8/11/2019 Good publication practices
1/89
TOWARDS GOOD PUBLICATION PRACTICES
Halmar [email protected]
Tim Validasi, Reviewer dan PAK Pusat
Presentasi pada Workshop Penulisan Artikel Jurnal Internasional oleh
Pascasarjana Unhas, Minggu 28 September 2014, Hotel Aston, Makassar
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
2/89
Background: retraction watch: disciplines and
institutions, policies for punishingbad practices
Type of bad practices (BPs) and how to detect
them: Plagiarism, Self-plagiarism, salami/tempe
pub., bogus Authorship, COI, rules &software
Unhas efforts against BPs: Self-Assessment
Good practices (return to the right path):
appropriate manuscript and reputable publisher
Halmar Halide @ physics unhas
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
3/89
Article withdrawal Policies and Formshttps://www.elsevier.com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/article-withdrawal
Article Withdrawal:Only used for Articles in Press which represent early versions of articles
and sometimes contain errors, or may have been accidentally submitted twice. Occasionally,but less frequently, the articles may represent infringements of professional ethical codes,
such as multiple submission, bogus claims of authorship, plagiarism, fraudulent use of data
or the like.
Article Retraction:Infringements of professional ethical codes, such as multiplesubmission, bogus claims of authorship, plagiarism, fraudulent use of data or the like.Occasionally a retraction will be used to correct errors in submission or publication.
Article Removal:Legal limitations upon the publisher, copyright holder or author(s).
Article Replacement:Identification of false or inaccurate data that, if acted upon, would
pose a serious health risk.
the importance of the scholarly archive as a permanent, historic record of the
transactions of scholarship. Articles that have been published shall remain extant, exactandunalteredas far as is possible. However, very occasionally circumstances may arise where an
article is published that must later be retracted or even removed.
Halmar Halide @ physics unhas
https://www.elsevier.com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/article-withdrawalhttps://www.elsevier.com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/article-withdrawalhttps://www.elsevier.com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/article-withdrawalhttps://www.elsevier.com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/article-withdrawalhttps://www.elsevier.com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/article-withdrawalhttps://www.elsevier.com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/article-withdrawalhttps://www.elsevier.com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/article-withdrawalhttps://www.elsevier.com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/article-withdrawalhttps://www.elsevier.com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/article-withdrawalhttps://www.elsevier.com/about/publishing-guidelines/policies/article-withdrawal8/11/2019 Good publication practices
4/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
5/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
6/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
7/89
http://retractionwatch.com/2014/03/21/controversial-paper-linking-conspiracy-ideation-to-
climate-change-skepticism-formally-retracted/
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
8/89
http://retractionwatch.com/2014/02/12/paper-on-refolded-mountain-range-a-
reproduction-now-retracted/#more-18545
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
9/89
http://retractionwatch.com/2013/05/07/double-dipping-leads-to-removal-of-petroleum-
research-paper/#more-14032
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
10/89
http://www.hindawi.com/journals/ijd/2013/310726/#B1
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
11/89
http://retractionwatch.com/category/by-subject/dentistry/
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
12/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
13/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
14/89
http://retractionwatch.com/2014/02/24/springer-ieee-withdrawing-more-than-120-
nonsense-papers/
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
15/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
16/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
17/89
Halmar Halide @ physics unhas
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
18/89
Halmar Halide @ physics unhas
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
19/89
Unfortunately, Amgen's findings are consistent with those of others in industry. A
team at Bayer HealthCare in Germany last year reported4that only about 25% of
published preclinical studies could be validated to the point at which projects could
continue.
Fifty-three papers were deemed 'landmark' studiesNevertheless, scientific findings were confirmed in only 6 (11%) cases.
Halmar Halide @ physics unhas
http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v483/n7391/full/483531a.htmlhttp://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v483/n7391/full/483531a.html8/11/2019 Good publication practices
20/89
http://www.ithenticate.com/resources/infographics/research-misconduct?...
