8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 1/68
5^
7
LÌ^D: λ.Γ. S`1I"F^NíS.13.^ ^^ ?3`^^
^1:λ Rλ 1 \ S. PL'T\, λ ^l iS.B. ^ ^1?$39}^^^ll^. R. L ^ _^C.λ S tS.E3. ^ ^ ^ ^ Π^^)C.)'^IEI_`"E^Y ^^ ^Il"LRS LLP1^)^^ .λ ^^^^ uι ι , t^ th^ Stars. ; th F^1v^^rLπ s .λ n«e1^^. Calif^π rní ι ^)ΠΠ ^ ^-(^U;^Tι 1ι ^^h^^nc : ε ^ 1Π) ^^ ;- ^ ^ ΠU
F ιt^sι m^lι . ς.á 1 U) ^-F(^-Γi77^.λ ttc,ι-τie^=5 foι' P]aintíttHυ11^ ιτ^óι^ d For ι. i^^n Fress Associatíon
UNITED STATES DISTRACT COURT
9
1 C}
11
21
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
HOLLYWOOD FOREIΓ N PRESSASSOCIATION, a CalíforníaCorporatíon,
Plaíntiff,
v.
RED ZONE CAPITAL PARTNERSll, L.P., a Delaware LímítedPartnershipp ; DICK CLARKPRODUCTIONS, INC., a DelawareCorporation, DOES 1 through 10,inclusive,
Defendants.
Case No.COMPLA INT FO R(1) TRADEMA RKINFRING EMEN T• (2) FALSEλ SSOCIATION• (^)DECLARATIONOF COPYRIGHTCO-OWNERSHIP;(4)BREACH OF CONTRACT;(5) DEC Lλ RATO RY RELI EF;
ÁC COU ^ Ì NGçR(7)BRE ACH O FTHE IMPLI ED COVENANT OF
GOOD
FA ITH AND
FA IRDEALING • 8) BREA CH OFFID UC Iλ IF b UTY• (9) UNFA IRCOMP ETITIO N §U1{DER CAL . BUS .
CAL IFORNI Á C b MMON LÁ W;10) INTENTIO NALNTERF ERE NCE WITH
PRO SPEC TIVE E CONOMICλ DVANT AGE ;AN D(11) REFO RMAT ION
JURY DEMANDED
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 2/68
1 ^ Plai^t^fti Holy ^ ι ππι l F^r^^^n Press Assoeíat^u^ ^"NFPA"^, b^^ an^i thwu«h its.
°^ i^ ι ^ dcl^si^ιlc ι i ιι ^^ n,^L ti^ τ its cla ^^ ^s fπ r r^l τcf ι ^ ι iιι ^t Def ι ^ ^iaι^τ> clτek ι iark
3 ^ j^r^^ei^^^li^ns. Duc. ^"^i^h") a^^í R^^ Z^^^^ C^^í^ital P^utne^s ^, l.J.l'. {"Red Zane
" C,^¡^ital'') ^^^^1l^ctively, "D^Ÿ^ndants") ι llt^^es a> f ι^ llow^^
^,"^ L RE ^?^ TIE DISPUTE^ ^ l . For the past ^7 years HFPA, a nonprofit organization dedica7 ' bridging the international and entertainment cammunítíes, has hosted the Golden
8 Globe Awards to recognize outstanding achievements ín foreign and domestic
9 motion pictures and television. The intellectual property and contract rights10 Golden Globes are HFPA's primary assets, and HFPA uses proceeds from the
11 Awards to fund its annual phïlanthropíc grant program, through which ít distribu12 mïllíons of dollars to support ar ts-related scholarships and charities, edu
film programs, and cultural preservation foundations.14 2. Since their inception ín 1944, the Golden Globe Awards have become
15 one of the most watched awards programs ín the world. HFPA is the registered and
16 indisputably exclusive owner of federally protected intellectual property rights in
17 the Golden Gybe marks and Golden Globe statuette.18 3. In 1983, HFPA engaged Dick Clark and his company, dcp, to produce
19 the television production of the Golden Globe Awards show and to help license the
20 ^ rights to a broadcaster for telecast, The parties entered into a new agreement four
22
24
25
2^
27
28
years later, and through later amendments extended that agreement to 2011,
(collectively, "the Awards Agreement"). In return far its services, dcp received a
handsome share of the revenue generated by the show.
4. Since 20011, ownership of dcp has changed hands twice. In 2002, ít
was acquired by Mosaic Media Group, Inc., and ín 2047 by, on information and
belief, Red Zane Capital (a private equity firm owned by dcp board member Daniel
Snyder, and managed by dcp Chief Executive Officer Mark Shapiro), Síx Flags
Theme Parks, Inc., and an unidentified third party investor. Over the last decade,
co^^^
τ,^τ^^ ^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 3/68
6
7
8
2g
^icp has ta}:c^ <^c^a^ lil^^ti^s «^ith its ac^^>u^tï^« f^^ r^^^ ι ^ ιι< «e^t^at^di^^ the
C;^,l^1^u G(^^E^ ,^^^arc^s shu^^^s. :^^I^^r^ r^^^nt1^^. d^.p has 1^ι ^Tuυ ¡^^ r>ιún« a^^rι ^ττ ι nt^
tc^ í^r^^c^u^^, ^reat^. ^r ^^pl^^t Ali«^tal r^^^ht^, ^^1^illar^ shu«s, ^p^^ls^>rsh^^s, a^ld
pr^^n^t^^^al ca τni ^ aï^>ι1s. ^ ι n th π ^ «E1, ít laι1^^ t ιι ι ^ï^^hts f^^ d^^ s<^ . ^ , ι^d nυ ^^^, dc}^ has
dr^^^ed ^^11 hret^ns^ uz ^u^perati^^^l ^^r ^^υ t^d faith, ^ ιι ιi τs ιttc ιι^ptiι ^ ^ to a^s ιιι nc
complete ^^^^1tr^^Í overthe ^^i^7}^tì to t1^e sh^^ τ^,
5. HFPA brings tl^s la^i^s^^ít k^^^ause ^n October 29, 2010, dcp
surreptitiously signed a television broadcast lícense agreement with NBC
Entertainment {"NBC"} for the Golden Globe Awards shows through 2018, wïthF[FPA' s consent or authorization. In fact, dcp did not even notïfy or consult with
fíFPA before entering into the NBC agreement, in marked contrast with extensions of the NBC agreement . Rather, dcp proceeded in stealth.Monthsearlier, FIFPA had specifically instructed dcp not to discuss televisíon broadcastrights with anyone unless and until HFPA and dcp were able to consumate a new
deal to extend their soon-to-expire contractual relationship. dcp assured HFPA thít would never do such a thing, but then broke that commitment by commencing
and completing broadcast rights negotiations with NBC-all behind HFPA's back,and all while pretending to negotiate a new contract with HFPA.
^. dcp acts as though it has the unilateral right to lícense the brrights for the Golden Globe Awards show an whatever terms ít pleases, without
HFPA's knowledge or authorization . And dcp claims that, so long as it grants thetelevisíon broadcast rights for the awards show to NBC- regardless of whether ídoes so in good faith or at market value-dcp can control the television production
and broadcast rights to the Awards ierpetuíty. dcp's actions fly in the face of
representations that ïts e^ecutves made to HFPA at the time the original Awards
Agreement and later amendments were negotïated and signed dcp never bargained
for such unlimited and unchecked rights; indeed, it strains credulity to ^
2 C0141PLAINT
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 4/68
19
2Cl
21
22
24
25
2b
27
^^^}^at ^lcp cc>ul^ ha^^^ «iti^^^1 t^ ^^clucc HFPA t^> ^^termi^at^l} ahcíi^at^ íti ^» π ^t
^al^^abl^; ^s^^t.
^. ^i^j^ ha> aL^s^^h^t^1^- ^o ^^^^htunder the .λ ι 4ιτ^^í; <3^reement tc> ;^ra^t
^el^^ í^^c^n br^^ad^^^^t lïC^n^^'S fir f^^ture C;υ lι t^ττ Globe A^.vards ^11u^^; ~^ïthout
N^P^'; 1^^^^^^lt^lg^ ^^nd autl^rn^ízatï^n. ^^ur d^^^s dcp have thy : ^^á^^ht t^^^^nílattrall}
e.^plo^t t^^c Golden Globe-related marks, license the digital and athe^ - ^^^^í^a^}
^-^ghts, create promotional campaigns , or sell sponsorships. MFPA never
surrendered these rights, and dcp is new trying to steal them.
8. dcp' ^ motivation for this betrayal is clear. This ís a brazen adcp not only to extend its television production and licensing rights beyond the
terms of the parties' agreement, but to do so ín perpetuity. dcp contends that anyunilateral agreement with NBC--even one that involves licensing fees substantially
below current market rates-permits dcp to remain as HFPA's licensee and to
usurp HFPA' s control over the production and broadcast rights for futureGlobe Awards shows. dcp ís wrong. Its agreement with NBC has no force or
effect because dcp has no broadcast rights to grant. Even íf dcp's vïew of its rights
were to be credited, at most ít would have had options.
But those options would
have been revocable, and HFPA revoked them ín February 201 Q.^. Although ïneffectíve , dep's actions have economic consequences far
1-IFP^^dep's bad-faith conduct createsιιncertainty about the broadcast rights the Golden Globe Awards show and severely compromises HFPA's ability to
exploit its property. Until the crud of this non -agreement, with sub-market rateís removed , HFPA wïll be unable to obtain a fair ma^.ket value far the proand broadcast of the Golden Globes Awards show- its primary asset.
1Q. 1-1FPA seeks a judgment confïrmíng the ínvalid^ty of dcp' ractions.HFPA also seeks injunctive relief preventïng any marketing, promotion,
other explaítatíon of its intellectual property and contractual rights ín th
^(^?^ØLAINT
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 5/68
,
4
C^l^b^ .^^^^ard^ ;h^^l^^ ^^ith^ut NF`PØ's l^^-m^>5i^^^. and a^h^ that ^i^ ιma^-ι ^ he
awarded to r^c^r^^> ^lcp's n^m^r^tzs ^^^>>Itractua^ í^r^a^^h^^ aid ^ia^í-faith
. L^^IS^ICTItJti _^^^ll ^^F.AtE
11. This Cuu^-t hay 5^^bj^^t ^^att^r juri^^ {ictíi^n undr thi L^^nha^t^ .pct, 15
U.S.C, 1121, ^^l^d thi Cup^^i^.^ht .pct, 17 U.S.C. ^ 201(a), anti pur^ua^t to 2$
U.S,C. ^^ 1331 and 1338. This Court has supplemental jurisdiction of California
claims under 28 U.S .C. § 13b7^a}.
12. Defendant dcp is based in Los Angeles County and is subject to the
personal jurïsd^ction of this Court. Defendant Red Zone Capital ^s based ^nVirginia and is subject to the personal jurisdiction of this Court because
alter ego, because HFPA is informed and believes that Red Zone Capital conductssubstantial business ín Cal^fornía, and because Red Zone Capital engagintentional wrongful conduct directed atØA, which it knew to be a resïdent of
California.
Venue is proper under28 U.S.C. § 1391 as dcp is a resident of this
2g
28
district, and has its príncípal place of business in this district; Red Zone Capital is a
corporate entity subject to the personal jurisdiction of this Court, and therefore isdeemed a resident of this judíc^al district; and actionsg^víng rise to this disputeoccurred ín this judïcíal dïstr^ct.
THE PARTIES
14. Pla^nt^ff Hollywood Foreign Press Association ís a nonprofit
corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of California, with its
príncípal place of business at b^^b N. Robertson 131vd., West Hollywood, California
9^flb9.
15. Defendant dick elark productions, inc. is a corporation organized and
existing under the laws of the State of Delaware, with its principal place of business
at 2944 ßlympic Blvd,, Santa Monica, California 9404.
^- co^^ Øτ.aτ^
τ^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 6/68
5
24
25
26^^ η
28
16. D^f^^^dant R^^í Z^n^ C^^hital Part^^c^r^ II, L.P, i ^^ l^^»ittd 1^^t^It^^h^p
^^r^.^aυ il ιι ^ aτι ιí ι ^^^tí^ « t ι ^ cí^r t}ι 1 ι ^^s ^^C tlιe 5t ιι tι c^fDeÌa^^^art,with its 1^rinci^^ al
^^1^^c^ ^^t hu,in^^^ at I^OO T^^uτi, B^^^^l^^a^d. Suïte ^U^. ^l^^Lean, Vïrgi^^ía, ^^l(l2.
1^7. ^^nc^ ac^^^^irin^^ a ^^^ntrolhng ^^a^^r^ty ^wn^^sl^ih ^^^t^^^^t ^^^ dcp in
`_'Ut) ^,Red Zona Ca}?it^ ι1 114, äl^^^^^d the ^^rpo^•4^te form and e^l^loìted dcp for its
u^^^n ^ain. #-IPPA ís ^ τlt^urmt. and be^ie^es that: RØd Zone kapital e^^lc ^ ^ees d ιτ cct
a^^d serf©rm important functïons at dcp; Red Zone Capital and dcp ^ ^eration^ are
conducted out of the same offices ín both Santa Monica, Calï^fornia and McLean,
Virginia , employees do not distinguish between Red Zone Capítal and dcp in
performing work related to major awards show event management, digital and
marketing strategy, and licensing , the managing members and directors of Red
Zone Capital are also directors and officers of dcp , and Red Zone Capítal has
knowingly abused this overlap to F[^PA 's detriment; Red Zone Capítal caused dcp
to put up an intellectual property library that includes all of the copyrights to the
Golden Globe Awards shows and Pre-Shows as security to obtain a $165 million
high -interest short -term lian , which will be used not to invest in dcp, but to repay
dcp's already-existing$
51 million bank loans and to obtain for Red Zone Capital a
$90 million distribution. N^^PA is further informed and believes that dcp will be
unable to answer for any judgment in favor of HF PA against dcp, ín part because of
the debt that Red Zone Capïtal has directed dcp to assume in order to benefit Red
Zone Capital In sum, a unity of interest and ownership exists between Red Zone
Capital and dcp such that Red Zone Capital has relegated dcp to the status of a mere
instrumentality and conduit for Red Z^^ne Capïtal, and is manipulating its control to
drain dcp of its assets. Red Zone Capïtal is abusing dcp's corporate form to its awn
benefit and to I^FPA's detriment , and unless dcp's acts are treated as those of Red
Zone Capital's, an inequitable outcome will befall HFPA.
l ^. The identities and capacities of Defendants Does l to 1 Û are unknow
to Plaintiff . Plaintiff therefore sues these defendants by fietiti^us names. As to all
1
5 C`C7MPLAIN
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 7/68
1 ^ ι i^:l^ndallt^ suedby fictl ^ ι>ιι, ιlaτ^ ι ;, Blaín ^ ft ι ^i11¡^ru^ï^ Íι rιt^tiι ^ ι^i^thi> ι ^^^ l¡^Iaí^ t
^ ι.ι^ιl th^ir ^ ιι ^ í^Ic°τιt^Cτcs ^ ιεl^í ^^ ιpa^:il^ ts π ^}^^π a^ι c:^ t ^ ιi^ ιε l. Plai ^ t^l^f ^: inl^ι^τ τ»^d a ^
1ι1
. 1^tI1c^^c^,a17C1 ^^aS^(^ t}1c'Í^(lI1 ^1^I ^ `_γι S, t }^ 1l Ì] Π ^.S I to 10 a ^^ , a1ICi aC a1Í 1'c'Í^ ^^a ^ C ^ 1I^ e s
^ ^^ ^ ^ ^ R, Π111 ^ 1' c Π11lC>l'aÍ^ or 1lllSII1^^S tlltltl^^, a« ε'1]tS. ^l t ι 'c<5l(1I', ς 1 Il 1Il[tT^St. 11S^1^T ^ >,
^
^
7
8
24
25
26
27
2g
rehr^^^^^a^l^^, ^ríl^cípal^ a^^ífc^r ^mp1^^)^c:ca ofdcp u^ld Red ^o^^c Cai^^t^^l ^^r its
at^t^Iiates alld are responsible for tl^e ait, and emissions resúlting in the pauses of
a^tio^ alleged in this complaint. Plaintiff ís further informed and believes, and
based thereon alleges, that each defendant was the ment, employee, servant , partner
and/or co-conspirator of each of the other defendants and/or is in some ether
manner legally liable for the conduct and damages at issue in this action and was
acting within the course and scope of one or more of such relationships and with the
direct or implied knowledge, consent and/or ratification of each of the other
defendants.
THE HOLLYWOOD FOREIGN PRESS AND
THE GOLDEN GLOBE AWARDS
19. Founded during World War II, HFPA was originally comprised of a
handful of Los Angeles-based overseas journalists seeking to canned theinternational community with Hollywood and hoping to provide a welcome
distraction from the hardships of war through film. Nearly seven decades later,
^^FPA members today represent some of the world's most respected publications ín
55 eauntries, with a combined readership of 25fí million people. Each year HFPA
members view more than 300 films and interview over 400 actors, directors, writers
and producers. The organïzation's first awards presentation for distinguished
achievements ín the film industry was held ín early 1.944 with an informal
ceremony at 20th Century Fox, The next year, the now-famous globe statuette was
adopted, and ín early ^ 945 the first offïcial Golden Globe Awards presentation was
held at the Beverly I-Ii11^ H^ te1.
6 coιι τ r, τ^ τ^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 8/68
3
5
6
7
9
27
28
^U. híh`P.^ h^^lcís n^^^ltihl^ fι dcralJ^ re^Tísttr^^i trιι ci^
?ιτ^arl:^ and ^^r^^i^^^',
n^a^^s in tfte C^^^ld^n GI^1^^ name (^^n^ttd States P ^ lt^:nt ^^ Trací^ma^l : R ^^^i^^rati^^^
ti^>. ,^-^-^.^ Π : ^.-I^^.`; ^ η: ^ ^ ι1 ^.^51, 1^5), as well ει ^1τε H^^P.λ n^1mι 1?ι^int^^ í ιin a
^1^^^
^7^ of thL^u ^ d ^ rn G1ι,h^ ^t ^ ltιι^tte (tT^ ited Strates Pateiιt ^i T^a^eτυ ar^:
R^'gïstration^i>. ?,--l^;,S;^ analη ,-117,15^j. Those trad ιιττ arl; ^ and se τ-^ïcε: τ^ a^l^^
a^-e ^^alïd and. enforceable. In addition , the Golden Globe st^^t^^^°tte ís the
copyrighted property of HFPA. HFPA also owns several Intunet domain names
incorporating its marks , ^ncludíng ^, ^ _, .^_r^,I^^^^:^^^1^^'^ ^ ^, ^.^^{_1^^.^r^. {Copies of these
trademark and service mark registrations are attached hereto as Exhibit A.)
21. HFPA uses proceeds from the Golden Globe Awards to achieve two of
its organizational missions . {1) contributing to other nonprofit organizationsconnected with the entertainment industry through educational, culturalhumanitarian activities; and (2) promoting interest ín the study of the arts thrscholarships to major learning instítutïons.HFPA donates millions of dollars in
fellowships and grants to, among other things, help film students complete theirthesis projects, fund educational and health videos for residents of Kenyan refuge
camps, and provide feature films to entertain hospitalized children.THE AGREEMENTS WITH DCP
22. In 1983, HFPA entered into an agreement granting dcp the exclusiverights to produce and license a live television broadcast of the 44th Golden Globe
Awards. The parties agreed that dcp would pay HFPA SQ^7^ of the net p
derived from the rights granted under the agreement. In addition, HFPAdcp four {^} consecutive and exclusive options to acquire from HFPA the same
television production and exploitation rights for the 198^^, 1985, 198, and 1987
Golden Globe Awards . dcp licensed the televísïon broadcast rights to TurnerBroadcasting System ^"T13S") in 1983.
