1
Market Structure:
Monopolistic Competition
2
Imperfect competition
A market structure between the extremes of perfect competition and monopoly
3
Today’s discussionWhat is the competitive strategy in M.C?How the equilibrium price and quantity are determined in M.C? -in the short run and -in the long run
4
Monopolistic Competition
• Many small sellers
• Differentiated product
• Easy entry
5
Product differentiation
The process of creating real or apparent differences between goods and services
6
Many small sellersEach firm is so small relative to the total market
Each firm’s pricing decisions have a negligible effect on the market price
7
Examples
• Most common in retail sector • Toothpaste• Clothing• Restaurants• Detergents etc
8
Easy entry in monopolistic competition?
Not as easy as in perfect competition (Why?)
9
Because of product differentiation
10
Nonprice competition
• Competition in ways other than pricing policies
11
Non-price competition
A firm competes using advertising, packaging, product development, better service, rather than lower prices
12
Price taker or price maker?
Product differentiation gives the firm some control over its price. Hence price maker.
13
Some monopoly power due to
• Better service
• Greater range of product verities
• Slightly lower price
14
Competitive and Monopolistic elements
• Many sellers of the differentiated product (competitive element)
• The product sold by each seller is somewhat different from the product sold by other seller (monopoly element)
15
Demand curve for monopolistic competition
It is less elastic (steeper) than for a perfectly competitive firm and more elastic (flatter) than for a monopolist (Why?)
16
Because of the availability of many close substitutes, the demand curve faced by a monopolistically competitive firm is highly elastic
-What is the implication?
17
Product variation and Selling expenses
• Product Variation: Changes in some of the characteristics of the product
• Selling expenses: All those expenses that the firm incurs to advertise the product, increase its sales force, provide better servicing for its product etc
18
Effectiveness and Effect of
Advertising
`Somewhat effective in the short-run but less effective in the long-run
19
Effect of advertising on Average cost of
production
It raises the long-run average cost (LAC)
20
2.001.501.00
.50
2 4 6 8
2.503.003.504.00
10 12 14 16 18
The effect of Advertising on Costs
LAC2
Co
st p
er u
nit With advertising
Without advertisingLAC1
P
Q
21
What price to charge and how many units
to produce?
MR = MC
22
2015105
1 2 3 4
25304050
5 6 7 8 9
AC
MCMR=MC
DMR
ProfitAVC
P
Q
Profit in the short-run (P>MC)
23
Can Monopolistically competitor make more than
normal profit in the long run?
24
Why only normal profit in the long-run?
Leftward shift in the firm’s demand curve (why?)
&The upward shift in the LAC curve (why?)
25
2015105
1 2 3 4
25303540
5 6 7 8 9
LAC
MC
DMR
In Long-run, only normal profit due to more selling expenses/advertisements (P=LAC)
AVC
P
Q
26
Efficiency of monopolistic competition
Less resources are used and a higher price is charged than would be the case under perfect competition
27
2015105
1 2 3 4
25303540
5 6 7 8 9
LAC
MC
DMR
Monopolistic Competition
AVC
Minimum LAC
P
Q
28
2015105
1 2 3 4
3025
3540
5 6 7 8 9
LACMC
MRP
rice
& C
ost
per
un
itMinimum
LAC
Perfect CompetitionP
Q
29
Summary
• Product differentiation
• Some monopoly power over price• More selling price
• More efficient than monopoly
• In the short run, above-normal profit
• In the long run, only normal profit due to competition
30
Market Structure: Oligopoly
• Few sellers
• Either homogeneous or a differentiated product
• Difficult market entry
31
Few sellers
• Few firms are so large relative to the total
market
• They can affect the market price
32
Sources of oligopoly (barriers to entry)
Economies of scale
33
Example
• Aluminum Industry in India• Bharat Aluminum Company
Limited and Hindalco accounting for 88 % of production
• Hindalco –one of the most cost-efficient producers globally
34
Entry barrier…
• Huge capital investments and specialised inputs (automobiles, aluminum and steel etc)
35
Entry barrier…
• A few firms may own a patent for the exclusive right to produce a commodity (eg: pharma firms, for instance)
36
Entry barrier…
• Loyal customer base for established firms
• A few firms may own or control the entire supply of a raw material required in the production of the product
37
Entry barrier…
• Limit pricingExisting firms charge a price low enough to discourage entry into the industry.
