Languages of Instruction: English as a Lingua Franca in the
Multilingual University
Ini%al Results Prof. Dr. Peter Siemund Jessica Terese Mueller
Deutsche Ak%onstage Nachhal%gkeit 2 June 2016
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 1
Overview
• Background Informa%on • Research Ques%ons • Methodology • Preliminary Results • Discussion • Q&A
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 2
Two Concomitant Developments
• Global spread of English and widespread use of English as a Lingua Franca
• Increasing levels of mul%lingualism due to high levels of mobility and migra%on
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 3
Global Spread of English
• About 400 million na%ve speakers of English vs. more than 2 billion non-‐na%ve speakers
• Increasing numbers of non-‐na%ve speakers
• Drive for universi%es to aQract interna%onal students (business opportuni%es)
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 4
Higher Education
• Universi%es as businesses, dependent on external funding
• Interna%onal students offer significant income • English-‐based degree programs aQrac%ve because – very low language barrier – scien%fic literature mainly in English – facilita%on of subsequent mobility
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 5
Research Questions
• How many and which languages can we find in typical higher educa%on classrooms?
• How does the use of English as a Lingua Franca interact with mul%lingualism?
• Do mul%lingual users of English as a Lingua Franca have advantages over other speakers?
• If so, how can such advantages be objec%vely measured and made use of?
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 6
Methodology
• Par%cipants (Goal: 500) – Students – Instructors
• Instruments – LimeSurvey Online Ques%onnaires – Semi-‐structured Interview Outline
• Procedure – Recruitment – Online Surveys – Interviews with selected Par%cipants
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 7
LimeSurvey-Questionnaires
• Informed Consent • Linguis%c Background • English as a Lingua Franca • Mul%lingualism • German as a Second-‐ or Foreign Language • Demographic Informa%on
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 8
Linguistic Background
• Up to 15 languages • Not only languages, also dialects and varia%ons permiQed
• Passive and ac%ve skills at any level • Interdependence Hypothesis (Cummins, 1984)
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 9
Linguistic Background
• Language List – Iden%fica%on of Mother Tongue – Loca%ons of Learning and/or Acquisi%on
• Self-‐Assessment of Proficiency (GER) – Listening Comprehension – Oral Communica%on – Reading Comprehension – Advanced Oral Communica%on – WriQen Communica%on
• Self-‐Assessment of Ability to Teach in English* • Language Use
– At the University – In private life
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 10
Preliminary Results
• Students – Pilot Project: (N=74; n=42) – Current Round of Data Collec%on: (N=1325; n=926)
• Instructors – Pilot Project: (N=18; n=15) – Current Round of Data Collec%on: (N=314; n=217)
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 11
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 12
Gender: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 13
Age: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 14
Area of Study/Expertise: Students vs. Instructors
Students: Degree Pursued
1502.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 16
Instructors: Type of Position at the University
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 17
Number of Languages Listed: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 18
Number of Mother Tongues: Students vs. Instructors
Preliminary Results
• Well over 200 different languages, varie%es and dialects iden%fied – Varie%es and Dialects of German, English, etc. – Na%onally recognised minority languages (i.e., Sorbian, Friesian, East-‐Friesian, Low-‐German, Danish*)
– Different na%onal and minority languages from Europe, Asia, Africa, and North-‐ and South America
– Various sign languages – „dead“ languages – Constructed languages (e.g., Esperanto) – Programming Languages
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 19
Languages Identified German English Greek Russian Punjabi Ukranian Low German French Farsi Turkish Spanish Hindi Portuguese Chinese Finnish Dari Norwegian Urdu Italian Estonian Romansh Occitan Karelian Meänkieli Faraoese Erza Mordvin
Welsh Swedish Tamil Danish Korean Binisaya Arabic Catalan Polish Japanese Yucatec-‐Maya Czech Persian Xhosa Indonesian Mordvinic Twi Hungarian Vietnamese Kurdish Kazakh Cantonese Setswana Nkwen East-‐Fresian Duala
Mandarin Swahili Wolof Bosnian Serbian CroaTan Scots Dutch Azerbaijani Romanian Hawaiian Thai Albanian Belarusian Valencian Tatar Bulgarian Chichewa Afrikaans Kyrgyz Kinyarwanda Kirundi Quechua Yoruba Dagbani Taiwanese
