COLLECT
1
Improving Your Collection Department: Building A Plan
David McPhersonDeputy Finance Director
City of San Jose
COLLECT
2
$HOW ME$HOW ME
THE MONEYTHE MONEY
COLLECT
3
Revenue Collection Strategic Plan (RCSP)
• The City of San Jose began the RCSP in January 2007 with the restructure of operations to maximize effectiveness of the time investigator collectors spent on collections.
• The goal was to implement an aggressive revenue collection campaign intended to:
1. Increase the tax revenue base2. Reduce the average number of days the
active accounts remain past due3. Audit programs which generate revenue (i.e.
TOT, UUT, Sale/Use Tax, etc)4. Improve the collection of data to maximize
collection efforts5. Improve customer service
4
Staff Survey
• Understand the needs of your staff• Provide growth for each individual
team member• Improve morale of the department• Don’t be afraid of risk taking• Encourage innovation• Think outside the box• Keep staff engaged
COLLECT
5
Evaluate Resources and Programs
• ABC Reports• Statistical Analysis• Accurate Accountability • ROI & Cost Benefits• Targets & Objectives• Technology Needs (laptops, multi-function
devices, etc)• Active Listening• Three P’s Implemented:
1. Policies2. Procedures3. Processes
COLLECT
6
Evaluate Resources and Programs
• Revenue Reserves (bad debt write-offs)• Why do we do what we do?• Payment Processing efficiencies
1. Kiosk at strategically placed locations2. Web Self Service (pay on-line)3. Counter (one stop shop)
• Alternative Collection Programs
1. Hardships 2. Exemptions 3. Low Income Plans4. Payment Plans
COLLECT
7
• Mail/Phone Analysis1. Returned Mail (What do you do with it?)2. Delinquent Notices (How many do you send?)3. Marketing Strategies4. Email Options5. Phone Tree’s – IVR Options
• Customer Service Evaluations1. Expectations vs. Resources 2. Listen and Learn
• Internal and External Controls1. Economic Conditions2. Software Programs3. Policy Decisions
Evaluate Resources and Programs
8
Revenue Collection Strategic Plan (RCSP) Phases
1. Accounts Receivable Collections2. Amnesty Program3. Business Tax Discovery Program 4. BLIP Program5. Compliance & Revenue Audits6. Collection Agency Back Stop Program7. Intern Program 8. Sales Tax Compliance 9. Unclaimed Property10. Cost Recovery Fees
• Business Tax Admin Fee• Collection Agency Fee• Lien Fees• Bank Fees
COLLECT
9
Strategic Re-Alignment of Revenue Management Division
Time Allocation Prior to RCSP Program
Complaint Follow-up
7%
CustomerService
26%
Support Service
24%
SpecialAssignments
10%
Administrative5% Collections
28%
COLLECT
10
RCSP Program Target Time Allocation
Time Allocation Goal for RCSP Program
Administrative15%
SpecialAssignments
5%Collections
70%
CustomerService
10%
COLLECT
11
Amnesty Programs
• Good Public Relations and Out Reach During Tough Economic Times
• Allows for Timely Bad debt write-offs• Qualifications
1. Accounts over 1 year past due2. Example: Admin Citations, Special Events/ Parade
Reimbursements, Animal Impound, etc.3. No taxes or lienable accounts (sidewalk repair, admin remedies,
and government agencies)• Resources
1. Schedule staff for proper coverage2. Budget for advertisement in local papers3. Utilize free marketing through the City website, communication
with the local Chambers of Commerce, and receive free ads through radio and TV via Public Service Announcements
COLLECT
12
Business License Information Program (BLIP)
• Initial PhaseSent out 2,300 business tax lead notices per week for a 12-week period
• Second Phase1. Sent out 1,800 notices per week for 8 weeks2. The primary objective will be to notify 13,128
delinquent businesses to pay their business tax or notify the City that they are no longer in business
• Third PhaseImplement Business Tax Discovery Program
COLLECT
13
Business Discovery Program
• Implement an E-Discovery Data Base• Create a partnership with Other Agencies• Business Tax (BOE, FTB, and EDD)• Sales Tax (BOE and other Cites)• Unsecured Property Tax (County Assessor)• Business Improvement District (Special Districts)• Sanitary and Storm Sewer Fee (Other Departments
and Special Districts)
COLLECT
14
Pilot Program Summary Results (January 2007 – June 2007)
Program
Additional Revenue
and/or Cash Flow
Staff/Consultant
Cost
$ Generated/Total Cost
(*ROI)
Business Tax $543,139 $191,511 $2.84
Accounts Receivables
$3,584,591 $59,330 $60.42
Compliance & Revenue Audits
$1,149,212 $63,972 $17.96
TOTALS $5,276,942 $314,813 $16.76
*ROI=Return on Investment resulting in $ generated per $1.00 in cost.
COLLECT
15
Comparison of Same PeriodJanuary to June FY 05-06 vs. FY 06-07
PeriodCollection Amounts
Staff/Consultant
Cost
$ Return on Investment
(ROI)
Jan-June FY 05-06 $2,143,000 $502,182 $4.27
Jan-June FY 06-07 $5,276,942 $314,813 $16.76
Percentage Change
146%Increase
37%Decrease
293%Increase
COLLECT
16
Summary of Revenue Collection and Audit Results
For Fiscal Year 2007-2008
Reporting Periods
Quarter Ended 9/30/07
Quarter Ended
12/31/07
Quarter Ended 3/31/08
Quarter Ended 6/30/08
2007-2008 Year-To-
Date Results
Revenues Collected $ 3,464,744 $3,559,635 $1,685,734 $2,095,193 $10,805,306
Revenue Target $ 662,500 $ 662,500 $ 662,500 $ 662,500 $ 2,650,000
COLLECT
17
Collection ResultsFor Fiscal Year 2007-2008
ProgramAdditional
Revenue and/or Cash Flow
Staff/Consultant
Cost
$ Generated/Total Cost (*ROI)
Business Tax Delinquencies
$2,339,478 $372,721 $6.27
Accounts Receivable Delinquencies
$6,300,803 $303,775 $20.74
Revenue Compliance/ Monitoring
$2,165,025 $502,775 $4.31
TOTALS $10,805,306 $1,179,271 $9.17
*ROI = Return on Investment resulting in $ generated per $1.00 in cost.
COLLECT
18
Collection and Target Chart
$3,464,744
$662,500
$3,559,635
$662,500
$1,685,734
$662,500
$2,095,193
$662,500
$0
$1,000,000
$2,000,000
$3,000,000
$4,000,000
Quarter Ended9/30/07
Quarter Ended12/31/07
Quarter Ended3/31/08
Quarter Ended6/30/08
REVENUE COLLECTION AND TARGETS For Fiscal Year 2007-2008
Revenues Collected Revenue Target
COLLECT
19
Summary of Collection ResultsTotal for FY 2007-2008 Quarters
$2,650,000
$10,805,306
$0
$2,000,000
$4,000,000
$6,000,000
$8,000,000
$10,000,000
$12,000,000
Target Revenue Revenue Collected
REVENUE TARGET AND COLLECTIONFor Fiscal Year 2007-2008
COLLECT
20
David McPhersonDeputy Finance Director
City of San José200 East Santa Clara Street
San José, CA 95113(408)535-7091