IPEQ - ICMP - SB - EPFLStation 3CH - 1015 LAUSANNE
J-D GaniereEPFL - SB - ICMP - IPEQCH - 1015 Lausanne
Credit: www.national.com
Experimental Methods in Physics
[2011-2012]
Photodetectors IR-FIR
InterestsClassificationNoiseFigures of meritExamples
1
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
References
Photodiode technical information [Hamamatsu]
The Physics of Semiconductors: An Introduction Including Devices and Nanophysics by Marius Grundmann / ISBN-13: 978-3540253709
Photodetectors: Devices, Circuits and Applications by Silvano Donati ISBN-13: 978-0130203373
Photodetection and Measurement: Maximizing Performance in Optical Systems (Hardcover) by Mark Johnson ISBN-13: 978-0071409445
2
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Objectives of this course
To classify photodetectors according to the physical mechanism by which they respond to light
To identify the sources of noise in optical detection
To define the parameters (figure of merit) which characterize the optical detectors (i.e. how to choose the right detector ?)
3
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Interests
IR spectroscopy
identification of compounds, teledetectionresearch and development
Thermal infrared imaging camera
industrialmedicalsecurity, military
Night vision systems
Remember that:
Highlighting a difference in temperature is relatively easy.Measuring the absolute value of temperature is very difficult.Spatial resolution of an IR image is still limited by diffraction !
4
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Interests IR molecular spectroscopy
UV-VIS spectroscopy deals with electronic transitions.
IR radiation is to low an energy to excite electronic transitions ... IR spectroscopy is limited to the study of the rotational and vibrational structure.
Rotovibrational spectrum is like a molecular fingerprint.
IR spectroscopy is a very important tool in qualitative analysis
5
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Spectral bands
25–200 nm Vacuum ultraviolet VUV
200–400 nm Ultraviolet VUV
400–700 nm Visible VIS
700–1000 nm Near infrared NIR
1–3 μm Short wavelength infrared SWIR
3–5 μm Medium wavelength infrared MWIR
5–14 μm Long wavelength infrared LWIR
14–30 μm Very long wavelength infrared VLWIR
30–100 μm Far infrared FIR
100–1000 μm Submillimeter SubMM
6
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Interests
7
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Interests Teledetection
8
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Interests Thermography
fom Infratec
from www.dias-infrared.com
9
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Interests Nightvision
10
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
IR arrays .... boosted by CCD and MEMS
CCD
Microbolometer array1970 1980 1990 2000 2010
ROICReadOut Integrated Circuit
Micro-electro-mechanical systems [MEMS]
Coupled Charged Devices [CCD]
IR detector arrays
from www.flir.com/ch
11
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Classification of the photodetectors
Thermal detectors
Quantum detectors
Photodiodes
Photoconductors
Photomultipliers
Photographic plates
Imaging Plates
Pyroelectric detectors
Bolometer detectors
Golay detectors
Thermopile
Phot
oelect
ric
effe
ctBl
ackb
ody
12
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Quantum detectors
Type Transition Electrical output Example
Intrinsic Interband
PhotoconductivePhotovoltaicCapacitancePEM
AlGaN, Si, GaAs, PbSe, InSb, HgCdTeAlGaN, Si, InGaAs, InSb, HgCdTeSi, GaAs, InSb, HgCdTeInSb, HgCdTe
Extrinsic Impurity to band Photoconductive Si:In, Si:Ga, Ge:Cu, Ge:Hg
Free carriers Intraband
Photoemissive
PhotoconductivePhoton-drag
PtSi, Pt2Si, IrSi Schottky barriersGaAs/CsOInSb electron bolometerGe
Quantum wellsTo and/or from spatiallyquantised levels
PhotoconductivePhotovoltaic
GaAs/GaAlAs, InSb nipiInAs/InGaSb SLS
from Opto-Electron. Rev., 12, no. 2, 2222004
13
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Thermal Detectors
Detector Method of operation
Bolometer - Metal - Semiconductor - Superconductor - Ferroelectric - Hot electron
Change in electrical conductivity
Thermocouple/Thermopile
Voltage generation, caused by change in temperature of the junction of two dissimilar materials
Pyroelectric Changes in spontaneous electrical polarization
Golay cell/Gas microphone Thermal expansion of a gas
14
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Photodetectors Quantum efficiency
The quantum efficiency, η, is defined as the
percentage of the electrons produced for every photon incident on the photosensitive surface
The carriers are produced via a photoelectric effect. There is production of electrons only if the energy of the photons verifies:
E= h $ o$ Egap= h $ ogap
h= h phe
h=mgapm
15
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Quantum and thermal detectors Noise
Shot noise (or quantum noise) is associated to the random fluctuations in a measurement signal due the random arrival time of the signal carriers (electrons, photons, ...)
Johnson-Nyquist noise (thermal noise) is generated by thermal agitation of the charge carriers inside an electrical conductor.
Flicker noise is an electronic noise with a 1/f, or pink spectrum
16
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Figure of merit Noise Equivalent Power [NEP]
The NEP (Noise Equivalent Power)* is defined as the radiant flux which produces an output signal equal in magnitude to that produced by noise signal.