By doing so, they voluntarily sacrifice short-run profits in order to maximize long run profits
38
Price Wars &Nonprice competition
Price competition- mostly price cut to compete
Competition in ways other than pricing policies (eg: more advertising)
39
Nonprice competition
• Oligopolists usually prefer to compete on the basis of product differentiation, advertising, and services
40
Example
• Pepsi vs Coca-Cola huge advertising campaign
41
Distinguishing feature of oligopoly
Mutual interdependence or
Rivalry among a few firms in the industry
42
Mutual interdependence
An action by one firm may cause a reaction on the part of other firms
43
Example
• In Airlines Industry
• Telephone
• Soft drinks
44
Pricing Behaviour
The way firm behave depends on how they think rival firms will respond to pricing strategy
45
Pricing strategy models
Difficulty in predicting pricing behaviour
-Nonprice competition model -A kinked demand curve
model-Price leadership model-Cartel model
46
Kinked demand curve model
Rival’s reactions
Rival firms will match a firm’s price decrease, but ignore a price increase
47
20015010050
5 10 15 20
250300350400
25 30 35 40 45
Oligopolist’s Kinked Demand Curve
Rivals ignore price increase
Rivals match price cut
P
Q
Initial price & demand
48
Pricing Strategy-Price Leadership-
They play the game “follow the leader” -- price leadership
49
Price leadership
A pricing strategy in which a dominant firm sets the price for an industry and the other firms follow
50
Price leadership
When a dominant firm in an industry raises or lowers price, other firms follow suit.
51
CartelA group of firms formally agreeing to control the price and output of a product.
Cartel may behave like a monopoly
52
Cartel
• Maximisation of joint profits• Sharing of the market by
agreement on quotas • Firms compete on non-price
basis• But, price wars starts when
any firm cheats
53
Examples
• Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC)
• International Telephone Cartel (CCITT)
• International Airline Cartel (IATA)
54
The major weakness of a cartel
Member firms cheating
55
Summary
56
Imperfect competition is the market structure between the extremes of perfect competition and monopoly Monopolistic competition and oligopoly belong to the imperfect competition category.
57
Monopolistic competition is a market structure characterized by (1) many small sellers, (2) a differentiated product, and (3) easy market entry and exit. Given these characteristics, firms in monopolistic competition have a negligible effect on the market price.
58
Product differentiation is a key characteristic of monopolistic competition. It is the process of creating real or apparent differences between products.
59
Nonprice competition includes advertising, packaging, product development, better quality, and better service. Under imperfect competition, firms may compete using nonprice competition, rather than price competition.
60
Short-run equilibrium for a monopolistic competitor can yield economic losses, zero economic profits, or economic profits. In the long run, monopolistic competitors make zero economic profits.
61
Comparing monopolistic competition with perfect competition, we find that the monopolistic competitive firm does not achieve allocative efficiency,charges a higher price, restricts output, and does not produce where average costs are at a minimum.
62
Oligopoly is a market structure characterized by (1) few sellers, (2) a homogeneous or differentiated product, and (3) difficult market entry. Oligopolies are mutually interdependent because an action by one firm may cause a reaction on the part of other firms.
63
The nonprice competition model is a theory that might explain oligopolistic behavior. Under this theory, firms use advertising and product differentiation, rather than price reductions, to compete.
64
The kinked demand curve is a model that explains why prices may be rigid in an oligopoly. The kink is established because an oligopolist assumes that rivals will match a price decrease, but ignore a price increase.
65
Price leadership is another theory of pricing behavior under oligopoly. When a dominant firm in an industry raises or lowers price, other firms follow suit.
66
A cartel is a formal agreement among firms to set prices and output quotas. The goal is to maximize profits, but firms have an incentive to cheat, which is a constant threat to a cartel.
