Health care financing Health care financing for the poor in Lao PDRfor the poor in Lao PDR
Student: Walaiporn Student: Walaiporn PatcharanarumolPatcharanarumol
Supervisor: Prof. Anne MillsSupervisor: Prof. Anne Mills
22
Outline of presentationOutline of presentation
1.1. IntroductionIntroduction2.2. User fees and protection mechanismsUser fees and protection mechanisms3.3. Lao People’s Democratic RepublicLao People’s Democratic Republic4.4. ObjectivesObjectives5.5. Conceptual framework and Conceptual framework and
MethodologyMethodology6.6. Work plan and budgetWork plan and budget
33
IntroductionIntroduction
The poor and the health: policy agenda The poor and the health: policy agenda
Poverty Ill health
cause
effect
44
IntroductionIntroduction
The mitigation of impact of user fees The mitigation of impact of user fees
on access to health services by the on access to health services by the
poor poor Main focus of the study: protecting the Main focus of the study: protecting the
poor from the financial burden of user poor from the financial burden of user
fees charged for fees charged for public health care public health care
servicesservices..
55
What is user fee?What is user fee?
User fees are payments made by User fees are payments made by
individuals or families at point of individuals or families at point of
service for buying health care service for buying health care
services with whatever form of services with whatever form of
charge and at whatever level of charge and at whatever level of
public health care provisionpublic health care provision
66
User feesUser fees
The policy aim: The policy aim: revenue raisingrevenue raising, improving , improving
health system health system efficiencyefficiency and enhancing and enhancing
equity in accessequity in access to the health system to the health system The main source of health services The main source of health services
financing in some countriesfinancing in some countries Can be a financial barrier which leads to Can be a financial barrier which leads to
inequity in access to health care servicesinequity in access to health care services
77
Protection mechanismsProtection mechanisms
FeatureFeature Direct Direct targetingtargeting
Characteristic Characteristic targetingtargeting
QualificationQualification Income levelIncome level Individual’s Individual’s characteristicscharacteristics
ExamplesExamples Poor familiesPoor families Armed forcesArmed forces
Children < 5 yrChildren < 5 yr
Pregnant Pregnant womenwomen
AdvantagesAdvantages Targets the Targets the poor directlypoor directly
Less infoLess info
Less cost of Less cost of adm.adm.
Less stigmaLess stigma
88
Experiences on user fees Experiences on user fees and exemptionsand exemptions User fees improved hospital servicesUser fees improved hospital services
However, user fees represented barrier in access to However, user fees represented barrier in access to
health services, especially for the low socio-economic health services, especially for the low socio-economic
group. It created a medical poverty trap group. It created a medical poverty trap
Ineffective exemption mechanismsIneffective exemption mechanisms Inadequate fundingInadequate funding A limitation of administrative capacityA limitation of administrative capacity Insufficient informationInsufficient information StigmatizationStigmatization Staff awarenessStaff awareness
Optional mechanisms e.g., the Health Equity Fund, Optional mechanisms e.g., the Health Equity Fund,
Universal Health Care Coverage Universal Health Care Coverage
99
Lao PDRLao PDR
Lao PDR: one of the Least Lao PDR: one of the Least
Developed Countries (LDCs)Developed Countries (LDCs)
5.3 million population5.3 million population
Life expectancy at birth: Life expectancy at birth:
54.3 years54.3 years
Adult literacy rate: 66.4%Adult literacy rate: 66.4%
Poverty: 32.7% of total popPoverty: 32.7% of total pop
(National poverty line = 8.5 (National poverty line = 8.5
USD/person/mo)USD/person/mo)
1010
1. Public health facilities1. Public health facilities– 533 Health centers533 Health centers
– 122 District hospitals122 District hospitals
– 13 Provincial hospitals13 Provincial hospitals
– 5 regional and 6 5 regional and 6
specialized hospitalsspecialized hospitals
– 3 Central hospitals3 Central hospitals
Health care delivery Health care delivery system in Lao PDRsystem in Lao PDR
A district hospital in Savannakhet Province
2. Private sector2. Private sector– 1990 licensed pharmacies and 261 private clinics1990 licensed pharmacies and 261 private clinics
– No private hospitalNo private hospital
1111
Health care financing in Lao Health care financing in Lao PDRPDR
Total health expenditure: 3% of GDP, 12 USD per Total health expenditure: 3% of GDP, 12 USD per
capita capita
Household OOP: 58% of total health expenditureHousehold OOP: 58% of total health expenditure
1/3 of OOP was spent on user fees in public providers 1/3 of OOP was spent on user fees in public providers
No national health insurance schemeNo national health insurance scheme– Government employee scheme: 16% of total pop Government employee scheme: 16% of total pop
– Social health insurance: <1% of total popSocial health insurance: <1% of total pop
– Community based health insurance: 0.2% of total pop (pilot)Community based health insurance: 0.2% of total pop (pilot)
– Most people has no health insurance and they are directly Most people has no health insurance and they are directly
faced with user fees at point of service.faced with user fees at point of service.
