Individual(Differences(in(Wellbeing((and(the(overlap(with(health(and(behavior((
(Prof.(Dr.(Meike(Bartels(Department(of(Biological(Psychology(
VU(University(Amsterdam(
Major(Depressive(Disorder(–(Global(Burden(of(Disease(2010(((((((
Ferrari(et(al,(2013,(Plos(Medicine ( ( ( ( (YLD=(years(lived(with(disabiliNes((
((
((
((
((((((
University(of(Leiceter,(2006(
((
((
((
((((((
UNICEF(2007(
((
((
((
((((((
Science(January(2010(
How(to(measure(WellXbeing?(
Science(29(January(2010:(Vol.(327(no.(5965(pp.(534X535((
Large groups of people live healthy and happy lives
Individual Differences
ENVIRONMENT(
GENES(
UNIQUE(ENVIRONMENT(SHARED(ENVIRONMENT(
Twins(
IdenNcal(=(MonozygoNc((MZ)(( Fraternal(=(DizygoNc((DZ)(
The(Classical(Twin(Design(
Causes(of(Individual(Differences(in(Wellbeing(
0%( 10%( 20%( 30%( 40%( 50%( 60%( 70%( 80%( 90%( 100%(
Tellegen(et(al.,(1988((
Lykken(&(Tellegen,(1996((
Røysamb(et(al.,(2002((
Stubbe(et(al.,(2005(
Bartels(et(al.,(2009(
Bartels(et(al,(2010(
Nes(et(al.,(2010(
Kendler(et(al.,(2011(
Bartels(et(al,(2013(
A(
D(
E(
GENES- 40%
ENVIRONMENT- 60%
Current State of Art
X0.70(
X0.60(
X0.50(
X0.40(
X0.30(
X0.20(
X0.10(
0.00( WITHDRAW
Nm(
WITHDRAW
Nf(
SOCIAL(CO
MPLAIN
TSm(
SOCIAL(CO
MPLAIN
TSf(
ANXIO
US/DEPRESSEDm
(
ANXIO
US/DEPRESSEDf(
RULEXBREAKIN
Gm(
RULEXBREAKIN
Gf(
AGGRESSIVE(BEHAVIORm
(
AGGRESSIVE(BEHAVIORf(
SOCIAL(PRO
BLEMSm
(
SOCIAL(PRO
BLEMSf(
THOUGHT(PRO
BLEMSm
(
THOUGHT(PRO
BLEMSf(
ATTENTIO
N(PRO
BLEMSm
(
ATTENTIO
N(PRO
BLEMSf(
Nonshared(Environmental(Part(of(the(Phenotypic(CorrelaNon(
Shared(Environmental(Part(of(the(Phenotypic(CorrelaNon(
AddiNve(GeneNc(Part(of(the(Phenotypic(CorrelaNon(
X.40((X.42,(X.37)(((
X.51((X.53,(X.48)((
X.19((X.21,(X.15)(
X.34((X.36,(X.31)((
X.44((X.46,(X.41)(
X.58((X.60,(X.56)(
X.18((X.21,(X.14)(
X.25((X.28,(X.23)(
X.18((X.21,(X.15)(
(
X.28((X.30,(X.25)(
X.28((X.31,(X.25)(
X.32((X.34,(X.30)(
X.23((X.26,(X.20)(
(
X.35((X.37,(X.32)(
X.26((X.29,(X.23)(
X.35((X.38,(X.33)(
55%(
67%(
((((67%(
71%(
57%(
63%(
83%(
93%(
90%(
72%(
66%(
71%(
84%(
75%(
69%(
71%(
45%( 33%
(
33%(
29%( 43%
(
(((17%(
37%(
(7%(
((10%(
28%(
34%(
29%(
16%(
24%(
31%(
29%(
Overlap(WellXbeing(and(Psychopathology(
Bartels(et(al,(Behavior(GeneNcs(2013(
Bartels(et(al,(Behavior(GeneNcs(2013(
((
((
((
((((((
((
((
((
((((((
Is(WellXbeing(Stable(within(a(person?(
SetXpoint(Theory(–(Hedonic(TreadmillX(Dynamic(Equilibrium(even(though(external(forces(are(constantly(changing(our(lives(and(our(life(
goals,(happiness(is(a(relaNvely(constant(state(
Science,(Aug(2009(
Dodds(and(Danforth,(Journal(of(Happiness(studies(2010,(Science(Vol(325(2009(
PNAS,(jan(2014(
To(be(conNnued:(
X The(search(for(genes(X The(search(for(geneXenvironment(interplay((epigeneNcs)(
Recommended