In 1987, dcp drafted a new agreement to replace the 1983 contract
between ït and HFPA (the "1987 Awards Agreement"}. {A copy of the 1987
^ COM Σ'L λι NT'
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 9/68
1 λ ^cιu^^lsλ ,7 ^ ^cn ε π t is attach ε d as FxhibitB.) The 1 ^^ 71λ ι a ^ c^, .λ17r^t ^ ι ^ t ^^^^ ιι ntec
27
2g
fee possible for the Awards show telecast was critical to achieving that objectiveand purpose. As under the 1983 contract, the 1987 Awards Agreement required
dcp to pay HFPA 50^1c of the net profits it derived from the rights granted under the
agreement; required each party to bear certain casts related to the event and
television production; allowed HFPA to maintain creative control over the
presentation and certain elements of the television production; and provided for
HFPA and dcp sharing a joint copyright interest ín the produced television
programs. In 1989, HFPA and dcp amended their agreement to grant dcp five (5)
additional optïons (for the years 1993 through 1997).
24. The rights granted to dcp under the 1987 Awards Agreement did not
include the right to produce or license a digital internet stream of the Awards show,
and did not cover any ancillary pre- or post-Awards shows, promotional campaigns
surrounding the Awards show, or sponsorship opportunities. Nor did the contract
^l^h ti^^ ^> ^ ^ππ ; ^cut ^ ^,e^^d exclusí^-e options to acquirethi ^^^^htsto produce alig ^ t^l^^^ï;^u^ ^7r^^^clcast of and to i^^^t^d^^^^: o^^ tapgi, or film tllcG^^7d^^1 Globe
_^^^^arci, p^^sc^^tati^^^^sfor 1988, 1989 , 1990, 1991, and 1992, and to espl^^t ; ιιι il
1 i ^ L talc ^^^^ï^n;tape, or film productions. dcp, in turn, agreed that itwould attempt
in good faith t^ arrange for the Golden Globe Awards show to be licensed for live,
^yndícated, ar network d^ mestic television broadcast. A central ob^ectíve and
common purpose of the 1987 Awards Agreement was to maximize the revenue
each party would receive through the broadcast and exploitation of the televised
Awards show. The parties recognized that obtaining the highest broadcast license
grant dcp the right to use HFPA's trademarks and service marks for anything
beyond advertising and publïcíty for the live television, tape, or film productions of
the Awards . And even then, the 1987 Awards Agreement required dcp to obtain
HFPA's prior approval before issuing any publicity relating to the Awards.
8 ca ^^ τ ^ ^aτ^ τ^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 10/68
25. The G υ l ^^ ell C1^ ^hc .^ ιι ^a ιls « ι e^ ^ in pi^(^ uiarítv ι ^Σ i1eτ^^ n TBS in the^ ^, ι,O^ ι ^ d '^ ιr1τ^ 1^ ^>O^. a^ ^1 uII ^-1pr^ 1 ^. 1093, NFP λ »1^^t w'ítlι d ι^h ιι1d ^tτthc^rizι d it
^^ Π il ^ Π t ^ LC^^ ^1^11^ c'^^OI1^1T11^11ti Í Π I' ^ }1^ 111 ^ ^^(JSC' of ^^1^ ^ ^1I^ ] ^ ^' ^1 11lLt^CI-VL ^ 1t EI ^ Π<1 ^ ,1C^15Í1^ ^T
6
7
8
9
10
^:^^r^e^nent ^^ith ^ ßC i^or th.e Gulden G1^l^e Awards. At t11at III^^^í^l^ . ^icp had
a^^^^i Id^PA to e^t^nd ^t^ r^la^unsh^p ^i ^tl^ c1cp, which^ti a t'^di^g gill 1997.HFPA
stated that any additional options to produce a television broadcast and license the
show would be depe^ldant on dcp negotiating and securing a firm broadcast
licensing commitment from NBC.
26. On September 22, 1993, dcp representatives attended HFPA's general
membership meeting. During that meeting, Dick Clark, Francis La Maina, and
Gene Weed of dcp described an opportunity to move the television broadcast froTBS to the NBC . The dcp team stated that NBC wanted to enter into amulti-yearbroadcasting license under which it would broadcast the awards show starting in1996 through 1999, with optíons through 2Q05.
27. At that same meeting, dcp representatives proposed an amenthe 1987 Awards Agreement that would provide dcp with the necessary addítionoptions to produce and license the Golden Globe Awards television broadcasts for
the duration of the proposed NBC broadcast license. HFPA members asked how
long ít would be potentially extending its agreement with dcp under such an
arrangement. The dcp representatives stated that the amendment to the 1987Awards Agreement would be finite , and that once NBC's broadcasts began ïn1996
it would be effective for no longer than 1 Q years.28. 1-1FFA's general membership and board of directors understo
dcp was seeking through this amendment a finite number of addítional optíons to
conform to the proposed broadcast license that dcp was negotiating with NBC, a
that in no event was ^1FPA making a commitment to either dcp or NBC beyond2OQ5.
9 co^ ØZ ττv^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 11/68
3
4
^
7
8
9
1^
2^
^^
26
27
^?9. {^^1 í^ltt^^^^^a^^n a^Id hel^ef. ^[ch ^^^a; t^t^llti^ ^^l^^ar^ of ^I1-^PA°
^u^^ler,tancíi^^^ ^,f^ the }^^^>}^^^;ed a^ne^^íme^It tu t}^^e 19;7 :^^ard^ ^^^^^eTo the
e^te^^t that an^^ d^^^^ repres^:^tati ^e u^derst^^d the pr^p^»ed a^^ic^^^dnlc^t ^ould
arF^^^^i dcp ^^^^1ate^-aÏ ^^pt^u^^ t^^license the te^c^^isïon broadcast rights for the
G^ld^;^ ^^1^^^^e ^^wards shu^^^tu NBC in pt^ -pen^it}^ and to remain as producer in
perpetuity under the same terms, that understanding was never disclosed to HFPA.
Nor would ít have made any sense for HFPA to grant options to dcp in perpetuity:
such an arrangement would have been unheard af ín the television industry.
30. Based on the interactions and discussions between the parties, dcp wwell aware of HFPA's understanding of the 1993 Amendment. C?n information
belief, dcp understood the 1993 Agreement to have the same meaning as HFPA atthe tïme of contracting. Indeed, dcp executives Gene Weed and Francis La Mainatold HFPA that dcp had always and would always come to HFPA for prior approbefore negotiating towards a broadcast license of the Awards show telecast, or another like efforts.
31. Based on its understanding of the proposed terms of the broa
license agreement with NBC, and of the amendment to the 1.987 AwardsAgreement, HFPA approved proceeding with both the extension of dcp's options as
licensee and with the NBC broadcast license pursuant to the proposed amendmen
to the 1987 Awards Agreement {hereafter referred to as the "1993 Ame(A copy of the 1993Amendment ís attached as Exhibït C.) Specifically, I-IFPA
approved the 1993 Amendment and the NBC broadcast agreement wïth theunderstanding- based on dcp's representations- that HFPA's prior informedapproval would be required for: (1) any extension, renewal, substitutïon, or
mod^fícation of the broadcast license with NBC; and (2) any further op
to remain as producer of the television program and licensee of the televïsíon
broadcast rights for the Awards shave.
^Ù COMPLAINT
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 12/68
In 19 ^^ , t11e (^aι°tïes ^^t«^^ tíat ι d a n π ι ^-ι ι hi ^ ^^í ιππ t ^ aιι ιιιτder ^^^hiι h
HFPA ^ ι aτttιι í d^^1^ t1^^ι i«}^t tu "}^r^^ιíιι c^, ι í^ tτ ^ hut ι. }? ^ u ιl^^^tι . a^i^^cτti se a ιι d ^ zpl^^it
.^^^nt-h^t^-h^-e-apt arcs sh^^^- ^t1^e "Prc-51^^>^^^") to he t^l^^ast f^^^ \BC
^la^^ asa lea #- n to the 20fl0 ,-^4^^ards, τvhi ch«aì t π f^at ιι r^ '^th^ a^riti^^ d of
5 ^^^l^brítie^^^ and "pre-taped segments about din^tr ^^enus, gitt pacl^a^^e
6 ^ interviews ín prior years, planning of parties, [and] scenes of celebrities enterïng
7 ^^ (but not inside) the ballroom." ^A copy of the 1999 Pre-Show Agreement is
8 attached as Exhibit D.j HFPA also granted dcp one option to produce the 20fl1 Pre-
9 Show, and the parties amended the Pre-Show Agreement in 2001 and agaín ín 2003
10 for HFPA to grant dcp options to produce the Pre-Show ín 2002 through 200. The
11 Pre-Show Agreement has since expired.12 33. In 2001, NBC expressed interest ín broadcasting the Golden C ^ lobe
13 Awards through 2011, In the spring of 2001, representatives of dcp once agaín
14 made a presentation to HFPA about extending the NBC broadcast license
15 agreement and granting to dcp further options to produce and license the televisiI^ broadcast of the Awards show. HFPA decided ín favor of both extending the
17broadcast license and granting to dcp further options. Thereafter, the NBC
18 broadcast license was amended to extend through the 2011 Golden Globe Awards
19 show telecast, and dcp exercised the options that would allow it to remain involved
20 thr©ugh the January 2011 Golden Globe Awards show,
21 DCP ATTEMPTS TO ASSL ;CNIE CONTROL OVER THE GLOBES22 ^4. Cln information and belief, i*n 2002, Díck Clark sold his majority stake
23 i*n dcp to a group of investors led by Mosaic Media G^:oup, Inc., and ín 2007, Red
24 Zone Capital {one of several similarly named private equïty companies owned and
25 operated by Danïel Snyder}, along with Síx Flags, Inc., purchased dcp f©r $175
2^ million. Six Flags represented ín its 2aØ9 bankruptcy disclosure filings that an
27 unïdentifíed third-party investor purchased approximately 2.0°lß of dcp from Síx
28 Flags and Red Zone Capital in late 2007. ^(^n information and belief, Red Zone
COívIPL^AIN
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 13/68
,
b
7
21
LLC had ucqu^^c;^f ^^^n^^^l of Sig Fla,^^ ^n `?^O^ ^h ^ ι^^ ^7}1 a ^u^^^^^^1^ιι1 ^ ι υ ^} ^ υ ntc^t.
S^^d^r und Scliar ^^^^^^l^d Rid 7^^n^ LLC. and ^la^h Shapira ^^^a^ R^^l Z^^ne LLC's
CLO. ^ft^^ Rid L ι>>1 LLC^^ a^du^^^ti^n ^^t cuntr^^1 ^^^cr Sir Flags. Sn^^d^^and
D«i,^}1t Scham h^ ι a ιτ ι di τ tι turs a ττc^ _^1ar^ ^Sh^ι} iro h^canl^ CEO, Si κ F1τι«^ filed for
Chuptur 1l banl:r^^pt^:^^^ ^ ^tl(a^. ffFPA is in^^^r^l^:d amid b^l^^t^^s that ^^.edZone
Capital now holds the controlling majorïty interest in dcp. th^^t Snyder and Schar
are managing members of Red Zone Capital and directors of dcp, and that Snyder
and Schar installed Shapiro as Director and Executive Vice Chairman of dcp.
35. Unbeknownst to HFPA, dcp and its new corporate parents have been
systematically attempting both to assert proprietary interests ïn the Gold
Awards shows , and to encumber the rights to those shows in return for finbenefit that ís not being reported to, or shared with, HFPA. HFPA is informed an
believes that dcp has repeatedly represented to third parties that ít ownsthe Golden G lobe Awards show and that it has the unilateral ability to gpieces of those rights without the involvement or consent of HFPA.
36. For example, HFPA recently hired digital consultants to negotiate w
third parties with respect to the digital rights surrounding the Golden GlAwards. dcp has no license from HFPA for digital rights. HFPA's digital
consultants had commenced discussions with senior employees at Facebook
regarding an online component to complement the live telecast of the Awards show.
On information and belief, Facebook was eager to have involvement with HFPA
and the Golden Globe Awards, and invited HFPA's consultants to meet ín Los
Angeles.
37. On information and belief, dcp was aware of 1^FPA's interesforming a business relatïonship with Facebook, and expressly and knowingly
pr^^^nt^d HFPA and Facebook executives from meeting by telling Facebook that
dcp owns all digital rights associated with the Golden Globe Awards-even though
dcp had never been granted such rights by HFPA.
12 co^ ^τε^ . τ^ τ^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 14/68
4
S
21
22
24
2^
26
27
28
;^ . IIFPt-^ is í^formed and belïev^s that Fac^b^wk termi^at^^i iu
d^sct^ssï^^^s♦^^it}1 .^ ^m^l^r the mista^^n h^li^t-created by d^•p'
n^^>^^^pr^^et^tati^^^-that dcí^ had the ^^cl^^^^^^^ authority to lí^t^^^ Golden Globe
digital rights to Facebook.
39. Further, HFPA is informed. and belíe^ es that ^^^ c rat c_^ther ^,
are now involved ín dcp's supposed digital plans, and that dcp falsely informed
those companies that ít owns or otherwise controls digital rights related to the
Golden Globe Awards show.
40. After Snyder, Schar, and Shapiro took control of Síx Flags and dcp,
Six Flags made public statements about its supposed rights to leverage the Golden
Globe Awards show. Ina 2009 bankruptcy filings, Six Flags stated that ít"leveraged the dcp library, which includes the Golden Globe Awards ... to provide
additional product offerings in its parks" and that it "believes that its investment ín
dcp provides it with additional sponsorship and promotional opportunities." And
HFPA recently discovered that dcp claimed for itself copyright ownership over the
2007 and 2009 Pre-Shows, even though HFPA is a rightful co-owner of those
copyrights.
41. At the same time, dcp has claimed questionable items as production
costs, has sold sponsorships without telling HFPA or sharing the revenue, and has
neglected to provide regular accounting statements as required under the Awards
Agreement. For example, HFPA discovered after the 2010 Golden Globe Awards
that dcp secretly entered into a verbal $200,000 promotional deal with a corporate
third party whose representatives believed HFPA had been informed of the deal.
But dcp did not inf^rrr^ HFPA of the agreement, and accounted to HFPA for the
revenue only after HFPA discovered what had happened from the corporate third
party and confronted dcp.
42. By 2010, the Golden Globe Awards-which is HFPA's primary asset
and the revenue source for its philanthropic grants-had become one of the most
13 co^ ^τ τ. τ^v^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 15/68
5
7
8
huhuia^. mar ^^^atched. a^cl r ^ π ^t ^^^ι^^ι^izι ci i^il^ t a ι1 l tι ( ^1^i;^ i π ι ^^ ιrci^ 1^rι^^=raτι ^
^n the world. , λ1(h^>u«h thι ,^^v^ ar ι í> λ ^ ι e ιι^C^ t υ n1^ τ ι^tι i τ ι ^1 1-1FP^ tπ n^^_ι^tiat^
^^.^^ith ^l^h af^te^ ^}^^ a^^ree^^^^ut^^ eY^li^atiu^ (i^ullu^t^in^^ the 2(.)11 C^uld
A^^ard^ ^huw), HFPA rep^esentat^^^c:^ bruac^led ^^^íth dcp í^1 e^u^^} ?01^ the
pu»i^^lïty ^f he^^^^ní^^; 5u^h talk s earl }^ ^n ^^rdcr tgive the p^^^-t^^s ^^cldít^únal ti
to discuss their relationship.
^l-3. ^n February $, 2010, Philip Berk {President of ^^FPA} sent Mark Shapiro an email stating that the 2011 Golden Globe Awards show was the
"last show" under the existing agreement between ^^FPA aid dcp, and offering to"begin exploring the nature of our relationship after the January 2011 G
Mr. Berk noted that entering into discussions early may "provide us with thenecessary time to secure the best possible licensing deal." Mr. Berk was clear thdcp had no right to license any further Golden Globe Awards show beyond the
2011 show, and should not pursue any broadcast license involving the Awards
show "until we agree upon the nature of any such future relationship." Thus,Mr. Berk emphasized that"I want to ensure that dcp does not seek or agree to anysubsequent broadcast licensing agreement with NBC
(or anyone else, for that
matter) as dcp' s options obviously also expire with that last broadcast in January2011."
44. The following day, Mr . Shapiro responded to Mr. Berk by email,agreeing to early discussions between dcp and HFPA. Mr. Shapira noted that the
was "no need to remind me ^r ask me not to seek a new license agreement for th
property. 1 would never make a move a^ a network renewal or new home without
your involvement."^5. Cher the months that followed, HFPA and dcp representatives entere
into substantial negotiations over a yew agreement that would allow dcp to rema
^nva^ved in the Golder Globe Awards Shaw after the 2011 broadcast. Taid counsel had multiple ín-person discussions , telephone conversations, and email
Σ 4 co^ 7τ τ:^.ττv^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 16/68
,
^
7
8
4
10
27
^^ g
^^ ι h ^ ι ^ ^^^s, aτιd ^ lιι c{ι p^^^ ^^π ^a1^ fι^r
d ^ ^p.
;zens a new agreement tic-t^^c^nI-IFPA and
^^. J^^s^^^i^ C^^1abr^s^ lt^utsid^ ^πιι ^ >t1 and lead n^^^^^t^at«r for HFPA} mit
i t h S 11 apí r^^ in persu n on .l my I ^, and spoke a^;aín o^ J^^ Iy 29 and August 7. On
1^^^^^st 13, 2QIQ, Cala[^r^se sent a l^tttr t^^ Sha}^i^^o oncea^4^í^2 notïng that the
existïng Awards Agreement between HFPA and dcp would shortly be expiring, and
that without a nerv agreement dep's involvement with the Golden Globe Awards
show come to an end . Calabrese stated : "REPA would very much like to make a
new deal wïth dcp to ensure its continued involvement with the Golden Globe
Awards show after 2011 . At this point, dcp has the right to be involved with only
one remaining main Awards show .... I appreciate the fact that dcp would like tocontinue on the same terms as they understand were originally agreed over 13 years
ago, but those terms will be expiring soon and are not acceptable to HFPA."
^7. That same day, HFPA sent dcp proposed terms for a new agreement.Shapiro called Calabrese on August 16 to discuss moving forward with talks, and
on August 19 Shapiro assured Calabrese that dcp wanted to schedule meetings ín
early September ín order to close a deal between dcp and HFPA by September 3
On September $, Calabrese again met with dcp to negotiate terms of the new
agreement. HFPA and dcp c^ntínued to negotiate into late September, and onSeptember 27 they again discussed the potential deal. Shapiro told F[FPA he
needed to discuss the matter with his board of directors. Believing that they were
close to reaching a new deal with dcp , HFPA waited for dcp to respond with aacceptance or counter-proposals , followïng up w ith dcp twice to inquire asstatus ^^ dcp's response, the last tïme on October 2I. The response HFPA was
waiting for never arrived.
^8. Instead, on October29, 2û1Q, dcp sent Berk a letter inforrr^ing HFPthat dcp had executed an agreement with NBC that same day under whi
purported to grant NBC a license for the excl^.^síve broadcast rights to th
15 co^ ^Øι,^ τ^^^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 17/68
G1obe A^^^ard^ tl^ruu«f1 ^Π1 ^. dcp a^^ π , ^π t HFPA í. ι τ l ι^tτ^ ι , attachØ l1 ε:r^t^^ as
τr τt F. th ιt d ι p «^ ι^ uπ ^^ atteιl^^^^^ ^> t« excrcisC ti^ι s^^ ^i1ι ^>ptiπ n^ it ι π uld 1^^^ ^ι
2O
^c'^il^t^ ^^1 c^r^^:^ ^^ter ï^^^ th^^t a^r^^m^^tØhti^n^ ^i^^p ^^^^^^' ti^ul i^1 ilia lira ^la^^.
^^^í ions thatdcp ne^- er bargained for, and Ito the extent they ever exíst^dj c^pti^ns
that were revo^abl^ acid had been unequivocally revoked through NFPA's February
^, COI (} and August 13, ZOIO letters as well as other statements . In short, dcp
granted NBC a broadcasting license fir ríghts that were not dcp's to grant.
