i
Institute of Technology of Cambodia
Department of Electric and Energy
(Tidal Energy)
Group: I4 GEE-EE
Assignment Group: 8
Lecturer: ETH OUDAYA
Students:
1. SOT DARO e20120665
2. SRY PHEARATH e20120691
3. SUM CHHENGSE e20120693
4. SUONG CHANPHIREAK e20120700
Year: 2015-2016
i
PREFACE
We are year 4 students from department of electrical and energy engineering at Institute
of Technology of Cambodia. To begin with, we would like to thank to our teacher Mr. ETH
Oudaya who gives us this assignment to research and learn more about the new technologies
that appear in the world of electricity and energy. The goals of this report are to help students
who want to know more information about new evolution of new renewable energy technologies
and also introduce people to the new way to get new energy for living. Additionally, we are
really appreciated to collaborate to do this report in order to improve a part of our knowledge
about this new energy that we didn’t know before. Moreover, the most important of this project
is studying about the renewable energy that we are installed it for producing electricity.
While every attempt has been made to produce a book free of error, the practicality is that
some errors will no doubt appear. I would be most grateful to have these brought to my attention.
I would also be pleased to hear from any users of the book who might have any comments or
suggestions for improvement.
ii
Table of Contents
Preface…………………………………………………………………………...i
I. Introduction ........................................................................................................... 01
1. Overview ........................................................................................................ 01
2. History of Tidal Power ................................................................................... 02
3. Objective ........................................................................................................ 02
II. Main content .......................................................................................................... 03
i. How Tidal Power works? ..................................................................... 03
A. Tidal Turbines ......................................................................................... 03
A.1 Types of Tidal Turbines .................................................................... 04
Tidal Barrages ......................................................................................... 06 B.
1 Categories of generation ............................................................................ 07
The potential energy contained in a volume of water is given by2 .......... 07
C. Tidal Lagoon ........................................................................................... 08
Geography of Tidal Power ............................................................................. 08 ii.
iii. Economics of Tidal Power ............................................................................. 09
iv. Environment concerns ................................................................................... 12
a. Tidal Barrages .......................................................................................... 12
b. Tidal Turbines .......................................................................................... 13
c. Tidal Lagoons ........................................................................................... 13
v. Pros and Cons of Tidal energy ........................................................................ 13
III. Conclusion ............................................................................................................. 16
IV. Reference ................................................................................................................ 17
1
Tidal energy
I. Introduction
1. Overview [2]
Tidal power exploits energy drawn from the movement of ocean tides to produce
electricity. There are two scenarios in which tides can be tapped for energy. The first is in
changing sea levels. This phenomenon is responsible for the advancing and receding tides on
shorelines. With the help of turbines, incoming tides can be manipulated to generate
electricity. The second way to exploit tidal energy is by sinking turbines to the sea floor where
fast-flowing currents turn generator blades much like wind does with a wind turbine.
Tidal energy is considered renewable because the tides move on a predictable, daily
schedule, depending only on the orbits of the Earth, Moon, and Sun, and are essentially
inexhaustible. Though tidal energy is carbon free, it is not environmentally benign. Concerns
over the health of shoreline and aquatic ecosystems mar this otherwise clean source of energy.
Older tidal barrage technology can devastate fish populations.
In the past, large-scale barrage systems dominated the tidal power scene. But because of
increasingly evident unfavorable environmental and economic drawbacks with this
technology, research into the field of tidal power shifted from barrage systems to tidal current
turbines in the last few decades. This new technology leaves a smaller environmental
footprint than tidal barrages, as turbines are placed in offshore currents avoiding the need to
construct dams to capture the tides along ecologically fragile coastlines. Harnessing tidally-
driven coastal currents cannot yet deliver the sheer amount of power that barrage style
facilities can, like at the 240 MW barrage generating station at La Rance, France.3 However,
and the technology is quickly evolving with numerous test plants popping up around the
globe.
Barred from the mainstream by financial difficulties and environmental concerns, both
tidal barrages and tidal current turbines face challenges in becoming major suppliers of energy
in the 21st century. Recent emphasis on the potential of tidal current turbines, ` and their
reduced effect on shoreline and aquatic ecosystems, suggests that they will replace tidal
barrages as the preferred method of exploiting tidal energy
2
2. History of Tidal power
The energy stored in tides been known to people for many centuries. The earliest records
of tidal mills are dated back to the 8th Century CE.7 The tidal mills were mainly used for
grain grinding and were of similar design to the conventional water mills with the exception
of the addition of a dam and reservoir. The industrial revolution increased demand for power
but tidal energy never got off the ground, undercut by cheap fossil fuels and other
developments which offered easier access to power generation. Existing tidal mills became as
obsolescent as pre-industrial water-mills. The first large scale modern tidal electric plant
started to operate in La Rance Estuary, St. Malo, France in the 1960s and has been operating
ever since. In recent years the search for renewable, non-polluting energy sources and the
increase in fossil fuel prices has encouraged renewed interest in tidal power.
