Australian Journal of Adult Learning Volume 52, Number 1, April 2012
Mathematics funds of knowledge: Sotmaute and Sermaute fish in a Torres Strait Islander community
Bronwyn EwingYumi Deadly Centre, Queensland University of Technology
The purpose of this article is to describe a project with one Torres Strait Islander Community. It provides some insights into parents’ funds of knowledge that are mathematical in nature, such as sorting shells and giving fish. The idea of funds of knowledge is based on the premise that people are competent and have knowledge that has been historically and culturally accumulated into a body of knowledge and skills essential for their functioning and well-being. This knowledge is then practised throughout their lives and passed onto the next generation of children. Through adopting a community research approach, funds of knowledge that can be used to validate the community’s identities as knowledgeable people, can also be used as foundations for future learning for teachers, parents and children in the early years of school. They can be the bridge that joins a community’s funds of knowledge with schools validating that knowledge.
Mathematics funds of knowledge 135
Keywords: Torres Strait Islands, Torres Strait Islander parents, Indigenous Knowledge Centre, funds of knowledge, sorting, partitioning.
What can be learned from Torres Strait Islander parents’ funds of mathematical knowledge and incorporating into the transition to formal school?
AtatimewhenanumberofstrategieshavebeenimplementedtoincreaseTorresStraitIslanderparents’participationineducationwiththeirchildren(seeforexample,DepartmentEducation,EmploymentandWorkRelations2011;TorresStraitIslanderRegionalEducationCouncil2011),Iarguethatgoingbeyondthesimpledichotomybetweenparents’fundsofknowledge(experience,out-of-school,intuitive,tacit)andacademic(in-school,linear,deliberate)iscritical.Forchildrenintheearlyyearsofschooling,instructionmustbeunderpinnedwithauthenticengagementinproductiveactivities,drawingonpriorknowledgeandcomplexityandthedialogicalemergenceofinstruction.Whatthismeansforeducationalpracticeisthatbyinvitingchildrenintoaworldofmotivatingactivitieswheretheeverydayandspontaneouscomesintocontactwithschool,thechildren’sandtheirparents’engagementwithboththeactivityandthesocialcontextareforegroundedsothatquestionsandinquirycanoccur(Gonzalezetal.2005).Thatis,theclassroombecomesaninformationexchangethatdrawsonmultiplefundsofknowledgethatareactivatedandtiedwithmathematicscurricula(see,forexample,AustralianCurriculumandReportingAuthority2009;DepartmentofEducationandTraining,Queensland2010;DepartmentofEducation,TrainingandtheArts,Queensland2008).
Attheheartofthisprojectafundsofknowledgeapproachisadoptedbecauseitprovidesapowerfulandrichwaytolearnaboutcommunitiesintermsoftheirresources,theirmathematical
136 Bronwyn Ewing
competencerelatedtosotmaute (sorting)andsermaute (partitioning)throughthegivingoffishandthewaytheyutilisetheseprocessestosupporttheeducationoftheirchildren.Throughfamilialandsocialnetworks,TorresStraitIslanderparentsbuildcapacityamongstoneanotherandwiththeirchildren(Makuwira2007).Suchnetworksvalidatetheparents’owndefinitionsofmathsastheyexistintheircommunities—‘fundsofknowledges’thatareappliedindailylife(Moll1992:133).Theideaoffundsofknowledgeviewsthatpeoplearecompetentandhaveknowledgethathasbeengrownanddevelopedthroughtheirlifeexperiencesthathavegiventhemthatknowledge.
