Microcalorimetry – versatile applications in biopharma
Natalia Markova, PhD
Challenge 1 - maintain protein stability and function to ensure efficacy and safety of the product.
Physical and chemical integrity of a protein can be affected in multiple ways:
Shear Stress Temperature fluctuationsAgitationHigh Pressure Filtration
OxidationUVpH and salt gradientsFreezing
SizeAggregationFragmentationHigh and low Mw variants
ImpuritiesProduct related impuritiesHost Cell ProteinsPrA leakageCell culture componentsDNAEndotoxinSubvisible particles
Charge heterogeneity and amino acid modificationsAcid forms: deamidated, sialylated and glycatedBasic forms: oxidated and C-terminal lysinevariantsIdentity
Amino acid sequence
Higher order structureSecondary and tertiary structureDisulfide bridgingFree thiolsThermodynamic stability
ActivityTotal concentrationActive concentrationTarget bindingFcR binding
Key aspects and quality attributes
StabilityShelf lifeDegradation profile
BioactivityTargetCDCADCCApoptosis...
GlycosylationGalactosylationSialylationMannosylationAfucosylation
Challenge 2 - determine and control criticalproperties and possible degradation pathwaysof a protein.
Condition 110 20 30 40 50
0
1
2
3
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Con
ditio
n2
Physical properties:Primary, secondary, ternary and quaternary structuresSolubilitySelf-associationViscosityMolecular weightHydrophobicityGlycosylationsCharge ...
Biological properties:Substarte or receptors affinityIn vitro activityFunction in vivo...
Multiple biophysical methods used for protein characterization › Mass spectrometry › Circular dichroism › Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy› Raman spectroscopy › X-ray crystallography › Nuclear magnetic resonance › Advanced detection SEC › Fluorescence › Light scattering› Differential scanning calorimetry › Isothermal titration calorimetry › Analytical ultracentrifugation › Microscopy Imaging› …..
Microcalorimetry in Life Science.Isothermal Titration and Differential Scanning Calorimeters (DSC and ITC)
Thermal stability of proteins at different conditions (buffers, excipients, adjuvants) Temperature is ramped Thermal denaturation of protein is monitored
A direct measurementof the heat generated or absorbed when molecules interact at constant temperature
ITC DSC
History of MicroCal™ products.Continuous development.
1977 2000
From 50 mg per run. At 5 ml cell volume.Difficult and touchy
The first commercially available
microcalorimeter.
From dozens of g per run. At 0.13 or 0.2 ml cell volume
Modern Malvern MicroCal systems
Advantages of calorimetric assays
Generic and directRobust-nearly any buffer can be usedMinimum assay development No molecular weight limitations Optical clarity does not effect outputsNon-distructive (for ITC)
Diversity of samples studied by calorimetry (ITC and DSC)
CytokinesHormonesPeptidesEnzymesAntibodies Antibody fragmentsAntibody-Drug conjugatesToxinsVaccinesAnticoagulantsFusion proteinsPEGylated proteinsVirus-like particles
How does ITC work?
Reference Cell Sample Cell
SyringeMonitors temperature difference between the sample and reference cells in a course of a titration experiment
Measures voltage across thermopile calibrated in units of thermal power cal/s Cell volume 200 L
Syringe volume 40 L
Compound – in syringeMacromolecule in ITC cell
ITC – Before titration
Ligand in syringeMacromolecule in cellMacromolecule-ligand complex
As the first injection is made, all injected compound is bound to target protein.
Titration begins: First injection
The signal returns to baseline before the next injection.
Return to baseline
As a second injection is made, again all injected compound becomes bound to the target.
Second injection
Signal again returns to baseline before next injection.
Second return to baseline
As the injections continue, the target becomes saturated with compound, so less binding occurs and the heat change starts to decrease.
Injections continue
As the injections continue, the target becomes saturated with compound, so less binding occurs and the heat change starts to decrease.
Injections continue
When the target is saturated with compound, no more binding occurs, and only heat of dilution is observed.