Figure 01: The Rance Tidal Power Station
3. Objective
There are 3 types of Tidal energy:
Tidal Barrages
Tidal Stream Generators or Tidal turbine
Tidal Lagoon
3
II. Main Content
i. How Tidal Power works?[2]
The energy potential of tidal power depends largely on the rate of flow, which is unique
for each location. Research has shown that little power is generated when only a few turbines
are installed, whereas too many obstructs the flow.
Tidal energy harnesses the natural ebb and flow
of the tides to produce power. Tides are created by
the gravitational pull of the moon and sun,
combined with the rotation of the earth.8 Tidal
energy can be harnessed both in the sea, and in tidal
rivers and estuaries. On some shorelines, water
levels can vary up to 12 metres. It is this drastic
change in water level that makes the first type of
tidal energy — tidal barrages — possible. Tides can
occur once or twice a day depending on location.
Due to the upward gravitational rotation of the
moon, the water level rises gradually until it reaches
its highest point and then gradually falls back to its
lowest point. Also, the tide does not occur at the same time every day, rather it fluctuates over
a period of two weeks or so.
Tidal energy is energy obtained from changing sea levels (the tide moving from
high to low and vice versa.) This renewable energy source has great potential as tides are
much more predictable than wind power and solar energy which are not at all consistent
(seasons, bad weather, etc...).
There are three main ways to harness tidal power, these are:
A. Tidal Turbines
Tidal turbines use similar technology to wind turbines, although their blades are much
shorter and stronger. So a good way to think of them is as underwater windmills. Basically the
water currents turn the turbines, which in turn activate a generator that produces electricity.
These systems work best where there are very strong tidal zones (Norwegian and British
coastlines.) and although it is still in its infancy it does show great promise. The upfront cost
of these tidal stream systems is very high and also installation and maintenance is difficult.
But it’s still cheaper and has less environmental impact than another tidal system which uses
barrages.
4
A.1 Types of Tidal stream Generators:
Tidal stream technologies are designed to harness the kinetic energy of the fast flowing
water in tidal areas. Research and development in this emerging field have led to the design of
several types of device to capture this energy:
Horizontal axis turbines :
Horizontal axis turbines work much the same as a conventional wind turbine and
some look very similar in design. A turbine is placed in a tidal stream which causes the
turbine to rotate and produce power. Some turbines may also be housed in
ducting/cowling to create secondary flow effects by concentrating the flow and producing
a pressure difference.
Figure 02: Horizontal axis turbines work
Vertical axis turbines : Vertical axis turbines use the same principle as the horizontal axis turbines only with
a different direction of rotation. A turbine is placed in a tidal stream which causes the
turbine to rotate and produce power.
Figure 03: Vertical axis turbines work
5
Reciprocating devices (oscillating hydrofoils) : These have hydrofoils which move back and forth in a plane normal to the tidal
stream, instead of rotating blades. The oscillation motion used to produce power is due to
the lift created by the tidal stream flowing in either side of the wing. One design uses
pistons to feed a hydraulic circuit, which turns a hydraulic motor and generator to produce
power.
Figure 04: Reciprocating devices work
Venturi effect tidal stream devices : The tidal flow is directed through a duct, which concentrates the flow and produces a
pressure difference. This causes a secondary fluid flow through a turbine. The resultant
flow can drive a turbine directly or the induced pressure differential in the system can
drive an air-turbine.
Figure 05: Venturi effect tidal stream devices work
6
B. Tidal Barrages
Tidal barrages are very similar to the Dams in hydroelectric plants, except that they are
much larger as they are built across an estuary or bay. The tidal range (difference between
high and low tide) needs to be in excess of five meters for the barrage to be workable. As the
tide comes in, water flows through the dam into the basin. Then when the tide stops the gates
are closed, which traps the water in the basin/estuary.
As the tide goes out gates in the dam which contain turbines are then opened and the flowing
water passes through the turbines, thus generating energy.
Tidal barrages have very high infrastructure costs and are very damaging on the local
environment. Also construction of such dams is a very lengthy project. A good example of
this is the La Rance barrage in France which took over five years to build (it’s the largest tidal
power station in the world.)