49. dcp's announcement of this purported broadcast agreement apurported exercise of non-existent options blíndsíded HFPA. HFPA had not
authorized dcp to negotiate over the broadcast ríghts for any further Go
Awards shows. In fact, quite the opposite. HFPA had explicitly informed dcp thatit was not empowered to even discuss the broadcast ríghts with any thirNor did HFPA offer dcp any further options to extend its role ín producing thetelevísíon broadcast of the Golden Globes Award show. Once again, the opposite
was true: HFPA had made clear that its relationship with dcp was coming to an eín January 2011 absent the parties reaching a new agreement.
50. dep's attempt in October 2410 to unilaterally license the televísíon
broadcast ríghts to NBC, and on that basis to attempt exercising options to extenits agreement with HFPA, was the first time in the parties' history that d
taken actual and affirmative steps inconsïstent with FIFPA's understandneeded its consent before entering into any license agreement for the Golden Globe
Awards show broadcast rights.51. dcp followed a similar pattern with respect to the Pre-Show
Agreement. HFPA repeatedly informed dcp that the Pre-Show Agreementexpired, and the parties engaged ín what HFPA believed were good faithnegotiations to enter into a new agreement. All the while, dcp was mïsleadíng
HFPA, ^^^d instead attempted to arrogate HFPA's rights for itself.
16 c©τιτ τ.^τ^ τ^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 18/68
2
5
6
7
8
9
24
25
26
27
28
ßiß inf^r^^^atz^^^t anti ^^Iief, thi Ji^.ens^ fees that dcp accep ted t^r^^^n
NBC are ^^-ell h^lu^^ ^^^^^^et rags. 1-fFP. λ i^ i^ i^>ι'τt 7^ d a π d h^lic^^^^ tl^a[ dip ^ ι^tι re^
into the a^reemc;^t ^^ith tiBC i^ the h^lic^ that d^^^ ti^^^^^^^d he ahle t« ^e ιιιι -e fir itself
a cont τττui ^ « τ-π1e a^ HFP.-^`^ ]ïc ι ^ lsee, at th ^ ι xp^n^^ c ^ f acg ι ^^ ι ^^ ^^ιι ^aτ ^et-level
license fees for the br^^adcast rights a ^ ú to ^IFPA's d^tríme^t.
53. Tl^e t^^1i^`T livas not a coincidence. tan information and belief, Red
Zone Capital has beep quietly seeking buyers for dcp. At the same time, on
information and belief, dcp recently sold ^ 1 ^5 million of senior secured first-lien
notes ín the 144a private placement market to Banc of America Securities LLC and
SunTrust Robinson Humphrey, Inc. HFPA ís informed and believes that the
notes-commonly known as junk bands-are due to be repaid in 2015. HFPA ^^informed and believes that dcp secured this money by placing the first-tier lien on a
copyright library that includes all of the Golden Globe Awards shows and Pre-
Shows. No one from dcp or Dick Clark Fílm Group informed HFPA that its
copyright interests were being pledged, nor was HFPA's consent obtained. Reuters
recently reported that dcp will be using the $165 million that it borrowed and that it
must repay ín just five years "to repay about $^ 1 million in bank loans and fund a$90 million distribution to the company's parent"-Red Zone Capital.
FIRST CLAIM F(^R RELIEF
{Trademark Infringement under 15 U.S.C. § lll4)
54. Plaintiff realleges and incorporates herein by reference, each and every
allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 53, inclusive, of the complaint as
though set forth at length.
^^. HFPA is the sole owner of multiple federally registered trademarks
and service marks ín the Golden Globe name {PTß Registration Nos. 2424703,
2422897, 2351145), as well ^^ the HFPA name printed on a design of the Golden
Globe statuette {PTQ Registration Nos. 2427$33, 2427955}. HFPA also owns
17 co^ ^Øτ.aτ^v^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 19/68
^^'^ :^^ll It]íc'1`f1c° ^ ^U(?IIl^U11 n^llll^^ 1 ^ COrpi}T^1Ì1t1^, liti t^^l^^t í111d serv^C^ 17lá1-^5, 1nC111^í111«
^(í. ^í^^p lla^ ^^>ι ^ I HFPA'^ ^-a^lel^Ia^^,and service marks in commerce,l^^itlluut I-IFÝA's 1:no^l^^lge or au^hurízafï^n, ^^^^^^^^ cet}I^r th^^^^^,^^n Sepieτi^h τ
2010 , dcp ^n_t^r^d nt^^ an agreementwith ABC purp^^ti^l^ t^ license ther^^ht t
8
^rc^a^^cast the 2012 to 2018 Golden Globe Awards shows throughout the United
States. dcp ís capïtalizing, to íís great financial benefit, on the fame and goodwill in
HFPA's marks, without HFPA's permission or approval. dcp has the right to use
HFPA's marks only ín connection with the Golden Globes Awards shows through
the 201 I show. It has no right to license the use of those marks in connection with
future shows.57. In addition, the agreement between dcp and NBC ís predicated on, and
expressly anticipates, dcp further infringing HFPA's marks and dcp causing NBC
to infringe the marks. The agreement was made for the express purpose of
imminently exploiting plaintiff's registered marks ín interstate commerce by
marketing, advertising, producing, and broadcasting the 2012 Golden Globe
Awards show (as well as shows in later years). C?n information and belief, those
efforts in connection. with the 2012 Awards show have already begun, and further
efforts will commence shortly.
58. Qn information and belief, dcp has also generally claimed to third
parties to have the exclusive right to license, and empower others to make
commercial use of, HFPA's Golden Globe-related marks. For example, on
ïnformatïon and belief, dcp falsely represented to Facebook that dcp owned all
digital rights assocïated with the Golden Glatie Awards and that it had exclusive
authority to license those rïghts. dcp made these false representations even though
HFPA never granted dcp any authority, let alone exclusive authority, to license
such rí^hts.
18 cc^^ τ τ.^τ^ ^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 20/68
2
4
5
6
7
22
23
24
^^
2^
^^
28
^^. D^f^ndant^^ ^ulauthurízed use ^f HFP,^^'s ^1u^r^:5 hay a1r^ ^^d}^ ^:a^^ed
and is líl~^1^- tt^ ^^ntinu^ tv a^^^c^ c^^nfit^í^n. mi>ta}^t. and dtcCp^un,
fßß. ^1^^'c^dantsacted ^^^^^ltull^^, ^^^^th t}^^ínt^nt t^ ^-ade ^^p^^^ thε~ ^^_>^d^^^i1
and r^p^^tatiun of ^-1FPA and the Gulden G ^uheAwards ;hu^^^, and with ti^ι int^^t t^
Cause C^nh1^1^7^, t0 ^aUS^ mistake, Or t{3 deCtive,
^ 1. Øn information and belief, Red Zane Capital vas aware ^f dcp' ^
actions, and dcp was acting at Red Zone Capital's directí^n and under its cc^ntr^l.
b2. Defendants' acts, as alleged above, have caused damage and
irreparable injury to HFPA ïn an amount to be determined at trial. By making
unauthorized use of HFPA's marks and creating uncertainty and confusion about
the broadcast rights for the Golden G1^be Awards show, dcp has, among otherthings, severely compromised HFPA's ability to exploit its rights in the Golden
Globes. While the cloud of uncertainty hovers, HFPA cannot effectively make any
effort to seek fair market rates for the production and broadcast of the Awards
show. Any other potential broadcaster would be "buying a lawsuit." Defendants'
acts wí11 result ín further damage and irreparable injury to HFPA íf Defendants are
not restrained by this Court from further violation of HFPA's rights, for whichHFPA has no adequate remedy at law.
63. As a result of the harm suffered as alleged herein, HFPA is entitled to
all of the remedies available under the Lanham Act, including actual damages, an
accounting of Defendants' profits, treble damages, Costs and attorneys' fees,
SECt^ND CLAIM FQR RELIEF
(False Association under 15 U.S.C. ^ 1125)
^4. Plaintiff realleges and incorporates herein by reference, each and every
allegation contained ín paragraphs 1 through b3, inclusïve, of the complaint as
though set forth at length.
65. dcp has unilaterally attempted to license the right to broadcast the
Golden Globe Awards shows for 2ß 12 through 241 ^, and ís purporting to empower
1 g C^ 1^IΣ'L λ INT
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 21/68
6
7
8
24
25
26
27
,g
ß;ßC to t^,^ H^`PA's C^^I^íe^ Gl^^hc'-r^lat^d n^arhs to ^narl:^t: a^^l advertise the
.^^^arci^ ^h^«^s. aid t}l^^ to b^^ad^a^t t}l^ ^ni^^^^ Gul^lea^ Gl^t^^ .^^^a^ci^ ^h^^^-s
^^^i^« NFP.^' Gul^ic^ G^^h^-rc°lat^^í ^arl:s. ^^ inf^ormat^^^^ aid. b^l^^f, ^l^p has
^l;u ^^^i^ralll ^laim^d t^^ third ¡^arti^; to 11«^^ thi r ι«ht to Ii ι^eτι^^ ind empc^ we^
óthcr^ ^1^0^^ ^^a^^}^1^, Fa^^lu^^} t^ ^^a}^^ ^u^1l^nercial ^^C ^^f^-1FPA's Golden G1obe-
related marks . These acts, among o^h^rs. constitute a false association , a false
designation of origin, and a false description or representation of goods and
services, tending wrongfully and falsely to describe ar represent a connection
between both dcp and its purported licensees , on the one hand, and HFPA and the
Golden Globe Awards show , on the ether hand. By these acts, Defendants have
infringed HFPA's marks ín violation of 15 U.S.C. ^ 1125(a).
^^. The impressions of affiliation created by Defendants' use of Plaintiffs'
marks are false. Thïs false impression of association has created and will continue
to create confusion as to the continued connection between both dcp and itspurported licensees, on the one hand, and HFPA and the Golden Globe Awardsshow, on the other hand.
67.HFPA ís informed and believes
, and on that basis alleges, thatDefendants acted willfully, with the intent to trade upon the goodwill and
reputation of HFPA and the Golden Globe Awards show, and with the intent tocause confusion , to cause mistake, or to deceive.
68. Can information and belief, Red Zone Capital was aware of dep's
actions, and dcp was acting at Red Zone Capïtal's direction and under its contr69. HFPA has suffered, and wí11 continue to suffer, irreparable dam
its business, reputation, and goodwill resulting from the confusïon of potential
licensees and the general pt^blíc regarding the continued association bedcp and NPC, on the one hand , and HFPA and the Golden Globe Awards show, on
the other hand. As a result , ^íh^'A is entitled to injunctive relief preventing
from creating a false impression of association between both dcp and its purport
20 cØ^ ^r^^i^^ ^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 22/68
1
4
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
1$
19
20
21
22
24
25
26
27
28
1ic τυ ^e>, ^π tl^^ π nι 1^aτιcl. a^ d H1=^Pλ a^1^ t}te Cι^Id^u G1^^1^ .λ ^^^ar^i^ ^hu^^^^,υ ^ ^ h^
υ ^1^c r han^1,
7Π. As a re^ult ^^^ 1h ι: harm ;utt ι r^^i a; a11^^^^d h^ι'e ^ ιι , HFP, λ i^ ais^a
^ ^ t'tt1^J to al1 ofthe oth^r r^ ιn^^íi^s a^^ailahl^.uncícrth ^ Lu ^ llam Act, includíng
aι ^ ιal da ^ la^^es,an acccτι»t ^ n^ υ f Defendιnts' proüts, treble damages, and cu^t,
and attorneys' fees.
THIRD CLAII^^ F{JR RELIEF
{Declaration of Copyright Co-Qwnership)
71. Plaintïff realloges and incorporates herein by reference, each and every
allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 70, inclusive, of the complaint as
though set forth at length.72. An actual controversy has arisenand now exists between HFPA, on
the one hand, and Defendants, on the other hand, relating to their respective rights
regarding ownership of the 1990, 1993, 1998, and 1999 Golden Globe Awards, and
the 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007 and 2009 Pre-Shows. HFPA contends:
a} The 1990, 1993, 1998, and 1999 Golden Globe Awards, as wed
as the 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007 and 2009 Pre-Showproductions, are copyrightable as motionpictures or other
audiovisual works. The agreements between HFPA and dcp
contemplate that HFPA and dcp are co-authors ^f the Awards
shows and Pre-Shows. HFPA made substantial and valuable
contributions to these works by exercísïng creatïve control and
input over the Awards presentations, script content, the identity
of presenters and performers appearing an the Golden Globe
Awards show, as well as the Pre-Show set decoration, and
casting of the Pre-Show hosts. HFPA and dcp intended that
their respective contributions to the 1990, 1993, 1998, and 1999
Golden Globe Awards, as well as the 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006,
21 co^ pτ.^τ^ τ^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 23/68
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 24/68
Fucκ ^ u cτ... ^ τ ε« ^ κτ:τ τ^r^^$reach of (^u ^ tract!
5^
7
8
22
24
2^
2 ^
27
2g
7^. P1aiτltit^f ^eιι lle^ ι ^ i^i^ ιi l ^ ^t ι-í π r ιté; lι rι iυ by r^ferc;nct^, ^ach ^u2de^^trti
ι ^ e^^ut^ υι^ c^^>utaint^ iτ ^ara^ ι^aP11s1 íh^^u^ ^ }1 l-1, ^^ lι lu; τ^^^^, of the ιυ ^ ^^^^l^ ι í^ t as
th^^u^h ^^t fort[ ^^t le^^th.
76. As described above,l^F`PA and dcp entered into the valid, bindingAwards Agreement ín 1987, as amended in 1989 and 1993, that expïres ïn January
2011.
77. Plaintiff has fully performed all obligations required of ít under the
Awards Agreement, except for those obligations waived, excused or prevented by
dcp.78. Defendants have materially breached the provisions of the Awards
Agreement by, among other things:
a) pursuing agreements to produce, create, or exploit digital ínternet
streams of the Awards show, ancillary shows, promotional
campaigns surrounding the Awards show, and sponsorship
campaigns, and by otherwise trading on the Golden GlobeAwards without HFPA' ^ knowledge and consent, in violation of,
inter alia, the limited grant of rights to dcp under Section 1 of the
1987 Awards Agreement ^whích includes only the right to
produce a live television broadcast of, and to produce on tape or
film, the Golden Globe Awards, and to exploit such recorded
television broadcast, tape, ar film productions), and the
requirement that dcp not interfere with HFPA' ^ rights pursuant to
Section 18 of the 1987 Awards Agreement;
b) unilaterally attempting to sell rights to the Golden Globe Awards
show that ít did not own, without HFPA's knowledge or consent;
23 CCl1^iPLι1iNT
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 25/68
1
6
7
$
c^ enc^u>>b^rin«>^ tran^t^^-r^^^^1-1FP.λ s copy ^ ^i^.^l1tτι tι ^ ι ^t^ ín the
1990, 1^^3, 199. aid 1909 Golden Gobe ^^ti^ards ^^ithout
HFPA's kτ^^ ι^l ι íl ^7c ^r t'i)11ti^^1^:
d) fai7i^^^ to cause HFPA to be listed as a proper cols}^^-^^^ht ^laima^t
and c^^^-owner of the 1 990, 1 993, 1998, and 1999 Golden Glvbe
Awards, as required by Section 7 of the 19 $ 7 Awards
Agreement;
e} entering into at leastone sponsorship agreement (with a
corporate third party). without HFPA's knowledge or consent and
thereafter failing to properly account for HFPA with written
documentation thereof, in violation of, inter alla, Section 1 of theAwards Agreement's limited grant of rights, and Section 3's
requirement that dcp account to HFPA for all profits;
taking impermissible deductions of expenses as production costs
in violation of, inter alía, Section ^ of the 19$7 Award
Agreement's requirement for accounting to ^^[FPA;
improperly apportioning licensing fees when selling the Awardsshow as part of a "package" with dcp's other, less popular, shows
in violation of, inter alfa, Section 3 of the 19$7 Award
Agreement's requirement for accounting to HFPA; and
?1
2?
23
^4
^^
^6
27
h} failing to disclose and pay the full compensation owed to HFPA
by virtue of any licenses granted to Six Flags or any other
entities, in violation of, inter alfa, Section 3 of the 19$ 7 Award
Agreement requirement that dcp account to HFPA for all profits.
^9. On information and belief, Red Zone Capital was aware of dcp's
actions, and dcp was acting at Red Zone Capital's direction and under its control.
24 co ^ pτ,^ττvr
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 26/68
80. tλ s a cíirect and prt^xí^ »at ι re,ult υ f thu 1^^are«uin^and other br^ ι ch^s af
the Awards Agr ι crυ tnt, Plaintíff ha^ h ^ CU da^ ^a^^edin a π aτl^πι u^t to be d ι tcι τ11ïτ1ed
at ^ ^^ ι1.
FIFTH CL^I^I Fi}R RELIEF
^Declarator}^ Relief j
Plaintiff realleges and incorporate herein by reference, each. and every
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
allegation contained ín paragraphs 1 through 80, inclusive, of the complaint as
though set forth at length.
82. An actual controversy has arisen, and now exists, between Plaintiff
and Defendants concerning their respective rights and duties under the Awards
Agreement. HFPA contends:a) dcp had no right to enter into a broadcast license agreement with
NBC (or any other broadcaster} for the right to telecast the
Golden Globe Awards show for any years after 2011, without
HFPA's express knowledge and consent. Therefore, dcp's
agreement with NBC, executed on October 29, 2010, purporting
to license the right to telecast the 2012 through 2018 GoldenGlobes Awards shows is invalid and ineffective.
b) dcp's exercise ín Qctober 201.0 of purported options to extend its
agreement with HFPA beyond 2011 was not valid or effective.
HFPA did not grant dcp such options, and dcp never bargained
for such options. T© the extent that such options existed, they
were revocable based on lack of additional consideration and
were revoked by HFPA on February ^, 2010-prior to dcp
attempting to exercise them ar even attempt to provide any
cons^deratïon to merit them.. Moreover, after NFPA made clear
that no options existed for dcp to exercise, dcp agreed to enter
into negotiations aver a new agreement with HFPA.
25 C014iPLAINT
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 27/68
2
3
5^
7
8
27
c) 1^h^ 1 ^ ^)3 ^^nten^l^^^nt does nut hcrmït dcp to e^te^^^,i,anew,
,uh^ti^^t^. ^^^- n^^^^^^f`v the broudca>t lreensc a«^cc ment wïth NBA
tizithu^t HFP:^'^ prior ^:nu^^Cec^^^C and ap^r^^^aL
d} Thy A^^ard> ^« ε t.cment-ïncl ιιd ^ n« ^ ^ithι^ ut limít; ι ti^^ n. t}1^ fair>t
paragraph l^ S^^aïon 1 of the 191 ^^ti^^ardigreen^ent--dc7^s
not grant dcp the right to produce, create, or exploït dïgital
ïntemet streams of the Awards show, ancïllary shows,
promotional campaïgns surrounding the Awards show, and
sponsorshïp campaïgns.
e) The Pre-Show Agreement has expired, and has no further forc
and effect.83. Based on statements made by dcp's representatïves, and on dcp's
actïons as described above, HFPA is ïnformed and believes , and based thereonalleges, that dcp dïsputes these contentíons and contends to the contrary.
84. HFPA desires a judícíal determination of its and dcp's respective
rights and duties under the Awards Agreement, a judícíal determinatïonparties' rights and dutïes under the Pre-Show Agreem ent, and a declaraHF^'A's contentíons, as set forth above, are correct.
85. Such a judícíal declaration ïs necessary and appropriate at th
under the circumstances in order to set at rest the respective rights and oof the partïes and to avoïd ^ multïplïcïty of actions. At present , the parties cannotagree on their respectïve rights and duties, creating a fïnaneïal burden a
uncertaïnty regarding future Golden Globe Awards shows.