End of titration
Basics of ITC experiment
Integration of heats are used to extract affinity (KD), stoichiometry (N) and binding enthalpy ( H) using appropriate binding model
Universal technique based on heat detection
-4
-2
0
0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
4
H
N
Kd
kcal
mol
-1of
inje
ctan
t
Molar ratio
μcal
s-1
Time ->
With isothermal titration calorimetry you can… › Get quick KDs
› Assess protein binding activity
› Confirm specific binding and stoichiometry
› Characterize mechanism of action
› Validate binding data from other assays
› Measure enzyme kinetics
› Novel applications continue to evolve
N=0.35
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
0.0006
0.0008
0.0010
0.0012
0.0014
0.0016
0.0018
0.0020
Data: EnzSub1R6_RModel: M2 Substrate OnlyChi^2/DoF = 1.159E-9Kcat
A1.86 ±0.057
KmA
4.08 ±0.26H -7000R
ate
(mill
imol
es/l/
sec)
[S] (mM)
More interactions with MicroCal ITC
Kamps, et al, Nature Commun, 6, 8911 (2015)
ITC titrations of 10-mer H3K4me3, H3C4me3 and H3G4 histone peptides binding to the TAF3 PHD domain. N=1 for each binding
KD 790 nM KD 36 MKD 24 nM
Molar Ratio
Kcal
/mol
inje
ctan
t
1.0 1.5 2.00.50.0
0
-2
-4
-6
-8
Protein Quality
Measure active concentrations
Compare protein batches
Fully Active
50%“Fully Active”
Partially Active
Measuring Bioactivity with ITC: Affinity and Stoichiometry
ITC in biotheurapetic drug discovery-Charaterization of multi-specific antibodies.
R.Castoldi, U.Jucknischke, L.P.Pradel, E.Arnold, C.Klein, S.Scheiblich, G.Niederfellner and C.Sustmann(Roche Diagnostics, Germany). PEDS 25, 551–559, 2012
Molecular characterization of novel trispecific ErbB-cMet-IGF1R antibodies and their antigen-binding properties
ITC confirms binding to all three epitopes of tri-specific antibody.
Top panel: soluble receptors titrated into a solution of their corresponding parental mAb in three independent experiments. Bottom panel: the three receptors titrated one after the other into the same solution of TriMab2
Conclusion: ITC showed all 3 receptors could simultaneously bind the tri-specific antibody
Protein quaternary structure by ITC. Self-association of protein X studied by ITC.
0.00 10.00 20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00 60.004.70
4.75
4.80
4.85
4.90
4.95
5.00
5.05
5.10
5.15
5.20
5.25
5.30
5.35
5.40
5.45
5 mg/ml PrX in PBS 7 mg/ml PrX in SEC 3 mg/ml PrX in Pi
Time (min)
μcal
/sec
Overlays of ITC titrations into and Pi, PBS and high ionic strength phosphate buffers
Protein has propensity to oligomerize. From ITC data supported by SEC -MALS dimerization KD is in the range of 30 – 70
M.
[NaCl], Temperature
PEAQ-ITC system enables fast and detailed characterisation of interactions involving multiple classes of binding sites
The PEAQ-ITC system enables fast and detailed characterisation of interactions between biomolecules involving multiple classes of binding sites. The instrument and software improvements compared to earlier ITC systems significantly increase the throughput - including data evaluation. Furthermore the low volume requirement broadens the applicability of ITC as an orthogonal technique in relation to other interaction techniques.
Anders Dybdal Nielsen, PhDSenior Research ScientistNovo Nordisk A/S
Differential Scanning Calorimetry, DSC
• Thermal stability of proteins at different conditions (buffers, excipients, adjuvants) • Temperature is ramped • Thermal denaturation of
protein is monitored
Protein unfolding
Protein unfolding
Protein unfolding
Protein unfolding
Protein unfolding
Protein unfolding
Protein unfolding
Protein unfolding
Native
Mutant
Phosphorylated
Complexed
Temperature (°C)
Cp
(kJ K
-1m
ol-1
)
Compare native, altered and mutant formsMicroCal™ DSC system the universal stability monitor
Tm shift reflects increased stability
Tm and heat of unfolding ( Hcal) in one scan
DSC basics. Analysis of irreversible thermal protein unfolding
40 60 80 100-20
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
Cp
(kca
l/mol
e/o C
)
Temperature (oC)
T1/2
H
Onset ofunfolding
Tm’s ofminor peaks
Tm ofmain peak
(monoclonal antibody)
› Shifts in Tonset (°C):Higher temperature = more stableLower temperature = less stable
› Shifts in Tm values (°C):Higher temperature = more stableLower temperature = less stable
› Changes in T1/2 values (transition width,°C):Smaller width = more cooperative unfolding usually associated with a compact structureLarger width – less cooperative usually associated with a relaxed, partially unfolded structure
› Lowering of “ H”, area under the curve:Indicates that it takes less energy to unfold the protein due to destabilization (works only if protein concentration values are well known)
Comparing DSC data in the context of irreversible unfolding
38
Direct nature of DSC readout allows to address protein complexity Individual domain stabilizationMultiple descriptors of protein stabilityDSC thermogram as a fingerprint,e.g. for biocomparability
Versatile application sof DSC in biopharmaD
iffer
entia
l Sca
nnin
g C
alor
imet
ryProtein engineering
Protein characterization
Process development and manufacturing support
(Pre)Formulation Development
Higher Order Structure Analysis
DSC results can be predictive of relative long-term storage stability
DSC thermograms are used in comparability protocols (comparability of tertiary structure and stability)
DSC thermograms are often included in the characterization package of a CMC section
MicroCal VP Capillary DSC
41
1) Sample preparation (96-well plate)
2) Input parameters into software 3) Automated sample measurement
4) Automated sample analysis
) AAuuttomated sample measurement
Multiple Tms. DSC allows to address protein stability on domain level. Protein engineering guided by DSC.