The NEP gives a measure of the minimum amount of light which can be detected.
the unit of NEP is [W]
The NEP varies with the active area of the detector and the temperature.
lower the NEP ... better the detector !
Some manufacturers and authors define NEP as the minimum detectable power per square root bandwidth, in that case the unit is of NEP is [W Hz-1/2]
*
17
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Figure of merit Normalized Detectivity [N*]
A figure of merit also used to characterize performance, equal to the reciprocal of noise equivalent power (NEP), normalized to unit area and unit bandwidth.Specific detectivity, D * (synonym D-Star), is given by:
where A is the area of the photosensitive region of the detector and Δf is the effective noise bandwidth. Its
common units are [cm W-1Hz1/2]
Higher the detectivity .... better the detector
D *= NEPA $ Df
18
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Normalized Detectivity D* [cmHz1/2/W]
19
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
NTED [Noise Equivalent Temperature Difference]
Noise Equivalent Temperature Difference (NETD) is a measure of the sensitivity of a detector of thermal radiation in the infrared, terahertz radiation or microwave radiation parts of the electromagnetic spectrum.
It is the scene temperature difference equal to either the internal noise of the detector (detector NETD) or the total electronic noise of a measurement system (system NETD). The signal-to-noise ratio is thus equal to one.
If a detector is limited by either shot noise or Johnson noise then the NETD can be decreased by using an increased integration time. The NETD of flicker noise limited detectors can not be reduced by increased integration time.
Typically uncooled bolometric detectors have NETD figures of 80-200 mK. Cooled photon detecting infrared detectors using materials such as HgCdTe (LWIR or MWIR) or InSb (MWIR) can approach a NETD figure of 10 mK.
from Wikipedia.org
20
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Thermal radiation summary
Planck’s law - Spectral Radiance for a blackbody at temperature T
Stefan Boltzmann law
Wien displacement law
I(m,T) =m52hc2
$ekTho
-1
1< F
J= v $T 4
mmax nm^ h$T= 2897
v=5.67 $ 10-12 Js-1m-2K-46 @
21
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Thermal Detectors
I(m,T)dm=H(T)m1
m2
#
λ1 λ2
if the emissivity is unknown ... a precise estimation of T is problematic !
estimation of T
22
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
IR Detectors
Detector Method of operation cooled spectral range
Bolometer - Metal - Semiconductor - Superconductor - Ferroelectric - Hot electron
Change in electrical conductivity no 0.2 !m - 1000!m
Thermocouple/Thermopile Voltage generation, caused by change in temperature of the junction of two dissimilar materials
no 0.2 !m - 1000!m
Pyroelectric Changes in spontaneous electrical polarization no 0.2 !m - 1000!m
Golay cell/Gas microphone Thermal expansion of a gas no 0.2 !m - 1000!m
PhotodiodeInduced current (photoconductor mode) or voltage (photovoltaic mode) yes material dependant
QWIPPhotoexcitation of electrons between ground and first excited state subbands of multi-quantum wells (MQWs)
yes material dependant
23
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Infrared detectors - figures of merit
24
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Bolometers
A bolometer consists of an absorber connected to a heat sink through an insulating link. Any absorption of radiation absorbed by the absorber raises its temperature above that of the heatsink. Temperature changes can be measured directly (if the electrical resistance of the absorber changes with temperature) or indirectly via an attached thermometer. The spectral response of bolometers is flat over a broad spectral range and can, in principle, be used from UV to FIR.
absorber
insulating link
heatsink
thermometer
EM radiation
+
R1
R2
D
A
R3
B
C
Vg
25
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Bolometer
the two arms form the two branches of a wheatstone bridge which was fitted with a sensitive galvanometer and connected to a battery.
Electromagnetic radiation falling on the exposed strip would heat it, and change its resistance, the circuit thus effectively operating as a resistance temperature detector.
Room Temperature Operation
26
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Microbolometer
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/bb/Cross-sectional_microbolomter.jpg
Individual sensor elements use the change in electrical resistance of a resistive layer deposited onto the tiny “platelets” fabricated by silicon micro-machining. Incoming target radiation heats the IR absorbing layer causinga change in electrical resistance, which is readout by measuring the resulting change in bias current. 80’000 and more sensors can be fabricated together into a two-dimensional array. The structure can be dimensioned to operate at 30 Hertz.
Room Temperature Operation
27
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Microbolometer Room Temperature Operation
28
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Microbolometer Room Temperature Operation
29
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Microbolometer array
30
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Bolometer ... the next step
31
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Photoconductors
The material (usually a semiconductor) becomes more conductive due to the absorption of EM radiation. When light is absorbed , le number of electrons and holes increases and raises the electrical conductivity of the material. The energy of the incident photon must be higher than the bandgap energy.
