
Conditions for campaign success Great dissatisfaction of doctorsEfficient form of protestStrong organisation (Physicians´ Union Club)Keeping the unity of the majority of doctors
Supported by CMCHelp of professionals – PR agency
Struggle for favourable public opinionBreaking the unity of politicians
Negotiating with the political opposition and with individual members of the coalition government
23
Health care reform goals To create a stable and transparent environment for
medical care respecting normal social and economic rules.
To find a fair compromise between the „unlimited“ possibilities of medical science and the limited economic resources.
To create for patients a friendly health care with satisfied health professionals.
To respect EU membership of the Czech Republic and to avoid experiments.
Reform is not made for one electoral term – consensus. 24
Health Care ReformHealth care reform laws passed in the Lower Chamber of
the Czech Parliament in July, August and September 2011Main positive changes: introducing standards of
treatment, possibility to pay for above-standard treatment openly, better definition of lege artis treatment
Main negatives: changes not discussed with opposition parties and health care professionals, transparency of the system remains the same, in some cases even worse, more bureaucracy
25
ConclusionsCzech health care = one of the best health care
systems in the world Last 20 years - changes due to not only fast
development of medical science, but also due to vast and profound changes in the Czech society
The main issues in Czech health care: - exodus of Czech physicians- non-transparent financing
Necessary reforms - consensus of all parties, politicians and professionals
26