Minor differences in primary sequence can have a big impact on antibody stabilityStability of each domain can be assessedThe least stable Fab variant expressed poorly and quickly formed high MW aggregates. Most stable antibody construct identified based on Tm of the Fab domain.
Demarest et al, Malvern Application note
30 40 50 60 70 80 90
0
50
100
150
Cp (k
cal/m
ole/o C)
Temperature (oC)
Tm3 = 82.0 °C
Tm2 = 73.3 °C
Tm1 = 60.4 °C
The use of DSC to enhance drugability of engineered monoclonal antibodies. Monitoring construct stability,›Use DSC to track stability changes of individal domains
50 60 70 80 90 100
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Cp
(kca
l/mol
e/o C
)
Temperature (oC)
50 60 70 80 90 100
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Cp
(kca
l/mol
e/o C
)
Temperature (oC)
50 60 70 80 90 100
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
Cp
(kca
l/mol
e/o C
)
Temperature (oC)
B: Engineered Protein 1
C: Engineered Protein 2
Park, Malvern Application Note
A: Parent Protein
TM3
TM4
TM1
TM2
TM1
TM1
DSC predictions correlate with industry standard
Eliminate candidates with potential long term stability issues
›DSC data correlates well with SEC-HPLC (accelerated stability studies)
Protein with lowest Tm had greatest aggregation formation
›Early eliminate constructs with potential long-term stability issues
Park, MicroCal Application Note (2008)
How does DSC compare?
›DSC was the most accurate and fastest predictor of suitable formulations
Size ExclusionChromatography
Laser Light Scattering
IsoaspartateFormation CE
DSC Tm
Black: T=0Grey: 2 weeks at 40 CRed: 4 weeks at 40 C
Ollila, MicroCal Application Note (2004)
Results from a pH primary screen of a therapeutic antibody
Tm. Sensitivity of DSC to changes in stability arising from a common chemical degradation pathway, oxidation
Arthur et al. J. Pharm. Sci 104:1548–1554, 2015
Malvern webinar by J. Gabrielson .
0 10 20 30 40 50
0
5
10
BPase 8.3uM=0.23mg/ml BB293in 20mM TBS + 200mM L-alaninepH 8.0
Data: BpaseTBSLa_cpModel: MN2StateChi^2 = 8813.30Tm1 17.85 ±0.1932
H1 2.19E3 ±181Hv1 1.13E5 ±1.06E4
Tm2 30.40 ±0.6202H2 1.41E4 ±2.8E3Hv2 8.04E4 ±4.94E3
Tm3 34.43 ±0.0458H3 4.01E4 ±2.68E3Hv3 1.25E5 ±2.92E3
Cp
(kca
l/mol
e/o C
)
Temperature (oC)
onset at 12ºC
Tm=34.5ºC
DSC: 10ºC upward shift of the low-temperature transition stabilizes Protein X kinetically.
Tonset. Shift in onset of thermal unfolding correlates withprotein stability and aggregation propensity. Case study 3.
Protein X Construct 1
20 30 40 50 60-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
ca 0.22 mg/ml BPase BB384in 20 mM TBS, pH 8.00.3% DMSO
Data: BB384TBS05_cpModel: MN2StateChi^2 = 7482.82Tm1 23.73 ±0.0840
H1 877 ±93.6Hv1 4E5 ±5.32E4
Tm2 34.30 ±0.1938H2 1.14E4 ±932Hv2 9.88E4 ±4.06E3
Tm3 40.10 ±0.0854H3 2.64E4 ±939Hv3 1E5 ±2.15E3
Cp
(kca
l/mol
e/o C
)
Temperature (oC)
onset at 22ºC
Tm=40ºC
Protein X Construct 2
SEC: Protein X homogeneity and stability to aggregation has dramatically increased
SEC
ppppppppppppp (((((((((( )))))))))
SEC
Construct 1 Construct 2
T1/2 and Tm. Multiple metrics of protein thermal stability make buffer optimization /preformulation funnel more efficient. Case study 4.
