Presented by Irondequoit Public Library Board of Trustees
December 11, 2013
Irondequoit Public Library Proposal
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Why are we voting again?
• After voters overwhelmingly approved the referendum in April, 7 residents sued the town
• To avoid a long and costly lawsuit, the town’s attorney advised the town to re-do the environmental review
• The residents then agreed to end the lawsuit
• Another vote was not required, but all town bond resolutions are subject to a permissive referendum
• A petition was filed to force a second vote, so the town scheduled new referendum for Saturday, December 14
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Has anything changed?
• After receiving feedback from residents at 21 public information sessions in the spring, the building was scaled back to 40,000 sq. ft.
• This single change will:
– Create a smaller foot print
– Preserve more green space
– Allow for additional parking
• Nothing else has changed
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
A New Central Library
• A new building with up to 40,000 sq. ft.
• Will complement the Town Hall architecture
• Larger spaces for library operations
• Flexible meeting room space for:
– Library programs
– Programs by other town departments
– Community organizations
• Possible revenue producing operations
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Not Meeting Library User Needs
• Last major renovation or expansion was 1985
• Inadequate space and facilities
• Cosmetic improvements do not address the issues
• Renovations are not a long-term solution
• Lack of space affects operations and public use
• Upkeep for current buildings costs $44,000 per year
• Two out-dated library branches still require duplicative services for janitors, trash collection, snow removal.
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Years Since MCLS Libraries Built New or Completed Major Renovations
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Brighton Chili Fairport Gates Greece Henrietta Irondequoit Penfield Pittsford Webster
24,000 24,700
38,200
20,000
24,000
28,10030,000
43,000
0,000
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
30,000
35,000
40,000
45,000
50,000
Brighton 35,588
Fairport 46,090
Greece 94,141
Henrietta 39,028
Irondequoit 52,354
Penfield 34,645
Pittsford 27,219
Webster 37,926
Sq
ua
re F
ee
t
Town and Population
Town Library Sizes
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Why Town Hall Campus?
• This is the central location
• Saves the cost of purchasing land
• Avoids removing land from property tax rolls
• Can be safely reached on foot or bicycle
• Parking, traffic and festivals are not a problem: – Adequate parking per SEQRA study done this summer
– DPW parking is moving, freeing up more spaces
– Traffic studies will ensure safety and easy access
– Fourth of July celebration will still be at Town Hall
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
A Central Location
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Library and Services are Improved
• Evolving to meet the community’s needs
• Leading shift from content storage to creation
• Providing adequate space for: – Access for patrons with mobility difficulties
– Modern and handicap accessible restrooms
– Dedicated teen and children’s areas
– More seating, computers and workspaces
– Enforced quiet areas for serious study
– Community meetings, teaching and programming
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Survey Says: Libraries Matter
2013 Pew Research study finds:
• Top reason people visit libraries is to borrow materials
• Second highest answer is to use the Internet or Wi-Fi
• 60% of young adults still visit the library often
• 80% of Americans say borrowing books is important
• 80% say reference librarians are an important service
• 77% say free access to computers and the internet is a “very important” library service
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Libraries Aren’t Going Away
Coffee makers haven’t put coffee shops out of business
iPads and e-books haven’t made libraries obsolete
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Libraries Mean Business
“The Irondequoit Chamber of Commerce recognizes that a 21st century central library will offer the types of valued services and amenities that attracts home buyers, retains homeowners, and keeps the business and spending power of residents in the Irondequoit community…for the good of our merchants and the good of our residents, the Irondequoit Chamber of Commerce endorses this long overdue plan to improve our town with a new central library.”
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Cost of a New Library
• The bond will be for up to $13 million dollars – This costs less than expanding both branches
• Passing the bond would equal an increase of less than $29 per year (including interest) for the average $100,000 home – 29 cents per $1,000 of assessed value
– $2.42 per month
• Figures are for a 30-year bond with 3.8% rate
• This takes advantage of very low interest rates
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Additional Funding Resources
• Fundraising committee with library trustees and community members has been established
• 1st Annual BBQ & Blues for Books fundraiser was a major success
• Grants are available and will be applied for to reduce costs
• Evans Branch (Cooper Rd) likely reverts back to the West Irondequoit Central School District due to deed restrictions – Eligible to be sold by the district
• McGraw Branch (Ridge Rd) will be sold and proceeds will help pay costs above the bond (current assessment is $1.1 million)
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Doing Nothing Isn’t Cheap
• Existing buildings desperately need updating
• Making a few of the most-needed repairs and upgrades costs $2,230,140, but adds no space
• Long-term improvements, such as electrical upgrades and better restrooms, costs $6,169,020, but adds no space
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Side-By-Side Comparison Build a new
central library
Upgrade our
2 old branches
Meets community needs YES NO
Plans for our future YES NO
Puts property back on tax rolls YES NO
Central location YES NO
Smart size based on studies & need YES NO
Flexible and adaptable space for enhanced services YES NO
Expanded parking YES NO
Better facilities for individuals with mobility difficulties YES NO
Expanded hours YES NO
Drive-up book return YES NO
Potential for a coffee shop YES NO
Meets green building standards YES NO
Eligible for NYS construction grants YES NO
Requires duplicate materials and operating costs to
maintain
NO YES
Average cost per household
(base on $100,00 house)
Less than $29
per year
$22 per year
Why Not Expand Both Branches?
• $13.7 million to expand both library branches, per 2012 report by Passero Associates – It would cost nearly $1 million more
than building a new central library
– Existing branches were not designed for expansion
• Maintaining both branches makes taxpayers pay for duplicate services and materials
• Building a new central library is the most fiscally responsible decision
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
What if the Bond is not Approved?
• If the referendum does not pass, the Library Board will be forced to make difficult decisions about the future of both branches
• A “No” vote does not guarantee both branches will remain open
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
We Want You To Decide
• Vote Saturday, December 14
– Polls are open from 9am-6pm
• One polling place for all residents
– Christ the King School, 445 Kings Hwy S
• You must be a registered voter
– You will be required to provide ID
• Absentee Ballots are available
– Request one form the Town Clerk, 585-336-6045
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
Get Informed
Information: • Held 23 public information meetings this year • Videos, questions & answers posted on website • Also available in print at each branch Online: • Visit www.libraryproposal.com for info • Follow on Twitter @LibraryProposal • “Like” New Irondequoit Library Proposal on Facebook Contact: • Library Board, [email protected] • Library Director Terry Buford, [email protected] or
call 585-336-6064
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME, INPUT AND QUESTIONS
Please write questions on a card an hand to a volunteer
Vote Saturday, December 14 www.LibraryProposal.com