Ifoneacceptsthepremiseofthisarticle,thatfundsofknowledgeofmathematicsarethosethatreflecttheuniquehistoriesandcultureofcommunitiesandwhicharehistoricallyandculturallyaccumulated,thenthequestionarises:Howaretheseknowledgesandthelearningofthemconnectedwithandsituatedincommunitiesandthevoicesofthepeople?Here,IdrawontheworkofLahn(2006)whodescribesthepracticeofgivingfish.Givingasermaute (share)offishisasignificantpracticeforTorresStraitIslanderwomen.Whilethechoiceoffishingcompanionscanillustratearangeofrelationships,forexample,familyandfriendships,the‘distributionoffishisnotasflexible’(p.301).Withthedivisionofcaughtfishcometheexpectationstogiveasharetorelativesaswellaselderlyneighbours.Distributingthefishisgenerallytowards‘ascendingmembersoftheirownfamilyandthatoftheirhusband’(p.304).Thisemphasisreciprocates
theearlierphysicalandsocialnurturancereceivedbytheindividualsinthisgeneration(inparticular,parents,aunties,mother’sbrothers).Theseindividualsareviewedashavingnurturedthemtoadulthood,anideacommunicatedlocallythroughexpressionslikelugaut(lookafter)andgromape(raised)....Thisethicinfactextendstoalloldermembersofthecommunity,whoareseenasresponsibleinamoregeneralsense
Mathematics funds of knowledge 137
forcreating(nurturing)thephysicalandsocialcommunitytowhichtheyoungergenerationsnowbelong.(p.304)
Womenareexpectedtoprovidetheirrelationswithfishofreasonablesizeandtypeinrelationtotheiroverallcatch.Throughthisprocess,theideaistomakeindividualbuckets‘lessunequal’bycomparisonwithothersthatarenotnecessarilyequal(p.301).Thepreferredwaytocontrolfishdistributionafterreturninghomeistochoosethefishtodistributetospecific‘householdsandindividualsfreeofscrutinyorpressure’(p.301).Butthedistributionoffishoccursamonganumberofhousesthatfunctionas‘multi-housenetworks’(p.303).Itisthroughsuchnetworksthatfundsofknowledgearelearned,sharedandpractised.
Where is the community, and what did I do?
Theprojectadoptedacommunity-basedapproachbecauseit‘conveysamuchmoreintimate,humanandself-definedspace’(Smith1999:127).Itreliesuponandvalidatesthecommunity’sowndefinitions.Iestablishedarelationshipwithcommunitymembersovertimeasaconsequenceofanotherprojectthatwasbasedattheprimaryschool,butchosetoembarkonapreliminaryprocessincollaborationwiththecommunityfollowingculturalprotocols,respectforthecommunityandbecausethisprojectwasbasedwithinthecommunityandnotschool.Whereisthecommunity?
TheTorresStraitIslandsconsistofeighteenislandsandtwoNorthernPeninsulaAreacommunities(TorresStraitRegionalAuthority2010).TheyaregeographicallysituatedfromthetipofCapeYorknorthtothebordersofPapuaNewGuineaandIndonesiaandscatteredoveranareaof48,000squarekilometres.TherearefivetraditionalislandclustersintheTorresStrait:topwestern,western,central,easternandinnerislands(seeFigure1,TorresStraitRegionalAuthorityMap2011).
138 Bronwyn Ewing
Figure 1: Torres Strait Regional Authority Map
AlthoughIhadvisitedtheislandonpreviousoccasions,Icomefromabackgroundofspeakingonlyonelanguage,English,whichwasoneofthreelanguagesspokenontheislandoroneoffourspokenintheTorresStraits.SpecificlanguagesarespokeninTorresStraitIslandercommunitiesincludingStandardAustralianEnglish,Yumplatok(Creole),KalaLagawYa(Mabuyag)andMeriamMir(Osborne,2009;Shnukal,2004).KalaKawawYa(KKY)isunderstoodtobeadialectofKalaLagawYa(Osborne2009).Thetraditionallanguagesofthetopwesternandwesternislands,KalaLagawYa(KKYandMabuyag)areunderstoodtocomefromthemainlandofAustralia,withtheeasternislandlanguage,MeriamMir,emergingfromPapuaNewGuinea.Yumplatok,identifiedasamodernlanguageandstemmingfrom
Mathematics funds of knowledge 139
colonisation,isderivedfrom‘meshing’bothtraditionallanguagesandEnglish,thuscreatingalanguageinitsownright(Osborne2009;Shnukal2004).Thislanguageisidentifiedasunifying,thatis,itistheonethateveryoneintheTorresStraitscanspeak,whereasthewestern,traditionallanguagespeakerscannotspeakandunderstandtheeasternlanguagespeakers(Osborne2009;Shnukal2004).
Who are the community?
Communitymemberswhohadavoluntarydesiretoparticipatewereincluded.Thereislittlebenefitderivedfromcommandingthatpeopleshouldattend.Whenthereisasincereinterestinreciprocallearninginacommunity,relationshipsandtrustcangrow.Twentyadultsandeightchildrentookpartinthecommunityconsultationmeeting.Allresideinthecommunitywherethemeetingwasheld.FouradultstookpartintheworkshopwhichwasheldinanIndigenousKnowledgeCentrethatiscentrallylocatedinthecommunity.Allparticipantsliveinthatcommunity.Theiridentitiesareprotectedinthispaperusingpseudonyms.