Rank by Tm
Focus with T1/2
Katherine E. Bowers, Malvern Application Note
12 selected
5 focused on
19 formulations tested
Hcal. Area under DSC curve is an indicator of the content of folded protein material. DSC can be used to assess quality of recombinant proteins. Case study 5.
Malvern Application Note
Hcal/ HvH ratio as indicator of size of cooperative unit for thermal unfolding
› HvH = Hcal – cooperative unit and molecular weight are the same: largely reversible unfolding of one single domain
› HvH < Hcal - cooperative unit is smaller than molecular weight: intermediates
› HvH > Hcal – cooperative unit is bigger than the molecular weight: oligomers or overestimated concentration of folded protein
20 40 60 80 100-50
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
Data: Data2_cpModel: MN2StateChi^2/DoF = 99.35Tm 69.15 ±0.021H 3376 ±17.2Hv 1.014E5 ±640
mgst2
Cp
(cal
/o C)
Temperature (Deg. C)
Ratio of calorimetric to van’t Hoff enthalpy H/ HvH, can be indicative of protein oligomerization state. Case study 7.
Ratio of van’t Hoff to calorimetric enthalpy ≈3 indicates that protein unfolds as an oligomer (possibly trimer).
cates that protein unfoldsmer).
…”The high throughput is supported by the analysis
software, which is easy to use and requires no more manual
calculations therefore saving us hours. These time savings have really improved our workflow.”
Dr. Katherine BowersFujifilm Diosynth Biotechnologies- A CRO
MicroCal DSC: The Gold Standard
The Gold Standard in Biopharma
› HOS consortium publishes the ‘value’ of DSC
Gabrielson and Weiss IV, J. Pharm.Sci. 104:1240–1245, 2015
DSC is very or extremely useful in manybiopharma applications
Lot 3
Lot 2
Lot 1
Reference
DSC readout is directly related to protein concentration and conformational state. DSC thermogram is a fingerprint for assessment of conformational equivalence and Higher Order Structure.
›Three lots manufactured at different sites
DSC demonstrates comparability of higher order structure (HOS) for material from different manufacturing processes or manufacturing sites
Malvern Application Note
Assessing modifications in HOS in stressed mAbX samples
In collaboration with Roche, Basel
pH-stress
Met255 oxidized (Fc-CH2)Met431 oxidized (Fc-CH3)
Significant difference in hydrophobic and charge profiles, dimer and oligomer formation
pH 9.0, 37 deg C 7 days
Asn #1 deamidated (Fab-LC, CDR)Asn #2 deamidated (Fab-HC, CDR)Asp isomerized (Fab-LC, CDR)Asn387/392/393 deamidated (Fc-CH3)
Light-stressed
pH-stressed
Forced-oxidized
DSC in chatacterization of protein samples from stress-stability studies: Modifications in stressed mAbXvariants
-50000
0
50000
100000
150000
200000
50 60 70 80 90 100
wt1
s2 corr
temperature deg C
Forced-oxidizedTm1(Fc-CH2)
Tm2(Fab)
Wild-type
SampleT1/2, deg C
Tonset, deg C
Tm1, deg C
Tm2, deg C
Wild-type 4,2 64,4 71,2 81,8forced-oxidized 4,2 59,7 69,1 81,9
Decreased thermal stability of CH2 domain offorced-oxidized mAbX detected with DSC
Destabilization of CH2 domain of light-stressed mAbX detected with DSC
Tm2(Fab)
Wild-type
Light-stressedTm1(Fc-CH2)
SampleT1/2, deg C
Tonset, deg C
Tm1, deg C
Tm2, deg C
Wild-type 4,2 64,4 71,2 81,8UV-light stressed 4,4 61,3 70,7 81,9Light-stressed
DSC is the only direct thermal stability assay. Rest of the techniques are phenomenological, i.e. based on observations of secondary effects
Hydrophobic surface exposure
Extent & energeticsof thermal unfolding
We routinely use DSC as the ‘gold standard’ forprotein stability studies and encourage ourresearchers to determine melting points with DSCfirst before using alternative techniques such as CDor Thermofluor. The wide temperature rangeensures that we can see all the transitions in asample and decide which techniques will beappropriate.