Z^? CO ^ ^ØLλ TNT
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 28/68
SIXTH CL:1I^I F©R RLI,IEF
^.^ct^o^ ^^r a^^ Accou^tín^ )
$^. PJai^t^i^t rc^^11^<_^^; and íncorporat^ (^^^-ti^ b^^ rc'te^^^^^, ^a^
;_1^ ^^.^^ ιtτt ιι cυι itaiι^ed inp ειra^^ral^ l^s 1 th^^ u^ }ι 55, ^ τ clιι ^í^^c>, of the cc>^ ^p]a^ it as
t11ci^^^h ^ι't f`çi^^t^ 4^t le^^th.
$7. Under the Awards Agreement, HFPA ís entítled to SO;^ of the net
profits from the exploitation of the Awards show, ^^ defined under termagreement. Under Section 3 of the Awards Agreement , dcp has a contractual duto account to HFPA with respect to HhPA's share of net profits on a quarterlybasis, and HFPA ís entitled to audit the information underlying those accounting
statements.$$. HFPA ís also entítled to an accounting of revenue generated by each of
the Golden Globe Awards shows based on its status as a copyright co-owner ïn all
Award shows and Pre-Shows produced with dcp.$9. Defendants have taken impermissible deductions of expenses as
productían costs in violation of the Awards Agreement to HFPA's material
detriment.Defendants have also failed to properly account for the revenue from least one sponsorship agreement, which was entered into without HFPA's
knowledge or consent, ín violation of the Awards Agreement . HFPA also is
informed and belïeves that Defendants failed to properly account for, among oththings: additional foreign revenue generated through exploitation of Golden Globe
Awards shows, revenue generated (and improperly apportioned) by bunto Awards shows in license agreements with Defendants ' other, less popular,shows ; and benefits ït derived, and that were derived, by its affiliated and parentítïes, through licensing, transferring or otherwise encum bering rights to
Golden Globes Award shows. (Jn information and belief. Defendants are also
continuing to p^^rsue ancillary agreements that trade on the Golden Glob
show, without HFPA's knowledge and consent.
27 co ^^ LAιι^^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 29/68
1^ 90. Ú ^ iτlt^o^ma^ on ^
ι ^ ιl h^1^^(^. Rιι í L ι ^,ι1 C ιpital wa^ a^ ι^a^ ^ ι^Í dcp's
actions , and dc }^ t^^a^ actín^^ at Rt^1 Lπυι ^apítal's ιíi ^ ιι ti^^rι ι ^ ιí ιιπ der τts ιυυ t ^ π i.
91. HFP:^ ^^ :^luzst^ a^^ ^^^í^^ f^r^^n tñc; Court cπι n1^ ^11iπ « ^icp to ^^^:^c^u^t
u^dc^ Gt^^P for all ^lp^^^^s, c^>>ts. re^^^n^^^_ ad^^an^c^, and ru^^alti^s relating to the
dïst^-íb^^^^^1, ^^^le, r^lι a^e, ^íisplt^}, broadct^sti^ig, a^l^í liccu^i^^^ ^ uf tl^e Golden Globe
Awards show, related pre- and post-shows, and any other sources of revenue related
to the Golden Globe Awards.
SEVENTH CLAIM F^?R RELIEF
(Breach of the Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair I ?ealing}
92. Plaintiff realleges and incorporates herein by reference, each and ev
allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 91, inclusive, of the complaint asthough set forth at length.
93. As described above, HFPA and dcp entered into a valid, bindingagreement in 1987, as amended in 1989 and 1993.
94. Pursuant to the covenant of goad faith and fair dealing attendparties' agreement, dcp was required to act in good faith ín the performance of itsobligations,
to deal fairly with HFPA, and to refrain from any acts or omissiowould frustrate the purpose of the agreement or deny HFPA the benefitagreement, including HFPA's right and interest ín maximizing revenue generatedthrough licensing broadcast rights for the Golden Globe Awards show.
95. Defendants knowingly and willfully breached the covenant of good
faith and fair dealing by, among other things, faïling to take reasonable steps tomaximize the license fee for the Golden Globe Awards show . Qn information anbelief, dcp dïd not solïcit license offers from any networks other than NBC, did not
consult experts regarding the market value of the license, and did not take other
reasonable steps to determïne and ensure that NBC's proposed terms for licensing
the broadcast rights for the Golden Globe Awards show were above, at, or even
near market rates for such rights.
? 8 e.c^^ pτ.^τ^ τ^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 30/68
5^
7
^
24
25
^ ^
27
28
t)E^. On i^t^ormat^^^n ^u1d [i^Íi^Í, thi 1^ι ^ π tiation between dcp anel ABC ^l^^ ιs
n^c^^ar^l^- ^rn»prun^^^d i^ccat^s^ it t^c'lic^ ^^i ít ^^^^^ld ^^h^ ^^uara^tee itself
^^,nt^^
ιι ^cl ^ ^^^ht^ and íntι rt,t^ i τ t1^e C^o1^^ ιπ Glvliz ^11^^arci^ ,how bÿ enterí ι^^ ^ntπ an
t^t^nsï«n. ^^'n^^^aL, substitutí^^^^ ^r modification ofth^ :'Oß1 NBCfdcp Agreement,
and as a r^^ult ^i<p. Biled to talc r^asonaL^le steps to^^^a^ds asà^^s^^^g the fair market
value ^f the rights to br^ad^ ^^st the Golden Gybes Award show; acted to benefit
itself to the detriment of HFPA by seeking only t^ explore a license agreement with
NBC; and expressly misled ^IFPA into believing that it was not engaging in
negotiations over the broadcast rights with any broadcast networks. Moreover, on
information and belief, dcp conducted an abbreviated, hurried negotíati^n with
NBC in order to quickly secure a deal.
97. On information and belief, Defendants have further breached the
implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing by, among other things, more
generally falsely representing its rights with respect to the Golden Globe Awards
show, and ancillary pre- and post-shows. This includes dep's false representation
that ít has the right to enter into a license agreement covering Award shows after
2Oll and that it has the exclusive right to license the digital rights for the 2ßl lAward show.
98. On information and belief, Red Zone Capital. was aware of dep's
actions, and dcp was acting at Red Zone Capital's direction and under its control.
99. As a direct and proximate result of Defendants' breaches of the
implied covenant of good faith and fair dewing, ^-IFPA has suffered substantial
damage in the form of being materially comprised in any efforts to actually and
effectively license the rights far those same Awards shows. And ín the event that
the Court were to determine that dcp'^ 2ß1O agreement with NBC is valid, as a
direct and proximate result ©f Defendants' breaches of the implied covenant of
good faith and fair dewing, HFPA has been substantially damaged by dep's
acceptance of abelow-market license fee from NBC. HFPA's ability to fully and
29 co ^ pτ:aττv^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 31/68
2
7
8
9
10
23
24^ ^ ^
2 ^
^7
^ g
f:^í^'l^^^l^lt^^t ity ^^^^^^I^ts hay been l^^^thc'^- ^c^n^prc?^^^^^^1 a^ ^ ^c^n^^^l^^i^
fate ^tat^^n^^lt, ah^^ut its ^^^°ne^-^h^1^ ^^r ^^^tr^l of ri^^l^^. HFPA «-i11 ^>tahli^h the
^^aCt am^u^t ^^f ^^s ^lama^res at trial. L^^t thc^^ ^^re in the n^illi^^^ ^ftíulla^> a^^uall^.
EIGI3TH CLAIM FOR R^LiEF
(Breach of Fíducí^^ry Duty)
l0Ø. Plaintiff realleges and incorporate herein by reference, each and every
allegation c^ntaíned ín paragraphs 1 through 99, inclusive, of the complaint as
though set forth at length.
101. As described above, HFPA and dcp entered ïnto a valid, bïndíng
agreement ín 1987, as amended ín 1989 and 1993. Pursuant to the agreement,
HFPA entrusted dcp to properly register and maïntain the copyrights for thetelevision broadcasts of the Golden Globe Awards shows, and to use HFPA's
trademarks and intellectual property only to promote or advertïse the Awards
televïsion productions. Consequently, HFPA relied on dcp not to improperly
exploit these rights.
102. The trust and confidence HFPA placed ín dcp, with regard to its.
intellectual property rights, created a fïducïary relationship under which dcp owed a
fiduciary duty to HFPA.
103. Pursuant to this fiduciary duty, dcp was required to deal faïrly with
HFPA and to refrain from committing any acts or omissions that would
eompromïse HFPA's intellectual property rights and ïnterests in the Golden Globes.
104. On information and belief, Defendants have breached their fiduciary
duty through dcp falsely representing its rights with respect to the Golden Globe
Awards show, ancïllary pre- and post-shows, and improperly bundling rights to the
Award shows with dcp's ether, less popular broadcasts. Also among the breaches
are dcp's false representation to NBC that it had the rïght to enter into a television
broadcast license agreement covering Award shows after ?011, and its false
30 coι ^Laτ^ τ^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 32/68
4
5
6
7
$
21
23
24
25
2^
27
28
r^^p^'e^entat^^^n^teat ít 11aá th^ e.^^=1^>^^^ ^ ^^ ,^ht t« 1ic^n>e t}^^ ci^ ^^ital ri^rht^ assπι iated
w1ä1 d1c' ^f) l'_ 1 ,i^^^a ^ CÌ ^}1Π ^^^,
I^^. C}n i^^t^^^^mat^^^^ anti he(ief, Red ^u^le Capital ^^ as a^^are of dcp's
actï^nl, ^^nd dcp ^^a5 actín^^ at Red Zane Capeal's dírecti^^n and under its control.
10^. As a d^^ct amid proxïmate ^^su1t ^f dcp's br^a^h^:s cif fiduciary duties,
1^FPA has suffered substantial damage in the fcum of being materially comprised in
any subsequent efforts to actually and effectively license the rights for those same
award shows, pre- and post- shows, and ancillary rights. Among other things,
HFPA has been substantially damaged by dcp's acceptance of below-market license
fees from NBC. HFPA will establish the exact amount of its damages at trial, but
are in the millions of dollars annually.NINTH CL^I1^I FQR RELIEF
(Unfair Competition Under Cal . Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200 and California
Common Law)
10^. Plaintiff realleges and incorporate herein by reference, each and every
allegation contained ín paragraphs 1 through 106, inclusive, of the complaint as
though set forth at length.
108. Defendants' unauthorized use of HFPA's trademarks and service
marks, and its related misrepresentations about controlling HFPA's intellectual
property, constitute unfair, unlawful, and fraudulent business acts, prohibited by the
California Business and Professions Code Sections § 17200 et seq. and by the
common law of California.
109, Defendants' unfair, unlawful, and fraudulent acts are more specifically
alleged above, belt include dcp's representatíóns to and agreement with NBC for the
period commencing ín 2012, dcp's purpol-ted empowerment of NBC to exploit
I^FPA's Golden Globe-related intellectual proper^y, and on information and belief,
dcp's misrepresentations to other third parties ^íncludíng Facebook}. By these acts,
among others, dcp has violated the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. §§ 1114, 1125(x), and
^ 1 CoØLAINT
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 33/68
h ιs ι un ιl^ïtt^d ι uτlawful, ιιττia ^^ a ι^d fratιclultnth ιι ^í^ t^^ u^t^ ^.ττ viola ^ π ^ ι^
f^
C ^ 1ít^^τ^ a Bu^ ^ ιlι ^s a ^ d P^ π fι ^siπ ^ s Code S«ti υ n^ 172Q^}c^t sec^. dcp's acts also
cun5ti ^ ιt^ ^^ ilι ir ιι ^ιυ h^ti ^ π ^ ín violation ^>f Ca1if«rnia cc^τl^τnπ ^ 1aw.
D^t^eneia^ts"' misc^^du^t has already eauseci and. ^^íll^^^ti^^^^ t^^ cau
5
b
7
8
9
22
^4
25
2^
27
28
confi^sio^, ^lì^t^^^^, a^ d deception. Defendants acted willfully with the í^tent to
trade upon the goodwill and reputatí^n ^f GIFPA and the Golden Globe show, and with the intent to cause confusïon, to cause mistake , or to deceive.
Qn information and belief, Red Zone Capital was aware of dcp's
actions, and dep was acting at Red Zone Capital's direction and under its control.
112. Defendants' commission of unfaír competítíon, unlawful business acts,
and unfair business acts have caused damage and irreparable injury to HFPA in anamount to be determïned at trial, and such acts wí11 result in further damage and
irreparable injury to HFPA if Defendants are not restrained by this Court. All
profits generated by dep through its acts of unfaír competítíon should also be
ordered disgorged.
TENTH CLAIM Ft) R RELIEF
(Intentional Interference with Prospective Economic Advantage)113. Plaintiff realleges and incorporate herein by reference, each and every
allegation contained in paragraphs 1 through 112, inclusive, of the complaint as
though set forth at length.
114. The Golden Globe Awards shows is one of the most anticipated
broadcasts of the season. In prepare for another successful Awards show, HFPA
and Facebook began conversations regarding the potentïal for a digital initiative to
complement and bolster the Golden Globes Awards show for the Z^l l broadcast.
In exchange for the rïghts to host Galden Globes-related content, Facehook was
going to pay HFPA a license fee and a share of revenue generated.
^ 2 CØ ^ IPI.AINT
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 34/68
5^
7
9
10
11
1.2
27
115, The a« ι^^eιl ι ^ t 1^^^ th ^^c :tf^uu^ ^^uuld hati^ ι ;^^^ ιι ^ ιt ι cl ^ιι h,t^ ι ^ ti ^ l
rc^^^^^c fir ^^FP:^. ,^> ^ucll. 1í ^ PA h^ci ^ ι ^ ^^a^t ιl ι hl ι pruE^ι E^ilit^ ^^f^ 1^ιι t ιι re
^^^^^^^miC ht^^f^it t τ π m this ccu^1<^^^î^ r^lat^^^^^hi^ l^^^tl^ Fac^bt^^k
l l^. On ínformatíon a^^d h^Iicf, dcp he^^a^ ^^g^i^^^ti^g ^1 i ι lτ F^t^'^É^t^^^ in
^rde^ t^ license Golden Globe ^-^ «hts that dcp did not ^í^ Σιtt ιι ll}^ pπ ^sCs.^, and
wrongly represented to Facebe ,ul: th^^t dcp had the exclusive right to grant digital
rights for the 2011 Golden Globs Awards show. dcp did so behind HFPA's back,
and without ïts consent or auth^rízation. As a direct result of dcp conduct,
Facebook cut off communications with HFPA ' s consultants and has since dealt
exclusively with dcp.
117. On ínformatíon and belief, dcp was aware of HFPA's ongoingdiscussions with Facebook . HFPA's consultants and Facebook discussed a meeting
that Facebook had with dcp, and only after that meeting did Facebook cut offcommunications with HFPA.
11$. Defendants' conduct was otherwise wrongfi^l as a false represconstïtuting, among other things, unfair competition under California Business &Professions Code section 17200.
119. On ínformatíon and belief, Red Zone Capital was aware of dcp's
actions, and dcp was acting at Red Zone Capital' ^ direction and under it120. As a direct and proximate result of Defendants' wrongful conduct, ít
disrupted HFPA' ^ economic relationship with Facebook and its ability
a licensing agreement. HFPA has consequently been substantially damaged ín an
amount to be proven at trial.
co^
τ,^τ^^ r
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 35/68
1
5^
9
10
22
24
,L
26
27
28
F.LE^I :N"^H CIJ^I1^ FOR KELTEF
t Reformation}
Pla^nti^t rc:^^llt«t^ t^^í ^^^rh^^^atts h^r^^^ by ref 'r^^^t, each ^^t1^i c^<e
a^1e^^atíιιι cc^^taí^^^í íßl },ara^^raph^ 1 th^^u;^h 1201, inclusive, of the co^^^lai^t as
th^^u^^h ^^ forth- ^^t 1^^ ^^tΣι.
122. dcp claims to be empowered by the 1993 Amendment to extend or
renew the broadcast license with NBC forever, without HFPA's specific consent or
auth^rizatíon. dcp points to the provision that states: "This wí11 confïrm that the
[ 1987 Awards] Agreement is hereby further amended to provide that HFPA grants
to dcp eight (8) addïtional, consecutive, exclusive, and irrevocable options to
acquire the exclusive right to produce a live television broadcast of and to produceon tape ar film the Awards for each of the years 1998 through and including 2005,
and for any extensions, renewals, substitutions or modifications of the NBC
Agreement, and to exploit such productions ín all media through the world in
perpetuity,"
123. Based on its own reading of the words of the 1993 Amendment, and
on statements by dcp representatives in 1993, ^^IFPA understood at the time ofcontracting (and still understands} that provision to merely anticipate the possibility
of HFPA extending further options to dcp to remain involved in the Golden Globe
Awards show ín the event that the NBC broadcast license is extended, renewed,
substituted, or modified with NFPA's approval. Neither the language of the 1993
Amendment, nor any other operative document executed by both parties, affords
dcp the right to unïlaterally enter into a license agreement with NBC, without
HFPA' ^ knowledge and approval, in order to trïgger further contractual options for
dcp under the Awards Agreement.
124. ^-lε^ weve^, to the extent that the Court were to ínte^pret the 1993
Amendment to empower dcp to extend, renew, substitute, or modify an existing
broadcast license with NBC, without HPPA's knowledge and authorization, then
34 cc^^ p^ ,aτιv^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 36/68
4
^^f^^rma^ ^^^^ t^f^ the 1993 Am^»cl^^^:^lt t« aid tht ^c^^^c^s `°e^t^r^d ^^Itu ^^^th HFl':^'s
,^phr^»=ai^^ ï^ ne^^^ssar^^ ^nd }^rope- c^^^ one ^^^ m^^^ ^^f tl^e t^π llu^ciιι ^r „ι υι ^ lcí^:
a) Thy ah^euc^ ^f thc: hhra^^ "^:^tered ^^t^ ^ti^ith H1^PA's aphruti^ ιl_..
att^^- t11^ ^^,rd "Agreement" on the ninth i^u^ of the third
par^^^rt^phof the 1993 Amendment ïs a result of a ^^ut^^al
mistake, and ít ïs contrary to the partïes' ïntent to ïnterpret the
1993 Amendment as only permïttïng dcp to extend, renew,
substitute, or modify an existing broadcast lïcense with NBC
with -1FPA's specific approval and authorïzation. To grant dcpthe abïlïty to license HFPA's intellectual property without any
authorization from HFPA would reverse the parties' baassumptions about the effect of the 1993 Amendment, and
would have a material effect on the partïes' agreed-uponexchange.
b) dcp knew HFPA dïd not intend to waïve all future approvalrights of a proposed extension, renewal, substitution or
modïfïcatíon of the license of its intellectual property , and dcpdid not express to HpPA its understanding that the 1993amendment should or could be interpreted ín that manntime of contracting. To the extent that dcp knew or believed atthe time of contracting that the 1993 amendment would allow
dcp to extend, renew, substitute, or modify an existïng broadcalicense wïth NBC without HPFA's specïfïc approval and
authorization, the 1.993 Amendment should be reformeit does not accurately reflect HFPA's ïntent by reason of
NPPA' ^ unïlateral mistake coupled wïth fraudulent or
inequitable conduct by dcp ïn that ít was or sho^^ld havaware of HFPA's mïstake.