How did the meeting and workshopcome to be and what were the methods for doing this?
Recentinvolvementwithcommunitiestaughtmeabouttheimportanceofmeetingwithcommunity.Ihavelearnt,andcontinuetolearn,aboutwhatworksandwhatdoesnot.Whatworksispredicatedontheassumptionthat,ifcommunitycanengageandidentifywithwhatisdiscussed,themoreinterestandenthusiasmisshown.Individualmeetingswereheldwithseveralpeople,forexample,theschoolcampusleaderandtheIslandCouncillorandtoseekpermissiontomeetunderthe‘OmeiTree’—TreeofWisdom—whichwassuggestedbyDenise,aseniorcommunitywoman.AmeetingwasalsoheldwiththelocalradioannouncerfortheIslandradiowhichthenresultedinaradiointerviewthatwasbroadcasttotheIslandcommunity.WithsupportfromDenise,andaparent
140 Bronwyn Ewing
fromthecommunity,apaper-basedflyerwasdeliveredface-to-facetothehomesofIslandparentstoletthemknowaboutaproposedcommunitymeetingandaworkshopgathering.Thecontentoftheflyerwasbriefandaimedtoprovidesuccinctinformationforeaseofreadingandclarity.Aspertheflyerschedule,themeetingwasheldforonehourundertheOmeiTreewithanumberofcommunitymembersinattendance.Accordingtoonecommunitymember,thefigtreeisbelievedtobeoveronehundredyearsoldandhasbeenasignificantmeetingplacefortheIslandcommunity.DuringthemeetingIexplainedtheprojectandhowparticipantsmightbeinvolved.Gainingconsentwasrespectfulofthecommunity’splaceandenvironmentasalsowasthat,asavisitor,Ineededtobemindfulofmyactionsandpresenceandconductinthecommunity.
What kinds of questions did I ask?
ThekindsofquestionsIaskedemergedasaconversationratherthanaresearchinterviewformat.Icarefullyexplainedthatconfidentialitywouldbemaintainedandthatpseudonymsarealwaysusedtoprotectthecommunity’sidentities.AtthemeetingIaskedthegroupwheretheyusedmathematicsintheirdailylives.Theresponsesincluded:buyingfoodatthesupermarket,cookingandcountingfishandshells,indicatingthatitemergesthroughdailyactivities.Asthediscussionprogressed,Iexplainedsomeoftheearlynumberideassuchassorting/classificationusingshells,sticks,leaves,andPoincianapodsthatIhadgatheredfromthecommunity.TheseitemswerecollectedafterseekingpermissionfromJulia,aSeniorcommunitymember.AtthesubsequentworkshopIaskedaboutsharingandwhereitwasusedindailylife.
Data collection techniques
Forthepurposesofthispaper,thedatacollectiontechniquesincluded:digitalphotography,fieldnotesandaudio-recordingofaworkshop.Digitalphotographyasanon-writtensourceofdata
Mathematics funds of knowledge 141
allowedforthecapturingofvisualimagesthatwerecentraltothepreliminaryprocessandwhichservedasareminderforme(Stringer2004).Fieldnotesprovideddescriptionsofplacesandeventsastheyoccurred.Theyprovidedongoingrecordsofimportantelementsofthesettingandassistedwithreportingandreflectingbackoverevents.Audio-recordingservedasadetailedreminder,capturingparticipants’knowledgeandunderstandingsverbatim(Stringer2004).Italsoprovidedongoingrecordsofimportantelementsofthesetting.Eachtechniqueaffordedthevalueofinsightintotheimportantpreliminaryplanningoftheproject(Stringer2004).
What happened at the community meeting?
Inrecentyears,buildingonwhatcommunitiesbringtoparticularcontextsandontheirstrengthshasbeenshowntobeeffectiveinengagingwithcommunities(Gonzalez&Moll2002).Howdoesthisoccur?Awaytoengagecommunitywastodrawtheminwithknowledgethatwasalreadyfamiliartothem,andwhichthenservedasabasisforfurtherdiscussionandlearning(Gonzalezetal.2002).However,withthisprocesstherewasachallengeanddilemma.HowdidIknowabouttheknowledgethattheybroughttothemeetingwithoutfallingintostereotypingtheirculturalpractices?HowdidIaddressthedynamicprocessofthelivedexperiencesofthecommunity?Smith(1999)hasarguedthattheresponsestothesequestionshaveemergedfromcommunity-basedresearchthatreliesonthecommunity’sdefinitionsanddiscussions.