A Tidal barrage is a close adaptation of conventional hydroelectric dam technology. This
method blocks off an existing tidal estuary with a dam, or barrage. Movable flood gates,
called sluice gates, on the dam allow incoming tidal waters to fill up in a reservoir. Once the
water reaches its maximum level, the gates close and trap the water. The water in the artificial
estuary is called hydrostatic head.
Figure06: The working of Tidal Barrage
7
1 Categories of generation are:
Ebb generation
Flood generation
Pumping
Two basic schemes
Figure 2: Categories of generation
2. The potential energy contained in a volume of water is given by:
E=
where
A is the horizontal area of basin
is the density of water
is the vertical tidal range
is the acceleration due to gravity
8
C. Tidal Lagoon
Tidal Lagoons are similar to barrages but have a much lower cost and impact on the
environment. They are self-contained structures cut off from the rest of the sea.
It works in pretty much the same way as a tidal barrage as when the tide raises the lagoon fills
and when it falls the water is then released through the turbines.
Figure 08: Tidal lagoon
ii. Geography of Tidal Power
Tidal power technology is only useful if
it is employed in a prime location. The
success of all types — barrages, turbines,
and lagoons — is contingent upon naturally
occurring geographical elements. Although
all tides produce power, there are only a few
locations where tidal power can be
harnessed. A suitable location must contain
the following:
1. The tide has to rise to unusual height. At
least 7 meter tidal differences are required.
2. Stable conditions for a barrier or turbine to
be built into.
3. Environmental disturbances must be
reduced to a minimum.
Figure09: Bay of Fundy at High Tide, an
ideal location for a tidal barrage.
9
The United Kingdom island nation is seeking to take a lead in this field. These locations
include the Pentland Firth, Irish Sea, North Channel, Alderney Race, and Isle of Wight to
Cherbourg, the Orkneys to Shetlands; and the Florida Current.
Major tidal currents also occur in
the Arctic Ocean, Skagerrak-Kattegat,
Hebrides, the Bay of Fundy, the gulfs of
Mexico and St Lawrence, the Amazon
and Rio de la Plata, the Straits of
Magellan, Gibraltar, Messina, Sicily,
and the Bosporus. In the Far East, useful
currents are found near Taiwan and the
Kurile Islands.
Tidal swell — the difference
between the high and low tide marks —
discerns the capabilities of the facility.
High tidal swell locations provide the
greatest potential for tidal development.
Often, good sites are located in areas
where incoming waters must funnel into
narrow channels, including bays, river
mouths, and fjords.
Not all coastlines feature the
minimum 5 meter range needed to make ventures feasible. The world's greatest tidal range is
found in Canada's Bay of Fundy, where tidal swell is over 15 meters.18 Ungava Bay and
numerous estuaries along British Columbia's coast also feature large tidal ranges. The coasts
of Argentina, NW Australia, Brazil, France, India, Korea, the UK, Russia and California,
Maine and Alaska display strong potential for tidal barrages as well.
iii. Economics of Tidal Power
How Much Does it Cost to Construct a Tidal Barrage Power Plant?
Figure 10: Artist's rendition of a tidal fence.
10
Large tidal barrages present several unfavorable economic factors: they have large capital
costs and long construction times. This is somewhat balanced out by long plant lives of 100
years for the actual barrage structure, and 40 for the equipment, as well as low operating
costs.
Much depends on the existing geographical and climatic conditions. A main investment
is devoted to the development of the basin. Generally, costs increase for sites that experience
violent winds and waves, as dykes must be built stronger and larger to withstand them.
Tidal energy generation is an emerging technology, yet in its infancy. With only four
main tidal barrage plants operating in the world, clear capital costs are unknown. An estimate
is given by researcher Eleanor Denny. Denny estimates that in order for a facility to be
profitable, its capital cost should be less than €530,000 (~$700,000 USD) per Mega Watt
which with the current technology is not a realistic goal, meaning that so far the industry
produces negative net benefits Tidal plants, however, do benefit from long life spans and a
relatively low cost of operation compared to other types of power plants. For example,
France's La Rance tidal barrage had an initial cost of about $66 million. Despite the high
initial costs, the La Rance power station has been working for almost 45 years to generate
enough electricity for around 300,000 homes and the plant's costs have now been recovered.
As with any tidal barrage, it has seen low operational costs, no fuel costs, and minimal
maintenance. Studies say operation and maintenance costs are typically less than 0.5% of
initial capital costs.
How Much Do Tidal Turbines and Tidal Turbines Cost?