67
Comparing oligopoly with perfect competition, we find that the oligopolist allocates resources inefficiently, charges a higher price, and restricts output so that price may exceed average cost.
68
PRICING PRACTICES
• Introduction
• Marginal Cost Pricing Rule
• Uniform Pricing vs Price Discrimination
• Multiple-Unit Pricing Strategies
Two-Part Pricing
Bundling
69
PRICING PRACTICES…
• Markup- Pricing/ Cost plus Pricing
• Pricing of Multiple ProductsJoint product pricingTransfer pricing
• Summary
70
Introduction
A pricing strategy aims to enlarge the customer base that the firm can sell to, and capture as much consumer surplus as possible.
71
Introduction
Pricing without market power (perfect competition) is determined by market supply and demand.
72
Introduction
• Perfectly competitive market
• MR=MC rule
• Price is set at marginal cost of production (P = MC)
73
Introduction
• Firms with market power have the potential to earn large profits (Why?)
• But realizing that potential may depend critically on the firm’s pricing strategy.
74
Introduction
• Pricing with market power (imperfect competition) requires the individual producer to know much more about the characteristics of demand.
• Characteristics of demand??
75
Introduction
• The simplest way to set price is through uniform pricing.
• That is a seller charges the same price for every unit of the product.
• It is least profitable way to set a price
76
Introduction
• The most profitable pricing policy is complete price discrimination (First degree PD)
• Every buyer is charged the maximum he/she is willing for pay for each unit
• Second degree & Third degree PD
77
Multiple-Unit Pricing
• When products have different values for different customers, profits can be enhanced by using multiple unit pricing
• Multiple unit pricing can result in some combination of “per unit” and “lump sum”
Example: Two part pricing
78
The Two-Part Pricing
The purchase of some products and services can be separated into two decisions, and therefore, two prices.
79
The Two-Part Pricing
Examples
1) Amusement Park
• Pay to enter
• Pay for rides and food within the park
2) Tennis Club
• Pay to join
• Pay to play
80
The Two-Part Pricing
• Charge all customers a fixed “membership” fee per month or per year, plus a per unit usage charge
• Choosing the trade-off between
Free-entry and high use prices or
High-entry fee and low user fee.
81
Bundling Price
Practice of selling two or more products together for a single price.
Examples?
82
Bundling
• Computer companies
• Car manufacturers (vehicle with AC, cassette decks etc)
• Hospitality sector (Room plus rent a car)
83
Bundling
• Bundling is more common (why?)
• It requires less information about tastes and preferences of consumers (compared to price discrimination)
84
Bundling
• Condition necessary for bundling
–Preferences of the consumers should be negatively related
85
How bundling can increase profits? An Example
Two consumers A & B (Tourists) and their willingness to pay
Consumer Room Rent a Car
Type A Rs 800 Rs 400
Type B Rs 1200 Rs 200
86
Example…
• If room charge is > Rs 800, consumer A will not stay in hotel
• If rent a car charge is > Rs 200, consumer B will not rent a car
87
Example…
• So maximum separate price the company can charge is
Rs.800 for room
Rs.200 for rent a car
Then Total revenue from separate pricing
2 (800 + 200) = Rs. 2000
88
Example• Suppose company follows
bundling room and car in a package deal
• Combination of room and car (Rs.800 + Rs 400 = Rs.1200)
• Combination of room and car (Rs.1200 + Rs 200 = Rs.1400)
89
Example…
• Both consumers will opt both room & rent a car if company charge Rs. 1200
• Then Total Revenue = 2(Rs.1200) = Rs 2400
• By bundling, company earns an additional Rs.400.
90
Peak-Load Pricing
Practice of charging a higher price for consumers who require service during period of peak demand and a lower price for those who consume during off-peak periods.
Example?
91
Peak-Load PricingExamples…
• Pricing of long-distance telephone calls
• Higher price for peak-period calls
• Off-peak customers have to pay lower rates
92
Peak-Load PricingExamples…
Electricity rates• Higher price per kilowatt-hour for peak
hours than for off-peak hours• Older and less efficient plants and
equipments have to be brought into operation to meet peak hour demand.