Inthemeeting,IintroducedmyselfandexplainedwhoIwasandwhereIwasfrom.Ialsoexplainedsomeofmybackgroundandexperiencesasamatterofprotocolandrespect.Byintroducingmyselftothecommunity,Iprovidedinformationaboutmyculturallocation‘sothatconnectioncanbemadeonpolitical,culturalandsocialgroundsandrelationsestablished’(Moreton-Robinson2000:xv).Thisprocessthenallowedthecommunitytolocatemeinthecontext
142 Bronwyn Ewing
ofancestry,whereIwasfromandmyfamilyrelations.Asthemeetingprogressed,Iaskedacoupleofopen-endedquestionstoinvitestoriesaboutwheremathematicsmightbeusedindailylifeontheisland.Thisledtoconversationsamongstthegroupaboutwheretheyusedmaths.Theirresponseshelpedtoconceptualisethemathstheyused,forexample,sorting.
Whenaskedhowtheymightsortshells,Denisevolunteeredtosortarangeofdifferentshellsintogroups.Wethenhadtoidentifywhatcriteriawereusedforthegrouping.Sortingactivitiesassistwiththepromotionofunderstandingsofgrouping.Childrenlearntosortobjectsintogroupsfromtheirdailyexperiences.Theylearntoidentifysamenessthatdefinesthecharacteristicsofgroupings(Sousa2008).Theideaofcreatingandnaminggroupscontinuesthroughoutlifeandisawayofcreatingandorganisinginformationandmakingconnectionswithpeople’sexperiences.Beforeyoungchildrencanlearntocountgroups,theybegintheprocessofdefiningacollectionusingtheobjectsintheirdailylives(Baroody&Benson2001;Sousa2008).Hence,theyneedexperiencesthathavearichvarietyoftwo-andthree-dimensionalobjects.Noticinglikenessesanddifferencesamongobjects,childrenbecomeawareofthefeaturesthatdifferentobjectshave.Theyalsobecomeawareofgroupingobjects.Suchanunderstandingpavesthewayforlearningaboutpartitioning.Deniseestablishedthefeaturesofeachofthesetsofshells.Ifthecriteriaformembershiptoagrouparevague,itismorechallengingtodecidewhethertheshellsbelongtoaparticulargroup.Wetalkedfurtheramongstourselves,withDeniseallowingustimetoidentifythefeaturesofeachgroup.
Frommyexperience,Icouldnotidentifythecriteriathatdefinedthegroups;however,therewasconsensusamongstcommunitythatcriteriahadbeenestablished—edibleandnon-edibleshellcreatures.Inthisexample,thecommunityusedtheirdailylivesandactivitiesasanopportunitytotalkaboutsortingusingtheirhome
Mathematics funds of knowledge 143
language—YumplatokandEnglish.WhenIaskedwhenchildrenlearnaboutedibleandnon-edibleshells,therewasconsensusthatthisoccursataveryyoungage,forexample,onetotwoyears,andduringtimeswhenfamilieswalkalongtheshoresoftheIslandandwhenfishingorplayinginthewater.ThisexamplereinforcesMoll’s(2002)statementthatlearningcanberichandpurposefulwhenitissituatedwithinthatwhichalreadyexists—theculture,communityandhome-languageofthegroup.Gonzalez(2005)explainsthisfurtherbystatingthatmathsisembeddedinsocialknowledgeandmediatedthroughlanguageandtheactivitiesofthecommunity.Itisnotlearnednorisitdisembodiedfromitssocialmeaningandcontextashappenswithinformalschoolingandbecomesalinearprocessofdialogue.Thelearningaboutsortingedibleandnon-edibleshellcreatureswasdistributedamongthegroup.Itwasashared,collectiveconstructionofmathematicalknowledge.Ifoundthatthisexperienceofsharedknowledge,richinitsowncomplexity,evincedknowledgethathadbeenhistoricallyandculturallyaccumulatedandsharedthroughdailyliving.Thecommunityvalidatedtheirdefinitionsofknowledge,sortingusingshellsfromtheirenvironment.Indoingso,thisprocessprovidedarichwaytorepresenttheirknowledgeandcompetencetosupporttheirchildren.