35 co ^ PLaι^^ ^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 37/68
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 38/68
2
5
6
7
8
9
5. For a pre^ímin^u-}'^r^dp^^^^a^^nt ánJ^l^fiun ^^^^^^^^t D^t^u^ia^t
ell^oíning thetll 1^1C^ ll^ll' 1^t^^^:^^5,A^c;I^^s, ^illhl( ?^c'E'S, ^^^ClI^c'1^RSc^lltt^i^^^^S ^1C}m
tτsin^rHFPA's t ^^ ιd ιι lla ι^h^ aτ^^1 se^ ^°^ ι t ^ ^a^ h, tu τ aτt^ p ιιτ-pυ s ^ ^π thtrt }^aιτ tlιe
p^^^^^^tïon, advertúing, ^^^^1 broadcastof the 2U11 Goldin Globs ^`^^^^ards show;b. A dc^laration that ^-IFPA ís a co-owner of all rights, title, and ïntere
ín the copyrights to the 1990 , 1993, 1998, and 19 θ 9 Golden Globe Awards, and th
2003, 2004 , 2005, 2005, 2Oû7 and 2009 Pre-Shows;
7. For exemplary and punitive damages;
8. For costs of suit herein incurred;
9. For reasonable attorneys' fees in accordance with Section 19 of the
1987 Awards Agreement and the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1117, and the Copyright
Act, 17 U.S.C. § 50 5;
10. For all allowable interest an any monetary award to FIFPA at the legal
rate;
11. For any other orders necessary to accomplish complete justice between
the parties; and
12. For such other and further relief as this Court may deem just andproper.
Dated: November 17, 2010 LINDA J. SMITHMARVIN S. PUTNAMAMY R. LUCASC^'MELVENY & MYERS LLP
By^ _^-^L1^`^^^r^^^J.Sí1r1ITN
Attornε ys ^1or PlaintíffHollywood Fc ^ reïgn Press Assocíatíon
37 co^^
za ιτv^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 39/68
D E ^tiA?^^ ^f1R JL1RY TRIAL
Purs ιι ant ^o Rul^ 3^(Eij ^ ,F th^ F ιι ^cral Ru1es of ^íví1 Proc ιι h ι^ t^, HFPA 1ι ^ ^ ι b
^ t7^and5 a trial by jury for ^ ιt1 ^, ιι ^s trialiÍe to a j ^ -^^.
7
8
Dated: November 17, 2010LINDA J. 5:^^^TNHAKVIN S. PUTNAMAMY R. LUCASO' MELVENY & MYERS LLP
LINDÁ'7. SMITHAttorneys for PlaintiffHollywood Foreign Press Association
By_
3 8eoι
^^
L τN^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 40/68
Exhibit A
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 41/68
C^ I. τ Ø 1
Prï+^r Σ:^.^. ^1s.: 1{)t1, 1O ^ a llcl t^^
^nifed ^t^ ι te^ ^'a#e ^ ι t ^n:d Tra^^e^r^ ^ rk C)f'i^c+ ι
ι ? l ^ ^ R Y . [ λ ., λ C. ^^ ^
^ 1 ^ ^
PlZ1tiC'1PAL REf^15 "I^I+;E2
^. ^ ^}^ , Ì . ^F. ι ^ ^u^. ^ {^^E
HflLLYWdOi λ FßRT=iGI^
PId Σ_.5S AS5OC2ATtd λ !{CØL.iFdC^ NlA CC7RPdIØ" ΓτdN )
292 S43l,λ ^ H LA C!E?3 τ3Cτ A [^ LVî3., 5L1I"!`i^ ^ !6BEVERLY 1-iILLS, Cfi. gCï2! !.
FQ τ^: I;NTïüRTAINP ωtENT IN T τ IE NATUItE dF" ANA^ART λ GEREN#dNY PC ΣOMC}TINt3 FJiC"ELLENCEIN 7 ' t IE FIEI. .U dF PC7P ULAR E T ^ 'TERT'A!I*!lvIENTrPRC7l^ #Ø"^ CNC, E7 ^ CF..L.I..ENCL? τ ^ ! THE FIELD C lP PtlP-ETLÄR EN ^ ERTAINMENT TlfRdt3G τi TFIEISSUAN{'E AND t'EtESENTATIßN ^ i^ AWA τt Σ }5; Eλ!-^ ERTAlNMENT SEItVICES, NAI ^ ELY, PïZdVI τ7ING
Re^,. tiu, 2,-i2^,7() 3I2egí ^ e ^^
τλ 3 ^^^ . 3Q, 2H Π !
1λlF^
7^
MATI{7t^i II^ Ti- τE FlELD OF ^
^I^
TF.RTAIN-hiENT ANI7 INI:3U5TRIPS üTA ^'ELE^ ι'[5 τdI ^ AìYI7V ! A r λ GLC3ßAL Cdl ^ MU N τCØTld λ lS λ2 ETWØRI^;PItC7l7I}C'FIC}N dF 7E I ,EVlSIfJN 5Hd4^λS ANI7CAI3LE ï Σ LE^ λ#S τdT^í C*t2CλGRAñIíS, # λ3 C L A S S 4 í{IJ.S, CLS. l ^^ , ^^ 1 Ø λ3Ia lt37j,
FIRST L7$E Ø - ! 9 4 3 ; IN C ü ^ ΛME τt C E 0 - ^ -t 943.
SER. Tξ^ d. 75--749,b2£i, 1'ILI:U 8 - τ
^ -I99S.
TRICIA St )NNEI ^ Π RN, EXAIvIiN^^ !{'^ ATTdRNEX
Exhibit A^9
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 42/68
lut. Cτ.: τ ^
Prí π r 1'.S. ^is..° 2, ^, 2^, ^3, ^ ^ , 3T, ^8 ancí ^{t
Un íted Siates Σ ate τι t a^ ι d Tradem ark Of ' t ice τ^
^^;. ^ ι ,.^
,^^^
?,^^
7Rc^íste ^ ed Jxu . 2 ^ Σ 2ΠΠ !
^ ^^ :^,^ ε1τ ,^a^Ø τ c ι^^, ^ ^ ε ^ τs ^ ^ τ.
Gt3L ^ .
ii^
LLYWC^
fλI^ P^
REIC*N PRESS ASSC}CiA^
ifλN(GALIPOR2^tL4 COR Ý {7RA ^ i^ ?J)zsa sc ^^ ^ ii* ι a ci ^ rr^^ ca ^ ^V ^^ ., s ι ir r ε ^^ sBEVERLY i3^ l,LS, CA ^ aa ι ]
r^ ^ τjcι ^ ε
THi: FiEL^
S {JF^
i{E Σλ r}^
Ci^^
A^
λ^ihlEλ^^
í3'+'I7L15'T"Σ€YAN ^ ? J ^ C}btNAi,fSM, tN CLA SS !6 (CI.S. Ci.S. 2, 5,a ^ , z ^ , a^^ , ^ τ , ^^ ai, τ^ T so}.
i ιι ^ S'r CISE 4-Ø-i 94 ^ ; ^ N C ü λAMEitCE ï}-CJ--t ü ^^ .
ε ^ R^ ^Riτ^^ tt ι MA'i^ ER, r ^ A^^ LY, Bo ^^ S,^ c^^ ιξ.Lε ^ s, ra ^ p^ t,>4^ s, Cc^^^ ε S, m^^ ε RViEw^^ ai ^ sC Ø ^ s A ^^ τ^ ^ z^ ε o ^^ A^ τ^ rιAιι FLYERS iitτ
SER.κ Ø. τs-τ^Ø,^^^ a, ^✓
^ LTú?^^ --it λ--ιs^^^ .
^ i^ iciA s^rτr^ ε ^ a ε^^
^^ , ε xa ^ irτrιv^ A7T ^ RNEY
Exhibit A4Q
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 43/68
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 44/68
In^. Ci^. ^ :^.`, Σ^ tηd 4^
I't^^c,rG.S. C1s.:I1^
Γ), 1O1,^ z ^ nd
i^e;^. ^ π. ?,42 î,3^3
[;τι itecτ. ^tate^ Ya#ent anel Tratíet ιτ ark Úftic^ R^
; ι,ε ^^^^
ι€ T-^^
.SΣ?R1^TCΣ ^ ^ι,^^^ ι,;
^* τ*^^c^^^^.^ ι.c τ ^rFR
HØLLYWOt}D F ΣJRFiΓ N PRES5 AS(s^ ALiPORNiA C{ ^ RPURATiCIN}
^ ^^^ sau ^ H LA Γ€ EλtEGA^ LVD,
SUiTE ^ €6E31;^^ ERLY HiLLS, t^A ^3C ^ 211
;,+^? í
oc^
ø^ iι^ N s€^t
^
NSC^ RS TQ AFFiLiATE THEiR G^?C1DS AN Σ7
Ft>R; ARRAN Γr1N.r AND Cf)NDU^T`i1v'G TRADGSHC ^ W EXHtt3ïTtE7 λ t5 1 ^ I Ti{E FiELDS t ^ F Pt3PULAREN`i`]'RTAiNME λλT AP;D 1{7^ 7T?ti^^Ll^ `^t; PRØ-MC}TïNf ^ TRE SAL1ti ClF G(3ßt:7S AN Γ) S^ RViC6SΩ F O^T^?FR4 T%^ RptT ι , i-i ` ΣHF PRf{1'λ€ ^ :A"Π tJ Γ! AND^ 7,^5E λΩ ^;^lTii^`d Γ}P P^ 1'• "ς'F ^^ ".i ^ TΓ RIι1 L5, t ^
Σ^ '1 ^ Γ^`^ T Σ'. Π Γ 'F?^>^^1Ω ^T't>NΛ t ',1 λ ^í^^ .`F1A1 SΛ F (lT,íí^FLS,^ι2+f^ +^' ' ΠΓSSFSt:^ λ TΓ^ ì^' tì^ λΠ YFR' ^ ìS?NG P ς1[ζ{Yi'tΠ: R$ " ^
µ UJι ι ^}1? 1^l`_Li' 'I^ÍιJN ! ' ^ tO^ ι l ^ Aλ ^-;trtiCí.^ 4Π T^Π 'd t ' ^ "^^^', ξ;4, λ h^ì{^ ιí Cìf Π T.iΛ L ^ O11λ9 t7.λ_1
^
^,?7^i*iιλ ^^ t^^
^^^
4^
^^^^
^ P:Zf1?,4Π ^^^1`.G ^[!íΓ _Γ, t ιι ;)[^5^ '^p _ R η '1,-t S í`I' (> ^ i^?P,.'_; ξ >γ ε \RK;1^:Cì ^ ^;Ù 1'C?R
SERViCES WiT Σi AN AWARDS ^ 'R(? ε^ RAM Wi ^ ICiT
r^CKNC3WLEDGES THE PRC?GRESS ANt? ACH[EVR-1YtENTOF PROi'ESSiONAL S IN 7FiE FiEi.f S OFPCλPULAR EN'ï'ER ^ "AiN€4tEλ TT AND 1C} Σ7RNALiSt ^ 1;PE7i3i.1CRELATïC λλiS; PR{?ViDiNCτ ^"RAT)E Tt*iFØR-MAT ΣΩN A N D Γ π NSULTAT € ClN iN Ct7Nt^iEC Υ3ΠNTHEREWITH, € N C:Lr1S5 35 {1_7.5. CL,S. tE ^
λ, t(?1 AN Σi€ ^ 2).
^ tRST ^ ι g Q-- ι^-- € 94á; I λ^ CO ε1ríM ^ ^CE 0--^ } -^^ dA ^
i^^ l Γi: (^.Γ1TF:Tt7^;1i?:b1t''+T P^ `i"I7Γ "^A`^^ '12T?ς Y•,^ ANAWAkb t_'F[^ Σ!, tΓ^NY ï'R[7R1t^T€ ^^G f'ïC E^^ λ ^iλ ^ ' Σ11 ^- Γ{F F € ^ D OP ι^
^ 1t'1_^ L ? ^ ^ λ ^fi- ^ T λ #λ äΓι1Γ,'^^T:PR^ ?^µ T ^ N<.; ^ ^\t ^ ?LL ^^:Γ t^1: 1`. Γ ^ Σ P ^ 1.-[? {)€^ P Π;^_t'`l λ R Γ_ +[^^:Γ^ !"π,^λι
^ ,τ t3T^ïÌ' It1RQT!CiH CHE}SiU λ . t'C^. ,+.^í^ FF?F^1'`í` ^ ιL1€U ^ ^' Π i" A,bVA1tL ^ $, TPo^^1,^`,^^; 4# ^U.S_ Γ T 5. t ^%!l,1©1 Ai+^ D € ^7^.
PTRST ^ SE η -0^- € Ød; tN ^ £lt ^ il^ iERC ^ ØØ-iØ44.
EXhÍ^λÍt ^
42
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 45/68
Ittt#.Cis.; ^^ a τι ti 41
F τ-ι τιr L'^,^.^is.: 1(} Π , 1 f)1. }(}`^ τττιcl 1t^^1^ e^;. 1 ιΠ . ^,^ ^ ^?^^Ì^t^
^.,.^i1ΣÍ^t^ ^tá^^eS ^^1^^t"1i ^1Ii^ ^^^C^ l .'^ ìi ^
ï^ ^fÍ1e^ τ2ι: ^ ι ^Ee^e υ^ ^υ , τ 3, 2ant
SEE7.^'^^E ^#.1RKYRiN(^:iPAL R^.G1ä" ^ I^.K
FtCλLLYWt}CλΣ7 Fε3 REI ιCN PRESS ASSOCEAT1dt*7ξCA L ΣPOR λ EtA CORPClRAT1(JNI
292 SOUTN LA C1EN8GA 13LV^
ι ., 5 U1TE 31^rSt ✓VECZ[ ^ ΣiI ^ LS, CA 9 Π21 t
FOR: ARRA λ E^ x{NC ANt] C^GIN Σ7LICT ΣNG TRAE7E.SHCnW E7fHIØtTIdE ^ S lA,i THfü FtELDS ()F P α flt1LARCλ7TCRTAF?íMENT At^ìC? 3ti(1i^ λ#AL1ihi, PitC ^ -E^ it?TtNC ^ TFi ^ SA1.,F α F GQC3L ^ 5 A{VI7 SERV ΣCESd1~ OTHERS TFiRC λïJGH THE Σ'REPARAT1 α EV A λ1DCt1SSFM1 λ1 Ø`^ 1Oλ ^ dF PK11ti ' ^
ΣFΠ MATERtALS, 1 ^ 'dPRd1 ^ TFD Ptt α M α T`IC?λ iAE; MA" ^ ERIALS ÇiF 4TWR ^ {5,AN1J F ^ ït 1'HE Σ 1 sSØ(^iEIvA'E`lt}N α F ,A ^ VE1 8 ^ '1 S1λΣCFC) Σ{ OTt"tEftS Tktt ΣC7?'G ΣF T^ t_(?°ttt^id λ d PRC7 ^ R ^ A{-M1t^;G, Mí ι T1C7N t'EC^^II u. Γ ti, η ^ Γ Λ GLt}BAL C^}t"i-tiaτ ^, ;Tε ,^..^r;^^ r^as ^ ,ε τ ^^`Ø ε>.κ; ^^ ι l*, τ ^^ ' τ^t^sι ^ ^ι^^εεεt;C ^ u Σ) ç ØNEI 51.h^^1^' Γ ,S dF Γ?THF- ^ ti Σ^ 1ε" AR1?;l1^tC -l2 ^(; }'U ^ +_ ^:^C5}?'^τ ε} AFFI Σ.t^^T[^ ^: ^ ςΣ^ (fiΣ ΓΠ ^ ?^^ 5.4 D '^ . 1 ι_ ^ ^ ^ ' , ι 1T Σ1 A^d λ ^` 1_1LL^4 pR ^ ^^,τ .,^.,^,.τ
WFttC:Fi ACKPi(?WLEI^GIñS THE PRf7GRE ^ 5 S A N Σ
ACHIEVEMÉh1T ^ E P R O F E S S t O N A Σ,S t λ# TNR
F1ELï3S Q F P Oτ'ULAR E{^TFFtTttTNMENT ANt?JC)URNALtSM; Pt.E Σ^ l..1C R.BLAT1d λISz PROVt Σl1NG
TRADE, t λ t Σ t3Rt^ lATFdN A?.EC7 CØtd5L7LTATEOhE lNCUTsINF^CT1C3λ ^ TNEI2EW{TtT, EN GLASS 35 {U_5. CL5.({^^^ , tol A ^ ^ ι 1 α z^.
F1RST τ^ s ξ ιι _. n._.1 QS2: 1N C α ^; ^ { ε ^ UE π - π - ι
^ sx ,
Fα R: ENTERTAtNMEt*TT 1N ' ^ H^? í^}ATURE? C}F A λΣAWARt? CFREMi ΣNY' PRdMC?TiNCi EXCF.LLt ^ hlCfvE
^^ { THE FEP Σ.D αΣ ^ P^)PC}LAR HCdT τ^RTP,lNl^1E? ^ `^ ,PR{) λ it)TIt ^ G E^C`E: Σ.1,.F.λ ECC tN T τdE CtE{_Cl ØF Pdt'-ULAE2 E]^ "I'ER7"AtWM ^ NT T1FRdUGti Tl1Et~;^*^+,P^ ^ `^=. AN Σ^ PRFSE?`^1`F`ATEd λ+i C)F A^VARDS, lNc•LASS .1i t^.^,s.OLS. 1{3^, EtiE A ^ ι ^ lo^ ^ ^.
Ftk'r, F ι ^;f^' E7-u . € 952; ti• ι ^ ^^1^1^ {E:R ^ ^^tï ß--4 ^ 1ß52,
`^ '1tE^. E;^^:(`; Π i5 , ' . 7!^ ^ Tl ^ R Γ U λ^ 'C ει4 ^ `-^tAE Σ K Aï`1L7ØdF.^ ε^ =^ -! ^ i`:^)1C^Ai [ (^<^ ι (, ^]kZ
Exhibit A43
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 46/68
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 47/68
^^`t^i'^^^^`iar η . ^ =^ Σ
^
7Ø f
1 7 G3 t
gt^llyw ^^ d Σ Øre í gn P re s s Ass oc i a ú ïon?92 ^ØUt^^ ι L a C i e n e g a B o u l e v a r d3everly :iills, ^alïfornía 9 Γ 211
Re»
^entlØLtØn»
E AWAR^yS"
^ ^;R^ ;l^^i
This letter
^^ lïllServe to confirm the agreement reac
^
edbetween díck clark productí α ns, ínc. ("dcp"} and Hollywood^v ^ eig ^ ^ress Ass α ciatí α ^ ς "riFPA"l relatíng to the Golde ^
^1obe Awards ^ "Awards" ) as follows»
^.. dcp has previously produced Awards prese^ta-tíons in accordance wïth the agreement Øetween ^^PA a ^ dc3cp Øat^d as of ^^a^uary ?, 2983, as revised . ^FPA nowg^a^ts t^ dcp fïve {5} consecutive, exclusïve, irrevocableoptions tv acquire the exclusïve rïghts to produce a livetelevision broadcast f and ko produc^± ^^ tape or film theswards presentations for 2 988, 2989, 199Q, 1991 and 1992,and to exploit such productions ín a21 meäía throughoutthe world ïn perpetuity,
teach respective optïe^n shall be exercised, íf at all, bywritten notïce tc^ ^^PA got later than July 15 of the yearimmedíatel^^ preceding the Awards prese^tatíon wîtháespect to which such ^ptio^ is exercised. if dcp fails^Ø exercise any of these apti^^s hereinabove stated, allop'tío^s, except those previously exercised, shall be nullaid void anc3 of no legal effect, a ^ d the agreement shall^e terminated. ^^IOwever, the sharing agreement between tháparties for previously cØmpleted productions shall remaino^eratíve.