1212
User fees and exemptions User fees and exemptions in Lao PDRin Lao PDR
Decree 52 on Medical Services and Guide of Decree 52 on Medical Services and Guide of
the Public Health Minister, 1995the Public Health Minister, 1995– Cost recovery in hospital was introduced to Cost recovery in hospital was introduced to
generate revenue generate revenue
– School children and students, monks and poor School children and students, monks and poor
people are exempted from payingpeople are exempted from paying
– Hospitals are allowed to keep up to 80% of their Hospitals are allowed to keep up to 80% of their
revenues from user charges (20% of revenue from revenues from user charges (20% of revenue from
user charges goes to local government)user charges goes to local government)
1313
User fees and exemptions User fees and exemptions in Lao PDRin Lao PDR
User charges:User charges:– Drugs at cost plus 25% margin Drugs at cost plus 25% margin
– Other services such as laboratory, radiology, Other services such as laboratory, radiology,
admission and surgery with a fixed fee schedule.admission and surgery with a fixed fee schedule.
Exemption mechanism is not functioning: the Exemption mechanism is not functioning: the
poor lack knowledge and believe that poor lack knowledge and believe that
exemption is unrealisticexemption is unrealistic
Vientiane Time: “people do not come to the Vientiane Time: “people do not come to the
hospital when they have no money unless hospital when they have no money unless
they have a serious health problem”they have a serious health problem”
1414
What do we know?What do we know?
What’s next?What’s next?
1515
Gap of knowledgeGap of knowledge
No clear evidence whether exemption influences the poor’s No clear evidence whether exemption influences the poor’s
coping strategies or not. Most studies haven’t looked atcoping strategies or not. Most studies haven’t looked at
demand sidedemand side
– Why households do / do not take up exemptions.Why households do / do not take up exemptions.
– Which factors might encourage the poor to take up exemptions? Which factors might encourage the poor to take up exemptions?
There has been little exploration of provider motivations to There has been little exploration of provider motivations to
grant exemptions.grant exemptions. Little research has been conducted with a comprehensive Little research has been conducted with a comprehensive
view from view from households, health care providers and policy households, health care providers and policy
makersmakers
No comprehensive analysis inNo comprehensive analysis in Lao PDRLao PDR
1616
ObjectivesObjectives
1.1. To assess the perceptions and To assess the perceptions and preferences of preferences of national policy makersnational policy makers on on fee exemption policy and fee exemption policy and implementation. implementation.
2.2. To assess To assess public health care providers’public health care providers’ behaviour and attitudes on exemption behaviour and attitudes on exemption mechanismsmechanisms
3.3. To To analyze barriers of access to public analyze barriers of access to public health care services, utilization patterns health care services, utilization patterns and and household illnesshousehold illness costs by socio- costs by socio-economic group.economic group.
1717
Objectives Objectives (continued)(continued)
4.4. To assess To assess the strategiesthe strategies households use households use to cope with medical bills with an to cope with medical bills with an emphasis on taking up the exemption emphasis on taking up the exemption mechanism.mechanism.
5.5. To analyse the financial implications of To analyse the financial implications of alternative protection mechanismsalternative protection mechanisms..
6.6. To identify policy implications for pro-To identify policy implications for pro-poor financing and provide poor financing and provide policy policy recommendationsrecommendations on improved ways of on improved ways of protecting the poor.protecting the poor.
Conceptual Framework
6
Government (Policy maker perspective)
Health system(Supply-side perspective)
Household/community(Demand-side perspective)
Illness
Impact on household
budget
Public health care expenditure implication
Policy options for protecting the poor
Utilization patternPublic Health care financing
Cost of Illness
Public health care providers- Health Centre- District Hospital- Provincial Hospital
Policies on health care financing
and exemption
policy
Coping strategies for
treatment cost of illness
Exemption mechanism
Demand-side design and implementation
Supply-side design and implementation
Policy design and
implementation
Take up?