Asthemeetingcametoanend,memberswereaskediftheywouldlikefurthermathsworkshopstobeorganisedfor,andwith,theparentsandchildren.OfimportancewasthatthecommunityneededtimetonetworkanddiscusswhethertheywantedmetoreturnandworkwithparentsandchildrenontheIslandandiftheyidentifiedthattherewerebenefitsfortheircommunity.Thenextsectiontalksaboutoneworkshopandwhathappened.
What happened at the workshop?
Buildingonwhatcommunitiesbringtoparticularcontextsandontheirstrengthshasbeenshowntobeeffectiveinengagingwith
144 Bronwyn Ewing
communities(Gonzalez&Moll2002).Thiswasevidentfromthecommunitymeetingandfirstworkshopconductedthatfocusedonearlyalgebra.Asecondworkshopwasheld,withparentsinvitedtoidentifyitsfocus.Itwasduringthatworkshopthatsharingandpartitioningemergedasmathematicalprocessesthatparentsusedintheirdailylives.Usingasemi-structured,informaldiscussionandusingitemspreviouslycollected,allowedforunderstandingsofhowthisknowledgemightbeusedtosupporttheirchildren’slearning.IwasinvitedtodotheworkshopintheIndigenousKnowledgeCentreontheIsland,aplaceofagencythatpermitsandpromotesengagementinarangeofactivitiesforthecommunity(Taylor2004).
Partitioningexperiencesareimportantforbuildingrationalnumberunderstandings(see,forexample,Piaget,Inhelder&Szeminska1960).Theabilitytodivideanobjectoragroupofobjectsintoequalpartsisidentifiedascriticaltounderstandingthelogicaldevelopmentofpart-partandpart-wholerelationshipsandnotionsofequalityandinequality(Lamon1996).Thisabilitymayalsoinfluencechildren’sunderstandingsofmathematicaltopicssuchasmeasurementandgeometry.Partitioningisaprocessthatgeneratesquantityand,indoingso,buildsunderstandingsofrationalnumbers(Lamon1996;Pothier&Sawada1983).Itisanactivitythatisintuitiveandexperienced-based;indeed,thisprocessconnectstheprocessofconstructingrationalnumberswithchildren’sinformalknowledgeaboutfairsharing(Pothier&Sawada1983).Unitising,however,isacognitiveprocessforcomingtoknowandunderstandtheamountofagivenitemorsharebefore,duringandafterthesharingprocess.InthefollowingexcerptstheprocessofpartitioningisdescribedbyAilia,oneofthreewomenwhoattendedtheworkshop.Ailiaeexplainstheprocessofgivingfish.ThisexplanationcameaboutasaconsequenceofaquestionIaskedaboutwheremathsisusedinthewomen’sdailylives.Ailiadrawsonlanguagethatisassociatedwithpartitioning—division.Ofsignificanceinthefollowingexcerptisthatsheexplainshow‘we’involve‘ourkids’ingivingfish.
Mathematics funds of knowledge 145
Ailia:Likeyouaskedmewhatwedoherelike,nowwhenwecomeinwiththefishandtheshareforthecommunity[unclear]wedowithourkidsandtheywatch.
Inthisexcerpttwoaspectsaresignificant.Thefirstistheuseoftheterm‘share’andthesecondisthat,afterthewomenhavegonefishing,that‘share’isforthecommunityandtheirchildrenareengagedintheactivity.Throughtheprocessofwatching,thechildrenlearnedthesubstanceofsharingexperiencesthatcanthenbeusedasopportunitiesforexperimentinginothercontextsand,indoingso,buildingtheirknowledgeoffairsharingviafamilyactivitiesandrelations.ThisprocessisinlinewithwhatLahn(2006)identifiedinherworkoffishgivingpracticesintheTorresStraitIslands.Thereciprocal,nurturingrelationshipoccursacrossgenerationswiththewomennurturingandmodellingtothechildrenhow‘oldermembers’arecaredforinthecommunity.
Here,thespecificcharacteristicsofcommunityrelationshipsandactivitiesseemtoconvergeonverysimilarlyorganisednetworksofrelationsbasedon‘denseexchange’(Velez-Ibanez&Greenberg2005:53).Foreachfamilyfromwhichthewomenandchildrencome,thefundsofknowledgeaccumulatedandthatformthebasisofdailylifecontainmuchofthepreviousgeneration’srepertoireofinformationandskillsforliving.Thesefundsofknowledgeareembeddedineitherhistoricalorcontemporaryexperiencesoffamilies.Thefundsandexperiencesarea‘currencyofexchange’(p.54)betweengenerationsandfamiliesthatformthe‘culturalglue’(p.54)thatmaintainsculturalrelations.Thisexchangeandtheideaofsharingareembeddedinthesocialknowledgeofthewomen.Itismediatedthroughthesharingexperiencesthatthewomenperformanddistributeamongthegroupincludingthechildren.Inthenextexcerpt,Ailiadescribessharingasapracticewhichismediatedanddistributedamongstthefamilies,activitiesandcontexts.