32
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
p-n Photodiodes
The high electric field present in the depletion region causes photo-generated carrriers (generated via an internal photoelectric effect) to be separated and collected accross the (reversed biased) junction. The energy of the incident photon must be higher than the bandgap energy.
p n+
-
- +
RL
depletion region
Bias Voltage
Load resistor
33
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Photodiode Equivalent Circuit
Il: Current generated by the incident light (proportional to the amount of light)
ID: Diode current
Cj: Junction capacitance
Rsh: Shunt resistance
Rs: Serie resistance
I’: Shunt resistance current
VD: Voltage across the diode
VD: Voltage across the diode
I0: Output current
V0: Output voltage
Is: Photodiode reverse saturation current
e: Electron charge
k: Boltzmann’s constant
T: Absolute
34
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Photodiode Equivalent Circuit
The output current, Io, is given by:
I0 = Il- ID- I ' = Il- IS exp kTeVD -1b l- I '
with:
Il = h $U $ hcme
quantum efficiency
with:with:
light flux
35
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Photodiode I-V characteristics
from Hamamatsu
36
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Photodiode open circuit mode (photovoltaic)
VOC = ekTln ISIl- I ' +1; E
the open circuit voltage VOC is the output voltage when I0 equal to 0:
Usually Il >> I’ and Il/Is >> 1:
VOC = ekTln ISIl; E= e
kTln hcIShUem; E
In photovoltaic mode, the net current, I0, is zero and the voltage developped across an open circuit diode is a logarithmic function of the light flux
37
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Photodiode - Photoconductive mode
In photoconductive mode, the junction is operated under reverse potential and it is the photon generated current which constitutes the measured output signal and not the voltage drop across the diode:
I0. Il = h $U $ hcme
The ouput signal is a linear function of the light flux. Photoconductive operation results in a higher response speed than photovoltaic.
38
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Photodiodes
PV logarithmic: Rl >> Rsch
PV “linear”: Rl << Rsch
PC load line
Photoconductive mode Photovoltaic mode
39
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
IR semiconductor photodetectors
HgCdTe [3-14!m]
PbSe [1.5 - 5 !m]
InGaAs [0.9 - 3 !m]
PbS [1.3 - 1.6 !m]
InAsB [8 - 14 !m]
Work as photoconductors (change in the electrical resistance under illumination) or as p-n photodetectors (± photovoltaic mode).
Most of the time, photovoltaic HgCdTe array are hybridized to a full custom silicon CMOS readout circuit.
Lower the temperature ... better the performances !
40
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
HgCdTe - MCT (Mercury Cadmium Telluride) detector
41
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
HgCdTe - MCT (Mercury Cadmium Telluride) detector
42
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
HgCdTe - MCT (Mercury Cadmium Telluride) detector
The retina of the detector is based on a photovoltaic HgCdTe array hybridized to a full custom silicon CMOS readout circuit. The readout circuit is versatile so that it answers several system requirements for hyperspectral applications.
43
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
QWIP
How QWIP Works
QWIPs operate by photoexcitation of electrons between ground and first excited state subbands of multi-quantum wells (MQWs) which are artificially fabricated by placing thin layers of two different, high-bandgap semiconductor materials alternately. The bandgap discontinuity of two materials creates quantized subbands in the potential wells associated with conduction bands or valence bands. The structure parameters are designed so that the photo-excited carriers can escape from the potential wells and be collected as photocurrent.
from http://qwip.jpl.nasa.gov/tutorial.htm
44
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
QWIP Characteristics
DQWIP* = 2.67Dideal*
spectral range 3-20 !m (Δλ=6 !m)
array size 600 x 500
QE 60%
NEDT 15 mK
Uniformity < 6%
D* max
45
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Thermopile
A thermopile is a number of thermocouples connected in series. A thermocouple is a junction of dissimilar metals which produce voltage when one side of the junction has a different temperature to the other. The so called cold side of the junction is kept close to ambient temperature by bonding it to a temperature stable mass. The hot side of the junction is exposed to incident radiation.Connecting many thermocouples in series produces higher voltage.
Thermopile detector output is proportional to incident radiation while the pyroelectric detectors output is proportional to rate of change of incident radiation. In other words, the thermopile detector is DC coupled while the pyroelectric detector is AC coupled.
Room Temperature Operation
46
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Thermopile
negativethermistorpositive
47
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Thermopile imaging array Dexter Research Center Inc.
48
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Thermopile imaging array Dexter Research Center Inc.
49
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Pyroelectric detector FUJI & CO. [Piezo Science]
Pyroelectric Infrared Detectors (PIR) convert the changes in incoming IR light to electric signals. Pyroelectric materials are characterized by having spontaneous electric polarization, which is altered by temperature changes as infrared light illuminates the elements. They can be used at ambient
temperature even in the presence of thermal noise. By choosing appropriate IR receiving electrodes, they serve a wide range of applications.
Characteristics
High SensitivityVersatile selection of IR wavelength filtersRoom temperature operationLow costRobust under severe environmental conditionsStable against ambient temperature and atmospheric changes
50
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Pyroelectric detector FUJI & CO. [Piezo Science]
Array (2005)
64x64 QVGA (320x240)
51
J-D Ganiere MEP/2011-2012
Golay detector
This detector is based on the deformation of a membrane mirror (due to the thermal expansion of a gas when EM radiation is absorbed. This is a rugged broadband detector and is still used in FIR spectrometers.
52