• The peak load pricing is different from third degree price discrimination (Why?)
93
Peak-Load PricingExamples…
Because higher peak hour electricity rates are based on higher costs of generating electricity at peak hours.
94
Conditions for peak-load pricing
• Demand characteristics vary from period to period
• The product or service is not storable
95
Markup pricing or Cost plus pricing
• Most commonly used pricing method
• Prices are set to cover all direct costs plus a percentage markup for profit contribution
96
Markup pricing
• This method requires less precise data than MR=MC rule
• Cost-plus pricing provide a clear justification for price increase when costs rise
• Simple and easy to use
97
Markup pricing
Markup on cost
• Difference between price and cost, measured relative to cost, expressed as a percentage
• Markup on cost = Price - Cost/Cost
98
Markup pricing
Firms usually apply higher markups to products facing inelastic demand than to products with elastic demand (Examples?)
Grocery business (price elasticity is very high). So markup on cost will be lower
99
Criticisms
• Cost plus pricing is based on the average cost of production rather than MC
• Does not take demand conditions into account
100
Pricing of Multiple ProductsJoint products
• More complex than pricing for single product
• There are two demand curves
• Demand curve could be different
• Demand for one good may be more elastic than other
101
Pricing of joint products
• In single product case, price is set by following MR=MC
• If two goods are assumed to be jointly produced in fixed proportions, then calculate the marginal revenue from good A and marginal revenue from good B. Sum the marginal revenues and equate it with joint cost of production, MC.
• Profit maximising rule is MR1 + MR2 = MC• Then we can estimate the the optimal
quantity which maximises profit
102
Transfer pricing (TP)
• Pricing of intermediate goods by vertically integrated firms
• Many large firms sell their products to another division
• Intermediate goods: materials that will be needed as inputs at a later stage of the firm’s operations
• TP is about pricing of goods and services within a multi-divisional organisation
• For example: Selling of goods from production division to marketing division
103
Transfer pricing
• Parent company to foreign subsidiary division
• Each division of the firm has its own function and its own management
• Choice of price depends on tax level in the country
104
Transfer pricing
• Firms use transfer pricing to shift profits from division to division to minimize tax liability
• Usually companies show that most of the profit is made in a country with low taxes
105
Transfer pricing
• Pricing and profit maximization decision when there is
-External MarketThe division making the intermediate goods can
sell it buyers outside the firm. If there exists perfect competition, then apply P = MC rule
-No external marketThe intermediate good can be bought and sold
only between the divisions of the firm. In this case there is no market determined price for the product
106
Transfer pricing
• If the divisions are not allowed to trade with other firms, a conflict may arise regarding the proper price to be charged
• If a higher price is set by the division which sells intermediate good, that division may benefit more.
• For buying division, it is input for final product and they benefit from a lower price.
• So price is a determining factor
107
Transfer pricing
• The goal of the top management is to determine the price for the product that results in maximum profit for the combined firm
• There will be two types of costs:• Marginal cost incurred by division that
produced intermediate good and • marginal cost incurred by the division that
produced final product using intermediate good
108
Transfer pricing
• Thus for the combined firm, the profit maximising choice is to produce where MR from final product is equal to combined MC. That is MC of producing both intermediate good and marginal cost of transforming the intermediate good into final good.
• MR (final product) = MC(Inter) + MC (trans)
109
Summary
• Pricing is important in management decision making
• Some goods are jointly produced in fixed proportions. Profit maximisation requires that the two goods be considered as a product package.
• Price discrimination occurs when variation in price for a product sold in different markets does not correspond to differences in cost
110
Summary
• Product bundling is a pricing strategy that allows firms to capture part of the consumer surplus.
• Pure bundling involves the selling of two or more products only as a package.
• Cost-plus or markup pricing is widely used by firms.
• This practice involves setting price at average cost (AC) plus a markup designed to provide a target rate of return.