146 Bronwyn Ewing
Ailia:Whenwedividethefishamongthefamilies,likeifI’vegotmythreesistersandtwobrothersthatIneedtocatchfish[unclear],withthefish,itdoesn’t,wedon’tall[get]thebiggeronesinthisfamilyandthentheothersistergetthesmallones,wedivideitquiteevenly,likeallthebigfishinthebasket,wegetoneeach.Andthenwegodowntothesecondsize,evenitup.
Bron:Sotheneveryonecangohomeandfeellikeithasbeenafairsharingout?
Ailia:Yes.
Bron:Andthat’stheprocessmostofthetime?
Ailia:Yeah.
Bron:Andthechildrenlearnthat?
Ailia:Yes.
Bron:Theygrowupknowingthat?
Ailia’sexplanationprovidedcriticalinsightsintohowdivisionwasdeeplyembeddedinfishgivingpractices.Itisthesesamepracticesthathavethepotentialtobeinvisiblethroughthetrainedeyesofformaleducation(Gonzalez,Andrade,Civil&Moll2005).Themathsinvolvedinsuchpractices,go‘beyondfacileconstructsofsocialcontextandmusttakeintoaccountthedeeplyfeltrelationshipsofco-participants,thesocialrelationshipsinvolvedinundertakingthepracticesaswellasthedeepengagementofconnectionwithaproduct,andnotjustaprocess’(p.264).Ailiawasinterestedinexplainingthefish-givingprocessbut,indoing,sowasalsointerestedinuncoveringthemathsinasystematisedway.Forexample,sheexplainedthatshehadthreesistersandtwobrothersthatsheneededtocatchfishforanddistributeevenly.Thefishwerefirstsortedintodifferentsizes.Thegroupswerecreatedbasedonsameness,thatis,fishweresortedbyweightthroughtheactionofhefting,andmeasuringlengthandgirthbysight(seeFigure1below).
Mathematics funds of knowledge 147
Figure 1: A fair share
Thisprocessaffordsyoungchildrenwithopportunitiestolearnaboutsorting,sharingandpartitioning.Howmanyparentsandchildrenareawarethatthisknowledgeasitrelatestodivisionresidesintheirdailypractices?Intheaboveexample,thefishweredistributedandthencheckedtoseehowmanyeachbucketreceived.Whenpartitioning,thenumberofgroupsisalreadyknown,buthowmanyobjectsmustbeplacedineachgroupisnotknown.Inthenextexcerpt,Ailiaexplainsthesharingprocessfurther:
Ailia:Ifweonlyhavefourbuckets,evenifweonlyhavethreebigfishthatneedstogointoandthenwetaketwosmalleronesthatwillmakeitlikeabigBron:Oh,okay.Ailia:Andthenthere’s[one]forthat,andthesethreebucketswillbethisbig[one]andthisone,twointhere.Bron:Youknowfeelintermsofweightorbysight?Ailia:Justby[movesarmstoindicateheftingaction].Bron:Sight?Ailia:Yeah.
148 Bronwyn Ewing
InFigure1,thesizeofthesetisunknownandiscalledfair-sharingorapartitionproblem.InAilia’sexcerptabove,thewhole(fivefish)issharedamongaknownnumberofbuckets(four)todeterminethenumberoffishineachbucketandequality.Equalitywasrepresentedastwosmallerfishequallingthesizeofonelargerfish.Whenaskedabouthowthesizeoffishweredetermined,Ailiarespondedbyheftingandgesturingtowardshereyetoindicatebysight.
InthisexamplepartitioningwasfoundtonotbeapossessionthatresidedinAilia’sheadasafixedattributeorskillonlyknowntoher.Rather,partitioningwasapractice,andgivingfishcreatedacontextforthedevelopmentandteachingofthatpractice.Gonzalezetal.(2005)arguethatunderstandingmathsisnotsimplyaboutthepossessionoffundsofknowledgeinmathematicaldomains.Thekeypointhereisthatsuchdomainsmustbesociallymediatedinto‘productiveknowledgeinordertobemeaningful’(p.266),asdemonstratedinthefollowingexcerptfromAilia:
Ailia:Whenwedothat,kidswillstandthereandsay,whydon’tyouput[indistinct]thequestion,sothenweexplainittothem.