:f dcp has exercised all ^^f its options under thïs agreØ-rtent, dcp and ^i^^'A shall negotiate with respect to the^ro^lucti^ `7n ^^ f su#^seØuez^ t A wards p rese^ ta t ísa^s ïn them anner se t fo r th be lc^w »
Exhibit B44
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 48/68
?:_57WC} α d £o Σ °3.^: ^ . - ^S S . ' ^ . 3 S G ^ ^ d ~ " ^ .0^2}.3r 1987; a^ µ
pe r i c d ^^ f t h í r t^ r ( 3^7 c a _^s ^ he ^ eï^^^ °^'egotíati ^
ς ? ár.,, ,~,^; •^ítk ι r ε
y 1^, 1987
^ . d ε p an^ ^ ^^ ?^ s^. ιa11 neg € ^
v ^ ^1^ . i4 λ Vns i ^ . .. 1 i3L3 ^ 3•g ' ^ ^ ,^ ^ di4W ^ 1
Øroadcast of the 192 Awards presentation, Such^^egatîatíng PerîØd nay be mutually extended fc^r so longas the parties cc^^ti^ue to negotiate ín good faith.?prior to and during thØ ^^Øgotïatíng Period , ^iFPA shallnot discuss with any third party the produ εΡtío^ , salu orlí εΡe^sî^g of any additional Awards p^esentatíons.
c^^me^ee thirty E3ß} days after the dale of fir
y for ared to as
ter^^s ands ^.zbseØuØ^t
ÿ•^^r^s prese ^ tatío ^ s. ^he Negotiati ^ g ?eriod sha11
b. Zf after the Negatíatîng Perî^^d dcp and ñ^PA
shall mot have agreed upon apglícable terms andco^dítio^s with respect to the produ^tian of su εΡhsu't^sequent Awards presentations , HFPA shall be free tooffer such rights to any third party, but ^FPA will notgrant such rights to any third party on terms a^^condítíon^ less fav^^rable thai those εΡontaï^ed în dcp'slast offer to HFPA during said Negotiating Period wítho^tfirst offermg ï^ go^^d faith t^^ εΡo^tract with dcp on suchterms , i^ which event d εΡp shall have a period of five t5}business days to accept su εΡh offer. It îs understoodthat dcp has to meet ^^ly those terms aid εΡo^ditio^s i^such offer whi εΡh relate solely to the production of theAwards presentations and which shall readily be reducibleto a payment of a determinable sum of money. If d εΡpfads to accept such offer , ^iFPA shad bØ frie to offersuch rights to a third party; provided, however, that íneach í^stance ^FPA shall make a similar offer, asaforesaid , to dcp before grantí^g su εΡh rights to others^^^ terms and conditions less favØrable thai those lastoffered by dcp durz .^g said Negotiating Period.NotWit, hSta^dá .ng anythí^g to the Contrary Co^taí^edherei», the foregoing shall be apgli εΡable until such tîrn^as ^i^PA shall have entered into an agreement with a thirdparty pursuant to all of thØ foreg^íng provisions ^^ ^7u1^15, 192, whichever first occurs.
2. Øcp agrees to endeavor i^ good faith to sause the
Awards to be li εΡe^sed for live, sy^di εΡated or network domestîctelØVisîon broad εΡast. lí1 the event a li εΡense for a live
Exhíí^ ít B45
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 49/68
^cp agrees __.^_ ï^ ^: í ll vape_ í t wi^' =. .^ea^. ^^ ï n ^, ^cü £#'Q υ C3^ 2 υ e s ^ ι .. `: ^ ι _ ..r:'.,: _._....^ _. . ^° °_xL1^.GiI: _a ^ _ ^°_3.^.^ f3f _ ^, ^: C^
^^.3t2oil a ^ _ ._^,;`: η ? i ^^ ^.^Ó_. _^ü Øt^reeS t:.j_ : tû pL'$3G"'.__^.t3 ^ t w111co^ ι sïstent ïn Øualit^ ^ wïth ^ ^ ri α r Ø r o d ^ zct io ^ s a ^ ^ _ .^? i 's
profess iona l s^ .a ture a ^ ci suïtable for televisían brcaaàca^^ í ^
th e ^ 7níted 5tates accordíng to árevailing broadcast stanc3rdsf α r cc^^ τ^^ a^abie programs, wïth due r ^ gárd fo r the appr α ^ imate
γ
c4 η
oη
sη
tη
øfς ^
τ^ r^+
α^
á^
uη
^y
t^
η
ïη
α^
^
η
,.ÿ j
^.
i ^
γ
ιz^
n¡^
g} ζ
rec^uj
iy^
rη .
erτe ^ 4s and :i^`?^A.`s creati4te^a^ o n tr α .,3.. s as λ 1 `v i
^
G i ^ t Σ a}^ ^^ e4
^
ι3Lr+ f^rLi Σ e
^. dcp shall gay to ^i^PA sums equal to fifty percentf5fl^l of one hundred percent ^1Q^J^^ of net profits, íf any,derived from the exploitation of dcp`s rights pursuant tc^ this
agreement. lo et profits shall be defined as the balanceremaining after the deduction from grass receipts of thefollowing:
a. Distributïon fees and sales commissionsprovided, howevØr that ^ cp shall not be entïtled t^eceive any distribution fees or sales commissions}:
^ , L3ís t r ï ï au t íon expenses ; and
c. Cost of production, provided however that dcpshall not be entitled to a» overhead fee, whetherpercentage or fiat.
dcp will accc^u^t to ^^'PA with respect to its share of net^^rofíts o^ a quarterly basïs t^egi^^inØ after the firstexploitation of its rights unde εΡ this agreement, dcp agrees touse mest efforts to require çuarterly accountings from itslice^s^^r with interest at twQ^^ve percent {12^? ger annum on allpayments not made by Licensor when due. ^ α th dcp aid Fï^PAshah be entitled to custØmary audit and i^sgection rights.
4, If dcp Øxercises one ^^ m^ εΡe of its options, äcpshall be d eemed to have acquired the rights specified in thisag εΡeeme:^t f subject to the fallowing:
a. The 1 θ 88 b ^ t:adcast wí11 Øe three C3} hours inn^th. Therea^ter, fa ε su τ
^ sequent Awa ε ds presentat:?: PA ^ti11 n ^ tify dcØ n ot l a te ε than Ap ε i l 1 S o f t h e
Exhibit B46
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 50/68
^CC,".' _ ^ _ °' . ?; ° _ ^ 5 . ^ s o c i c . `it3.Øi2
^ ^ ^ ^7" ^p^ ς
^„
s^
Ψι t ^ ^ ^ ^ th^sς ,,,2
^it Ý ^ ^ ' ^ J ^ : ` r * ' ^ .s ^ :i^aL ^^ ?Γ 3 tas tØ S.ife ^^. iYØtrLt
oi ι .^ ° :
^ +εi^ _' Δ . ^ . ^ i ^ ^.+rC3v :35^.
Ønses the Ø ^ ca ^^s t o^: a tw^^ { ^ } hoerr^,WardS ^re^°^ ^3 icon fC^r live nt^^Or^^ :rCíaC^»St: Øy ABC,CHS or ,t^^^ o : t y an y o th e r t e l e^ • i. ^ iØ n ^ ^ - ^ ^ c ^ r k t ^
l ie :Ø ^ se f ee fo r w h i ch ï s equa l to o r exceecs the Øurttine Million Two ^ ? undred Thousand Dollars {^I,^QQ,C?^^{}},then dcg shall pay to ^^aA a sur ετ equal tØ five percent.{5g} of the gross ^etworfc lïeense fee. such sum shall hedeemed to constitute a^ element of the cost of grad^^ctic^nfØr the applicable Awards gresentatiort groductic^n. Inthe event net profits are derived from such graductio^,dcp shall be entitled t^ receive, as an addï^ïonalele^te^t of the cost of production, an amount equal t^ thefive percent {S$} fee paid to ^i^PA out a £ sums whichwould otherwise co^stïtute first net profits, andthereafter ^FPA shall be e^tïtled to its fifty percent{5f3^1 share of remaïning met profits. {In the event dcplicenses the broadcast of a three {3} hour networkpresentation , the lïce^se fee must equal or exceed C7^eMïllïon Eight Hundred ThØUSa^d ^^allars {$ 1,8!1û,QØ0}.3
c. In the event dcp has not recouped t he en^ïrecost ^^f groductio^ far the Awards presentation ín anygiven year , then dcp shall be entitled to recoup any suchdefïcït { sl from fifty percent ^5fl^ } of ^i^PA's fiftypercent { 50^} share of net profits derived fzorn
subse^uent Awards gresentatia^s grod^ced by dcp, ïf any.The other fifty percent {50^) o f ^FPA's share o f netprofits shall be paid to ^FPA. The balance of dcgtssharØ o f net profits s h a d be agplïed toward recougment.
d. The awards presentations shall be scheduled forthe last Saturday in t7a ^ uaryt provided, however, that if^iï ^ PA desires to reschedule any specified d2^ter ït shallfirst consult with dcp in g α o d faith.
5, dcp shall be rØSØonsible far, and shall gay, a11c α sts attríbutable to the gerformance of ít.s televisi α nØroduction oi ^ lígations u ^ der this agreement. E κ cept as
ex^^
ressly pro^^
ided to the contrary i^
thïs agreØment, the costsα f graductí α n for which dcg shall be resgonsible ^ hall
^
ot.
ínclude costs which ΣiFPA wØU1d atherwise have í^
curr ε*d {í.e. ,
Exhibit B47
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 51/68
4^
ι ^+ d L V Y G 3 . .^
t 2 ^ 1 e . .^ i J .^ . ς J^
1^
^ J.^ . Σ 4 i
^
t 3
3^ ^^ ? ,^^ t 1^8^; :^evis ε?d ^ ι 21 y i^, 1^^37
,.^.^ _^.M1^
^
3: '1ÿ^
á^ ^ . í_ .o^ j °S} .,.. ^î:°_ a^se^
ce^
ç . .Q γ^
^....~. λ ^ Γ,-. ^ {,,. ι . y ^C^4 ' á .d λ ° v 4 e 2^ ^ ι': ^ .. ^ p L Ø S ° ; .y,? . t ιΓ . ^ ^ 2.i':^ .. ι ^ :. SÉ1$1._ .^ ^
°^.s..Ø1e f ε
^ r acc sñ a^ . l pay a l1 . .u^ . , ^^^_- Σ t _^ express lyvd t ^ ^^at :^^ sha l l cØ ;^tract :^ ^ r, and sha l l
co τr,^ensatïc ^ n, i ^ cï,^dir ι g u ^
ι i ε^^ re σ ui.r^d £ees { ^ r i ^ . ax^ers ^ ^
uni ^ n scale if dcp sc ^ elects}, fringes and residua: ι s, asapplicaì ^
le, for the groducer{s}, hostfs}, presenters,τ
^ Ørformers, musicians, televisïo ^ writerfs} ar τd di ^ ector, theccrst α f cust ^ mary televisiØ ^ production insurance, the cost o Σaudio facilitïes for the awards banquet and such other costs asshall be requï ^ ed a s a result of producti ^^
f^ r televisïon
broadcast {as cc ^ ntrasted to costs which w ^ uld be incurred ïfthe awards banquet were not the sub^ect of a televisionproducti ^ n}, includí ^ g televisio ^ crew, eØuigme ^ t, cue cardsa ^ d the like. fZt is understot ^ d that alth α ugh HFPA hascreatïve c ^ ntr ^ l rights as hereinafter set f ^ rth, dcp shallhave a rïght ^ f reas ^^ able apgroval with regard to theselectio ^ and number of such persons i ^ light of its fi ^ a ^ cïalresponsïbílitïes relating thereto.}
dcp agrees to gay, as eleme ^ ts of cost of productio ^ th efoll ^ wïng:
a. HFPA"s thïrd party publicist fnot to exceed TwoThousand Dollars {^2,00ß};
h. banquet tickets, at HFPA`s actual cost, forapproximately fifty-two f52} persons, includïng host{s},performers aid presenters, the exØCt number to bedetermined by mutual agreement of the parties. Provided,^
^^wever, that tickets for dcp`s invited guests will bepaïd for by dcg at HFPA`s actual cost. ^iFPA guaranteesthat at leØSt ten {lØ} tickets will be available fordcp"s invited guests;
c. Hotel rooms #proviØed, however, that H^PA willprovide twØ {^} suïtes aid two {2} rooms without chargeto dcp};
d. All fire τne ^ ;
e. All security personnel; and
u si ^ ^ t r a ^ spØrtat ion fc^r the tics` # s}presenters and perfor^^ers appe^^ring at the A•^ards^^resentatíon»
Exhíbít B4$
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 52/68
^^ c o d P o r e τ ^~: ?re^s ssoL., . ati ^^
ui^ ?5, ?}8?
dc^^
sha l l a l s^
^a^ alf ^ lj2 } Øf ^. π 4 cos ^s aAwards ^a l ' ^ o ^s p3ya ble o f . .^`PA taaccØ:^n ïanLs , c^^^ a^ r ° ^ s ^^,a` :cr
p^
aduct^
on anet# ^ e ^ou ^
ti^ g af the
fir τπ cf certífïed puØlic13^II t^ r aadcas t that .fir: τt
sha l l ^e A rr.à ^ r `^ou ει g a^u Com,pa τ3y. ^`or s ^ bseq ^ e n t y α ars : íFPAwill c^nsult with d c p b e f o r ρ e n t e r í n g in t o a n y a g r e e m e ^ t w i than accoun t ïng fi ^ τ^ ι fc ^ r s u c h s e r v i c e s .
^
. ii^PA shall. have creatirt^e control aver the Awardslive presentations; prØVided, however, that HFPA shall nitexercise such ca^trol i^ ^ manger which would frustrate thep^^poses of this agreement and shall case such prese^tatíansto be conducted ïn a manner creatively ca^sístent withtelevísí^an broadcast standards and req^ïrements» in the eventdcg licenses any production far national televísíön networkbroadcast, then dcp and H^PA shall have m^t^al creative controlin connection with dealings relating to éreatíve matters with.the ^et^aark.
7. dcp shall have central aver the televisïongrod^ctíon aspects of the Awards insofar as the perfarma^ce ofdcp's responsibílitïes are concerned and shall, ïn additia^,have ea^trol over all matters relatíng to the distributïon aide^plaitatíon of the rights granted to ít p^rs^a^t to thisagreement » ^n this regard, dcp shall case the televisionprc^d^ctian of the Awards to be copyrighted joïntly ín the namesof äcp and ^ #FØA» dcp shall have the sale right to admïnister
and expl^^it the rights therein and tc^ Øxecute in dcp's name anyand all distrïb^tion agreements, license ØØreeme^ts and suchath^r agreements as may relate ^^ the prod^ctian and exploita--tian ^f dcp's televisían prod^etion^s} of the Awardspresentatïon{sD and the ct^g^yright{s} relating thereto» dcpshad stave the sole right ta intíate proceedings tc^ enforce ïts^rigYtts, including without limitation the rights ^^copyright{s), and ín the evert that dcp initiates proceedingst Ø enforce any such capyrïght, any recoveries {i.e», afterdeductíun ^f attorneys' fees a^td casts, which wí11 Øe advancedby dcp and recappable by dcp front grass rØceípts) shall bed^em^d í^cl^ded in the calculØtian e^f ^i^'PA's profitpartíci^^atian»
Exhibit B49
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 53/68
7
^: ^ ^^_ _ _.^^. . _^ ^ea ε ^. ; ay a^'?^ ^ σ.^.Q°
^
`^V _ . ^°:F^IS32 .^.^,á, .^C? _. ^^ ^^..,.^^ ^ _.^_ ^ e _^1.- _ 'i Γ ι _ ..^ ι )h
ud ^^ :_ s . . , ' ^ ^Z
:^^;( λ c^Qp _ ^r .^ ^y re^:^ ^ oa, ι ^
^:^
..^ ^A Σ 3 Ø^..{,. ,^aÿâ: . ι : ^ +^.. at'S^f cla ^ :π s, a c t ^ .e ^ ^ s , ].1{3i}á ^ ï.^.t'a. ° J t . . ^ ' ; : g ^ ` .^ ¡ cØS 4.s a r
exgenses {including attorneys' fees^ rela^.i ^ ,^ c^ τ er
9, dcp agreØS t ^ pro=aïde copies o:t a11 cotttractsrelating to the exercis ^ of its rights pursua ^ t to thísagree τ ent to a desig ^ ated represe ^ tatí^ ^ Ø oL M Σ PA € ori ^ formatïo ^ al purposes, includi ^ g wïthout limïtatïon,teïevision sy ^ dïcatï ^ n agree € ^e ^ ts, network 2ice ^ se agreementsa ^ Ø tí ^ e líke. Sï τ^ ïlarly, ΣiFPA wï13, upo ^ re α uest, ^ur ^ ísh dcpwith copíes of agreements relati ^ g to the busï ^ ess o ε
co»ducti.^
g the Awa^
ds presentatïo^
S, ïncludï^
g, but^
ot lïmïtedto, tacïlitïes agreemsnts, agreements with ac^ounta ^ ts a ^ d thelíke.
lß . dcp wï11 not issue publïcïty relatïng to the Awardswithout ííFPA"s prïor app ^^ val« Similarly, HFPA will not ïssuepublicity c ^^ cer ^ i^g dcp"s partïcipatïon í ^ the Awardstelevïsíon production wíthout dcp's prior appraval«
1l « ^ FPA reprØse ^ ts t Σ^ "at ^ .t , ^ rï1^. ^ ^.t ïnclu ^ '^ the . τ zse Øfc, l ïgs or ex cergts E ^ s^ m moti ^^ pïç t ^ res or.^ te levis ^ .o ^ pr ^ gramsï ^ the.-Aw ards presentat i α ns w ï th .ou t dcp ' s p r io r.w r ï tt enc©ns,^ ^ t. Σ3FP ^ Ø il2 use .^ i ts be ^ t ef^or.ts i ^ assístí ^ g dsp toε^ 3^ tai ^ cleara ^ ces for^use of . •c l ips ox excerpts w i t t+ou t cost .
12. dcp wïll furnïsh to HFPA one {1} video-cassette, atàcp's expense, af its completed televisio ^ production af the
^ wards prese ^ tatïo ^
«
dcp a ^ d 'rI Σ Ø^ agree that televïsï ^^ productïo ^
c ^ edït ^ wí21 be accorded in con ^ ection with the Awardsprese ^ tatïo
^ {,s} as follc ^ ws.
Ø. An au ε io grese ^ tati τ^^ crpdí t wï11 ^ e accc ^ rdedto HE'PA at the ape ^ í ^ c^ ^ ^ ;` th ε program .^ubØt a ^ tial Σ y í ^
the ^ol lowïrtg fØrm d "The Fiollywood F ^ reig ^ PressAssociatïc ^ n prese ^ ts . . . .'^
b. ^ prc^^u ctíØn credit wil l be accorded to 3cØ.
Exhibit B5Q
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 54/68
5 ^ PressMa4o.. : .3, 1987 , ? ev í ae^Paoe
c. C
^^ecutíve %
z
he accor^Q^ ^ ε^
ε í:^^ ε G1ar4: as the
d. ^ r e d í t f.aíΣ 2 i`^ e accΣ^α r e ig r n . a ^ s A s s c ^ ciatíon as^olde ^ G1o^e Aw ards Ev e n t.
o ^ he ^^ ^ llyw ε^ Øεii ^ e P ε adu c e r Ø f t r :e
e. Credit wi11 be accorded to Σ ra ^ cïs ^. La t^aínaas the ε xecutíve ín Charge of Prcrductío ^
.
f. dcp will acc α rd credïts to not m ^ rØ tha ^ fívØ{ 5} índívíduals desígnated b^ ^ Σ3ΣPA in a ti ^ ^e3y mannersubstantïally as ^ollows t "^ ^ r 2he Σiollyw ε :α d Σ α reígnPress Assocíati α ^ {ínsert names of not m α re than ^íve { 5)
índivíduals},tt
g. Cλther credïts wí11 be reaso ^ ably consistentwíth those credíts whïch were acc α rded ín connectio ^ wïththe televisí α n praductí ε
^ n of príor Awards gresentatíons.
h. Credïts wí11 ín all events be customary andconsistent with teievisï^n broadcast standards andrequirements, and if any production ís licensed tco atelevísï^n network for broadcast, such credits shall ñecgnsistent with the standards an d requirements ^f suchnetwork.
l4 . ^^PA grants t^ dcg the nonexclusive rïght to usethe names "Galder Gybe," "Goren Globe Awards," "^ollywoodF^reïgn Press Assoclatíon^n "TYte F«P.A. Ass^ciati^n" and sí2chother proprietary names, trademarks, trade names andcogyrightaØle materials as may be cor^trQlled by ^i^PAconnection with advertising and publicity for dc^^`sprc^ductí^n{s) pursuant t^ this agreement.