Dr. David StauntonFacility ManagerBiochemistry Department’s Molecular Biophysics Suite
DSC as the ‘gold standard’ for protein stability studies
DoE: Impact of extrinsic factors on mAb1 thermal stability scored differently by different techniques
DSF identifies NaCl as VIP factor. Salt might be affecting hydrophobicity of a protein and affecting protein-dye binding.DSF does not relaibly assess effect of Tween 20 on mAb1.
DSC traces are fingerprints of protein HOS. DSC ensured highly reproducible thermal unfolding profiles.
DSF DSC
DSC gives means to assess conformational equivalence/similarity of protein samples
Irreversibility of protein denaturation
N U INative Reversibly
UnfoldedIrreversiblyDenatured
k2
Thermodynamics/EnergeticsFormulations/Functional Stability
K
DSC offers means to assess and optimize kinetic stability of proteins
Tm dependence on the DSC scan rate suggeststhat the denaturation process is kinetically-determined
Scan rate dependence experiments performed on two mAb batches with different glycosylation profiles. VP-capillary DSC scans were collected on 1 mg/mL mAb batch (A) and (B) at multiple scan rates (10, 35, 60, 120, 180, 240ºC per hour).
Morar-Mitrica S. et al. Drug Development. BioPharma Asia. July/August 2013, pp 46-55.
Presence of different oligosaccharides does not affect the thermodynamic or kinetic stability of this mAb.
Tm dependence on the DSC scan rate suggests that the denaturation process is kinetically-determined.The trends in Tm variation with scan rate were found to be equivalent between batches.DSC provided evidence of batch-to-batch comparability.
Morar-Mitrica S. et al. Drug Development. BioPharma Asia. July/August 2013, pp 46-55.
Mode of action
ConcentrationSimilarity of HOS
SolubilityStructure
ActivityBinding to interaction partners
ITC and DSC in chracterization of protein stability and interactions
Stability
DSCITC
DSC
ITC
DSC
DSCITC
Manufacturability DSC
ITC
BindingITC
DSC
DSC in the studies of liposomal DDS, vaccines, viruses and biofluids
Characterization of liposomal preparations with DSC
68
Images from wikipedia
Biltonen et al. Chemistry and Physics of Lipids, 64 (1993) 129-142B. Stark et al. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 41 (2010) 546–555
Fig. 3. Excess heat capacity curves lyophilised/rehydrated liposomes mixed with glucose (2), lactose (3), trehalose (4) and mannitol (5) in a lipid to carbohydrate molar ratio of 1:10.
Fig. 2. Dependence of the transition temperature (Tm) of DPPC unilamellar vesicles on vesicle diameter.Fig. 1. DSC thermogram of DPPC MLVs
Characterization of liposomal drug delivery systems with DSC
Images from wikipedia
Fig. Normalized DSC scans of DPPC bilayers containing losartan (antagonist of AT1 receptor) at different concentrations
B. Stark et al. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 41 (2010) 546–555
DSC can be used tocontrol overall stabilityof Liposomal DDS
Viruses and VLP in DSC. MDa-size complex samples.
Fig. 1. Differential scanning calorimetry analyses of three different strains of purified active influenza virus. Krell et al. Biotechnol Appl Biochem (2005) 41: 241–246.
Fig. 2. pH-dependence of the thermal unfolding of type I poliovirus ofstrain Mahoney. Krell et al. Biotechnol. Appl. Biochem. (2005) 41, 241–246
“The precision in the determination of the Tm va-lues makes a DSC analysis a very suitable tool to follow the vaccine production process and to assess lot to lot consistency.”
DSC in application to blood plasma samples
Relevance:Extend the use of DSC to more complex samplesInvestigate feasibility to use the profiles for diagnostic purposes
Why DSC:Heat is an extrinsic propertyAllows studies of complex compositionsAccounts also for intermolecular interactions - the “plasma interactome”
Differentiation of diseases by DSC
Reproducibility of experimental serum thermograms from a healthy subject (A) and a diseased patient (B). Two non-consecutive scans with sample refilling were performed for each individual.
DSC thermograms are highly reproducible and serve as fingerprint.
MicroCal DSC in studies of biofluids.
› Comments from Adrian Velazquez-CampoyInstitute BIFI-University of Zaragoza (Spain)
Especially appropriate for running unattended largesets of samples and for minimizing human/accidentalmistakes.Characterized by a remarkable scan reproducibility andan impressive sensitivity for reducing sample usage.Straightforward to program with the control software.Easy to maintain and keep in shape by programmingperiodic cleaning/control scans.
Thank you