With very few examples of tidal turbine power plant development, it is difficult to
determine a typical cost. To provide a ball-park investment, it is possible to consider two
existing tidal current installations.
Canada's Race Rocks site, where a single turbine generator converts 65 kW of energy,
cost $4,000,000. This figure was met with $3,000,000 investment from project partner
EnCana's Environmental Innovation Fund, and a grant of just under $1 million awarded to
Pearson College and their partners in the project.
On the higher end of the dollar spectrum, we have Ireland's SeaGen, a 1.2 MW generator,
driven by a pair of turbines. This plant produces about 100 times the power generated at Race
Rocks. An investment of around €8.5 million ($11 million USD) made SeaGen a reality.
11
What Do Consumers of Tidal Generated Electricity Pay?
SeaGen, the world's first commercial current turbine generator, located in Strangford Lough,
Northern Ireland.
The 240 MW La Rance power plants provide electricity at 3.7 cents/kWh, which is much
more reasonable than the 10.8 cents/kWh charged by thermal plants in the area. The cost is
even lower than that of France's nuclear power, which is 3.8 cents/kWh. Only hydroelectric
plants, at 3.2 cents, are more efficient.
BC Hydro's 2002 Green Energy Study for BC estimated the price of electricity from
potential tidal developments to be in the range of 11-25 cents/kWh. This is a figure based on
past and present technologies, and it is likely that as designs are improved, prices could fall
considerably. The BC Sustainable Energy Association (BCSEA) notes that costs are expected
to decline to around 5-7 cents/kWh.
Economic Effects on Tourism and Fishing
An increase in tourism has been observed at Canada's Annapolis tidal plant, as well as at
France's La Rance plant. More than 40,000 tourists visit the Annapolis facility each year. Sites
have a potential to double as information centers, employing individuals in a range of tourism
positions, in addition to the general operation jobs created by the power plant itself. Temporary
construction jobs are opened up as well during the installation of the facilities.
On the other hand negative environmental effects on marine life can be detrimental to the
fishing industry. Some fishermen have raised concerns over the fact that most identified sites
for tidal power are also key migration routes for fish. Additionally, sedimentation caused by
tidal barrages could kill clams, while also damaging local shellfish fisheries. Studies on
fisheries impacts caused by tidal development are hard to come by, and comparison with the
effects of existing facilities only offers a possible prediction for new power plants. The La
12
Rance facility displayed no major effects on the immediate fish community or local fisheries.
The area, however, had a minute fishing industry to begin with and no professional fisherman
After 1960, Impacts are expected to be much more apparent in locations where fish are
abundant and fish passage is repeated by the same populations multiple times over the year,
such as Canada's Bay of Fundy site.
iv. Environment concerns[1]
Tidal power can have effects on marine life. The turbines can accidentally kill swimming
sea life with the rotating blades, although projects such as the one is Strangford feature a
safety mechanism that turns off the turbine when marine animals approach. Some fish may no
longer utilize the area if threatened with a constant rotating or noise-making object. Marine
life is a huge factor when placing tidal power energy generators in the water and precautions
are made to ensure that as many marine animals as possible will not be affected by it.
The Tethys database provides access to scientific literature and general information on the
potential environmental effects of tidal energy.
a. Tidal Barrages
Installing a barrage may change the shoreline within the bay or estuary, affecting a large
ecosystem that depends on tidal flats. Inhibiting the flow of water in and out of the bay, there
may also be less flushing of the bay or estuary, causing additional turbidity (suspended solids)
and less saltwater, which may result in the death of fish that act as a vital food source to birds
and mammals. Migrating fish may also be unable to access breeding streams, and may
attempt to pass through the turbines. The same acoustic concerns apply to tidal barrages.
Decreasing shipping accessibility can become a socio-economic issue, though locks can be
added to allow slow passage. However, the barrage may improve the local economy by
increasing land access as a bridge. Calmer waters may also allow better recreation in the bay
or estuary. Nova Scotia Canada - August 2004, a Humpback whale swam through the
open sluice gate at slack tide, ending up trapped for several days before eventually finding its
way out to the Annapolis Basin
b. Tidal Current Turbines
The main environmental concern with tidal energy is associated with blade strike and
entanglement of marine organisms as high speed water increases the risk of organisms being
pushed near or through these devices. As with all offshore renewable energies, there is also a
13
concern about how the creation of EMF and acoustic outputs may affect marine organisms. It
should be noted that because these devices are in the water, the acoustic output can be greater
than those created with offshore wind energy. Depending on
the frequency and amplitude of sound generated by the tidal energy devices, this acoustic
output can have varying effects on marine mammals (particularly those who echolocate to
communicate and navigate in the marine environment such as dolphins and whales. Tidal
energy removal can also cause environmental concerns such as degrading far field water
quality and disrupting sediment processes. Depending on the size of the project, these effects
can range from small traces of sediment build up near the tidal device to severely affecting
near shore ecosystems and processes.