1S. KFPA agrees t^ ca^perate with dcp ín procuringsigned written releases , in forØ satís^act^^ry t^ dcg, by allpersons aDpearíng on ca^^era during the c^urs^ o^ the Awards.In additío^, ^iF^'A agrees t^ furnish sígne^^ written agreements,ïn :Form sa^í^factory t^ dcp, authorizing the use ^^ anyfacilities utilized by H^'FA Ear the Awards o^ televísíc^n an dthe use t^^ a^^ ^írm ^r trade a^^es utíli^ed during the course^f the Awards ,. including wï tht^ut IímitatriØn, the name{ s } ^^^ thecertïfied public accountants whose services are utïlïzed isy^iFPA in connection wïth tine c^u^tinc^ ^^f ballus.
16. Ø1l revenue derived by Ø^PA from the sale ^ftickets for the Awards b^n^uet{s} shall Øe the sole property ofHFPA.
Exhibit ^51
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 55/68
.^ 1g's1 Γ ^ ^ s J ^s^so tir
η
i .3l-:.^.
^: ^ó^j3.sF?C ^u1y 1 ^, .
:?^^r. e a c h r p µ -^sá., λ ^cs t:;^ a^.,a^ ^ ^ at t Στey
ar° ^=m^1^^
^ w ^ ^ . ^^
. η ° :.eZ`^1S L^
F ^ev^^.^ ,^..5 ^^.Ìd°=3.^ ι CQT:1l ln^^ . .a_7,C.^ .5 , ^' iC. λ .ς and °_d.... ^ ° ^ : C Ø S e ^ L S 3^^d 3 ^
Γ 2° S t h a t
i ^ i xas no t . v io : . ^ Ced a ^ d w ï 1 . I n o t v i o l a t e a τ^ y o do^ : i s icns o^. suchs ε c^io ^ , nor wi11 e í t h e ^ dc^ a^y act ^ ^ thic. h woulá ^ e σ uí^e '^ í s c lo s u r e Ø u ^ s u a n t t o s u c h s e c t io n .
18 . ^i^PA represents that it is exclusive awne^ of, andc^^n4rols , all rights granted to dcp, that ït ï^as t he right toenter ì ^t^ amid perform thïs agreement and grant the rightsherein gra^te^^ to dcp and that ít has not done moor will ït d^any acts which would ï^terfere with the full e^^oyment of dcg'Srights. çï^FR further represents t ^ at none of the materïalfurnished by ít in connectïon with the swards presentatïo^ willviolate, por will ïts conduct or exercïse of rights withrespect to the Awards or their presentatio n víalate, any lawsor rights of any peson , firm or corporation . dcp representsthat ït has the right to enter ïnto this agreement and that íthas not doge nar wïll it do any act which wïll i^terf ere withthe enjoyment o f ^^PA's rights. dcp represents to the best o£its abï2ity that gone of the materïal furnished by it incon^ectian wïth its televïsian c^^verage of the Awardspresentatïan will ^ïalate any laws or rïghts af any person,firm ar corparatïo^. Each party agrees to defend , i^demnïfyand bald the other ( and ït $ lïcensees, officers aid agents}harmless from and against any claims, actïons , liabilitïes,damages , costs and expenses ( i^cludïng reasonable attorneys'fees} arising out of the breach o f its respectï^e promïses and
representatïon ^n this agreement.
l^ . This agreement captains the entire agreement of theparties , supersedes all prior negotïatíons aid/or ag^^eements,and may only Øe or amended or m^dífíed by written ínstrumen^signed by the party ta be charged . I^ leá,the ^ party has entered^ïnto this agreement ï^ relïance inan any promïse orrepresentatïon not contained ín this agreement, Nathï^gcaptained ïn this agreement shall constitute eïther party the.agent cif the ether . Neither dcp nor ^FPA shall assign o ratherwíse transfer this agreement without prïor written con,septcif the other, and any attempted or purported assignment"
^
rtransfer shall be vald. Each party agrees to sign and deliverto the other suúh documents as ^aay be reasonabl }• requested tof urt ^ Ør evidence ar effectuate the purposes of th^.s agreement.Thïs ØgreAmer,t shall be governed ñy Californïa law. In the
Exhibit Bti^
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 56/68
,;oo^^ arc; 13,^ a^
^. 3L"eS s^evised
c`3t2L' t t ^ ^ ^?t':J?2
S , ι a..1 ?:'3t1.c.led^e ^` t^
recn^^.'^ Q r . Π ° ^É a
Ø 1 e ^ S e s l ^ n if1et^er agree^τ^ urpose .
herel A. e^zeVice President ^fBusiness Affairs
MAT:hg
?7^°V ^ 1 ,1 i Π 4 ^ ^ r } ^
_ö. Π ^ys` ^eás anú c^
ats
a^reeme ^ t tc ^ t h e t e r m s r e c ï t e d in t h i ssignir τc^ in the space grc ^ vided f € ^r that
AGØ ^D ^© ANI? ACCEP ^^n
Σ3QLLYWOßA ØC}REIGN PRESS AS5dCIA ^ IC ^ N
AG^ tε ED TQ ANÚ ACC Σ P ^ ε L}.
Exhibit B53
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 57/68
Exhibit C
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 58/68
. Ç ! , > 1 i 2 ^ ^ Γζ 3^^ ^ ía ι ., ^ ,u1
^.^ ^ 33á ^^ r Cc ^ p^ ^ ,,, ι ; c
{ `1 C.) L
^ ι 7^RT.AiNλ^t^Ø^
^s ^ ^ se^^temá^^r- s, 1993As revisecì SeØtember 24, 1993
T#r. Fran LaMaí^ad i c k . e i a r k p r a d u c t i o r l s , í n c .^^ß3 W. b^i^e ^ve^u^üurba^k , C1^ 91545
G4L1^82i GØØØ AW^^2Lts
Dear ^ ^ an:
T h í s ï s t a c ^^ f í r τn. tha tcr τ^ s o € the a ε}^eeØe ^ t betwee τt NSCE ^ tertai ^
ιne ^ t, a dîvîsia ^ oP hTatío ^ al Br ^ adcasting Campa ^ y, Inc.("NEC") a ^ d £ ^ ïck Clark Productio ^ s^ T ^ c. ("Pa ε kager") ξε ^ r thefollc ιwi ^ g :
1.ßa} N3C hereby o rders p roduc t^ t^^ and de3 ivery by Packagero^ a three {^) haur spec ia l en tî tl^d "THE G Q7^^^En^ GLC ^ßEA.i^T^^^^US"(GG A } fa r the 1995 j^^ b roadca s t season , t^^or i.g ína te ^ ro^a the Ø ^evez ly H i^ tt^^ Hote l ^ r a com parab lev e ^ ^ e ^ ^ o m L o s A n g e l e s , C a l í fo r ^ ïa . f ihe í^roadcastdatt a ^ d t iØ e sh a l l be a s de s í g ^ a t e d ^ y N B C ^»r e a s o n a b le ^ a t i c ^ t a P a c k a g e r b u t m u s t ^ c c u ^ k ^ e t w e e t t^7`a^uary 15 - - .Tanuazy ^1 , 159 € ^^ a Sa tu rday o r aSunday. ThØ program wi l l have the samme fa^-^^at a ^ d b ecç^^xpa rab le in t e res o^ hc^ . st .s , p r^se^^ te r s and gues t s a spr^vït^tzs GG A prograØS.
(b ) ^tBC has also aØered the grod ^ ctïa ^ a ^ d delivery byPackager of a three (3} hoax GGA specíØl f ir the1996,197 and the l9ß7¡98 broadcast seasons c^^ the samete^^as a ^ d c^^^ditiens as set forthy i^ Paragraph l (a}above, fØr the GGA special f^^r the 1995j9& broadcastseason .
'T"Σ^^ GGA sgecíal for tì τØ 1995¡96 ^ ^^ d +aa ε h st ^ 3^ sequent
brc ^ ad ε ast ^east ^ n shall ^e prØduced far live brØad ε asta^d sh^ ^ ll be deliverØd via satelite c ^ r tele ^ line i ^
accardance τ: ïth N Σ3C's Sta ^ dazd Prr ^ grat ^ De1 i.vezyKeq ιΣ ire^ ιe ^ ts (Live Special} attached heretca a ^ dineorr ^ c
^ rØted hereí ^ ^ s Schedule Ä. ^ elivery sha Σ 1 bet^ade í
^ stere ^ i ^ a ε cc ^ rda ^ ce with N8C`s technìcal
Ex^ ïbit ^54
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 59/68
t
Mr. F ^ a ^ L3.üaí ^ aA.s of Sep t^ τ ,E^r ^ , 1993Σι s revis^d S cp ^ ι ^ ε r 2 4 , i .9 Ø 3R F : G C T, Σ?^:7 GZ^P,E A;^ AΣtL3^^^^^^^, ^
specifications for Stereophc^^ïc 2^elevísion Progra^^sattached hereto amid i^xcorpatet# herein as Scheäule A-î,P a c k a g e r sh a l l d e ] .z v e r b o t h ^ ^ ^ r z u ^ a r y a m i d b a c ^ .--uρ fe e ι^.Packager shall be resg^^nsik^^.e for alt costs i^curreci i^c o ^ ^ e c t ï ^ n ^ ^ i th t z a ^ s ^ ^ i s $ io n o f a g r í ^ t^ a r y a n d b a c k - u psí.gnals fir such special from the p3.ace of orïgn to}ißC's k^roadcast facilïties in ^urba^k, California,^.^cluäi^y^ all Charges far s^teZíte, ^ic^^^wave or telcc^l i^e use î^ ca^^ectian with the primary and seco^d^ryfeed o^ any such sØecial to NBC's broadcast facïiities
ire Burba nk , C^^ l î fcxn ía , Timely delivery f the 19^^5f96a T t d s u b s e q u e n t G G A ^ r o g ^ r a Ø S s h a l l b e o f th e e s s e ^ c ^ t oth is Agreez aen t .
278 0 wi ld , hav e a r c ap t i ^^ , e^p re î s ab l e r ; ^ t later thannicety {9^} da^^s followí.^g the broadcast c^ the 1.97,/98GG A spec i a l , t co c^ r ^^ e r ^ h r ^e { 3} a d d ^ , t io ^ ^ l t h r ee { 3^h o m e r G G A . s g a c i a ls f i r t h e 1 S 9 8 j 9 ^ ^ , 1999j20^c ^ az ^ d^ o t ^ ß j ß ^ b r o a d c a s t s e a s o n s c ,n t Y ^ ^ s Ø ^ ^ ^ t e r τas amidG o n c i i .t ^ 0 2 1 S a s s e t f o r t h i ^ P a r a g r a z ^ 2 ^ 1 ^ á } a b o v e , f ^ ^ rthe GGA, speai^l fir the I935j3 ^ br^^at3.ca.st season.
{b} I f M B C h a s ^ X ^ r c i s e t^ t h e o p t io n i n P a r a g r a p h z { Ø }a Σ'
^ v ^ , it mill have an aØØiti^nal oØt.i^^, ex.^rcisa.ì^Ie^^^t later than r^iz^tztì^ {9ß} days foll^wi^g broadcast ^fthe 2ßß¡^l G6A special , tv ^^rd^r four ^^^ additia^alt h r e e ( ^ } h o m e r G S A s ^ e c i a l s fi r th e 2 c ^ ß ï j ^ ^ 2 , 2 ß C ^ 2 , /^ 3 ,^ß03/^4 and 20ß4j45 broadcast seasons ^ the saØ^ termsaid candit^,^^^s .3s set. forth í τz P a r a g r a p h 1 { a } a Ø v e ,for the GGA speci^^l for the l3Ø5/96 broadcast season.
{cj I f N B C h a s e x e r c i s e d ì^ c ^ t h o p t io n s i ^ P a r a g r ^ ^ h s 2 { a }at^^3 2{b} above, then ^tBC ^hal1. have the right ^f ^^fil^5t^egatiationt^îrst ref^ ^Sal,^ r^7^t-^,^i ,^,ç^^ ; . : ,^. :2t2ri'aedbr©3dcast rights to them CGA pr^grat^. Such excl^si^eright o^ "first ^egotiatic^^" s^t^ll continue far ag e r i Ø ø f t h iz ~ ^ . y ( 3 0 } d a y s c o m ^ i e n c in Ø ^ i ^ e ty { s ß } d a y sfo22owi^g the broadcast o^ the 2ßß4j ^ 5 GGA prcg ^ aØ .Such ''rí.Øht ^^ firat re^^sal" shat i ^^ean ^t:a^^ ^f n^agx-Øe^^ent is reached during the first negotïatïo^^peY°iod, then until tñe expiration of one {z} ye^^rf t^ i law ing t? ι o expiration of th:^ first neggtiatic^rtpex`i ι d, iackaq°r sha#.1 not enter i^t^ army agreem^^t^azth any third p3r^y res^ecti^^^ exhïbitîon ^^f ^^utureGSA ^^^^c ia ls omser any f ^^ r ^ of t+e Σ evzsíc ^^ o^ Øcan^taryterms less favorable tco PaG ^ agex` th.^^ packager's lastteritten a^fer tco NBC durïng the exclusive ne^^otiati^^
Exhii ^ ïi^
55
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 60/68
Mr. Fran Σ,a M a i n a^ Se µ e ^ ι ^
er^
, Σ ^3 θ 3v^sed 8ep te^- ιΣ^er Z 4 , Σθ 93
^N GiABE ^ ι ^ ti ^ ïFt[^. θ
perít ^ d, w τ th ^^ t Σ irst giví ^ g NBC t?, :e Σ ï^-s ^ . c ι ppur tu ^ ity{c ^ n a five {5} ^ tι si ^ ess day t ^ rnar ^ u: ι d} t ^ enter ïntaa ^ agreeØe ^
t^
ïth Pasl-ager c ^ zτ t^ ι e s a ^ ^ ^ t e r ^ ιs as w ε ren f Σ ered by the thírØ garty.
The flat 3icense fees fear mane I^rC^^^ dca5t of ^acY ι trG^.progra3 ^ shill be as fellows.
$EASßh' LICENSE FEE SEAS^ti 3,ZCENS^ FEE
3 . 7 7 . . i f θ ^t ^
J.. ε f47 ../ ^ λ ^ L ^ 2t30C}ftt 7, γ^ ^ 1 l V G J , V V ^
1s9s f gτ $^
,^
ao,oε^
a 2ao^
.ja^
^^, αa4,aaazgs τ fs ^ S ^ , ^ sεl, ε^ a ^ 2at^^ fa ^ ^4, ^ rι ^ ι ,π a ^
2 9 θ 8 /4 θ $ ^ ,5C λ 0,00 fl 2aa3fCY4 $4,4^{},t7(7flî35^9f ^ß $3 , 65Q, 4 ι QQ 2Q ^ 4f t1^ $4, 65 ^ , 4'tId
4. z ^ the e ^ e ^ t that 2 u r n e r Brc ^ adcastíx τg S γ s t ^ avo7. ιxnta r i3y re lz ^ q ^ í she5 i t s r ig# - ι ts tt) tl τe GGA specíØlsPcι r the τ ^ θ ^ j Ø a a ^ d I 9 9 4 f θ 5 brc ι ^ εì cas t seasans }ayw^ rítteh n ^ t z f iGa t îc ^^ t o NßC , the c ι zØe ^ ceme^t ^ L' theteØ of t23is . ^ ^gree ^ en t sha ;31 be acce l e r a ted t ^^ theï9 9 ^ f S4 br ε^ aàcas t s ea sa ^ a ^ dE tt εe f ^ regc ^ zr ^ ^ * t e Ø s s h a Σ.1be ad ju s t ed acc ^ rdïngly.
5_ N3C herei^y orders the productít ι^n a n d Ø e 3 i v e r y k ^ l ^
2ackager of a one ζ 1} h¢tz r v^
.dec ιtape s;n.ecia3 e^
tz t^ .edthe "5{ iT Σ; ^;li^ii ^ FR ^ ^RX C}F THE Gf^^ENï DØBE AT^AR ^ JS , ι4vh íGh w í^1 l be a úz^ ττter tzíbuta t τ
^ preu io t^ .s aw ard^ ïnners aØ wi17. pri ^ aríly e ει ^ sist oi clíga fr τ^^ ^grev í c ^ u s G G A g r Ø r a ^
s. The Sgecial wi11 ieáture f ^^ rς 4) hasts (z fe τττa2.e¡^ aale}, t^ao {^} on-stag ε^perfor^zers ar.d at. 2eØSt t τ ^ er: ty ζ'^{?^ guests to k ^ eselected fra ^ the attached Sched ιtι le A. The prcxgraØ isínt ^^^ ,ed fc ^ :, te2ecast in the Fa31 c ^ f 1 θ 9 ^ , NBC ^ tzllp a y P a c k a g e r a 7 . í+ ^ e ^ se fe ^ α f Ei+3ht ^ ι : ^dreá T τJenty_F2.v^: Thousa ^ d Øliars ( 58.25, aßß j f lat >áar
^^ e br ^ adcastof t2xe proqr ^ Ø.
5 . NBC W2.3 Σ l1dVØE 1t5 Ct. ΣStØ ^ l^ ιry j3r ^ , .c?r cr ^ at3.ve ^ tpprØ τι^^^
l t^ f
a13 .key ι rc^ative ele τ^
e^
ts in^ λ uding executive and iineprod ^ Cers, pre ^ et t t ε^ r € ^, 2 ι c^ s t5 , C l1rE . *c tOr t W r l te r i 3 ,ch Ø ιnges i ^ l'C}Øi ^ ιt , tit3e, sc χ^ípt, ax τd Ø ^ sicj l ^^
t s ι zchagp ra^ ra l s sha23 ^ c^ t b ^ e x e r ci sa c ^ b y N B C i ^ such a ι^an ^ er as to ^rt2strØte thís Agre ε z^ e ^ ^ .
Exhi ^^ it C56
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 61/68
t^r. F^ä ^ L^tiI'ai ^ ar; ^ >; Septe^ Σ
^ er 9, 1 θ 93i-,^ r_ev i s ε d S e p t e ^ .. ^ er 2G, Σ ß 9 3
G^LDEN G7^,HE λ.^Th.°,DS
^?ag e ^<
7 E a c h p ^ wt^ g r a m m u s t c o ^^ p ly w i th N^ . ìC` s P rog ram C red i tG u i d e λ i ττ e.s, ^ ι copy of whîch ís attached hereto.H ^ WetJer, ít is ür ^ derstoØ tY3cît wíth r ε sç ^ ect tr ^ each CGA5^ ^ eci ^ l, the ccmk ^ ^ ^ ed credíts ^ ^ ^ ^ cεf . exc ε: ed a tot ^^ l o Σeighty {8ßj seCO ^ ds a ^ d wi11 ru ^ ïull-screen.
8 . For the p ^ ograras , PØCka εΣ^ r ^ ιgrees ta furnîsh NBC with aCertïficatØ 4f Tele ^ íszt ^ n P z `4 t iuce r ' s E ^ :rors a ^ dOØïss^.c ^ ns zr ^ surax ^ cs w χ. t} τ ccsverag ε c ^
ι ^ xσ t less tt^ a ^ c^ n^
Mi.lli α n per accurrencej ^ hrae M il λ ïan a ^^ ual aggregate€ or the prögra τι^ íss ^ ed by a cartier app ^ `α v e ε3 by MBC.
NBC sha3.1^
e included as as3 addztïo^
a l i n su r+ ^ c # î^
τ^
aidp τ^ lîcy and NBC wi1^, be fur ^ isheØ with t Σ:e Certîf.íc ^ εteprior t α the co τ^
ιme ^ ce τøa ^ t of pr α dtzct:,Ø ^ .
θ . T ^^
ε 1 icensed territory w ^ ι 11 }. ^ e t .he üz τ í t ed S ica ιtes, ^ .tst ^ r r í t α ries a ^ d Øssessions í ^ cludî ^ g b lØ C k o u tprotactio ^ 3 for Øtroit ^ nd 5a τ^ D i e g o .
10 . Duri ^ g the t t ?Ø„ e^ ιC h p r Ø r a Ø a ^ d new1^ p r ^ εluced^ leØe ^ ts (excludi ^ g f i1^ τ e l íp s } a f t h e p r o g r a m w i 3 . 1 b eexc lus îve to ì38C i τ3 the lice ^ sed t e r r it o ry í n a11 . m ed íaexclud ^ .ttg ^ αex'cha ^ äísi ^ Ø , pub l ish î ^ g a ^ d mu s ic .