Hausa Yiddish Slovak Khmer Islandic Georgian Zazaki Pashto Sorbian Latvian Lithuanian Lakota LaoTan Armenian Fresian Marquesan Aragonese Asturian Nepali Öömrang (North-‐Fresian) GujaraT Malay Tagalog Tibetan Kashmiri
Basque Gagauzian Ivrit Marathi Ainu Buryat Amharic Gaelic Belorussian Maltese Nahuatl Haya Kreyol Ayisyan Manx Tigrinya Lingala Pali Veps Masai Bengali VeniTan Ladakhi Uzbek Selkup Sousou Zulu... 02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 20
Other Types of Languages Identified
Pidgins and Creoles Classical Languages Sign Languages Constructed Languages
Pidgin English French Creole Creole Tok Pisin Kreyol Ayisyan
La%n Classical Greek Old Norse Old High German Old English Middle English Middle High German Sanskrit Ancient Hebrew Old Islandic Classical Tibetan Classical Chinese
German Sign Language French Sign Language American Sign Language Deanlind Manual Alphabet Austrian Sign Language Norwegian Sign Language
Esperanto Elvish 1337-‐$P34K (Leet-‐Speak)
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 21
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 22
Language 1: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 23
Language 2: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 24
Language 3: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 25
Language 4: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 26
Language 5: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 27
Language 6: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 28
Language 7: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 29
Language 8: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 30
Language 9: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 31
Language 10: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 32
Language 11: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 33
Language 12: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 34
Language 13: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 35
Language 14: Students vs. Instructors
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 36
Language 15: Students vs. Instructors
Instructors: Self-Assessment of Ability to Teach in English
• Majority feels comfortable using English when teaching
• As required proficiency rises, number of instructors comfortable with tasks decreases
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 37
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 38
Instructors: Self-Assessment of Ability to Teach in English (A1/A2)
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 39
Instructors: Self-Assessment of Ability to Teach in English (B1/B2)
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 40
Instructors: Self-Assessment of Ability to Teach in English (C1/C2)
Discussion
• Interpreta%on of Data – Pending • Strengths
– flexibility Re: language defini%on – Larger number of languages permiQed – Passive skills incorporated
• Limita%ons – Classifica%on of languages/dialects/varie%es – Anonymous Data – Possible double entries – Subjec%ve Assessment of Language Skills
• Plan for further Research
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 41
Questions?
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 42
Selected References
• Bolton, K.; Kuteeva, M. (2012). English as an academic language at a Swedish university: Parallel language use and the ’threat’ of English. Journal of Mul+lingual and Mul+cultural Development, 33: 429–447.
• Canagarajah, S. (2007). Lingua Franca English, Mul%lingual Communi%es, and Language Acquisi%on. The Modern Language Journal, 91: 923–939.
• Derwing, T.M.; Munro, M.J.; Thomson, R.I. (2009). Comprehensibility as a Factor in Listener Interac%on Preferences: Implica%ons for the Workplace. The Canadian Modern Language Review/La Revue canadienne des langue vivantes, 66(2), 181-‐202.
• House, J. (2003). English as a Lingua Franca: A threat to mul%lingualism? Journal of Sociolinguis+cs, 7(4): 556–578. • Jenkins, J. (2006). Points of view and blind spots: ELF and SLA. Interna+onal Journal of Applied Linguis+cs, 16(2):
137–162. • Mauranen, A.; Ranta, E. (eds.). (2009). English as a Lingua Franca: Studies and Findings. Newcastle upon Tyne:
Cambridge Scholars Publishing. • Munro, M.J.; Derwing, T.M. (1995). Foreign Accent, Comprehensibility, and Intelligibility in the Speech of Second
Language Learners. Language Learning, 45, 73-‐97. • Munro, M.J.; Derwing, T.M. (1999). Foreign Accent, Comprehensibility, and Intelligibility in the Speech of Second
Language Learners. Language Learning, 49, 285-‐310. • O’Brien, M.G. (2014). L2 Learners’ Assessments of Accentedness, Fluency and Comprehensibility of Na%ve and
Nonna%ve German Speech. Language Learning 64:4, 715-‐748. • O’Brien, M.G. (2015). Methodological Choices in Ra%ng Speech Samples. Studies in Second Language Acquisi+on,
1–19. • Seidlhofer, B. (2010). "Lingua franca English – the European context". In Kirkpatrick, A. (ed.). The Routledge
Handbook of World Englishes. Abingdon:Routledge, 355-‐371.
02.06.16 Languages of Instruction: Siemund and Mueller 43