Barriers on access to
health care services
Policy recommendation
Treatment seeking pattern
Government (Policy maker perspective)
Health system(Supply-side perspective)
Household/community(Demand-side perspective)
1919
Study settingStudy setting
Savannakhet Province
National Growth and National Growth and
Poverty Eradication Poverty Eradication
Strategy (NGPES), Strategy (NGPES),
Lao PDR 2004Lao PDR 2004
Totally 142 districts Totally 142 districts
are classified into are classified into
three groupsthree groups Very poorVery poor
PoorPoor
Non poor Non poor
2020
Study settingStudy setting
Savannakhet Province
Savannakhet Savannakhet ProvinceProvince
Very poor or poor Very poor or poor districtsdistricts
Why Savannakhet Why Savannakhet
Province? Province? – SafetySafety
– Possible to travelPossible to travel
– No dialect problemNo dialect problem
2121
MethodologyMethodology
Supply-side perspectiveSupply-side perspective
1. National policy makers (qualitative method)1. National policy makers (qualitative method)
2. Providers (quantitative and qualitative 2. Providers (quantitative and qualitative
methods)methods)
Demand-side perspectiveDemand-side perspective
3. Households (quantitative and qualitative 3. Households (quantitative and qualitative
methods)methods)
SynthesisSynthesis
4. Financial modeling4. Financial modeling
2222
The first sub-studyThe first sub-study: : national policy makers national policy makers
ObjectivesObjectives– Existing exemption policy (funding, design, Existing exemption policy (funding, design,
implementation)implementation)– Attitudes on user charges and exemption Attitudes on user charges and exemption
policypolicy– Policy options for protecting the poorPolicy options for protecting the poor
ToolTool– Key informant interviews using semi-Key informant interviews using semi-
structured Q’nairestructured Q’naire
2323
The first sub-studyThe first sub-study: : national policy makers national policy makers
VariablesVariables (examples) (examples) The purpose of user feesThe purpose of user fees
Who controls the fee policy?Who controls the fee policy?
Existence and clarity of national policy on exemption, Existence and clarity of national policy on exemption, resource, benefit packageresource, benefit package
Who decides means testing? What criteria are used for Who decides means testing? What criteria are used for means testing?means testing?
Relationship between criteria and national poverty criteriaRelationship between criteria and national poverty criteria
Responsiveness of eligibility criteria to local circumstancesResponsiveness of eligibility criteria to local circumstances
Effective exemption mechanism, how to finance (tax, pre-Effective exemption mechanism, how to finance (tax, pre-payment), which option is feasible, not feasible, who and payment), which option is feasible, not feasible, who and what package will be protected, priority settingwhat package will be protected, priority setting
2424
The second sub-study: The second sub-study: public health care providerspublic health care providers
Both quantitative and qualitative methods will be applied to obtain all important information from all levels of public health care providers.
Quantitative data: financial data, revenue from user fee, exemption (+/- debt)
Qualitative data: attitude and practice on user fee and exemption, factor affecting exemption in practice
2525
The second sub-study: The second sub-study: public health care providerspublic health care providers
Health care facilities Site of study for quantitative method
Tools for qualitative
method
Savannakhet provincial hospital
Provincial hospital KI interviewOne FGD
All district hospitals (15 DH)
Provincial health office
-
Four district hospitals 4 DH (2 high and 2 low level of exemptions in very poor or poor district)
4 DHKI interviewOne FGD
Some health centers Some health centers in 1 high and 1 low level of exemption with less leakage
One FGD or KI interview for each health center
2626
The third sub-study: The third sub-study: household sidehousehold side
Three methods are applied to Three methods are applied to
obtain information from obtain information from
household sidehousehold side
– Analysis of national surveyAnalysis of national survey
– Rapid rural appraisalRapid rural appraisal
– Household case studiesHousehold case studies
2727
The third sub-study: The third sub-study: household sidehousehold side
Analysis of national surveyAnalysis of national survey
Objectives Objectives – To quantify household members’ To quantify household members’
information on morbidity rate, use of information on morbidity rate, use of health services, cost of treatment and health services, cost of treatment and transportation cost by socio-economic transportation cost by socio-economic groupgroup
– To determine cost of treatment as % of To determine cost of treatment as % of household income or expenditurehousehold income or expenditure
2828
The third sub-study: The third sub-study: household sidehousehold side
Rapid rural appraisal (RRA)Rapid rural appraisal (RRA)– It is aimed at exploratory researchIt is aimed at exploratory research
to generate baseline datato generate baseline data to handle complicated information setsto handle complicated information sets to rank lists of items such as foods and to rank lists of items such as foods and to understand variation and complexity to understand variation and complexity
within field settings within field settings
(Seaman, Clarke et al. 2000)(Seaman, Clarke et al. 2000)
2929
The third sub-study: The third sub-study: household sidehousehold side
Rapid rural appraisal (RRA)Rapid rural appraisal (RRA)– It emphasizes the use of It emphasizes the use of
existing dataexisting data interaction with local residents andinteraction with local residents and a judicious combination of qualitative methods. a judicious combination of qualitative methods.