1 i. A1i prvqra.ms sha.11 co ^ τ^ p ly τ^ ith the reØí.re τaer ι t, o ξN"B C^s Broadcast St.a ^ c3ards a ^ d Practïc ε s D2pá.z-tø ^ eì^
ιt,i nc lud i ^ g τ ^ itP ι.^ ui^ ,Σ íØi ta t îo ^ ti ^ e ^ aquireØ^. ^ t ^ ^ `et fc ^ x th
í ^ t N B C ` s p ro g r a τα S ta ^ dards a ^ d Practices ^ ^an^3a Σ a ^ di?irectíves az τε^ other Øidez i ^ es τυhích shal i be pr ^ v i dedtc ^ Package3: .
22 . NBC st3all h2tvØ z3 ^ ^ biig α tí εsτ3 to lbroatïca ε;t thØ p ^ ~^ e^ra τas.NΣ^ C's o ^ l γ Ø#^ l ïga^ ian shØ1 1 be pay ^^^^ t t o p a c k a ιg+^r att h e aØ p l ic ^ : ^ le Iic^z ^ s ε fee .
I3.{aj Packager represents Øßd warra^tØ thatz
Cî Ì
[i î
Packager has the ^'îght t.e^ enter ínt^^ and fullyp^^fox- r^ th i s Agreem ent . 2 ιnd grant the rightsg ran t ed é^ ^ r P a c k ag e r u^Z de r t h i s A g reem en t ;
P a c k a g e r h i t s ^ Ø t Ø c ^ ^ e a m i d s h a ll n c t d ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ y ^ ^ c t c a renter î^^ta any agreØ ^ïae^^t whîch w^^ u^d vïc^late c1t^yci f tt:e rights gra^t^ed tØ NBC c^ti í^ter^ere with the^^^r fQ ^cz^a^ ce ^ f Packager `s ^ab ï iga t îons ^^^^ iex t t^ í s
Ì
Exhii^ it C57
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 62/68
4'dß I,^ !aí^aSeptet=tier 3 ^ ^^^3
revised 5e µ e^ber 24, 19=^_ ^
GC}LL}E21GL, Ω ß^ ' áW λ7•'_DS^ -
^ .". e 5
[iii] ^^ch prcgrara sha,lì be daï Tvered free and clear cifa^^ encuØ: ante, irteluØi^g any lien car tax which^.s T^4^ subt ,r di ^ ate aid subject tco all rightsgrated tt^ 21ßC hy thïs A.gree^aent;
ji ^
] the exercise by NBC i:^ accc^rda^ce with thecif this Agree^te^t of tY^e rïghts granted tiashall not vi^^late or í^fri^gé any rí^}tts o^ anyperson, f ïØ ar corpc ^ ratian:
jvj can delivery af each pro^3ram, all p^r^ar^i^g rights
tc o musïc ä» the pr^g^am shall be co^
tr^
2ied bypc3ckager, àSCAP, BéF1, ar SESAG, or shall b? in thepublic da^^aä^, and packag ^ r shall have ^btaíne^^^ll r^ec^r^iï^g a ^ Ø synci^ro^^.zatíon rïghts to such
^bj Packager`s representati^^s a^à warranties hsre ^ τ^ cler ar^Øund e r t he r e l^ t e^3 i ^d^^a^ í ty l e t te r ag^eø ^^e : t t be t ^^^ee^^8C and packager, as well s Packagez^s and NSe'sobl ic^a t ïo^s under such . i^deØ^^. ty^ le t te r a ,gr^e^^e^t r,shall survive the teru^inati^n a^ this Rgr^n^^^t.
Z4 _ Nto ^^ub l ic ï t^ t r e l a t^ .T le j t o t h ïs A gree^n^^ t m ay Ø e r e l ea sedunless bot#^ parties ^^utually agree but it is u^ders toc^d
tehat the finat^cïal terØ caxt^ot te discl^^se^.
xo the e^^^e^.t they are not i.riCOnsiste-rit Wíth the teres sit ^c^rthabove, those custoØar}t pr^vïsíons whïch ^^^e n^ØØlly i^clu^ïed .^^
formal agreeØe^ts o^ this type shall be negotia^^^dh hy the parties amid ínc^rp^rated herein , l^cltldír^g without
itatia^ pra^^is^.o^s with respect to talent exclusivïtY,publicit ^ y, írìcØpadíty, disability, foxce Øajeurer k^reaet^, aidi ^deØ ^ i .f ï c a t ion an ^ i a s s i g n m e n t , x^ due c^^urse, tote partieshereto ^^ay p repa re ^ Ø t s re Parmal agz'ee^^e^t, bit the partiesf ^ ι ïlure to d^ so shall rzo ^t Ater the bín ^ i^g effect ©E thisØgreeØe^t, which s^a^ers^de5 all prig understandings andcc^^zmunicat i^^s k^^^t^ee^ ti^^ gart^:es with respect t^ the suk^j pctmatter hereof.
K i ^ dly sig ^ i P y y o u r ^ greeØ^ertt τ o the Poreg ^ i ^ ^^ by sxg*. τ ing a ^ dr e t t z r ^
ïng a11 e ^ closed copíes oP th ^
.s ag ^ `ee^ ιe: τ t. Σ h i s A Ø r e e ^ e n tsYτall c ^^ Ø e u ^ der the pur τ
^ 'i ε^ w o f t h e t 3 m . b r e ll a I ^ d ι Ø n ì t y Ag'ree ^ τe n t
Exhibit C58
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 63/68
^^ σ.ξ.
^^^3^_ ^ -._^1
Σ 'r^h L ^ 2^1a^ .^.a^^f Septet^^er 9, 1593
revis^d Sept.e^er 24, 29Ø3^;ε_ c ^
τ,^,^ τ r ^ ^_,o^ ε rwF,εc^s^^,^ .
^ e e
be^twee ^ h'HC E ^ tertai. ^ Øe»t a ^ d díck clax3 ς producti α rts, ír ^ α . datea s α f I3eC ε,.- > ^ ^ ^ 7 , 2 9 8 2 , < ^ s a Ø e n d e d M a r e t τ 7, 2983. WΣ3e ^ fully-execc τted o ^ i^ eha^ . f c ι i' Σ7$G, a co Σ^ y α f ^his agree ^ ιe τι t wilZ ^er^tur ^ ed ξ cι yo ^ Σα r y α ur rec α zds.
Very truly yvurØ,_:_.,^
ACCE Σ}TED ιλ1^ L} AG Σ2EE Γ3.NBC ENrtE#2TA?'1v^íE λ7T, ^ Dívísí ^ ιn of
d í c2 t c1a^ ,^e^Ø d ^ τc^^#s , ínc . NÀ2 Σ C}NRLSRQAD^Ø^IMG Ct^ÑEPR.N f , 2l^ ΣC .
^ald ε n_agØ
Exhíbíi C59
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 64/68
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 65/68
^^^^^^^^^^ ^Ø^.^^^^ ^^.:^^^ ^ss ^ c ^ .^ ^ τc^^
^ :^^ εε τl^τ^
T;-{ISλ G^EM^
, ü madε as cf t^
e 1st day of'lovcm6c^
, 1999 b} ι a^
d
Σ € ELMüT ^s^ ssPra ιae,o^
vAxtεaa_*cι^^
τs^^ ae^
^^
α t^ ^ e
τ^ AS^ ι^ C^+^ ε^ τ ^ rrτ .εvYι*Yαι , ^ ,. ^ α*Ø
JA C ΣC Σ EWKSHtTRYΣ ^^^ τ u^ ιτ
^o ^ ^ τι a ι ^ 1Dts^^ .e τr^ aτs
c
εtA^ ετ r ^^ τ^^^ tιv
ι,^
3ØN2s3 ØØRx π^ s^ E Ø Ø
^ NS3
^ HnιτP ^ ε ^^
^
üσ ^
aa
τ^^ ε^^ εκcs pa^
sr^
c τca^
HANTAL DIIŸNAGE
x h ^ eea ;,he HOLL'τ'WØb FCR Σ€ GN PRΣ SS ASC roductìony, '.^ c_ (dcp).
a ^ ^;ic3c c;aτk
!. T1ι t 1^ :Σ'PA g ^ anu ta dcp (^ ) the ñ ^ }at t4 pØc ε , d'st ^ íbute, p ^
σ^tote,adve τtísØ and exploít c ^ rouØout the u ^ ;ve^ ε in ^ erpctuíry a one{ 1} hoι^ pro3τ'aatt;Ÿτ't ^ g^^^ ι ) t^ ^ e εetec.ast dι ^ τ^ g t iι o ha ιιr ØØíately p ^ Øi ^ g Øe teí^ of Øa^^ caldect Gioba .+4wa^ de prraenta^ í^ a ptØgçraτα {Awards ProgtØ} on Ia ^ ua ^ γ 23, Z ^ t^ and(1^ } ^ íz ^ voØle exclusiv α aptíon {C3ptiaa} fora secotcd PτngrazYτ c#uτ^ g broadcast yca τ2t3flØtØ t. The fiFPA εa^ srastt ta the sale of tha Pτngτaτια by ^ ts ^ 1^8C fs ^ ε batiadcasiïsι the Uτtited States,its T ε c^ itaríea aØ Possessíocas, e ^ recpτ Puerco F^ co.
2. ihe ProgrØ will fεatuεe εhs axrívaís of celcbriti ε s and may iacluds p ^ e-taped segments abotu diØ me αus, gífì packages, press ^
s^
om ints^
views in pcio ε yea^
,pla^ níng of pa ιrtíε s, scants of s:steØØes s ^^ tericsg(óut ^ Ø 1^ sØs} the äaü ^ ao τn, at^ í ØaEike. dcp shall p ^ aεhua a progra τ
^
Ø ^ sistε ^
τ wids Øe slualíty s^ f the Awaräs Frogtaaττs ínprioε yeaaaι, prssvaíli^ g b ^^ aØØ sta ^ τáards far compa ^^ tale progracα s, aαd tha ptoftss#sØalstatureof Øs HFPA.
3. The Prógra ^ n shatΣba the o αly psaví εØ shaw af the Gs ^ lden Globe AwarØ ^ aactia ^ sdby the Ø A , a ^ d tha HFPA wíll llce τtse ^ o ath ε ^ s:^ t ^ ty tsa da a prcv^ +ιr show d ι^ itig thattime or befars:, F ^ ε t#ιe PrograØ a^ d Ø titles, Øss ØA grmia tca dcp tha right ta u ^ a thsnaιmes "Goisíeα Gioña", "GoIØ Globa Awstds' and " ^ ollywoα t Fo εeígα PressAssociatïo α" aαd approvts Dick Claríc Øá Na αcy t}"I}eìl aa Øs hosts, For ths Pcog, τaι^ :,NHC will hava ac ε ess ta tha a εea {Pεττn ^ ry A ^ ea) wíthi α Øa coaßn α af Øa BtvexiyHílton Hot ε l e ιcts^ rïar andτntcs^^ ε (á ^ t r^ ot tha bali ^^ Ø) iα whích cslsi ^ rit^ ss arnïvs a^ d ^cong τegate, I3u ^ l^ sg t!^ e P τngrambre^adc^ st, ^ o atlisar eα iîty wíll be pØíØd τo ttlecast€
vs wíthi^
Øe PØary Area, except fs^
shart °c^
^aw^
ys" '^
thsι contØ of a ha^^
i-^
ιewabroá^ r,ast. Othe ε tha^ theca, thsι FiF'PA^ íΣl piaca na, restríctioαs oα electronïc Ø^ priata
^ edis cavezi ^ g acrivals, u^le^ s sτ iØ res ^^ ctians ^ avt bee τt imposed i ^ pτior y εara. ThsHFPA has tha r ^ ght ta apprαve the hosi and th α iττtcr^ íewετ a of Øe Pa^ ag^ a^xs. dε pundeε^ds thesa eo ^ ditío^ a ^ vitai t ε^ prs^ tect the IiPPA asad it^ jour ^ aíØ Øcmberatfror^ chargss tñty ars pcevs α ^^ g sØssrj oumatís4 froØ ι Øíng U ιe ^ ^ js^ bs. If tha ØAdiscoveεs a b τo ^ de ^ ster otïtØ #ta^ NBC is vialatíng a tradc τa.arkaf the HFFA by usØgτhe Galdta Giobe Awa ^ ds ds^ig^ atfØ as part of the d τle of a prsvís;w shaw i ^ αP ^ y ^^ ιg ØØshow ïs wsth ths a ι ^ #toí•zτ áιtØ α af the FIFPÀ, Øar the HFPA wíít usa reasottahle effo εks ^^
stop tha u^ autharíx,sdτιss to Øa exDenat fε:asiØis.
4. dcp shallpreparo a budget for allprc^duc>tisa^ rosts^srosiu^ttoasCasts} of t}ao?rog^-a^n forapp^tivai ^^ (hes HI^ PA $oa^d. fludgetú^g ^s year-to-year, and t ^ a panicsecognize cf:crc^Y bß ín^latïna i^ future years. dcp shall advance all P^ducØOn Crisis.
:kny Froductian Ccsts ín excess (Lhe Excess) of the budget approVCd hy ^^^e l^'PA sllaïi^-:e ror the acco^^n^ of dep..The Production Cosh not inci^d^g any Excess shall ^ededucted from the rev^nuca fog the Pr+aØ ^^nclud^^g tie lí^er^sa fee paid b^ ; ^ BC,revenues f^o^^ fo^^^ga^ saes, and revenues for any ot,`acr ^xpiu^tatìon hy dcp}, and the-cma^^dor shall he dívíded fifty pc^cnt X50°^^) to the H^^PA a^^d f_Ty^ pcrcen^ ; S^"/^}dcç^. dcp has suparior knowledge and shah use the highest p^ofess^ona^ standards topromote and protect the inte^esta of the HFPA ^ its payment of P^4duction Ccstr,coilecti^^ncaf revenues, ac^ou^ting for Prod^ctíotaCosts and re venues , and payrn^nt ta the
6 4 $ - 6 4 8 i " l , i^iØBE ^ 2i`SUN á ^3t}L'LEVARD, W. Ht ^ LLVWC}OD, CALIP{} Σt λ1ïA 9^d ^ 3é39-5^7$
ξ 3 l t 3 ) 557- i73 I 1^AX (310) 657-5576EE b AΣL^ t3F'PA95^} A^1L.CCàM tNEBSt7Ø WoYW. ΣiFPA.CC3M
6Q
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 66/68
NFP^, ^t an}• reaso πΡaòle time, the HFPA and ijs professional advisors may revíe^,^,zudi^, and ceov t ^ e îιπΡanc^ al records of dcp end all coneacts related :o the Prog^^m.
^. Credit for the Program s ^ ^l^ be co^sístent with she credits for the Awards.Program, aid the desig πΡatlon offie five (^) individua'.s by the ^^P.4 undes p^^agraph13(fl ofthe agreement between the ^a^ies dated as of?viarch 13, 1987, as revised JulyI^, ; 989, as am^^ded (Other agreement} shall be ^o later t ^ a^ ^^o (2) weeks befare thee.P^og^am. ^cp shall copyri?ht the Program jointly in the names of dcp and the I^FPA. Atits expense, dcp shad furnish to the HFPA one (1) video cassette of its completed^e,ev^s^t^^ production of the P^g^zm. dcp shall indemnify and boid harmless the. HFPAfor zny claimsarïsing out ofthe Program or its production. Any rights not expresslygranted to dcp in tl^ís Agreementshall not be infe^^d.
^. If dcp chooses to exercise the Option far a second preview show, it shall do so bywritten notï^to the HFPA ^o later than.. July 15, 2{}00. Far.braadcast years 200112002and later, the HFPA reserves the ^íght whether it will consent ta production. of a prevíewprogram. If theHFPA consents to p^oductían ofsuch a p^og by dcp during broadcastyear 2001 (2042 , the HFPA shall gïve written notice to dcp by February 15, 20U l . If nosuch notice is gïve^ , dcp will have a right of first negotiation and last :refusal far such.program using the p^ocedu^es in paragraphs I{a} and ^(b} of the Other Agreement. SoSang as NBC is the b^aadcaster af the Awards Program and the HFPA has licensed theAwards Pragrarn to dcp,{a} íf theHFPA does a preview show , it shall be with dcp andNBC, and (b) iftfie HFPA decides not ta da a prevíew show wiØ dip and NBC, theHFPA shall not do a prevíew Shaw with any other producer or network. Ail futureprevíew shows with dcp and NBC shall be pursuant ta the terms af this Agreement.
7. Thïs ïs the e^ti^e agreement between the parties. N^ prior orcantempora^eaus oral statement a^ príor writing may be used to interpret thisA ree^^e^t. The pa^tïes are not pa^t^ers ar joint ventu^e^s. Neither party may assign itsrights or obiigat^ans without the príor written consent of the other party. Noínte^pretat^on may be drawn against the HFPA becaus^ ít ìs deemed to be the maker ofthis Ag^eeme^t. This Ag^ee^nent may be amended only by a writing ^íg^^ed by the partyto be bound. This Agreerne^t shall. ^e governed by the laws of Calïfarnia except for itschoice af law rules . If there ís a dispute under this Agreement, the parties shall attemptto resolve ^t by direct negotiations between their respective se^ ior executives , fallingwhich eïther parsy map ínïtïate canfídentíal arbit^at^o^^ in Las At^g^les County under thComn^ereíal Rules of the Arnerïcan Arbítratía^ Association. The p^evailíng party shallbe awarded its. reasonable attorneys" fees and costs: The decísío^ af the arbitrationtribunal shallbe bïndí^g o^ the parties and enforceable in arty Statea^ federal wart ïnLas Angeles C^untp to whose juñsdícts'an the partïeshereby conse ^ t.
HÖLL Qß ^F,ØREIGN PRESS dick cASBO IATI^}^ `q Λ íßo.
Exhibit D61
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 67/68
Exhibit E
8/8/2019 Golden Globes Complaint
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/golden-globes-complaint 68/68
f^XFRC^ISF,Π F f7f'"i^IΠ ^iS
As of OCtoher ^`^, 20i0
`^^"E i}^I^.i✓AS, the HOLLYWOOD COItE1GN ^'ItESS ASSOCIA'^ION (HFPA} and dickelark. prad^^ctí^ns, inc. (dcp} made an agreement (the Agreement} dated as of March i3, i987, asemended N^vernber i 3, i 989, September 22, 1993, and May 20, IØ97 far the iícensing andp^oduc#ían öf Golden Globe Awards programs;
W^IEREAS, NBC and dep made an agreement (the NBCldcp Agreement) as afSeptember 9, 1993, as revised September 2 4, 1993, as amended April 2 0, 2 0Qí, as amended June
11, 2001, and as amended as af July 29, 2 005, far the Galden Globe Awa^Ø pragrarns;
WHEREAS, NBC and dcp made a^ agreement as af September 3Q , 2010 to extend theNBCIdep Agreement far the Galden Globe Awards p^agrams through the 2 017!2018 broadcastyear;
WHEREAS, the Agreement is deemed extended far any extension of the NBCldcpAgreement,
NOW, THEREFORE , dcp exercises its aptias under the Agreement for each of theyears through the 2Q l 712 Q i 8 broadcast year; provided that NBG performs under the NBC/dcpAgreement; pr^v^ded fi^^ther that íf, by reasyn ^f breach ^f the NBC/dcp Agreement by NBC,NBC does not perform and this gives rise ta a cíai^n by dcp against NBC, dcp shad vígaraustyprosecute this claírrt and divide the proceeds (after deducting costs and ^easonabie attorneys fees}tífty percent (50°l0} ta the ^íFPA and fifty percent (50°fo) ta dcp? provided farther that dcp maycarnpr^mise and settle such claim sa ling as ít is within the exercise af s^u^d business judgmentand with. full consideratí^n of the interests af the HFPA,