Bron:Yep.
Ailia:Sowewantiteven.
WhatisevidentintheaboveseriesofexcerptsisthatAiliaandthewomenshereferredtowhowereinvolvedinthefish-givingpracticehavetheskills,connectionsandunderstandingswithhowtheprocessworks.Itisuptothewomentopassonthisknowledgeandsupporttotheirchildrenbecausetheyarebroughtupthiswayandthereforeitiswhatisexpected(Lahn2006).Thereciprocityamongfamilywasevidentintheexcerpt.Eachstepintheprocessrevealedanetworkoffamilywhogaveorreceivedfishandadvisedthechildrenoreachother,thusmaintainingsecondgenerationandorthirdgenerationrelationsandpractices.Suchactivitiesdemonstratehowtheprocessestablishedenduring,socialrelationshipsandinterdependenceas
Mathematics funds of knowledge 149
wellasthepartitioningprocess,wherethefocuswasonequalityandsameness.
Theknowledgeofgivingfishhadnotbeentaughtsystemicallytothechildren.Butsuchknowledgebecomesusefulwithinthemathscurriculuminschoolsasameansofstimulatingandengagingstudents’curiosityabouttheirenvironmentandtheirculturalpracticesinacontextthatisrelevanttotheirlives.Whenchildrenbeginschool,andwherethereisanunequaldistributionoffundsofknowledgeandwherematerialsandtextbooksmaybelimited,theuseofapedagogythatdrawsonthechildren’sculturalknowledgeandtheresourcesavailabletothemmakesgoodsense(Browning-Aiken2005).Whenchildrenareprovidedwithactivitiessuchastheexamplesaboveintheirdailylivespriortoschooling,astrongargumentcouldbemadethattheyshouldbemuchmorecloselylinkedwhenchildrencommenceformallearningofpartitioning—division.
Conclusion
Inevaluatingthemeetingandworkshopasstrategiesforengagingwithparentsandtheirculturalpracticesandthemathsthatispartofsuchpractices,theexperiencehasrevealedseveralthemesthatdirectlyaffectthenatureofhome-communityrelations-earlyyears’schoolingandhavethepotentialforimprovingeducationalachievementsonthebasisofmoreknowledgeofpedagogicalpractices.Forone,Ailiaplacedhighvalueonfairsharing—partitioningwhichwasindicatedinthedailypracticesusedtosharethisskillaswellasexhibitingrespectforfamilymemberswhowerealsoteachers.Learningwassomethingthatoccurredinthecommunityandathomeinaformofincreasinghouseholdresponsibilitiesandinthebusinessofpeopleintheirfamilynetworks.Together,thethemeshaveimplicationsforthenatureoftheteachingthatparentsengageinandforthepedagogywithinclassroomswhen
150 Bronwyn Ewing
childrenbeginschool.Thus,teachersneedopportunitieswheretheycanengagewithparentstolearnwhatfundsofknowledgeexistamongtheirstudentsbecausetheyprovideanimportantpartoftheteachingandlearningprocesswhenmaterialsandresourcesarelimited.Conversely,fundsofknowledgecanbeconsideredasenrichingasthecurriculumwheresuchresourcesareavailable.
Acknowledgment
Theauthorrespectfullyacknowledgesthesupport,enthusiasmandengagementoftheIslandcommunity.Withouttheirconsent,theprojectwouldnothavetakenplace.
References
AustralianCurriculumandReportingAuthority(2009).Mathematics.Retrieved01/12/2011,fromhttp://www.australiancurriculum.edu.au/Mathematics/Rationale
Baroody,A.&Benson,A.(2001).‘Earlynumberinstruction’Teaching Children Mathematics,8:154–158.
Browning-Aiken,A.(2005).‘Bordercrossings:Fundsofknowledgewithinanimmigranthousehold’,inN.Gonzalez,L.Moll&C.Amanti(eds.),Funds of knowledge: Theorizing practices in households, communities and classrooms(pp.167–182).NewYork:Routledge.