– ToolsTools semi-structured key informant interviewssemi-structured key informant interviews focus group discussionsfocus group discussions supplemented by observation, photographs, and a supplemented by observation, photographs, and a
preliminary review of secondary data. preliminary review of secondary data. – Various techniques e.g., social mapping, Various techniques e.g., social mapping,
wealth ranking with card sorting, and wealth ranking with card sorting, and preference rankingpreference ranking
3030
The third sub-study: The third sub-study: household sidehousehold side
Household case studies (by in-depth interview)Household case studies (by in-depth interview)
ObjectivesObjectives– To measure costs of treatment in the hospital To measure costs of treatment in the hospital
paid by the householdpaid by the household– To explore coping strategies used by the To explore coping strategies used by the
household to deal with financial costs of illnesshousehold to deal with financial costs of illness– To explore experience and probe attitudes of To explore experience and probe attitudes of
households on exemptionshouseholds on exemptions– To investigate other barriers of access to To investigate other barriers of access to
health care serviceshealth care services
3131
The third sub-study: The third sub-study: household sidehousehold side
Household case studies (by in-depth interview)Household case studies (by in-depth interview)
Two selected districts form the second sub-study
High level of exemption
Low level of exemption
Poor household Poor household
1. Non-use DH and PH* 3 3
2. Use DH
2.1 Admission 3 3
2.2 Chronic illness 3 3
2.3 Acute care > 2 episode
3 3
Total 12 12DH = district hospital, PH = provincial hospital* for example death (from disease) at home, giving birth at home
without birth attendance
3232
The fourth sub-study: The fourth sub-study: financial modellingfinancial modelling
ObjectiveObjective– To analyze financial implications for health care To analyze financial implications for health care
providers’ budgets of various options for protection providers’ budgets of various options for protection mechanismsmechanisms
Data/information neededData/information needed– Coverage data:Coverage data: size and structure of entitled population size and structure of entitled population
by protection mechanismby protection mechanism
– Utilization dataUtilization data: pattern and intensity of the utilization: pattern and intensity of the utilization
– Benefit package and amount of benefit data:Benefit package and amount of benefit data: over a over a certain period of time.certain period of time.
– Expenditure and revenue dataExpenditure and revenue data
3333
The fourth sub-study: The fourth sub-study: financial modellingfinancial modelling
Possible dummy tablePossible dummy table
Status quo Scenario I Scenario II Scenario III Scenario…
A. Coverage data All poor All poor For all
B. Utilization data
C. Benefit package and amount of benefit
OP, IP and P&P
IP and P&P OP, IP and P&P
D. Expenditure of DHS
E. Revenue of DHS
E1. Government subsidy
E2. Revenue from user fees
E3. Other revenue
S X Y Z
Financial gap S – X S – Y S – Z
Diagram of samples and Diagram of samples and methodsmethods
National level MOH and NIPH
Provincial level One provincial hospital
District levelin the
province
All district hospitals
In-depth interview
In-depth interview
Village level in the 2 districts
Some health centers
12 households for case study
Some health centers
KI interview, FDG and financial data collection
Exemption level
Less leakage
4 district hospitals (low and high exemptions)
12 households for case study
1 district hospital with low exemptions
1 district hospital with high exemption
KI interview, FDG and financial data collection
Financial data collection
KI interview, FDG and financial data collection
KI interview
3636
CollaborationCollaboration
National Institute of Public National Institute of Public Health, Lao PDRHealth, Lao PDR
Provincial Health Department: Provincial Health Department: Savannakhet ProvinceSavannakhet Province
Savannakhet Provincial HospitalSavannakhet Provincial Hospital District Health Office (two District Health Office (two
districts)districts)
3737
Work plan and budgetWork plan and budget
Duration of fieldwork: 10 monthsDuration of fieldwork: 10 months
from Oct 05 - July 06from Oct 05 - July 06 Total budget requirement for the Total budget requirement for the
fieldwork ~ 900,000 baht fieldwork ~ 900,000 baht All costs are covered by Dorothy All costs are covered by Dorothy
Hodgkin Postgraduate Award Hodgkin Postgraduate Award 2004.2004.
3838
AcknowledgementAcknowledgement
To Prof. Anne Mills for her intellectual To Prof. Anne Mills for her intellectual
guidance and continuing supervision.guidance and continuing supervision.
To advisory committees, Dr. Steve Russell To advisory committees, Dr. Steve Russell
and Dr. Catherine Goodman, for their and Dr. Catherine Goodman, for their
supports and suggestionssupports and suggestions
To DHPA for financial support of my PhD To DHPA for financial support of my PhD
studiesstudies
To IHPP-ThailandTo IHPP-Thailand
Thank you for your Thank you for your attentionattention