c. Tidal Lagoon
Environmentally, the main concerns are blade strike on fish attempting to enter
the lagoon, acoustic output from turbines, and changes in sedimentation processes. However,
all these effects are localized and do not affect the entire estuary or bay.
v. Pros and Cons of Tidal energy
The worldwide potential for tidal power is estimated to be 700 TWh a year. Currently,
tidal power is early in the development stages and not able to compete with fossil fuels.
However, focus on renewable energy sources and demand for clean energy contributes to a
rapid development of methods to harness this energy source. What are the pros and cons of
tidal energy and what can we expect in the future?
Advantages of Tidal energy
1. Renewable
Tidal Energy is a renewable energy source. This energy source is a result of the
gravitational fields from both the sun and the moon, combined with the earth’s rotation
around its axis, resulting in high and low tides.
It is this difference in potential energy that is the source of power generation from tidal
energy, whether we are talking about stream generators, tidal barrages or more the more
recent technology, dynamic tidal power (DTP).
So, why is tidal energy renewable? Compared to fossil fuels or nuclear reserves, the
gravitational fields from the sun and the moon, as well as the earth’s rotation around its axis
won’t cease to exist any time soon.
14
2. Green
Tidal power is an environmentally friendly energy source. In addition to being a
renewable energy, it does not emit any climate gases and does not take up a lot of space.
However, there are currently very few examples from real tidal power plants and their
effects on the environment. An important task is therefore to study and assess these things.
3. Predictable
Tidal currents are highly predictable. High and low tide develop with well-known
cycles, making it easier to construct the system with right dimensions, since we already know
what kind of powers the equipment will be exposed to.
Because of this, even though the turbines that are being used (tidal stream generators
that is) are very similar to wind turbines, both the physical size and the installed capacity has
entirely other limitations.
4. Effective at Low Speeds
Water has 1000 times’ higher density than air, which makes it possible to generate
electricity at low speeds. Calculations show that power can be generated even at 1m/s
(equivalent to a little over 3ft/s).
5. Long Lifespans
We have no reason to believe that tidal power plants are not long lived. This ultimately
reduces the cost these power plants can sell their electricity, making tidal energy more cost-
competitive. The tidal barrage power plant La Rance was opened already in 1966 and still
generates large amounts of electricity.
Disadvantage of Tidal energy
1. Environment Effects
As previously mentioned, the effects tidal power plants have on the environment are not
completely determined yet. We know that these power plants generate green electricity
Tidal barrages rely on manipulation on ocean levels and therefore potentially have the
environmental effects on the environment similar to those of hydroelectric dams.
Technological solutions that will resolve some of these issues are currently being developed.
15
2. Close to Land
Tidal power plants needs to be constructed close to land. This is also an area where
technological solutions are being worked on. Hopefully in a few years we can exploit weaker
tidal currents, at locations further out in the sea.
3. Expensive
It is important to realize that the methods for generating electricity from tidal energy is a
relatively are relatively new technologies. It is projected that tidal power will be commercially
profitable within 2020 with better technology and larger scales.
16
III. Conclusion
Tides[4]
play a very important role in the formation of global climate as well as the
ecosystems for ocean habitants. At the same time, tides are a substantial potential source of
clean renewable energy for future human generations. Depleting oil reserves, the emission of
greenhouse gases by burning coal, oil and other fossil fuels, as well as the accumulation of
nuclear waste from nuclear reactors will inevitably force people to replace most of our
traditional energy sources with renewable energy in the future. Tidal energy is one of the best
candidates for this approaching revolution. Development of new, efficient, low-cost and
environmentally friendly hydraulic energy converters suited to free-Sow waters, such as triple-
helix turbines, can make tidal energy available worldwide. This type of machine, moreover,
can be used not only for multi-megawatt tidal power farms but also for mini-power stations
with turbines generating a few kilowatts. Such power stations can provide clean energy to
small communities or even individual households located near continental shorelines, straits or
on remote islands with strong tidal currents.
17
IV. Reference
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tidal_power
2. http://www.energybc.ca/profiles/tidal.html
3. http://www.slideshare.net/clavinrali/tidal-energy-28557847?related=1
4. http://www.gcktechnology.com/GCK/images/ms0032%20final.pdf