DepartmentofEducationandTraining(2010).A flying start for Queensland children: Education green paper for public consultation.Retrievedfromhttp://deta.qld.gov.au/aflyingstart/pdfs/greenpaper.pdf
DepartmentofEducation,EmploymentandWorkRelations(2011).‘NationalAboriginalandTorresStraitIslanderEducationPolicy(AEP)’.Retrieved26/2/2011fromhttp://www.deewr.gov.au/Indigenous/Schooling/PolicyGuidelines/Pages/aep.aspx
DepartmentofEducation,TrainingandtheArts(2008).‘Foundationsforsuccess:GuidelinesforanearlylearningprograminAboriginalandTorresStraitcommunities’.Availablefromhttp://education.qld.gov.au/schools/indigenous/projects/foundations.html
Gonzalez,N.,Andrade,R.,Civil,M.&Moll,L.(2005).‘Fundsofdistributedknowledge’,inN.Gonzalez,L.Moll&C.Amanti(eds.),Funds of knowledge: Theorizing practices in households, communities and classrooms(pp.257–274),NewYork:Routledge.
Mathematics funds of knowledge 151
Gonzalez,N.&Moll,L.C.(2002).‘CruzandoElPuente:Buildingbridgestofundsofknowledge’,Educational Policy, 16(4):623–641.
Lahn,J.(2006).‘Women’sgift-fishandsocialityintheTorresStrait,Australia’,Oceania, 76(3):297–309.
Lamon,S.(1996).‘Thedevelopmentofunitizing:Itsroleinchildren’spartitioningstrategies’,Journal for Research in Mathematics Education,27(2):170–193.
Makuwira,J.(2007).‘Thepoliticsofcommunitycapacitybuilding:Contestations,contradictions,tensionsandambivalencesinthediscourseinIndigenouscommunitiesinAustralia’,Australian Journal of Indigenous Education,36(supplement):129–136.
Moll,L.C.(1992).‘Fundsofknowledgeforteaching:Usingaqualitativeapproachtoconnecthomesandclassrooms’,Theory into Practice,31(2):132–141.
Moreton-Robinson,A.(2000).‘Talkin up to the white women: Indigenous women and feminism’,StLucia,Brisbane:UniversityofQueenslandPress.
Osborne,E.(2009).Throwing off the cloak,Canberra:AboriginalStudiesPress.
Piaget,J.,Inhelder,B.&Szeminska,A.(1960).The child’s conception of geometry,NewYork:Basic.
PothierY.&SawadaD.(1983).‘Partitioning:Theemergenceofrationalnumberideasinyougchildren’,Journal for Research in Mathematics Education,14(5):307–317.
Shnukal,A.(2004).A dictionary of Torres Strait Creole,Kuranda:TheRamsSkullPress.
Smith,L.T.(1999).Decolonizing methodologies: Research and Indigenous peoples,Dunedin:UniversityofOtagoPress.
Sousa,D.A.(2008).How the brain learns mathematics,ThousandOaks:CorwinPress.
Stringer,E.(2004).Action research in education,UpperSaddleRiver,NJ:Pearson.
Taylor,S.(2004).‘Challengingideas:Indigenousknowledgecentre—theQueenslandexperience’,paperpresentedatAustralianLibraryInformationAssociation,21–24September,GoldCoast,Queensland.Retrievedfromhttp://conferences.alia.org.au/alia2004/pdfs/taylor.s.paper.pdf
152 Bronwyn Ewing
TorresStraitIslanderRegionalEducationCouncil(2011).‘T.S.I.R.E.C.’Retrieved04/09/2011,fromhttp://www.tsirec.com.au/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=37&Itemid=72
TorresStraitRegionalAuthority(2010).‘TorresStraitRegionalAuthority’.Retrieved09/07/09,fromhttp://www.tsra.gov.au/the-torres-strait/community-profiles.aspx
Vélez-Ibáñez,C.&Greenberg,J.(2005).‘Formationandtransformationoffundsofknowledge’,inN.Gonzalez,L.Moll&C.Amanti(eds.),Funds of knowledge: Theorizing practices in households, communities, and classrooms(pp.47–70).NewYork:Routledge.
About the author
Dr Bronwyn Ewing is a mathematics education researcher at Queensland University of Technology, specialising in the pedagogy of mathematics classrooms from the early years to VET contexts. She has a special interest in the teaching and learning of mathematics to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander students and the role of Torres Strait Islander women in their children’s prior-to-school mathematics education.
Contact details
Senior Lecturer, Yumi Deadly Centre School of Maths, Science and Technology, Faculty of Education, Queensland University of Technology, Kelvin Grove Campus, GPO 2434, Brisbane, Queensland 4001Tel: +61 7 3138 3718 Fax: +61 7 3138 3985Email: [email protected]