Halmar Halide @ physics unhas
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
21/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
22/89
http://www.utm.utoronto.ca/academic-integrity/students
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
23/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
24/89
https://ori.hhs.gov/definition-misconduct
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
25/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
26/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
27/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
28/89
KELENGKAPAN DOKUMEN PENILAIAN KARYA ILMIAH
UNTUK USULAN KENAIKAN JABATAN FUNGSIONAL, KOPERTIS WIL IV, MARET 2011
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
29/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
30/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
31/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
32/89
http://budisansblog.blogspot.com/2014/02/ga
gasan-asuransi-bencana.html
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
33/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
34/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
35/89
Halmar Halide @ physics unhas
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
36/89
Halmar Halide @ physics unhas
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
37/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
38/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
39/89
SNIP=1,250, SJR=0,643
SNIP=1,38, SJR=0,591
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
40/89
SNIP=2,641, SJR=5,473
SNIP=3,,628, SJR=2,672
SNIP=2,108, SJR=3,145
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
41/89
Type Examples Weight(*)
Primary primary research articles in peer-reviewed journals
dissertations and theses
technical reportsconference proceedings
1
Secondary monographs (books dealing with a specific area of
research in the sciences)
literature reviews (or review articles)
2/3
Tertiary encyclopediastextbooks
handbooks
1/3
(*) untuk pembobotan kemutakhiran dan kedalaman pembahasan
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
42/89
KEMUTAKHIRAN= (rujukan dlm 3 atau 5 tahun terakhir/ total rujukan) x 100%
KEDALAMAN = (rujukan pada bagian hasil dan diskusi/total rujukan) x 100%
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
43/89
Rujukan 5 (tiga) tahun terakhir Jumlah bobot Jumlah x bobot
Primer 28 1 28Sekunder 1 2/3 0,67
Tertier 1 1/3 0,33
Total = 29
Total rujukan = 37
Mutakhir (%) (29/37) x 100 % = 78 %
Rujukan 3 (tiga) tahun terakhir Jumlah bobot Jumlah x bobot
Primer 20 1 20
Sekunder 1 2/3 0,67
Tertier 1 1/3 0,33
Total = 21
Total rujukan = 37
Mutakhir (%) (21/37) x 100 % = 57 %
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
44/89
Publikasi SJR SNIP Kemutakhiran(%)
Kedalaman(%)
3 Tahun 5 Tahun
PNAS 5,473 2,641 57 78 53
J. Ecology 3,145 2,108 29 52,7 49,1
Nature Climate Change 2,672 3,628 31,2 39,6 31,2
Physica A 0,634 1,25 13,3 36,7 7,7
Natural Hazards 0,591 1,38 34,2 42,1 23,7
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
45/89
http://publicationethics.org/cases
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
46/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
47/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
48/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
http://publicationethics.org/text-recycling-guidelines
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
49/89
Text recycling in a published article
Journal editors should consider publishing a correction article when:
Sections of the text, generally excluding methods, are identical or near identical toa previous publication by the same author(s);
The original publication is not referenced in the subsequent publication; but
There is still sufficient new material in the article to justify its publication.
The correction should amend the literature by adding the missing citation and clarifying
what is new in the subsequent publication versus the original publication.
Journal editors should consider publishing a retraction article when:
There is significant overlap in the text, generally excluding methods, with sections that are
identical or near identical to a previous publication by the same author(s);
The recycled text reports previously published data and there is insufficient new material
in the article to justify its publication in light of the previous publication(s).The recycled text forms the major part of the discussion or conclusion in the article.
The overlap breaches copyright.
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
50/89
http://publicationethics.org/cases
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
51/89
fdc11166046-photo https://www.inmagine.com/searchterms/salami.html
http://www.123rf.com/stoc
k-photo/tempe.html
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
http://www biochemia-medica com/2013/23/237
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
52/89
http://www.biochemia-medica.com/2013/23/237
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
53/89
Updated October 2013
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
54/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
55/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
56/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
57/89
http://www.icmje.org/icmje-recommendations.pdf
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
58/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
59/89
http://www.icmje.org/recommendations/browse/roles-and-responsibilities/defining-the-role-
of-authors-and-contributors.html
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
60/89
http://www.icmje.org/recommendations/browse/roles-and-responsibilities/defining-the-role-
of-authors-and-contributors.html
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
61/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
62/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
63/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
64/89
http://www.citefactor.org/journal-impact-factor-list-2014_N.html
http://www.scimagojr.com/journalrank.php
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
65/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
66/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
67/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
68/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
69/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
70/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
71/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
72/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
73/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
74/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
75/89
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
76/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
77/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
78/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
79/89
http://www.elsevier.com/journals/learning-and-instruction/0959-4752/guide-for-authors#25001
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
80/89
http://www.elsevier.com/journals/learning-and-instruction/0959-4752/guide-for-authors#25001
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
81/89
www.bms.bc.ca/resources/library/pdf/GuidelinesScientificPapers.pdf
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
82/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
83/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
84/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
85/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
86/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
87/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
88/89
Halmar Halide, Fisika FMIPA Unhas 2014
8/11/2019 Good publication practices
89/89